Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Methodologies For Determining Tariffs For Intermodal Cargo Transportation

Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1004105

Abstract

The article presents an analysis of tariffs for international freight traffic along the route Nur-Sultan station (Republic of Kazakhstan) - Mazare-Sharif station (Republic of Afghanistan). The freight charge is determined according to three existing methods for determining the freight charge: based on the Rail-Atlas and Rail-Tarif software package; Uniform Transit Tariff (UTT); International Transit Tariff (ITT). Calculations convincingly show the lowest tariffs for freight transportation, their availability for a wide range of railway customers. Moreover, the advantages of low-price tariffs are given in a tabular format, which creates convenience for users of railway services.

INTRODUCTION

To determine the freight charge, the tariff break method should be applied. The bottom line is that the freight charge is determined by the railways to the border stations. The starting point of shipment is the Nur-Sultan 1 station (Kazakhstan), and the final point is the Mazare-Sharif station (Afghanistan). Delivery of cargo is planned by rail transport on the rai- lways of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the Republic of Uzbekistan and the Republic of Afghanistan. To determine the freight charge for the transpor- tation of grain by rail, it is necessary to use the Rail-Atlas and Rail-Tariff methods.

To calculate the freight charge, it is necessary to take into account the transit distance between the crossing points for each country separately. Figure 1 shows the grain route from Nur-Sultan station to Mazare-Sharif station.

The next step is to use the Rail-Tariff program to determine the fare. It is planned to send wagons in universal wagons. The transported cargo is grain, the mass of cargo in one wagon is 65 tons, the type of rolling stock is a grain carrier with a carrying capacity of 65 tons, as well as the return of empty wagons to the departure station.

Equations and mathematical formulas are available in the original paper PDF.

© 2023. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 949

950 Kuanyshbayev

gde SKz – transit distance on the railways of the Republic of Kazakhstan, km; SUz – transit distance on the railways of the Republic of Uzbekistan, km; SAf – transit distance on the railways of the Republic of Afghanistan, km.

Figure 1: Freight train route, Nur-Sultan st. (Kazakhstan) - Mazare-Sharif st. (Afghanistan).
Original PDF Figure 1:
Figure 2: Freight train route, “Nur-Sultan1” st.- “Sary-Agash” st.
Original PDF Figure 2:
Table 1. Tariff for the transportation of wheat from “Nur-Sultan1” st. - “Sary-Agash” st.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Methodologies for Determining Tariffs for Intermodal Cargo Transportation 951

Figure 3: Freight train route, “Keles” st. - “Galaba” st.
Original PDF Figure 3:
Table 2. Tariff for the transportation of wheat, “Keles” st. - “Galaba” st..

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Figure 4: Freight train route, “Hairatan” st.- “Mazare-Sharif” st.
Original PDF Figure 4:

952 Kuanyshbayev

Table 3. Tariff for the transportation of wheat, “Hairatan” st.- “Mazare-Sharif” st.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Thus, the total distance is 2631 km from st. Nur-Sultan 1 to st. Mazare- Sharif (Table 4).

Table 4. Carriage charge for the carriage of wheat.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

№Country Start station End station Distance, km Freight charge, CHF 1 Kazakhstan Nur-Sultan1 Sary-Agash 1668,0 471,86 2 Uzbekistan Keles Galaba 882,0 2962,52 3 Afghanistan Hairatan Mazare- Sharif 81,0 598,0

ITO0O : 2631,0 4032,38

Knowing the freight charge for each country, it is necessary to find the total freight charge using formula 2.

Tsum = TKz + TUz + TAf, CHF (2) gde TKz – transport tariff on the railways of the Republic of Kazakhstan, CHF; TUz – transport tariff on the railways of the Republic of Uzbekistan, CHF; TAf – transport tariff on the railways of the Republic of Afghanistan, CHF.

Tsum = 471,86 + 2968,52 + 598 = 4032,38, CHF Determination of the Carriage Fee According to the Method of the Uniform Transit Tariff (UTT)

To determine the carriage charge, the charge for the carriage of loaded and empty wagons is summed up. The payment for the carriage of goods in a wagon is calculated by multiplying the tariff rate for one ton given in Table 2 by the number of tons of the estimated weight of the shipment. The fee for the return of empty wagons is calculated by multiplying the tariff rate for one axle given in Table 2 by the number of axles. The unit tariff rates for carri- age charges in CET are set in Swiss francs. When determining the tariff rate of payment for transportation, transit distances between the crossing points (border points) of the transit railway are taken into account. From Table 1, the transit distance between the points of transition along the railways of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the Republic of Uzbekistan and Afghanistan, respe- ctively, is 1668.0 km; 882.0 km; and 81.0 km. Additional information that is necessary when calculating the freight charge, it is established that grain belongs to the second class of cargo; - a grain carrier with a carrying capacity of 65 tons was chosen as a rolling stock (Table 5).

Methodologies for Determining Tariffs for Intermodal Cargo Transportation 953

Table 5. Tariff rates for the carriage of goods in wagons.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Tariff rate per axle

Distance, km Country Tariff rate for 1 ton in Swiss francs

in Swiss francs Cargo class

1 2 3

75-84 Afghanistan 3,60 1,80 3,96 875-884 Uzbekistan 40,50 20,30 43,46 1650-1749 Kazakhstan 78,30 39,20 83,91

where: Tgr. - tariff for the carriage of goods in a loaded wagon, CHF; f1t - unit tariff rate for 1 ton of transported cargo, CHF; Qv - carrying capacity of the rolling stock, 65t.

TKz

TKz

where TKz

por.- transport tariff for the return of an empty wagon in Kazakhstan, CHF; f 10 - tariff rate for 1 axle, CHF; n - is the number of axles.

TKz

TKz

rp + TK3

5op, CHF (5)

TKz

sum. = 2548 + 335,64 = 2883,64, CHF Thus, the freight charge on the railways of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Nur-Sultan 1 station - Sary-Agash station is 2883.64 CHF. Similarly, it is necessary to calculate the freight charge on the railways of the Republics of Uzbekistan and Afghanistan. The freight charge on the railways of the Republic of Uzbekistan for one wagon will be:

TUz

TUz

sum. = 1319,5 + 173,84 = 1493,34, CHF The freight charge on the railway of the Republic of Afghanistan for one wagon will be:

TAf

954 Kuanyshbayev

TAf

Carriage charge for transportation of a rolling stock unit along the route Nur-Sultan 1 st. (Republic of Kazakhstan) - Mazare-Sharif st. (Republic of Afghanistan) is presented in Table 6. It should be noted that the freight charge is determined according to the scheme with a tariff break.

Table 6. The total cost of transportation according to the method of the Uniform Transit Tariff for one wagon.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

№5/5 Country Freight charge, CHF

1 Kazakhstan 2883,64 2 Uzbekistan 1493,34 3 Afghanistan 132,84

TOTAL 4509,82

Determination of the Freight Charge According to the Methodology of the International Transit Tariff (ITT) The fee for the carriage of goods in a wagon is calculated by multiplying the corresponding tariff rate (Table 7) for the weight category of the shipment by the number of tons of the estimated mass of the shipment. The fee for the carriage of an empty wagon (after unloading or for loading) is calculated at the tariff rate of 0.10 Swiss francs per 1 axle-km.

Table 7. Tariff rates for the carriage of goods in wagons.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Distance, km Country Weight category 5t 10t 15t 20t Over 25t

v xvecapskih fpankah 81 - 90 Afghanistan 21,65 18,06 15,01 12,08 11,42 881 - 900 Uzbekistan 174,08 145,14 120,88 96,72 91,94 1654 - 1700 Kazakhstan 231,09 192,58 160,48 128,38 121,96

The fee for the carriage of goods in a wagon is calculated according to the following formula:

TKz

gde TKz

gr - tpanspoptny tapif za pepevozku gpunogo vagona po Kazahstanu, CHF; g - tapifna stavka za 1 tonnu, CHF; Qv - gpuzopodmnost~ zepnovoza, (65t).

TKz

TKz

Methodologies for Determining Tariffs for Intermodal Cargo Transportation 955 gde TKz por. - transport tariff for the return of an empty grain truck in

Kazakhstan, CHF; p - tariff rate for 1 axle, (0,10 CHF); m - number of axles; l - distance, km.

TKz

The next stage is the addition of the charge for the carriage of goods and the charge for the return of an empty wagon.

TKz

por., CHF (8)

Now it is necessary to determine the freight charge for a loaded and return of an empty grain carrier along the railways of the Republic of Uzbekistan and the Republic of Afghanistan (Table 8).

For the Republic of Uzbekistan: TUz

TUz

TAf

TAf

Table 8. The total cost of transportation for one wagon according to the method International Transit Tariff (ITT).

Table available in the original PDF paper.

№p/p Country Freight charge, CHF

1 Kazakhstan 8594,6 2 Uzbekistan 6328,9 3 Afghanistan 774,7

TOTAL 15698,2

Calculation of the Cost of Services of the Main Railway Network (MRN), Locomotive Traction (LT), Wagons and Containers (WC), Freight and Commercial Work (FCW) Tariffs for the services of the main railway network (MRN), locomotive tra- ction (LT),freight and commercial work (FCW),the use of freight wagons and containers (WC) are calculated separately. Costing is an extremely important parameter, the definition of which ensures a reduction in the cost of material and labor resources. Costing is the determination of the cost per unit of out- put. The cost price includes the following costs: wage fund, payroll, fuel, cost of materials and spare parts, etc. (Table 9).

956 Kuanyshbayev

Table 9. Costing for services main railway network (MRN).

Table available in the original PDF paper.

% Methodology № Name of cost elements Rail-Tariff UTT ITT

Value, CHF

Kazakh- stan

Uzbeki- stan

Kazakh- stan

Uzbeki- stan

Kazakh- stan

Uzbeki- stan

Afga- nistan

Afga- nistan

Afga- nistan

12 10,76 67,55 13,63 65,75 34,05 3,03 195,96 144,30 17,66

1 Payroll fund 25 22,41 140,72 28,41 136,97 70,93 6,31 408,24 300,62 36,80 2 Payroll accruals 4 3,59 22,52 4,54 21,92 11,35 1,01 65,32 48,10 5,89 3 Fuel 5 4,48 28,14 5,68 27,4 14,19 1,26 81,65 60,12 7,36 4 Materials and spare parts 5 Depreciation 12 10,76 67,55 13,63 65,75 34,05 3,03 195,96 144,30 17,66 6 Security labor 5 4,48 28,14 5,68 27,4 14,19 1,26 81,65 60,12 7,36 7 Overheads 8 7,17 45,03 9,09 43,83 22,70 2,02 130,64 96,20 11,78 8 Overhaul 15 13,45 84,43 17,04 82,18 42,56 3,79 244,95 180,37 22,08 9 Profitability 14 12,55 78,8 15,91 76,7 39,72 3,53 228,62 168,35 20,61 10 Total 100 89,65 562,88 113,62 547,89 283,73 25,24 1632,97 1202,49 147,19

Tariffs for the services of the Main Rail Network are 19%, for the services of Locomotive Traction - 23%, for the services of Wagons and Containers - 57% and for the services of Freight and Commercial Works - 1% of the freight rate of each country. Calculations are carried out according to each of the methods and each country separately.

According to the methodology using the Rail-Tariff software package, the freight charge on the railways of the Republic of Kazakhstan was determined, Nur-Sultan1 st.- Sary-Agash, st. which amounted to 471.86 CHF; on the railways of the Republic of Uzbekistan, Keles st. - Galaba st.- 2962.52 CHF; by railway of the Republic of Afghanistan, Hairatan st. - Mazare-Sharif st.- 598.0 CHF. According to the methodology of the Uniform Transit Tariff (UTT), the freight charge on the railways of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Nur-Sultan1 st. - Sary-Agash st., is 2883.64 CHF; on the railways of the Republic of Uzbe- kistan, Keles st.- Galaba st.- 1493.34 CHF; and for Afghanistan, Hairatan st. - Mazare-Sharif st.- 132.84 CHF.

According to the methodology of the International Transit Tariff (ITT), the freight charge in Kazakhstan, Nur-Sultan1 st. - Sary-Agash st., amounted to 8594.6 CHF; for Uzbekistan, Keles st. – Galaba st. freight charge amounted to 6328.9 CHF and in Afghanistan, Hairatan st. - Mazare- Sharif st.- 774.7 CHF. The calculation results are shown in Table 9.

MRN = 19% · T 100, CHF (9) Let’s determine the costs for the section of the Main Rail-Tariff, Main Railway Network (MRN):

Methodologies for Determining Tariffs for Intermodal Cargo Transportation 957

100 = 147,19, CHF “Live money” is the Remuneration Fund, payroll and profitability (Table 9). According to the method using the Rail-Tariff methodology, “live money” is 38.55 CHF in Kazakhstan; CHF 242.04 for Uzbekistan and CHF 48.86 for Afghanistan. Total “live money”- 329.45 CHF for the services of the IHC.

According to the methodology of the Uniform Transit Tariff (UTT) - 235.59 CHF in Kazakhstan; CHF 122.01 for Uzbekistan and CHF 10.85 for Afgha- nistan. In total, the total amount of “live money” for the services of the IHC is 368.45 CHF per wagon.

According to the methodology of the International Transit Tariff (MTT) - 702.18 CHF in Kazakhstan; CHF 517.07 for Uzbekistan and CHF 63.29 for Afghanistan. The total amount of “real money” under the Main Rail Network section for one wagon is 1282.54 CHF.

Now let’s make calculations of “live money” for the Locomotive Tra- ction (LT) service section, which make up 23% of the freight charge of each country, (Table 10).

Table 10. Costing for services locomotive traction (LT).

Table available in the original PDF paper.

% Methodology № Name of cost elements Rail-Tariff UTT ITT

Value, CHF

Kazakh- stan

Uzbeki- stan

Kazakh- stan

Uzbeki- stan

Kazakh- stan

Uzbeki- stan

Afga- nistan

Afga- nistan

Afga- nistan

10 10,85 68,14 13,75 66,32 34,35 3,05 197,68 145,56 17,82

1 Payroll fund 12 13,02 81,77 16,5 79,59 41,22 3,67 237,21 174,68 21,38 2 Payroll accruals 4 4,34 27,26 5,5 26,53 13,74 1,22 79,07 58,23 7,13 3 Fuel 22 23,88 149,9 30,26 145,91 75,56 6,72 434,89 320,24 39,2 4 Materials and spare parts 5 Depreciation 1 1,09 6,81 1,38 6,63 3,43 0,31 19,77 14,56 1,78 6 Security labor 0,6 0,65 4,09 0,83 3,98 2,06 0,18 11,86 8,73 1,07 7 Overheads 24,4 26,48 166,26 33,56 161,83 83,81 7,45 482,33 355,18 43,48 8 Overhaul 1 1,09 6,81 1,38 6,63 3,43 0,31 19,77 14,56 1,78 9 Profitability 25 27,13 170,34 34,39 165,81 85,87 7,64 494,19 363,91 44,55 10 Total 100 1632,97 681,38 137,54 663,24 343,47 30,55 1976,76 1455,65 178,18

958 Kuanyshbayev

“Live money” according to the method using the Rail-Tariff program is payroll, payroll and profitability. In total, they will give 44.5 CHF for Kaza- khstan; CHF 279.37 for Uzbekistan and CHF 56.39 for Afghanistan. Total “real money” - 380.26 CHF for Locomotive Traction (LT) services.

According to the methodology of the Uniform Transit Tariff (UTT) - 271.93 CHF per one wagon in Kazakhstan; CHF 140.83 for Uzbekistan and CHF 12.53 for Afghanistan.

According to the methodology of the International Transit Tariff (MTT), “real money” for one wagon in Kazakhstan is 810.47 CHF; in Uzbekistan - 592.82 CHF and in Afghanistan - 73.05 CHF. Thus, the total amount of “live money” under Locomotive Traction (LT) is 1480.34 CHF per wagon (Table 10).

Let’s imagine the calculations for determining the costs of the Wagons and Containers (WC) service, which make up 57% of the freight charge of each country.

Methodologies for Determining Tariffs for Intermodal Cargo Transportation 959 WCUz = 57% · 1493,34 100 = 852,20, CHF

100 = 441,579, CHF “Live money”is payroll, payroll and profitability. According to the method using the Rail- Tariff program “Live money” is 123.72 CHF in Kazakhstan; 776.78 CHF - in Uzbekistan; 156.79 CHF - for Afghanistan. Total “real money” for PV services is 1057.29 CHF.

According to the methodology of the Uniform Transit Tariff (UTT) - within Kazakhstan CHF; in Uzbekistan - 391.55 CHF and in Afghanistan - 34.83 CHF.

According to the methodology using the International Transit Tariff (ITT) - 2253.5 CHF in Kazakhstan; 1659.44 CHF - in Uzbekistan and 203.13 CHF - in Afghanistan for one wagon. If you sum up the “real money” for each country, you get 1182.47 CHF per wagon.

Thus, the total amount of “live money” under the section Freight and Commercial Work for one wagon is 4116.06 CHF (Table 11).

Table 11. Costing for services wagons and containers (WC).

Table available in the original PDF paper.

% Methodology № Name of cost elements Rail-Tariff UTT ITT

Value, CHF

Kazakh- stan

Uzbeki- stan

Kazakh- stan

Uzbeki- stan

Kazakh- stan

Uzbeki- stan

Afga- nistan

Afga- nistan

Afga- nistan

15 40,34 253,3 51,129 40,34 127,68 11,36 734,84 541,12 66,24

1 Payroll fund 22 59,17 371,5 74,9892 59,17 187,26 16,66 1077,76 793,64 97,15 2 Payroll accruals 2 5,37 33,77 6,8172 5,37 17,02 1,51 97,98 72,15 8,83 3 Fuel 6 16,13 101,32 20,4516 16,13 51,07 4,54 293,94 216,45 26,49 4 Materials and spare parts 5 Depreciation 10 26,89 168,86 34,086 26,89 85,12 7,57 489,89 360,75 44,16 6 Security labor 1 2,68 16,89 3,4086 2,68 8,51 0,76 48,99 36,08 4,42 7 Overheads 10 26,89 168,86 34,086 26,89 85,12 7,57 489,89 360,75 44,16 8 Overhaul 12 32,27 202,64 40,9032 32,27 102,14 9,08 587,87 432,89 52,99 9 Profitability 22 59,17 371,5 74,9892 59,17 187,26 16,66 1077,76 793,64 97,15 10 Total 100 268,96 1688,64 340,86 268,96 851,20 75,71 4898,92 3607,47 441,58

Freight and Commercial Work (FCW) costs are 1% of each country’s freight charge. Freight and Commercial Work (FCW) costs are 1% of each country’s freight charge.

960 Kuanyshbayev

The results of the calculations of “live money” in the section Cargo and Commercial work are presented in Table 12.

Table 12. Costing for services freight and commercial work (FCW).

Table available in the original PDF paper.

% Methodology № Name of cost elements Rail-Tariff ETT MTT

Value, CHF

Kazakh- stan

Uzbeki- stan

Kazakh- stan

Uzbeki- stan

Kazakh- stan

Uzbeki- stan

Afga- nistan

Afga- nistan

Afga- nistan

35 1,65 10,37 2,09 10,09 5,23 0,46 30,08 22,15 2,71

1 Payroll fund 22 1,04 6,52 1,32 6,34 3,29 0,29 18,91 13,92 1,70 2 Work with documents

10 0,47 2,96 0,6 2,88 1,49 0,13 8,59 6,33 0,77

3 Technical organization

4 Informing clients 5 0,24 1,48 0,3 1,44 0,75 0,07 4,30 3,16 0,39 5 Making deeds, etc. 28 1,32 8,3 1,67 8,074 4,18 0,37 24,06 17,72 2,17 6 Total 100 4,72 29,63 5,98 28,8364 14,93 1,33 85,95 63,29 7,75

“Live money” under the section “Cargo and commercial work” is the payroll fund (PAY). According to the methodology using the Rail-Tariff pro- gram - 1.04 CHF in Kazakhstan; 6.52 CHF - in Uzbekistan; 1.32 CHF - for Afghanistan. The total value of “live money” for the services of Freight and Commercial Work (GC) is 8.88 CHF per wagon.

According to the methodology of the Uniform Transit Tariff (UTT) - 6.34 CHF in Kazakhstan; CHF 3.29; in Uzbekistan and 0.29 CHF in Afghanistan. The total amount will be - 9.92 CHF “live money” per wagon.

According to the methodology of the International Transit Tariff (ITT) - 18,908 CHF in Kazakhstan; CHF 13.92 for Uzbekistan and CHF 1.70

Methodologies for Determining Tariffs for Intermodal Cargo Transportation 961 for Afghanistan. Thus, the total amount of “live money” is 34.54 CHF per wagon.

Summary and Comparative Analysis of Methodologies for Determining Freight Charges To determine the fare from Nur-Sultan 1 station to Mazare-Sharif station, three methods were used: based on the Rail-Tariff and Rail-Atlas software package; methods of the Common Transit Tariff (ETT); methodology of the International Transit Tariff (MTT). Now let’s compare the freight charges for each of the methods and identify the most cost-effective of them for organizing the transportation of grain from the Nur-Sultan 1 station (Repu- blic of Kazakhstan) to the Mazare Sharif station (Republic of Afghanistan). We present a comparative analysis of the indicators of the freight charge in Table 13.

Table 13. Comparative analysis of freight transportation methods.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Methodology Country Name of service Total Total amount Main Rail Network

Locomo- tive Traction

Wagons and Containers

Freight and Comme- rcial Work Rail-Tariff Kazakhstan 89,65 108,53 268,96 4,72 471,858 4032,38 Uzbekistan 562,88 681,38 1668,64 29,63 2962,52 Afghanistan 113,62 137,54 340,86 5,98 598,0 UTT Kazakhstan 547,89 663,24 1643,67 28,84 2883,64 4509,82 Uzbekistan 283,73 343,47 852,2 214,93 1694,33 Afghanistan 25,24 30,55 75,7 1,32 132,81 ITT Kazakhstan 1632,97 1979,76 4898,92 85,95 8597,6 15698,2 Uzbekistan 1202,49 1455,65 3607,47 63,29 6328,9 Afghanistan 147,19 178,18 441,58 7,75 774,7

Thus, the most economical way to transport cargo is the method that uses the Rail-Tariff program. The freight charge is 4032.38 CHF per wagon. In second place is the CTT method with a freight charge of CHF 4509.82 per wagon, and the most expensive transportation method is the MTT method with a freight charge of CHF 15698.2 per wagon. Table 14 provides a matrix that shows the difference in freight charges between different methods.

Table 14. Economic efficiency matrix.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Methodology Rail-Tariff, CHF UTT, CHF ITT, CHF ITT, CHF 11665,82 11188,38 - UTT, CHF 477,44 - - Rail-Tapif, CHF - - -

Thanks to this matrix, we can conclude: how much money can be saved per wagon. Table 11 shows that by choosing the Rail-Tariff method, CHF 11,668.82 can be saved compared to the MTT method; 477.44 CHF - in relation to the method using ETT. The next cost effective method is the ETT

962 Kuanyshbayev

method. In this case, you can save 11188.38 CHF compared to the method using MTT. And the most uneconomically effective method is the method using MTT. The next step is to compare “live money” between countries and different methods (Table 15).

Table 15. Comparative analysis of “live money”.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Methodology Country Name of service Total Total amount Main Rail Network

Locomo- tive Traction

Wagons and Containers

Freight and Comme- rcial Work Rail-Tarif Kazakhstan 38,55 44,5 123,72 1,04 207,81 1775,84 Uzbekistan 242 279,37 776,78 6,52 1304,67 Afghanistan 48,86 56,39 156,79 1,32 263,36 UTT Kazakhstan 235,59 271,93 756,09 6,34 1269,95 1986,13 Uzbekistan 122,01 140,83 391,55 3,29 657,68 Afghanistan 10,85 12,53 34,83 0,29 58,5 ITT Kazakhstan 702,18 810,47 2253,5 18,91 3785,06 6909,48 Uzbekistan 517,07 592,82 1659,44 13,92 2783,25 Afghanistan 63,29 73,05 203,13 1,7 341,17

“Live money”in the method using the Rail-Tariff program is 1775.84 CHF in total; according to the ETT method - 1986.13 CHF; according to the MTT method - 6909.48 CHF. Their value depends on the freight charge for the carriage of goods. Thus, thanks to the performed comparative analysis, it was concluded that the most cost-effective method of freight transportation is the method using the Rail-Tariff software package, the amount of “live money” is 1775.84 CHF per wagon.

REFERENCES

INTERNATIONAL RAILWAY TRANSIT FARE (ITT) is valid from January 01, 1997 (as amended and supplemented as of January 1, 2022). Tariff 8100. Official publication. OSJD Committee, Warsaw. Software package Rail-Atlas, Rail-Tariff. Nur-Sultan, Republic of Kazakhstan. UNIFIED TRANSIT FARE (UTT) is valid from July 01, 1991 (as amended and

supplemented as of January 1, 2020). Official publication. OSJD Committee, Warsaw.

Cover of the proceedings volume Human Interaction & Emerging Technologies (IHIET 2023): Artificial Intelligence & Future Applications

Explore the complete digital volume

Human Interaction & Emerging Technologies (IHIET 2023): Artificial Intelligence & Future Applications

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-87-2

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →