Andrew Ebekozien, Clinton Aigbavboa (2022). Early Impact of COVID-19 on Private Sector Income Earners Homeownership Delivery in Nigerian Cities: Issues and Possible Solutions. In: Human Factors in Architecture, Sustainable Urban Planning and Infrastructure. AHFE Open Access, vol. 58, pp. 213–221. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1002354
Studies showed that the private sector positively influences the country’s economic growth. The Nigerian Government housing policies and programmes tailored towards homeownership may not have favoured the private sector. The COVID-19 crisis might have compounded the issue. There are scarce studies concerning private sector income earners’ (PSIE) homeownership in the COVID-19 era. Therefore, the paper investigated the perceived early negative impacts of COVID-19 on PSIE and proffered measures to improve homeownership across Nigerian cities. Given the unexplored dimension of the issue, a qualitative research method was employed via virtual interviews. Thirty semi-structured virtual interviews were conducted with knowledgeable participants across Nigeria. Each geo-political zone was represented, and saturation was achieved. The researchers collated the data and thematically analysed them. Findings show that housing policies and programmes are pro-public sector homeownership. Also, it reveals that the private sector businesses are worse hit by the COVID-19 pandemic. Findings will offer a rich insight into the influence of COVID-19 on PSIE and contribute towards informing key stakeholders, especially government, to revamp housing policies and programmes towards private sector homeownership in Nigeria’s cities.
The housing development is one of the essential programmes for coun- tries with a growing population. Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights acknowledges the entitlement to good shelter (United Nati- ons General Assembly, 1968; United Nations, 2016). It is an entitlement to an acceptable standard of the living component. Globally, accelerated and inclu- sive housing development and delivery can revitalise the national economy (Adenuga, 2021). Statistics as of 2011 revealed that not below 1 billion peo- ple live in rickety houses (United Nations-Habitat, 2011). This is of concern to stakeholders. Globally, by 2050, an estimated 68% population will be
residents in cities. Africa and Asia would take about 90% of the new addi- tion (United Nations, 2018). Hence, the Nigerian Governments attempted in the past to provide affordable and accessible housing to the people through several policies and programmes (Ebekozien et al., 2021a). These policies and programmes were tailored towards homeownership may not have favoured the private sector. The COVID-19 crisis for the past two years might have compounded the issue (Alharbi, 2021). The author found that in Saudi Ara- bia, many citizens on housing mortgages during the COVID-19 era failed to meet up with their monthly obligation regarding repayment. Chetty et al. (2020) asserted that employment rates reduced by 37% around mid-April 2020, during the COVID-19 recession. Homeownership debate has been a global discussion because of its impor- tance to humanity. Studies have shown that city locations house majority of the population (Meerow et al., 2016). Also, studies have shown that 1.2 bil- lion estimated persons residents in rented houses (Gilbert, 2016). There is a gap between the housing demand and supply in cities. The developing countries might be the worse hit. Majority of people in developing cities are working to become homeowners. They see house ownership as a form of insu- rance and a reliable social net to make their future safer (Abdul-Aziz et al., 2018). Homeownership signifies the prosperity of the medium/low-income category in developing countries (World Bank, 2018), including Nigeria. Kamal et al. (2019) corroborated Abdul-Aziz et al. (2018) and asserted that homeownership is prosperity making and states the people’s achievements. It was discovered that the low-income Malaysians see homeownership as a form of a reliable social net to protect against financial suffering when the need arises (Abdul-Aziz et al. 2018). Alan (2017) affirmed that Hong Kong and Singapore are among the countries with commendable housing policies. This is because the government plays a significant part in housing development and ensure a sufficient supply. In Austria, not less than 62% of Vienna’s inhabitants live in government homes (Forrest, 2018). Homeo- wnership is vital in government housing policies and programmes, but the COVID-19 crisis may endanger the goal.
In Nigeria, the private sector is expected to contribute about US$114.2 billion in investment opportunities to the United Nations sustainable develo- pment goals (SDGs). The US114.2 billion is from the US$10 trillion global opportunities in emerging markets on or before 2030 (Egene, 2020). Okobi (2021) reported that governments needed the support of the private sector to actualise 2030 SGDs. It indicates that the private sector is key as a sta- keholder in realising SDGs 2030. Yet, there are no significant policies and programme evidence from the various governments (federal, state, and cou- ncil) to improve the private sector employees’ homeownership. Examples of housing policies and programmes include the Federal Integrated Staff Hou- sing Programme (FISH-P), My Own Home, and National Prototype Housing Programme. Others are Presidential Housing Mandate Scheme (PMHS), National Housing Policy, National Housing Programme, National Housing Fund, among others (Ebekozien, 2021). Majority of the requirements to be qualified for these programmes are tailored towards public employees. For example, the latter author affirmed that the FISH-P focused on federal
Early Impact of COVID-19 on Private Sector Income Earners Homeownership Delivery 215
government employees. The programme is private sector driven (Jumbo- Asukwo, 2018) and might be expensive for medium/low-income earners. The COVID-19 crisis might complicate the repayment scheme for a few inten- ding house owners on the mortgage (Alharbi, 2021), Nigeria not excluded. Government needs to lead in housing provision for nations that have recor- ded success in mass housing provision. Examples of the government leads are Hong Kong, Austria, Singapore, and Malaysia (Ebekozien, 2021). This includes land subsidies in urban location for the masses, housing loan, grants, subsidies, and direct construction at fair prices. Majority of these attributes are absent. The few that might be available are not affordable and accessible to the Nigerian medium/low-income earners.
The Nigerian economy was not exempted from the COVID-19 pande- mic hit. When the country was attempting to ‘bounce back’ from the 2016 economic recession, the COVID-19 crisis erupted. It was reported that Prof Osibanjo’s panel predicted that 39.4 million Nigerians might lose their jobs because of the COVID-19 problem (Madueke et al., 2020). The most hit may be employees in the private sector because majority of their businesses were shot-down. Many staff were placed on redundancy and some on half-month salary for the crisis period (Ebekozien and Aigbavboa, 2021). Private sector homeownership is one sub-sector that the pandemic might have hit. Glo- bally, the COVID-19 crisis has worsened homeownership for many, including Nigeria’s PSIE. Among the measures that have been adopted globally include forbearance (Blakeley, 2021), refinancing mortgage (Ettman et al. 2021), pay- ment relief (Amromin, 2020), among others, to assist intending homeowners to ensure they meet their mortgage payments obligation. There is insufficient evidence from the reviewed literature that the Nigerian Governments have considered these possible solutions. Hence, they are worth investigating so that SDGs associated with housing may be accomplished. The perceived abse- nce of government support tailored towards PSIE homeownership in Nigeria is an old issue that persists. The COVID-19 crisis may have compounded the issue. This may be a danger to accessible PSIE homeownership in Nigeria and, by extension, might affect the SDGs associated with housing provision. There are scarce studies concerning PSIE homeownership in the COVID-19 era. Thus, the paper investigated the perceived impacts of COVID-19 concer- ning lockdown on PSIE and proffered possible measures to improve PSIE homeownership. The stated objectives below will be used to achieve the aim of the paper: i. To investigate the perceived influence of Covid-19 on private sector income earners’ homeownership. ii. To suggest possible measures to improve private sector income earners’ homeownership.
RESEARCH METHOD Findings from the preliminary investigation guided the researchers to adopt a phenomenological qualitative research design. It is in line with Creswell and Creswell (2018). The authors affirmed that the approach could be adopted
216 Ebekozien and Aigbavboa
Table 1. Description of the participants background.
when research gain a novel of the underlying issues. Phenomenology deri- ves the meaning of a phenomenon via questioning a small group of people (Paley, 2016). In this instance, it was employed to investigate experts’ opini- ons regarding the impacts of Covid-19 on PSIE homeownership in Nigerian cities. The virtual interviews were complemented with the reviewed lite- rature. Concerning the utilised purposeful sampling method, the research targeted interviewees who are considered well-informed (Marshall and Ros- sman, 2006), as presented in Table 1. For a better representation, five cities across Nigeria were engaged. The study obscured the participants’ identities for confidentiality reasons and aligned with Ebekozien (2021). The virtual interview lasted 45 minutes on average via Zoom and Whatsapp calls.
The semi-structured questions answer the study’s objectives. The resea- rchers adopted a theme technique for the data analysis. Thirty interviewees (P1 to P30) indicated interest and were engaged across Nigerian five cities (Kano, Abuja, Onitsha, Port Harcourt, and Lagos) from September 2021 to December 2021. It is in line with Ebekozien et al. (2021a). The authors asser- ted that Kano and Lagos have the highest population in the northern and southern cities. The collected data were analysed via thematic analysis. The study achieved saturation. The study coded the collected data (Corbin and Strauss 2015, Jaafar et al. 2021). Sixty-two codes emerged from the coding and categorised into seven categories. From the seven categories, two themes emerged.
FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION The section presents results and discussion as emerged from the study.
Theme 1: Perceived Influence of Covid-19 Majority of medium/low-income earners in developing countries, a case study of Nigeria, see homeownership as an alternative to a good insurance and a reliable social net to guard and aid better future life. Findings agree with World Bank (2018). The author avowed that homeownership signifies the prosperity of the medium/low-income category in developing countries.
Early Impact of COVID-19 on Private Sector Income Earners Homeownership Delivery 217
Despite the relevance of homeownership, findings reveal that majority of the homeownership policies and programmes have been targeted at PSIE against regular income earners. In advanced countries, housing policies and program- mes are all-inclusive and accessible to ordinary and regular income earners (P13, P20, P24, P27, & P29). Participant P20 says, “…. why must Nige- rian Government ways of doing things be different from what is obtainable in other clans? Are we not entitled to a home of our own? Don’t PSIE pay taxes to government? Why is it that majority of the policies such FISH-P, My Own Home, PMHS, among others, exclude PSIE technically….?” Findings agree with Ebekozien (2021). It was found that FISH-P, to correct past errors, is private sector driven and focused on federal government staff.
Increased financial vulnerability, rising foreclosures, possible increase in homelessness, and eviction because of job losses emerged as the major percei- ved impact of Covid-19 on PSIE homeownership. Others are increased rental housing (P13, P17, P22, & P27), financial instability (P9, P14, P22, P26, P28, & P30), a threat to SDGs associated with housing delivery (P1 & P4), and danger to monetary policy (P6, P7, P11, & P15). Findings show that these issues are linked with the private sector’s income earners in Nigeria. The results agree with Sidawi (2014). The author advised policymakers and mort- gage institutions to consider the requests of the medium/low-income group when it comes to housing loans to meet their housing demands. Participant P27 says, “….before the COVID-19 pandemic, we were planning to buy 50 plots of land via the staff welfare scheme but was put on hold because the company is facing some challenges because of the pandemic crisis. Also, some staffers have been either sacked while others are placed on redundancy. We are still trying to recover from the COVID-19 shock that almost liqua- ted our company ….” Results align with Wong et al. (2021). It was found that the COVID-19 has increased the underemployment rate in the hotel employees’.
Theme 2: Possible Measures to Improve PSIE Homeownership Findings show that the current Nigerian housing policies and programmes and the COVID-19 crisis are threats to PSIE homeownership and might affect SDGs associated with housing. Findings reveal that policies and programmes have not been friendly to the PSIE homeownership, but corporate and indi- vidual efforts were tailored towards PSIE homeownership. The pandemic is threatening these efforts. Thus, this sub-section presents the proposed feasi- ble measures to improve PSIE homeownership in developing countries, using Nigeria as a case study. Government agencies to assist PSIE to access low mortgage rates via policy and programme tailored to PSIE homeownership, payment relief to help homeowners, refinancing mortgages, financial coun- selling, and forbearance emerged as the major possible measures to improve PSIE homeownership. Others are rental housing programme (P4, P8, P12, & P15), offer incentives to mortgage institutions (P1, P6, P10, P15, & P20), unemployment insurance schemes (PP7, P9, P14, P20, & P23), and govern- ment instrument as guarantor for PSIE (P9, P16, P19, P22, P24, P28 & P30). The rental housing programme should be encouraged and target PSIE with
218 Ebekozien and Aigbavboa
irregular sources of income to have access to affordable shelter to rent (P3, P13, & P26).
Concerning refinancing mortgages and forbearance as major possible mea- sures, the latter is one approach mortgagors can use to make up the missed payments through housing loans payment relief. The outcome might miti- gate or annul for a limited duration. Mortgage institutions should use a refinancing mortgages mechanism. It could be cash-out as an alternative mechanism to improve housing funds. The outcome would increase the cha- nces of paying back housing loans when due. It would mitigate the impact of interrupted income like the PSIE. Findings show that the absence of policy and programme to improve homeownership for the sector that drives the eco- nomy is not satisfactory. Policymakers should focus on PSIE homeownership. It is germane and cannot be over-emphasised. “…mortgage institutions and investors should be motivated by the government to invest in housing develo- pment. Also, more emphasis should be on PSIE homeownership. It allows for bridging the gap between the private and public sectors homeownership that has been created over the years….” said Participant P9. Findings recommend a vibrant collaboration between the government and private sector in housing provision for the PSIE to improve their homeownership. The call for colla- boration would enhance the intentions of some private sector attempting to provide homes for their staff via welfare schemes (P3, P9, P23, P27, & P29). Findings agree with Alan (2017), Forrest (2018), Jha (2018), and Ebekozien (2021). The latter author suggested a comprehensive policy driving private sector housing mortgage programmes and improved housing loans schemes to intending PSIE homeowners. Alan (2017) affirmed that Hong Kong and Singapore’s housing policies were successful because the government plays a significant part in housing development. Also, as evidence that government plays a significant role, Forrest (2018) affirmed that in Austria, not less than 62% of Vienna’s inhabitants reside in government homes. Jha (2018) asser- ted that homeownership is a vital part of Singapore’s government housing policies and programmes, with over 80% of the citizens in government- built houses. “….. PSIE needs to join the unemployment insurance scheme to save them during COVID-19. Experience of inability to repay mortgage because of job loss will not occur if a worker is a subscriber with a registered unemployment insurance scheme…..” said Participant P9. This aligns with Hsu et al. (2018). The authors discovered that joblessness insurance disallo- wed 1.3 million foreclosures throughout the Great Recession. Also, it might enhance the stabilisation of the property market within a reasonable period.
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS This paper investigated the perceived impact of Covid-19 and proffered mea- sures to improve PSIE homeownership across Nigerian cities. Data were collected from 30 experts in five cities. The limitation was overcome with the supplemented reviewed literature. If not checked, the perceived impacts of COVID-19 were identified and could hinder PSIE homeownership. The paper recommended possible measures to improve PSIE homeownership in the five cities and, by extension, across Nigeria. Findings could be adapted by
Early Impact of COVID-19 on Private Sector Income Earners Homeownership Delivery 219
other developing countries with similar challenges, considering, he political, social, and cultural background of Nigeria. Therefore, the study suggested the following measures to improve PSEI homeownership in Nigerian cities.
i. The study recommends a comprehensive policy to drive private sector housing mortgage programmes and improved housing loans to inten- ding PSIE homeowners. The proposed approach should be all-inclusive, including mutual collaboration between the public and private sectors in housing provision. The government has a vital part to play for this to be fruitful. The PSIE needs a special policy drive to bridge the homeow- nership gap between the public and private sectors homeownership. The institutional framework to achieve this is inevitable. ii. The paper recommends a mortgage refinancing mechanism as a better option to improve on the available funds to settle housing loans through cash-out. The possible outcome is that it would mitigate the impact of disrupted income during crisis-era like the pandemic and improve homeownership by extension. iii. The paper suggests that intending homeowners should be engaged in financial counselling and management. Becoming a house owner requires some level of financial discipline as an income earner.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Special thanks to the participants for providing scholarly contributions to enhance the findings of this paper. Also, the authors appreciate the comments, suggestions, and recommendations provided by the anonymous reviewers, which collectively helped hone and strengthen the quality of this manuscript during the blind peer-review process.
FUNDING Faculty of Engineering and the Built Environment and CIDB Centre of Excellence (05-35-061890), University of Johannesburg, South Africa.
REFERENCES
Abdul-Aziz, A-R., Tah, J.H.M., Olanrewaju, A.L. and Ahmed, A.U. (2018). The nexus between government and private developers in Malaysian housing sector. In U. Sengupta, & A. Shew (Eds.), Country of age: Trends and issues in housing in Asia cities (1st ed., pp. 110–136). London, United Kingdom: Routledge. Adenuga, A. (2021, October 25). FG, Lagos partner to boost housing sector.
Punch Newspaper, Retrieved from https://punchng.com/fg-lagos-partner-to- boost- housing- sector/ Alan, T. (2017, October 14). Move forward with affordable housing. The Star Online. Retrieved from https://www.thestar.com.my/business- news/2017/10/14/move Alharbi, R.K. (2021). Early impact of Covid-19 on private sector employees finance homeownership in Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. International Journal of Housing Markets and Analysis, Vol. ahead-of-print No. ahead-of-print. https://doi.org/10. 1108/IJHMA-08-2021-0093
220 Ebekozien and Aigbavboa
Amromin, G. (2020). Helping homeowners during the Covid-19 pandemic: Lessons from the great recession. The Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, Vol. 443, pp. 1–9. doi.10.21033/cfl-2020.443 Blakeley, G. (2021). Financialization, real estate and COVID-19 in the UK. Commu-
nity Development Journal, Vol. 56 Nos. 1, pp. 79–99. doi:10.1093/cdj/bsaa056 Chetty, R., Friedman, J.N., Hendren, N., Stepner, M. and The Opportunity Insights Team. (2020). How did COVID-19 and stabilisation policies affect spending and employment? A new real-time economic tracker based on private sector data (pp. 1–109). Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research. Corbin, J. and Strauss, A. (2015). Basics of qualitative research: Techniques and
procedures for developing grounded theory (4th ed.). Thousand Oaks, California: Sage. Creswell, J.W. and Creswell, D.J. (2018). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches (5th ed.). London, United Kingdom: Sage. Ebekozien, A. (2021). A qualitative approach to investigate low-cost housing policy
provision in Edo State, Nigeria. International Planning Studies, Vol. 26 Nos. 2, pp. 165–181. doi.10.10.1080/13563475.2020.1779671 Ebekozien, A., Abdul-Aziz, A-R. and Jaafar, M. (2021a). Low-cost housing policies and squatters in Nigeria: The Nigerian perspective on possible solutions. Inter- national Journal of Construction Management, Vol. 21 Nos. 11, pp. 1088–1098. doi.10.1080/15623599.2019.1602586. Ebekozien, A., Ayo-Odifiri, O.S., Nwaole, C.N.A., Ibeabuchi, L.A. and Uwadia, E.F.
(2021b). Barriers in Nigeria’s public hospital green buildings implementation initiatives. Journal of Facilities Management. doi. 10.1108/JEM-01-2021-0009. Ebekozien, A and Aigbavboa, C. (2021). Covid-19 recovery for the Nigerian construction sites: The role of the fourth industrial revolution technologies. Sustainable Cities and Society, Vol. 69, pp. 1-10. doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2021.102803 Egene, G. (2020, January 22). Nigeria presents $114bn SDGs private sector investment opportunity. Thisday Newspaper, Retrieved from https://www.thisdaylive.com/index.php/2020/01/22/nigeria-presents-114bn-sdgs -private-sector-investment-opportunity/ Ettman, C.K., Abdalla, S.M., Cohen, G.H., Sampson, L., Vivier, M.P., and
Galea, S. (2021). Low assets and financial stressors associated with higher depres- sion during COVID-19 in a nationally representative sample of US adults”, J. Epidemiol Community Health, Vol. 75, pp. 501–508. doi:10.1136/jech- 2020- 215213 Forrest, A. (2018). Vienna’s affordable housing paradise. Huffpost. Retrieved from https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/vienna-affordable-housing- para- dise_us_5b4e0b12e4b0b15aba88c7b0 Gilbert, A. (2016). Rental housing: The international experience. Habitat Internati-
onal, Vol. 54 Nos. 3, pp. 173–181. Hsu, J.W., Matsa, D.A. and Melzer, B.T. (2018). Unemployment insurance as a housing market stabiliser. American Economic Review, Vol. 108 Nos. 1, pp. 49–81. Jaafar, M., Ebekozien, A. and Mohamad, D. (2021). Community participation in
environmental sustainability: A case study of proposed Penang Hill Biosphere Reserve, Malaysia. Journal of Facilities Management. doi.10.1108/JEM-03-2021- 0033 Jha, A. (2018). But what about Singapore? Lessons from the best public housing programme in the world. The World Bank. Retrieved from blogs.worldbank.org/ sustainablecities/what-about-singapore-lessons-from
Early Impact of COVID-19 on Private Sector Income Earners Homeownership Delivery 221
Jumbo-Asukwo, F. (2018). Winifred Oyo-Ita, Freda Prempeh provides solution to fix housing deficit. Todayng. Retrieved from https://www.today.ng/news/nigeria/wini fred-oyo-ita-freda-prempeh-solution-housing-deficit-134848 Kamal, M.E., Hassan, H., Osmadi, A. and Fattah, A.H. (2019). Government
and homeownership: The Penang scenario. Pulau Pinang, Malaysia: Penerbit Universiti Sains Malaysia. Madueke, O., Iheonu, A. and Emmanuel, E.O. (2020). Post covid-19 pandemic Nigeria: Implications for good governance and development. Journal of Public Administration and Social Welfare Research, Vol. 5 Nos. 2, pp. 43–54. Marshall, C. and Rossman, G.B. (2006). Designing Qualitative Research, 4th ed..
Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA. Meerow, S., Newell, P.J. and Stults, M. (2016). Defining urban resilie- nce: A review. Landscape and Urban Planning, Vol. 147, pp. 38–49. doi.org/10.1016/j.landurbanplan.2015.11.011 Okobi, S. (2021, October 16). Private sector crucial in actualising SDGs in 2030, says don. Thisday Newspaper, Retrieved from https://www.newsheadlines.com. ng/thisday-newspapers-headlines-news-today/2021/10/16/private-sector-crucial -in-actualising-sdgs-in-2030-says-don/ Paley, J. (2016). Phenomenology as Qualitative Research: A Critical Analysis of
Meaning Attribution. Routledge, Abingdon, Oxon. Sidawi, B. (2014). An evaluation of the performance of the housing finance system in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. International Journal of Housing Markets and Analysis, Vol. 7 Nos. 2, pp. 156–174. United Nations (2016). Urbanisation and development: emerging future world cities
report. United Nations, New York, NY. United Nations (2018). United nations: department of economics and social affairs.
New York: United Nations, available at: www.un.org/development/desa/en/news/ population/2018-revision-of-world-urbanisation-prospects.html United Nations General Assembly (1968). Index to proceedings of the general assembly. United Nations General Assembly, New York, NY. United Nations-Habitat (2011). Affordable land and housing in Asia. Nairobi,
Kenya, United Nations. Wong, A.K.F., Kim, S.S., Kim, J. and Han, H. (2021). How the COVID-19 pandemic affected hotel Employee stress: Employee perceptions of occupational stressors and their consequences. International Journal of Hospitality Management, Vol. 93, 102798. World Bank. (2018, February 2). Housing finance. The World Bank. Retrieved from
Human Factors in Architecture, Sustainable Urban Planning and Infrastructure
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-34-6
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional