Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Online learning space environment in colleges and universities based on learning effectiveness

Harbin Institute of Technology, China ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1006608

Abstract

With the expansion of online teaching demands and the gradual maturity of remote conferencing software, online teaching models have rapidly developed after the pandemic, becoming one of the mainstream learning methods for university students. The shift to online learning has transformed educational practices and methodologies, necessitating a reevaluation of how educational spaces are designed and utilized. In recent years, research on the influencing factors of online learning behaviors has gained significant attention, and studies in this area have been increasingly prevalent.The physical environment is one of the critical factors affecting behavior; the material elements of space significantly influence human behavior patterns. This influence extends to learning environments, where aspects such as lighting, acoustics, and spatial layout play a vital role in shaping students’ learning experiences. Therefore, studying online learning spaces is essential for understanding the factors that influence the effectiveness of online education.Unlike traditional teaching methods, the structure of learning time allocation and the nature of learning behaviors in online learning have undergone significant changes. Traditional learning spaces, designed for face-to-face interaction and physical presence, are often ill-equipped to meet the diverse online learning needs of university students. Factors such as flexibility, accessibility, and technological integration become paramount in creating effective online learning environments. As a result, investigating university students' online learning space requirements is crucial for enhancing the effectiveness of their online learning experiences.This paper explores the impact of architectural space factors on university students' online learning behaviors from a human factors research perspective. It investigates how various environmental factors—such as thermal environment, air quality, and furniture and equipment—affect the online learning effectiveness of college students. For instance, a comfortable thermal environment can enhance concentration and reduce fatigue, while poor air quality can lead to decreased cognitive function and engagement. Additionally, the arrangement and quality of furniture and equipment can significantly influence students' ability to interact with digital learning tools and participate in online discussions.To gather relevant data, this study developed a survey questionnaire on satisfaction with online learning spaces in universities, based on interviews and established space satisfaction scales. The questionnaire aims to assess students' perceptions of their online learning environments and identify areas for improvement. By employing empirical analysis methods, the study verifies the reliability of the questionnaire, exploring the differential impacts of spatial factors on learning effectiveness.The findings of this research are expected to provide valuable insights into the specific needs and preferences of university students regarding online learning environments. By understanding these factors, educational institutions can better design and optimize their online learning spaces to enhance student engagement and learning outcomes.Finally, this paper interprets the demands of online learning environments by combining offline space surveys and empirical analysis results. Based on the existing spatial conditions, it proposes targeted optimization strategies for online spaces aimed at enhancing learning effectiveness. These strategies may include recommendations for improving air quality, enhancing ergonomic furniture design, and ensuring adequate technological support. By addressing these critical aspects, educational institutions can create more effective and supportive online learning environments, ultimately leading to improved student performance and satisfaction.

INTRODUCTION

With the rapid development of information technology, society has entered the “Internet Plus” era, where the integration of the education sector and the internet has revealed significant market potential and commercial prospects. The online learning model has rapidly evolved, becoming an important method of study for university students, altering their learning behaviors and environments, and allowing them to engage in coursework in relatively independent spaces. The structure of time allocation for learning has also undergone significant changes. Although there has been research exploring online learning behaviors, studies on how environmental factors influence students’ online learning remain relatively scarce. Therefore, this study aims to analyze the spatial aspects of online teaching for university students from the perspective of human factors research. It seeks to understand the spatial factors affecting students’ online learning through surveys and to establish corresponding evaluation tools through data analysis, in order to enhance the efficiency and user experience of online teaching spaces. This

© 2025. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 44

Online Learning Space Environment in Colleges and Universities 45

research expands upon the methods of spatial design within environmental psychology through empirical analysis, providing guidance for the design of online learning spaces and helping universities formulate more effective online learning strategies to improve educational quality.

RESEARCH THEORIES AND MODELS Environmental Psychology Theory

Environmental psychology is the comprehensive science that studies the relationship between human behavior and experience and both artificial and natural environments (Paul A. Bell). It emphasizes the importance of examining the environment-behavior relationship as a whole, as there is a genuine interaction between the two: the environment encompasses and influences behavior, while behavior also alters the environment. Statistical analysis is a commonly used method in the field of environmental psychology. Therefore, this study employs statistical knowledge to investigate spatial factors.

Indoor Environmental Quality Indoor Environmental Quality (IEQ) refers to the various environmental conditions and characteristics within living or working spaces that directly affect people’s health, comfort, and work efficiency. It primarily includes aspects such as air quality, lighting, temperature, humidity, noise, and spatial layout. The different aspects of the indoor environment are interconnected and collectively influence individuals’ physical and mental health as well as work performance. Improving indoor environmental quality is a crucial way to enhance the quality of life and work.

Learning Engagement Theory In the 1980s, Mosher et al. (1985) pointed out that student engagement includes not only the investment of time and effort but also the attitudes and emotions of the learners. At the same time, there is a significant relationship between student engagement and outcomes such as academic performance and social behavior. Jimerson (2003) reviewed 45 research reports on student engagement and identified dimensions for measuring engagement, including emotional, behavioral, and cognitive aspects. Behavioral engagement refers to the level of student participation in the classroom, such as attendance and completion of assignments. Emotional engagement involves students’ feelings towards school, including their attachment to teachers and peers. Cognitive engagement pertains to the depth of understanding and thought that students apply to the learning content.

The Impact of Environment on Learning Engagement Zhang Lin et al. (2023) found that environmental factors are important influences on student engagement. Tawarah et al. (2022) indicated that students’ motivation and the availability of facilities can affect the achievement of course objectives. Hollister et al. (2022) discovered that when

students lack interaction with peers and teachers, it reduces the appeal of learning. Akpen et al. (2024) showed that the digital devices used may have restrictive effects, making it difficult for students to maintain engagement levels comparable to those in face-to-face learning environments. Wang Yashuang et al. (2023) found in their research that physical environmental factors have an indirect impact on online learning engagement.

RESEARCH METHODS AND TOOLS This study uses a questionnaire for investigation. A scale is a tool used to measure specific variables or characteristics. Established scales are usually validated through practical application, providing significant reference value. Due to the lack of authoritative scales in existing research on online learning environments, this study constructs a research questionnaire through interviews and spatial scales.

Environmental Quality Satisfaction Measurement Tools This study uses spatial environment satisfaction to measure users’ feelings about online learning spaces. According to research by Schaufeli et al. (2002), learning activities share similarities with work activities in terms of role composition, allowing the MBI tool developed by Maslach et al. (1981) to retain its research value by substituting “learning”for “work.”Therefore, this study references established work space satisfaction scales for its research.

CBE Questionnaire for Occupant Survey This questionnaire is sourced from the Center for the Built Environment (CBE) at the University of California, Berkeley, and is widely used in empirical research on office spaces. The sample for the questionnaire is drawn from data on 351 different types of office buildings surveyed by CBE since 2000. This questionnaire provides a framework (such as lighting environment, acoustic environment, and air quality) for assessing spatial factors’ satisfaction and serves as a reliable survey tool for this study.

Composite Scales Newsham et al. (2009) developed this scale in their research on the impact of environmental satisfaction on job satisfaction, testing and expanding it based on the COPE (Cost-effective Open-Plan Environments) research model. The scale aims to explore the significant effects of satisfaction with environmental factors such as lighting, privacy, and furniture on job satisfaction. Most of the anticipated bivariate correlations in the study were significant and consistent in direction, indicating that overall environmental satisfaction is an important factor influencing job satisfaction. This suggests that the scale can serve as a reliable reference tool for the investigation in this study.

Learning Engagement Measurement Tools Online Student Engagement Scale The Online Student Engagement Scale (Dixson et al., 2015) is designed to measure student engagement in online learning environments. This scale

Online Learning Space Environment in Colleges and Universities 47

not only focuses on student behaviours but also encompasses multiple dimensions such as emotions, skills, and performance, providing a comprehensive tool for assessing student engagement.

QUESTIONNAIRE DESIGN Based on the review of previous literature, coding of interview texts, and the online learning engagement scale, the research dimensions for the subsequent questionnaire were defined. Grounded in the literature review and interview analysis, and referencing professional scales, this study has established the necessary measurement scale. Below is the overall structure of the scale and the indicators for each research variable.

Demographic Variable Information The basic information section primarily investigates two aspects. First, it collects demographic information about the participants, including gender and highest educational attainment. Second, it examines learners’ online learning behaviors, including preferences for learning environments and online learning equipment.

Table 1: Demographic variable information table.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Dimensions Questionnaire Items Demographic information Gender/Education level, etc. Learning Behavior Learning environment/Learning equipment, etc.

Online Learning Space Satisfaction Section Based on the CBE Questionnaire for Occupant Survey, the Composite scales, and interview analysis, the satisfaction section for online learning spaces is divided into three dimensions: environmental quality, spatial layout, and furniture and equipment.

Table 2: Online learning space satisfaction table.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Dimensions Questionnaire Items Environmental Quality Thermal Environmental Quality/Air Quality/Lighting Environmental Quality Spatial Layout Size of Storage Area/Size of Learning Area/

Interactivity with Others Furniture and Equipment Online Learning Equipment/Furniture in Online Learning Space/Decoration in Online Learning Space

Online Learning Engagement Scale Section Use the OSE Learning Engagement Scale to investigate students’ online learning engagement, exploring four dimensions: skill engagement, emotional engagement, interactive engagement, and performance engagement.

Table 3: Online student engagement scale.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

IEQ Dimensions Questionnaire Items Skills Study regularly/Stay up on reading, etc. Emotion Put forth effort/Find ways to make materials

relevant/Apply to my life, etc. Participation Have fun in online chats/Participate actively in forums, etc. Performance Do well on tests/Get good grades

In the questionnaire, each section uses a 5-point Likert scale, with levels ranging from 1 to 5, representing five levels of psychological feelings. A higher value indicates a greater degree. Generally, a score of 3.0 is defined as the average intensity value; higher scores indicate that respondents’ actual learning experiences are more aligned with the situations described in the questionnaire.

QUESTIONNAIRE DATA ANALYSIS After pre-questionnaire testing and expert review, a total of 120 questionnaires were collected in the formal survey. After excluding 9 invalid questionnaires and those from respondents who had not participated in online learning, 111 valid questionnaires remained, resulting in a valid response rate of 92.5%.

Reliability Analysis The reliability coefficients for each item in the scale exceed 0.9, with an overall reliability coefficient of 0.949, which is less than 0.950. This indicates that the questionnaire has high internal consistency, and each item can measure the same indicator from different dimensions. This proves the reliability of the questionnaire results, allowing for further in-depth analysis.

Validity Analysis Conduct KMO and Bartlett’s tests on the overall scale. A KMO value between 0.7 and 0.9 indicates that the research data is suitable for extracting information. A value less than 0.01 in Bartlett’s test indicates that the current analysis results are significant. When the significance P-value is less than 0.05 and the KMO value is greater than 0.6, it suggests that the data meets the requirements for factor analysis.

Table 4: Online learning space satisfaction table.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

KMO& Bartlett’s Test KMO 0.897 Bartlett’s Test p <0.01

Based on the rotated factor loading matrix, items with rotated factor coefficients greater than 0.5 are selected. Items on the same vertical axis are

Online Learning Space Environment in Colleges and Universities 49

considered to be in the same dimension, indicating that the factor dimensions align with the research’s predefined dimensions.

DESCRIPTIVE STATISTICAL ANALYSIS Demographic Variable Statistics

In the demographic variable statistics of the participant group, there are 50 males, accounting for 45%, and 61 females, accounting for 55%. All participants are college students, with undergraduates making up the majority at 62.2% of the total. Graduate students account for 30.6%, while those at the doctoral level or above make up 7.2%. Additionally, over 80% of participants reported engaging in discussions during classes, while those who have not participated in discussions comprise only 14.4%.

Learning Preference Statistics Online Learning Space The highest frequency of online learning occurs in dormitories, with a response rate of 29.1%, followed by home at 24.5%. The frequency for learning pods is the lowest, at only 1.8%. Interviews indicate that most students prefer spaces with a certain level of privacy and seclusion to meet the acoustic needs for online discussions. However, the usage frequency of learning pods that meet these needs is the lowest, indicating a need for further on-site research to understand more.

Table 5: Online learning space satisfaction table.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Learning Space Response Penetration Rate(%)

n Response Rate(%) Library 55 19.5 49.5 Café/Bookstore 19 6.7 17.1 Learning pod 5 1.8 4.5 Dormitory 82 29.1 73.9 Study area/Classroom 52 18.4 46.8 Home 69 24.5 62.2 Total 282 100 254.1

Learning Devices Among these, the proportion of computer users is the highest, while the proportion of smartphone users is the lowest. Additionally, feedback on online learning using other types of devices is very limited, so they will not be included in the study. Based on interviews, most students prefer to use computers as their primary device for online learning, while also using tablets and smartphones as supplementary learning tools.

Table 6: Online learning space satisfaction table.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Learning Devices Response Penetration rate(%)

n Response rate(%) Computer 101 50.8 91 Tablet 58 29.1 52.3 Smartphone 40 20.1 35 Total 199 100 179.3

DIFFERENTIAL STATISTICAL ANALYSIS Differences in Spatial Perception Based on Varying Learning Duration

In terms of spatial perception, the P-values for all dimensions are greater than 0.05, indicating no significant differences. However, the samples with online learning durations of 0–1 hour reported the lowest satisfaction with the online learning space, suggesting that the learning environment may have a significant impact on this group’s learning duration. Additionally, the overall satisfaction with spatial layout is lower than the other two dimensions, indicating that when optimizing online learning spaces, greater emphasis should be placed on designing the layout of the learning environment.

Table 7: Online learning space satisfaction table.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Learning Duration(h) M+SD F P Environmental Quality 0–1 3.434±0.867 2.557 0.059 2–3 3.595±0.699 3–4 4.000±0.625 >4 3.696±0.754 Spatial Layout 0–1 3.395±0.842 0.227 0.877 2–3 3.370±0.903 3–4 3.288±0.916 >4 3.583±0.684 Furniture and Equipment 0–1 3.569±0.909 0.505 0.680 2–3 3.692±0.829 3–4 3.852±0.625 >4 3.703±0.590

ONLINE LEARNING SPACE SURVEY AND STRATEGIES This study conducted an offline survey based on the public online learning spaces mentioned in the questionnaires and interviews. The spaces surveyed include the study area in the Zhengxin Building at Harbin Institute of Technology, seminar rooms, and library study pods. Observations were recorded over one day for each learning space, documenting student learning behaviors. Finally, optimization strategies for the functionality and overall spatial layout design of each type of space were developed based on the questionnaire data.

Online Learning Space Environment in Colleges and Universities 51

Table 8: Online learning space strategies.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Space Factor Analysis Optimization Strategies

Photos of Learning Space Space Name

1. Establish this type of space in underutilized public areas of the school, such as corridors 2. Install curtains, air conditioning, or fans to reduce direct sunlight and lower indoor temperatures 3. Install space dividers to reduce glare 4. Use smaller-sized tables and chairs, with modular tables that meet multifunctional needs to improve usage efficiency 5. Increase the number of lockers to meet storage needs 6. Increase the number of power outlets

Study area Frequency of Use: 52 people in the sample reported having used it; Vacancy Rate: Remains fully occupied throughout the day; Thermal comfort: With poor insulation and average comfort; Lighting: Good lighting, but there is glare; Storage Space: There are many lockers, but there are still many books placed on the seats; Furniture: Each set of tables and chairs can accommodate 4–6 people, but on average, three people use each table.And the furniture has a single function

Discussion

Space

1. Design seminar spaces in tiered segments of varying sizes to enhance usage efficiency 2. Increase the availability of such spaces or provide alternative spaces to meet students’ needs

Frequency of Use: 52 people in the sample reported having used it; Vacancy Rate: Advance reservation is required, and demand exceeds supply, but the number of users at one time rarely exceeds four; Thermal comfort: Indoor temperature can be adjusted, providing a high level of comfort; Lighting: Comfortable artificial lighting environment; Furniture: Fully equipped with screens, outlets, etc., and with partitions to minimize external disturbances

Continued

Table 8: Continued

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Space Factor Analysis Optimization Strategies

Photos of Learning Space Space Name Learning

Pod

1. Increase the number of study pods on campus; 2. Add curtains or blinds to enhance privacy 3. Regular maintenance to ensure the safety and hygiene of the space 4. Design a modular study pod that accommodates multiple users

Frequency of Use: people have used it in the sample; Vacancy Rate: Remains fully occupied throughout the day; Difficult to make a reservation; Thermal comfort: Indoor temperature can be adjusted, providing a high level of comfort; Lighting: Comfortable artificial lighting environment; Space functionality: Single- purpose, designed for use by one person only Furniture: Fully equipped with screens, outlets, etc., However, the partitions are transparent, providing no visual privacy

CONCLUSION

Online learning has become one of the mainstream methods of education in universities, and research on online learning spaces significantly impacts the effectiveness of online learning. This study proposes the following optimization strategies for online learning spaces from three perspectives: environmental quality, spatial layout, and furniture and equipment: Optimize the environmental quality of online learning spaces to ensure good sound, light, thermal conditions, and air quality; Ensure the rationality of the learning space layout by setting appropriate sizes for storage and work areas, providing suitable space for student interactions; Arrange suitable online learning equipment and reasonable space decoration, and enhance the maintenance and management of the space.

REFERENCES

Akpen, C. N., Asaolu, S., Atobatele, S. et al. Impact of online learning on student’s performance and engagement: A systematic review. Discov Educ 3, 205 (2024). Carlopio JR. Construct validity of a Physical Work Environment Satisfaction

Questionnaire. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology. 1996 Jul;1(3): 330–344. Cunyou Wang, Yaru Li, et al. Research on the Dimensions and Measurement Scale of College Students’Online Learning Engagement with Bilibili as an Example[J]. Chinese Journal of ICT in Education, 2025, 31(1):121–128. Dixson, M. D. 2015. “Measuring Student Engagement in the Online Course: The

Online Student Engagement Scale (OSE).” Online Learning 19, no. 4.

Online Learning Space Environment in Colleges and Universities 53

Hollister B, Nair P, Hill-Lindsay S, Chukoskie L. Engagement in online learning: Student attitudes and behavior during COVID-19. Front Educ. 2022;7:851019. Maslach, C. and S. E. Jackson: 1981, ‘The measurement of experienced burnout’,

Journal of Occupational Behaviour 2, pp. 99–113. Mosher, R, MacGowan, B. Assessing student engagement in secondary schools: Alternative conceptions, strategies of assessing, and instruments[R]. Boston: The University of Wisconsin Research and Development Center, 1985. Newsham G, Brand J, Donnelly C, et al. Linking indoor environment conditions to

job satisfaction: A field study[J]. Building Research & Information, 2009, 37(2): 129–147. SR Jimerson, E Campos, JL Greif. Toward an understanding of definitions and measures of school engagement and related terms[J]. California School Psychologist, 2003, (1): 7–27. Schaufeli W B, Salanova M, González-Romá V, et al. The measurement of

engagement and burnout: A two sample confirmatory factor analytic approach[J]. Journal of Happin ess studies, 2002, 3(1): 71–92. Tawarah H, Mahasneh M O, Shuaybat A W. Factors Affecting in Achievement of Universal Courses Objective by Using Distance Education during COVID-19 Pandemic[J]. Journal of Curriculum and Teaching, 2022, 11(8). Zhang Lin, Lu Hui. Analysis of the Current Status and Influencing Factors of

College Students’ Online Learning Engagement: An Empirical Study Based on SPSS Statistical Analysis[J]. Data, 2023(2): 170–172.

Cover of the proceedings volume Human Factors in Architecture, Sustainable Urban Planning and Infrastructure

Explore the complete digital volume

Human Factors in Architecture, Sustainable Urban Planning and Infrastructure

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-964867-67-0

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →