Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Beyond the Classroom: A Case Study of Higher Education Internship Support for Industrial Design Students

1 University of Kansas, Lawrence, KS 66045, USA ↗
2 University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY 40506, USA ↗
3 Western Michigan University, Kalamazoo, MI 49008, USA ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1005391

Abstract

This paper presents a case study that investigates the organizational structure and support mechanisms provided by industrial design programs at three comprehensive universities for student internship placements. The ultimate goal of the study is to evaluate the success of each program. Internships serve as a pivotal component in preparing students for the professional landscape, offering a practical bridge between academic knowledge and real-world application. Existing research suggests that students engaged in internships are more likely to secure employment in their chosen field (Binder, Bagueley, Crook, and Miller, 2014). However, the strategies and institutional support contributing to high participation rates in quality internships remain inadequately understood.Internships are valuable for students’ resumes because they offer an immersive experience of work culture, design methods, and a range of professional environments. While academic coursework primarily focuses on core skill sets and theoretical knowledge, internships play a pivotal role in cultivating soft skills, fostering an understanding of professional expectations, and providing insights into the practical realities of the field. Internships bridge the gap between academic learning and professional expectations, equipping students with a holistic skill set for their future careers.The study focuses on three 4-year comprehensive universities in our country, aiming to assess the range of strategies employed by each institution in supporting their students in securing internships. The variables under scrutiny include the impact of institutional support structures, the maturity of the industrial design program, availability of mentorship programs, access to alumni in the field, prioritization of internships in the program, and level of faculty engagement. A mixed-methods approach was used in this research to evaluate the success of internship structures at the three institutions. Quantitative data was collected through a survey administered at three separate 4-year industrial design programs in our country, including current 2nd year, 3rd year, 4th year, and graduated students from the prior year (n=117). Qualitative data was gathered through semi-structured interviews of 9 students, representing 3 from each institution. These interviews focused on how institutions did or did not participate in students' search for an industrial design internship. This investigation serves as a model for subsequent research involving a broader range of institutions and internship experiences.

INTRODUCTION

Internships play a pivotal role in preparing students for full-time employment in the field of Industrial Design, providing valuable experiences that enhance their professional readiness. Extensive research indicates that internships effectively equip students with the necessary skills, insights, and understand- ing of industry expectations that may be challenging to acquire solely within an academic setting. (Binder, Bagueley, Crook, and Miller, 2014) One of the distinctive features of internships is the unique level of mentorship they can offer, a facet often lacking in regular employment opportunities. The typically structured nature of internships ensures that participants receive guidance and support in honing their skillsets, fostering an environment conducive to professional growth. As a result, internships both instil confidence in stu- dents navigating their educational journey and significantly contribute to their employability upon graduation (Maertz et al., 2014).

INSTITUTIONAL STRUCTURE AND GUIDELINES FOR INTERNSHIPS There has been little to no published data on the impact of internship programs in Industrial Design. This case study examines three four-year

© 2024. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 63

comprehensive universities’ approach to internships, specifically the organi- zational structure and support mechanisms of industrial design and how they impact internship placement. The Universities involved in our study include the University of Kansas (KU), The University of Kentucky (UK), and West- ern Michigan University (WMU). The relative size of each program is similar, however, the programs vary in when they were established, internal support for preparation to apply for and obtain internships, if students are required to have an internship to graduate, and option to obtain academic credits for internships.

The University of Kansas, Industrial Design Program The University of Kansas (KU) Industrial Design Program, established in 1941, is a four-year program with approximately 70 undergraduate students. While graduation does not mandate an internship, KU requires three three- credit professional practice courses, ADS 378: Problems in Industrial Design. Students can register for these courses during an internship placement to get academic credit during their internship experience. KU’s curriculum also includes a mandatory INDD 430: Portfolio course in the third year.

KU allows students to apply for 3 credits of ADS 378 for full-time intern- ships, including in the summer or school year, if it meets the specified criteria. Most KU students participate in internships during the summer; however, students may also engage in up to two semesters of off-site full-time intern- ships during the fall or spring semester and still graduate on time. Each semester, up to 3 credits can count towards INDD 378 credits, 3 towards core studio requirements, with online courses filling the remaining credit requirements. While uncommon, some graduates partake in twosemester internships, with an average of one student per graduating class opting for this extendedexperience.

In order to make this possible, the University of Kansas has clear criteria for obtaining credit for internships: “Experience in industrial design prac- tice gained while working in an internship position within a professional industrial design firm (consulting office or corporate design department). Experience must be gained while working under the guidance of a cooper- ating, qualified design professional. Details of each internship, e.g., name and location of firm, identity of cooperating professional, length of intern- ship, hours worked each week, nature of work experience, methods to be used in evaluating student performance, etc., must be satisfactorily defined, arranged, and agreed upon jointly by the student, the firm offering the intern- ship, the instructor under which the course is listed, and the industrial design area head prior to the student’s enrolment in the course.”

Western Michigan University, Product Design Program The Richmond Institute for Design and Innovation (RIDI) at Western Michi- gan University (WMU), established in response to local industry demand, offers a relatively new four-year Product Design program. The program, which had its first graduating class in 2021, maintains an average enrolment of 100 students. WMU mandates a professional internship and an online

Beyond the Classroom: A Case Study of Higher Education Internship Support 65

course (RIDI 4640 Design Internship) for graduation, omitting a dedicated portfolio development course.

WMU students typically complete internships during the summer after their junior year, concurrently registering for the three-credit asynchronous, online RIDI 4640 Design Internship. The program does not facilitate intern- ships during fall or spring. There is no dedicated opportunity to earn academic credit for a second internship. The criteria for industrial design internship credit is only what is on the course description. WMU RIDI 4640 Design Internship course description: Design internship provides stu- dents with work experience and exposure to professional practice through an internship in a professional setting. The Internship can be taken in the summer between the second and third and/or the third and fourth years of the Product Design program.

University of Kentucky, Product Design Department The University of Kentucky (UK) Product Design Department is set to grad- uate its first class in spring 2024. This is a burgeoning department with an anticipated average enrolment of 60 students. UK does not require internship participation to graduate from the program nor do they provide course credit for internship participation. Currently, students are not formally supported in participating in internships during the Fall or Spring semester if it means not being able to attend on-site courses.

To aid in employment readiness, UK offers two Portfolio courses: PRD 261: Design Visualization: Photo/Portfolio and PRD 450: Portfolio for Prod- uct Design. As this program has not graduated any product designers there is the unique challenge of not yet having alumni available as a resource for current students. Alumni are often instrumental in securing internship place- ments and provide outside mentorship for students. Faculty in new programs often have limited time to assist students outside of class due to the effort and time it takes to build a new program.

QUANTITATIVE MEASURES This study employed quantitative methods for data collection and analysis. A survey was administered at KU, UK, and WMU, and included current 2nd, 3rd year, 4th year, and graduated students from the prior year.

University Participants were asked to identify their university. The options included: Western Michigan University (WMU), University of Kansas (KU) and University of Kentucky (UK).

Internship Participation Participants were asked if they had participated in an internship program since beginning their ID program (responses were Yes or No).

Number of Internships Participants were asked “How many internships/ apprenticeships have you participated in?” with a range of 0–4 provided.

How Landed Internship Among participants with internships, participants were asked “How did you land your internship? Please select all that apply” with the following options: 1) you responded to a job/internship posting, 2) you met someone at the company through networking, someone outside your university to the com- pany, if so, who? and 3) someone inside your university referred you to the company, if so, who? And Other (open response). For analytic purposes, we recorded these variables to include two categories: 1) applied via a posting only (participants who only selected “responded to a job/internship posting”) and 2) applied with any personal connections. Importantly, or our analy- ses, we focus only on how participants landed their first internship (if they reported more than one internship).

Perceived Impact of Internships Participants who had participated in at least 1 internship were asked: “How would you rank the impact of all your internships on each of the following? (With 0 showing no impact, and 5 showing maximum impact)” with the following domains: 1) career/professional learning, 2) benefit to your future, and 3) benefit to your industrial design education. Our analyses use each individual scale as well as a summed version of the three scales to determine overall impact, where higher scores indicate greater perceived impact.

Application to Internships Participants without internship experiences were asked: “Did you apply to any internships?” with the options: “Yes” and “No.”

Sample Size & Missing Data In total, 117 individuals began the survey. Of these participants, 116 provided responses to which university they attended, 111 provided responses to the question about participating in any internships and the number of internships they have had. Of the 35 participants that reported having an internship, 30 provided information on how they landed their internship and the per- ceived impact of their internship experiences. Among participants without any internships (n = 76), all provided information about whether they had applied to any internships.

Analytic Plan The focus of this paper is on how mentorship programs impact intern- ship placement rates. To investigate this topic, we used cross-tabulations and bivariate ordinary least squares (OLS), negative binomial and logistic regression. Coefficients for the negative binominal and logistic regression

Beyond the Classroom: A Case Study of Higher Education Internship Support 67

analyses are exponentiated to ease interpretation. Due to small samples sizes, multivariable analyses were not conducted.

RESULTS

University Affiliation In total, 32.8% of the sample attended WMU, 43.1% attended KU, and 24.1% attended UK (Table 1).

Internship Participation and University Bivariate logistic regression analyses showed that participants at WMU were 5.43 times as likely to have any internship experiences compared with UK participants (SE = 3.468, p<0.01). However, there was no statistical differ- ence between likelihood of having any internship between UK and KU (OR 2.30, SE = 1.443, p>0.05) (Table 2).

Number of Internships and University Negative binomial regression analyses showed that compared to students at UK, WMU students had significantly higher odds of having an internship (IRR = 5.014, SE = 2.695, p<0.01) and KU students had marginally signif- icantly higher odds than UK students (IRR = 3.168, SE = 1.866, p<0.10) (Table 2).

How Landed Internship Importantly, there were no students at KU who landed their internship via ad only. As a result, KU was excluded from the regression analysis. The results showed no significant difference in the odds of landing an internship via an ad only versus landing it via personal connection for WMU and UK students. However, the odds-ratio was large (OR = 2.100, SE = 1.654, p>0.05), which suggests that this non-significant result may be due to a lack of statistical power (Table 2).

Perceived Impact of Internships and University In the overall scale, there was no difference in perceived impact of intern- ship experiences by school among those who participated in an internship (Table 2). However, participants at KU reported significantly higher scores on the education impact subscale relative to the students at UK (B = 1.794, SE = 0.851, p<0.05).

Application to Internships among Participants Without Internship Experience and University Among students who did not have an internship, there were no signifi- cant differences in the likelihood of applying to an internship by university (Table 2).

Table 1. Survey participation by school.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

N Percentage Western Michigan University (WMU) 38 32.76 University of Kansas (KU) 50 43.10 University of Kentucky (UK) 28 24.14

Total 116 100.00

Table 2. Bivariate regression analyses.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

INTERVIEWS To further understand the experiences of our students, informal, semi- structured interviews (n = 12) were conducted with 4 students from each participating program, including equal numbers of 3rd and 4th year stu- dents interviewed. These qualitative interviews were conducted to understand the support provided by their program in finding and obtaining internships as well as support provided during the internshipandthe students’ perceived importance of internships.

Questions That Were Asked Questions for Students Who Participated in an Internship(s)

  • Where was your internship?
  • What were your primary responsibilities during your internship?
  • How did you get your internship?
  • How did your school support you when you were applying?
  • Did you have support from your university during your internship interviews? (What sort of support?)

Beyond the Classroom: A Case Study of Higher Education Internship Support 69

  • Did you have support from your university during your internship? (What sort of support?)
  • Were you able to get academic credit for your internship, how was that process?
  • What additional support would have been helpful that you didn’t have?
  • Have your internship(s) changed your approach to your education?
  • For Seniors: How prepared do you feel to graduate?
  • For Juniors: How prepared do you feel for your senior year?

Questions for Students Who Did Not Participate in an Internship(s)

  • Did you apply to any internships? How many?
  • How important is it to you to have an internship?
  • Why do you think you have not had an internship?
  • Can you think of any ways your school or program could better support you in securing an internship?
  • For Seniors: How prepared do you feel to graduate?
  • For Juniors: How prepared do you feel for your senior year?
Mathematical equation reproduced from the original PDF
Equation reproduced from the original PDF.
  • Instructor turnover was an issue for WMU and UK, the disruption caused inconsistency in faculty stressing the importance of internships, and how much support is provided in preparing for internships.
  • Instructors offering different viewpoints in what is viable for industrial design portfolios and projects causes stress and confusion for students, making them feel insecure.
  • Instructors who consistently talk about the importance of finding an internship and help students put together their portfolios and resumes early and often have a high impact on students applying for internships.
  • Instructors’ connection to the field and opportunities directly impacts student’s placement in internships. Internships are intensely competitive and having instructors connect and recommend students for positions is effective.

Students’ Expectations

  • Students expect their departments to help prepare them for internships and employment, if the department attempts to outsource that preparation (for example, to the career center) the students feel unsupported and frustrated.
  • Students’ who were sent to the University Career Services Center when they asked for help preparing for internships and employment were frustrated by the lack of knowledge and understanding of the ID field.
  • The School Career Fair was suggested for students from one program to find internships or employment, when there were no ID specific opportunities present the students felt “abandoned and helpless.”
  • Students at WMU and KU felt that finding an internship was their respon- sibility, while students at UK felt that their institution had not done enough to support them finding an internship.

Internship Experience

  • Students were sometimes unclear as to what counted as an internship experience, some internships were not industrial design related and some students had jobs that they applied to which served more as an internship than just employment.
  • Students perceived internships as having a mentorship aspect and helping them grow as a designer.
  • None of the programs had a protocol for checking in on students during their internships.

Preparation and Obtaining Internships

  • Students need significant individual support putting together their portfo- lios outside of a portfolio class.
  • Mentors were a trusted and consistent resource in portfolio preparation and preparing students for interviews.
  • Many students interviewed from all three programs had a connection for their internships, either through family, mentors, or faculty.

Confidence Through Internship Experience

  • Having internships improved students’ confidence in the classroom and in their preparedness after graduation or for their Senior year.
  • The mentors assigned during students’ internships made the students feel more confident, helped grow the students’ skillsets, helped navigate a pro- fessional work environment, and often continued to be their mentor after the internship ended.
  • Students who did not participate in an internship felt less prepared for the next year of school or graduation.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, internships play a crucial role in preparing industrial design students for the workforce. The study reveals varying effectiveness in intern- ship preparation strategies across the three programs analysed. Notably, a significant proportion of 4th-year students had engaged in internships, whereas a majority of 2nd-year students expressed a lack of preparedness, emphasizing the need for portfolio development which resulted in opting out of the application process.

Successful strategies encompassed consistent emphasis on internship importance from the 1st year, integrating portfolio discussions and devel- opment into studio projects from 1st to 4th year. Program-wide consistency among faculty regarding portfolio expectations and internship application guidance is recommended, but none of the programs studied had achieved this. Conversely, programs neglecting internship discussions risked students not recognizing their significance.

Notably, programs reliant on one or two faculty members overseeing internships faced challenges, especially with faculty turnover. This research underscores the necessity of clear internship guidelines, enabling students to pursue opportunities that optimize their educational and professional

Beyond the Classroom: A Case Study of Higher Education Internship Support 71

growth. Clear communication, early and ongoing application encourage- ment, and portfolio integration emerged as key elements in ensuring success- ful internship experiences for industrial design students.

REFERENCES

Binder, J. F., Baguley, T., Crook, C., & Miller, F. (2015). The academic value of internships: Benefits across disciplines and student backgrounds. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 41, 73–82. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cedpsych.2014.12. 001 Coburn, C. E., & Penuel, W. R. (2016). Research–practice partnerships in education:

Outcomes, dynamics, and open questions. Educational Researcher, 45(1), 48–54. Dundes, L., & Marx, J. (2006). Balancing work and academics in college: Why do students working 10 to 19 hours per week excel? Journal of College Student Retention: Research, Theory & Practice, 8(1), 107–120. Maertz, C., Stoeberl, P., & Marks, J. (2014). Building successful internships: Lessons

from the research for interns, schools, and employers. Career Development International, 19(1), 123–142. https://doi.org/10.1108/cdi-03-2013-0025 McKinney, K., Medvedeva, M. A., Vacca, K., & Malak, J. (2004). Beyond the classroom: An exploratory study of out-of-class learning in sociology. Teaching Sociology, 32(1), 43–60. Nunley, J., Pugh, A., Romero, N., & Seals, R. A. (2016). College major, intern-

ship experience, and employment opportunities: Estimates from a résumé audit. Labour Economics, 38, 37–46. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.labeco.2015.11.002

Cover of the proceedings volume Training, Education, and Learning Sciences

Explore the complete digital volume

Training, Education, and Learning Sciences

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-964867-31-1

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →