Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Field operators' visual inspection practices in the operating Finnish nuclear power plants

1 Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, Helsinki, 00032, Finland ↗
2 VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland Ltd, 02044, VTT, Finland ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1004883

Abstract

In nuclear power plants (NPPs), the integrity of the plant is assured, among other safety measures, by regularly conducted field operator (FO) visual inspection rounds. During these rounds, the FOs tour the NPP and inspect the equipment. Despite the term ‘visual inspection,’ other senses are also used in the task. Previously, no systematic information on visual inspection practices in NPPs has been collected.The objective of the study is to gain an understanding of the visual inspection practices. The goal is to systematically document how visual inspection is conducted, expertise developed, and to compare the practices between the different NPPs. Altogether, five FOs and two trainers, representing all operating NPPs in Finland, participated in the semi-structured interviews. We grouped the plants based on their similarities, resulting in three plant groups.All FOs considered the visual inspection as their most crucial task. During the inspection rounds, the FOs examine the integrity of equipment and appropriateness of the facilities. They record readings and make notes about the equipment; one group uses a paper checklist and two others a tablet with a brief history of the process values. Furthermore, looking, listening, touching, and even smelling form an integral part of inspection rounds for all FOs. The inspection rounds are usually performed by one FO at a time, twice in a 12-hour shift. If something deviant is noticed, another FO often participates in the round. In two groups, rounds may have interruptions due to other tasks, such as separations and reconnections. In contrast, one group reported that the rounds are always performed uninterrupted.In general, vision was reported to be the most critical sense for visual inspection. By looking, the FOs get information about the integrity of the surfaces, perceive the meter readings, and evaluate the appropriateness of the facilities. However, hearing was often reported to be as important as vision. With increasing expertise, FOs can collect information by actively listening for indications of faults within the equipment, such as bearing malfunctions. In addition, tactile sense was found important for detecting deviant temperatures of both rooms and equipment and unusual vibrations. Also, smell can be used to detect, for example, oil leaks.All FOs collaborated with the main control room (MCR) operators to whom the round information was delivered. In addition, the FOs were in contact with the maintenance concerning faults and the cleaning personnel regarding the cleaning matters.The initial training for visual inspection is a classroom learning lasting two to three months. However, the most vital part of the training, in terms of the work in practice, is training during working. Then, the FOs perform rounds under the supervision of experienced FOs for approximately one year. After this period, the work is carried out independently.For the most part, all FOs perform the visual inspection rounds similarly. However, some differences are found, which, at large, seem to be explained by the devices used and the structure of the facilities.

INTRODUCTION

Despite all technical advancements, the human operator continues to play an essential role in ensuring nuclear safety. One vital safety measure for opera- tional reliability and continuous functionality of the plant and its equipment is regularly conducted field operator (FO) visual inspection rounds.

Research has explored visual inspection in conjunction with various inspection methods across multiple fields, such as aviation, infrastructure, renewable energy, manufacturing, construction, and nuclear industry. No studies have focused on nuclear power plant (NPP) FOs’ daily visual inspec- tion practices. Here, we investigate the FOs’ visual inspection practices in all operating Finnish NPPs. The goal is to document how visual inspection is conducted and how the related expertise is developed. Furthermore, we compare and evaluate the practices between the different plants.

VISUAL INSPECTION IN SCIENTIFIC LITERATURE Visual Inspection

Visual inspection is one of several non-destructive testing (NDT) techniques utilized across various industries. NDT can be characterized as a collection of

© 2024. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 79

examination methods and techniques to gather information about an object or structure without altering its physical state. Visual inspection is the most common, oldest, and usually the first-line NDT method. It is often applied, for instance, in aircraft maintenance, medicine, the food industry, and the nuclear industry (See, 2012). Despite the term ‘visual,’ the method may also involve using other senses, such as auditory, olfactory, and tactile senses (Charles et al., 2015). The aim is to detect discontinuities, flaws, and defects in products, machinery, or equipment that could affect their integrity and functionality. Depending on the context, visual inspection can be conducted during manufacturing fabrications or as an in-service inspection.

Visual Inspection in NPPs In NPPs, visual inspection is done as part of the in-service inspection, i.e., the inspection is conducted during the operational period. The aims are 1) to detect discontinuities and imperfections on the surfaces or compo- nents, such as cracks and corrosion; 2) to detect evidence of leakage from pressure-retaining components; and 3) to determine the general mechanical and structural condition of components and their supports (Norris, 1999). The most critical objective of visual inspection is to record those flaws that exceed the predetermined reporting threshold and to identify the ones that are significant enough to endanger the plant’s safety. These are known as critical defects (Bertovic, 2015).

Factors Affecting Visual Inspection The benefits of a human operator performing visual inspection lie in the oper- ator’s ability to use various senses, adapt to unexpected situations, and make decisions (e.g., Vasconcelos, 2019). However, in NPPs, the inspection task is vastly complex in NPPs; inspectors must examine the plant consisting of large components over a long period while relying on their sensory, percep- tual, cognitive, and motor skills (Vasconcelos, 2019). Nonetheless, the success of visual inspection is affected by individual factors such as mental and phys- ical abilities and expertise (See et al., 2012), and external factors such as task, group, and organizational characteristics, as well as the characteristics of the physical environment, (Bertovic, 2015; Chen & Huang, 2014; Cumblidge, 2017; Vasconcelos, 2017) and their interaction.

Good Practices in Visual Inspection Human factors research has yielded a considerable amount of information in response to shortcomings in visual inspection reliability. Research has highlighted different search strategies, including systematic search techniques and positioning optimization, to minimize errors (Hrymak & Codd, 2021; Hrymak & de Vries, 2020; Takamido et al., 2022). Additionally, imple- menting thoughtfully created job aids (anything that assists the inspector in the inspection, e.g., lists, check sheets, and pictures) is recommended to foster systematic search strategies (Charles et al., 2015). Particularly, less experienced inspectors can have difficulties identifying deviations or their criticality. Improving teamwork can reduce such uncertainty by allowing

Field Operators’ Visual Inspection Practices in the Operating Finnish Nuclear Power Plants 81

feedback exchange and the sharing of expertise (Cumblidge et al., 2017). Similarly, constructing clear accept and reject criteria has been shown to sup- port decision-making (Cumblidge, 2017). Other factors improving inspection reliability found in the previous research include allowing sufficient time to perform the task (Drury & Watson, 2002), minimizing interruptions (Cumblidge, 2017), job rotation, and support from management (See, 2012).

METHODS

To gain a holistic understanding of FO visual inspection practices, we con- ducted a semi-structured interview study, including all five operating NPPs in Finland.

Participants Five FOs, all male (mean age 39 years; min 33, max 45 years), participated in the interviews. Their work experience as an NPP FO varied between seven and 15 years (mean 11 years). All interviewees provided written informed consent.

Interviews The interview questions were tailored under the six main topics: background questions; the basic features of inspection work; success and challenges in inspection work; training; guidance and development; a brief look at the past; and a final question concerning what a good inspection worker is like. Each main topic had several sub-questions, and the interviewer could ask more detailed questions if necessary. The same interviewer interviewed all the par- ticipants. One additional researcher always participated in the interviews for notetaking and asking further questions if needed. The interviews were also recorded to resolve discrepancies or omissions in the notes. One interview lasted approximately 1.5 hours and was conducted using Microsoft Teams (version 1.6.00.28557).

Analysis The data from the interview transcripts was collated and summarized to a table covering the key topics of the current paper: composition of premises; FO training; main tasks of the FO; types of inspection rounds; senses and how they are used; devices used; and round sharing and collaboration. Thus, only the part of the interview that dealt with inspection practices was included in this study. Each researcher cross-checked the generated table to ensure all relevant information from the transcripts was correctly included. Once the table was verified, the data were reorganized in three groups (see Table 1) based on the described similarities and differences in the plant characteristics.

RESULTS

The Composition of the Premises Inspection of the composition of premises and how FOs characterized the plants resulted in three groups: Group 1 (G1), comprising two plants; Group

2 (G2), comprising two plants; and Group 3 (G3), comprising one plant. Thus, the preliminary analysis of the plant characteristics is the key fac- tor according to which all responses are collated. Despite some differences between the plant characteristics (see Table 1), all FOs reported that the plants were noisy.

Table 1. The composition of premises by group.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Group Number of Plants Plant Characteristics G1 2 Facilities are spacious and easy to inspect. G2 2 The facilities are mazy, with confined spaces and lots of stairs. Some places have high temperatures. Visibility is good in general. G3 1 The facility is roomy and adequately lit. There are no confined places, and the access to inspected items is good.

Training The FOs in all groups reported similar training structures. During the first months, the FOs participate in theoretical classroom training under the NPP’s training curriculum. This is followed by practical training; new FOs begin to do rounds under the supervision of an experienced FO. One FO mentioned that the duration of supervised training depends on how fast the understand- ing of the plant and the tasks develop—the enthusiasm and motivation of the experienced FO influence this. Finally, the shift supervisor decides when the new FO is ready to carry out the rounds independently. The final practical test is conducted and evaluated by the manager. In general, it was said that the training takes a minimum of one year. However, as commented by one FO in G1, three to four years of inspection experience is practically required before one can consider him/herself as fully professional. This is due to the fact that some equipment is inspected rather rarely, and it takes time to gain experience with them. FOs in G1 and G3 receive training to operate in both the turbine and reactor areas, while those in G2 work exclusively in either one of those.

The Main Tasks of an FO All FOs considered performing the inspection rounds as their most impor- tant work task. During the inspection rounds, the FOs examine the integrity of equipment and the appropriateness of the facilities. They record readings, make notes about the equipment, and observe that everything functions as planned. The FOs in all groups reported being responsible for periodic test- ing as well as process separations and reconnections, e.g., for maintenance. Furthermore, they conduct several rarely occurring tasks, such as filling and emptying systems and checking alarms. Only the G1 FOs participate in some maintenance tasks.

Field Operators’ Visual Inspection Practices in the Operating Finnish Nuclear Power Plants 83

Types of Inspection Rounds FOs work in two shifts: a 12-hour day shift and a 12-hour night shift. In each group, there are two rounds during the day shift. Also, two rounds are performed during the night shift in G1 and G2. In G3, FOs do the round once during the night shift. The first round is always scheduled at the beginning of the shift. Typically, those places visited in the first round of the shift are not visited in the second round by the same FO. Equipment requiring more pro- found monitoring, such as the reactor coolant pump, is inspected more often than other equipment. The rounds are organized so that the entire facility is inspected within 24 hours. The FOs can decide the order of the inspection route themselves. In addition to the regular rounds, all groups perform addi- tional checks when needed. For instance, when there is a pump leakage, the area is followed more frequently during the shift.

The G1 FOs conduct the first round of the day shift with a tablet (duration: 1–2 hours) and the afternoon round, the so-called “free round,” without it. During the second round of the day shift, they inspect that equipment that has been separated from and reconnected to the process for, e.g., mainte- nance activities, are operating as intended (duration: ∼30-45 minutes). Both rounds during the night shift are inspected using the tablet. The rounds are divided into a restricted area and a controlled area. The FOs in the same shift alternate visits between the two areas. During a shift, one FO inspects the restricted area and the other FO the controlled area, and vice versa the next time the inspection round is performed. The FOs also mentioned that one more exhaustive round is scheduled for each week on Saturday (dura- tion: 2-2.5 hours), and one even more exhaustive round is conducted on the first Saturday of each month (monthly round; duration: 3–4 hours). The day rounds are often interrupted by tasks related to maintenance. However, there are no interruptions during the night and weekend rounds.

The G2 FOs record the readings using a paper checklist during the first round of the day shift. Both plants of the group have two turbines and one reactor. Regarding, for instance, the turbines, during the first round of a shift, one FO inspects one turbine, and the other FO inspects the other. They switch turns in subsequent rounds to improve the reliability of the inspection, but this was also mentioned to decrease monotony. The round is performed as one entity. However, the round can be interrupted by the need to per- form process separations or reconnections. The round lasts a minimum of one hour. If the round includes checking external facilities, such as the water supply facility, then the round is extended by half an hour. Tidiness is essen- tial; hence, leaks or any inappropriateness of the facility (e.g., unclosed fire doors or misplaced items) are often handled by the FOs, extending the round’s duration.

The G3 FOs reported that the round, including the supervised and tur- bine area, as well as the yard, lasts about three hours. However, there is slight variation; the afternoon round of the day shift is not as extensive as the first round, lasting approximately two hours. Moreover, as in G1, one more exhaustive round is scheduled each Saturday, and one more exhaus- tive round is conducted on the first Saturday of each month. Lastly, it was

reported that an FO is not to be disturbed during the rounds; there are no interruptions, nor does one need to rush during the inspection.

Senses and How They Are Used In all groups, vision, hearing, touching, and smelling are used to detect faults. In general, vision was reported to be the most critical sense for visual inspec- tion. By looking, the FOs get information about the integrity of the surfaces, perceive the meter readings, and evaluate the appropriateness of the facili- ties. However, hearing was often reported to be as important as vision. With increasing expertise, FOs can collect information by actively listening for indications of faults within the equipment. Background noise, together with the use of earmuffs, was reported to make differentiating between normal and non-normal sounds challenging. The sense of smell was also considered crucial for detecting certain faults. One FO even stated that experienced FOs can detect low oil levels in equipment by smelling. The tactile sense is impor- tant for detecting unusual vibrations and deviant temperatures or moisture in both spaces and equipment.

Tools Used During the Round The G1 FOs have a tablet on which the readings are recorded. The tablet also shows a brief five-day history of recorded values and the trends of the past 30 days. The tablet can also be used for taking pictures and recording video and sound. The tablet includes threshold values, allowing inspectors to identify and assess whether equipment values approach or surpass predetermined lim- its. In addition, round devices include a pen and paper, keys, a DECT phone, a badge, a multi-purpose tool to tighten door handles, and radiation meters (when the FOs go to the restricted area). Lastly, some FOs report sometimes having a circuit diagram in the round to understand the piping better.

The G2 FOs reported using a paper checklist. The checklist is round- specific for the first round of the day shift, and both rounds of the night shift. The checklist also has free space for additional information if needed. Fur- thermore, they have a walkie-talkie or a DECT phone, a flashlight, radiation meters (in the restricted area), and a spanner on the round.

The G3 FOs have a tablet on the round. The tablet has a checklist for marking the items that have been inspected. The tablet also provides the order (defined by the FOs themselves) in which the premises are inspected and has free space for writing additional information. The tablet also includes thresh- old values and provides information on what needs to be inspected for each equipment. Tool cabinets exist in the restricted area, and they also reported having radiation meters on the round when needed.

Round Sharing and Collaboration Each plant has at least two FOs working in the same shift. Primarily, all FOs conduct the inspection rounds individually, i.e., one FO at a time. The G1 and G2 FOs reported that when there is a fault in plant equipment, the second FO often joins to inspect it. When there are any anomalies, the infor- mation is always delivered to the main control room (MCR) operators. All

Field Operators’ Visual Inspection Practices in the Operating Finnish Nuclear Power Plants 85

FOs reported discussing all matters with the MCR operators during and after the round as well as among the colleague(s) in the shift.

The G1 FOs reported that during the rounds, FOs are sometimes in contact with the MCR operators and the other FO in shift via walkie-talkie and vice versa. If there are concerns or issues with the plant equipment, the FOs may request maintenance for inspection or ask them for advice. The FOs deliver the daily round report primarily to the auxiliary panel operator. The report is then evaluated and approved by the shift supervisor. Cleanliness issues are separately reported to the cleansing department. In addition, the FOs between the units of the same plant sometimes collaborate; the FOs from one unit may call the FOs on the other and ask for support.

The G2 FOs reported that the FOs consistently work alongside the same colleague during their shifts, fostering collaborative practices. For instance, one FO reported occasionally cleaning the seawater filter with his colleague. The FOs that were interviewed stated that the turbine operator in the MCR is the closest operator for the FOs inspecting the secondary circuit. Thus, any change in equipment values is reported to the turbine operator. Addition- ally, the FOs may call the maintenance to take the required actions. Once a month, FOs inspecting the secondary circuit conduct the round with a tur- bine operator. Supposedly, the same applies to the FO inspecting the primary circuit – the closest MCR operator is the reactor operator. Lastly, the FOs collaborate with the cleaning personnel concerning the cleaning matters.

In G3, the FOs may conduct the round with another FO if the other FO is not busy with other tasks. If the two FOs conduct the inspection together, they follow each other without spreading out to the plant. The MCR operators are informed about any deviations in equipment or values during the round. If any work is left for the FOs in the following shift, that is written in the control room diary by the MCR operators. The shift supervisor approves the notes before the shift ends. The shift supervisor was reported to be the FOs’ closest superior.

DISCUSSION

The current study examined the FO visual inspection practices in all five oper- ating NPPs in Finland. All FOs considered the visual inspection rounds as their most important work task. In addition to inspecting the components and plant’s structure, utilizing all senses except taste, the FOs also inspect the appropriateness of the premises. This can include inspecting that the fire doors are closed, the facility is clean, and there are no misplaced items. The most significant differences were found in the composition of the premises and the tools they used.

In some groups, the FOs used a tablet to guide the inspection, and some used a paper checklist. The FOs have determined the sequence in which the premises are listed on the tablet, guiding the inspection order accordingly. Two main differences were noticed between the two tools. First, compared to the paper checklist, the tablet can provide a history and short-term trends of the process values. This can benefit the FOs by improving their under- standing of the functioning of the equipment relevant to the inspection work

and by increasing their interest in the work. The tablet allows FOs to track trends, enabling FOs to identify consistent value changes and, thus, pro- vides insights about evolving potential issues. Moreover, the tablet includes threshold values, allowing inspectors to assess equipment values more effi- ciently, which supports decision-making. Second, using the tablet, one can take photos and record a video and sound. This facilitates delivering accu- rate information about the equipment state to the MCR operators. From the tablet and paper checklist, one can structure the inspection round by follow- ing the order in which the items are listed. Hence, both methods can guide the task and support performance if they are carefully designed (Charles et al., 2015). In all plants, the inspection duration was at least one hour, often extend- ing beyond. All plants were noisy, and some included occasional workplace restrictions, had high temperatures, and were described as mazy. On the other hand, some plants were described as roomy, having sufficient lighting, and some were easy to inspect. Long inspection work in a challenging working environment can result in cognitive overload and fatigue, finally lowering vigilance and posing a threat to inspection quality (Cumblidge et al., 2017; Drury & Watson, 2002). To mitigate the impact of prolonged duration in such tasks, See (2012) suggested that five minutes of rest can restore vigilance. Such breaks do not need to be non-working time; alternating inspection with other tasks every 30 minutes has been shown to suffice (See, 2012).

Another notable difference observed between the groups was related to inspection interruptions. While the FOs in one group reported no inter- ruptions or rush during the inspection, FOs in two groups mentioned that those occasionally occurred due to, for instance, process separations and reconnections. According to Drury and Watson (20002), interruptions can create a possibility of memory failure, and the search may become incom- plete, increasing the likelihood of error (Drury & Watson, 2002). When coupled with challenging environmental conditions, external factors such as interruptions and time pressure can add to the complexity of the inspection task.

The effectiveness of the inspection was reported to largely depend on the training, particularly on the tacit knowledge accumulated from the experi- enced FO. According to the FOs, the proficiency, practices, and the trainer’s motivation greatly affect the trainee. FOs reported that approximately after one year of learning, the new FO can perform rounds independently. How- ever, learning to inspect using all senses typically takes years to master, highlighting the complexity of the task. Furthermore, some events are so rare that it takes time for the FO to become familiar with all equipment- related events in the plant. This may put new FOs at risk of missing defects as the required skills are still developing during the first years of inspection. Research indicates that a modular training approach, building progressively on earlier learned modules, enhances learning and defect detection (Pro- gressive part training; Dury & Watson, 2002). However, whether such an approach in combination with learning in practice could aid FOs in their inspection is yet to be studied.

Field Operators’ Visual Inspection Practices in the Operating Finnish Nuclear Power Plants 87

Finally, the interviews uncovered three practices on how FOs may improve inspection reliability. First, all FOs can decide the order in which they con- duct the round. This can lead to a sense of autonomy, increasing motivation, a feeling of responsibility, and greater ownership over the FO’s work, all attributes of an effective inspector (Behravesh et al., 1989). Second, the FOs develop collaborative practices with their work pair, who are the same in each shift. For instance, one FO reported performing some tasks with another FO in the shift. Also, some FOs alternate inspection areas from shift to shift, each inspecting the other’s previously examined area and vice versa. Such practices can support vigilance as these behaviors may reduce the monotony of repet- itive work. Third, the FOs engage in continuous discussions with each other, MCR operators, and sometimes with maintenance concerning the observa- tions made in the field. Such collaboration, especially if it includes feedback from colleagues, can benefit inspection reliability, resulting in more correct defect detection (Cumblidge et al., 2017). Lastly, different FOs inspect the same components and structures consecutively throughout the shifts. Inspec- tions performed repetitively by different inspectors are suggested to increase inspection reliability (Tian et al., 2012).

CONCLUSION

Visual inspection in the NPP, conducted frequently and regularly by FOs, is an example of the constant endeavor to ensure safety. Workers conduct it without extensive theoretical training but largely with the skills they develop during their work. This way, they constitute an important barrier against otherwise unnoticeable flaws in the equipment. Using a tablet or a paper checklist, the FO scrutinizes the equipment, identifies the important infor- mation, and delivers the message to the MCR. Visual inspection completes the daily safety measures performed by MCR operators who monitor plant processes from a distance through sensors. As visual inspection is performed daily and by several FOs, the possibility of a latent flaw is diminished. Iden- tifying an anomaly that would develop into a critical defect over time saves the plant many resources and ensures the safe operation of an NPP.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The research is funded by the Finnish nuclear research program SAFER2028. The authors would also like to acknowledge Finnish NPP companies, espe- cially the operators who agreed to share their insights on visual inspection practices.

REFERENCES

Bertovic, M. (2015). Human factors in non-destructive testing (NDT): risks and challenges of mechanised NDT. Technische Universitaet Berlin (Germany). Behravesh, M. M., Karimi, S. S., & Ford, M. E. (1989). Human factors affecting the

performance of inspection personnel in nuclear power plants. Review of Progress in Quantitative Nondestructive Evaluation: Volume 8, Part A and B, 2235–2242.

Charles, R. L., Johnson, T. L., & Fletcher, S. R. (2015). The use of job aids for visual inspection in manufacturing and maintenance. Procedia CIRP, 38, 90–93. Chen, W., & Huang, S. (2014). Human reliability analysis for visual inspection in

aviation maintenance by a Bayesian network approach. Transportation Research Record, 2449(1), 105–113. Cumblidge, S., D’Agostino, A., Morrow, S., Franklin, C., & Hughes, N. (2017).

Review of Human Factors Research in Nondestructive Examination. Hrymak, V., & Codd, P. (2021). Improving Visual Inspection Reliability in Aircraft Maintenance. ESREL2021: 31st European Safety and Reliability Conference, Angers, France, September 19–23. Hrymak, V., & de Vries, J. M. (2020). The development and trial of systematic visual

search: A visual inspection method designed to improve current workplace risk assessment practice. Policy and Practice in Health and Safety, 18(1), 9–24. Drury, C. G., & Watson, J. (2002). Good practices in visual inspection. Human factors in aviation maintenance-phase nine, progress report, FAA/Human Factors in Aviation Maintenance. Norris, W. E., Naus, D. J., & Graves III, H. L. (1999). Inspection of nuclear power

plant containment structures. Nuclear engineering and design, 192(2-3), 303–329. See, J. E. (2012). Visual inspection: a review of the literature. Takamido, R., Kurihara, S., Umeda, Y., Asama, H., Kasahara, S., Tanaka, Y.,... & Ota, J. (2022). Evaluation of expert skills in refinery patrol inspection: visual attention and head positioning behavior. Heliyon, 8(12), e12117. Tian, L., Hai, Y., Qingyue, Z., & Qin, Y. (2019, July). Non-destructive testing tech-

niques based on failure analysis of steam turbine blade. In IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering (Vol. 576, No. 1, p. 012038). IOP Publishing. Vasconcelos, V., Soares, W. A., Marques, R. O., Silva Jr, S. F., & Raso, A. L.

(2019). Human reliability in non-destructive inspections of nuclear power plant components: modeling and analysis. Brazilian Journal of Radiation Sciences, 7(2B).

Cover of the proceedings volume Human Error, Reliability, Resilience, and Performance

Explore the complete digital volume

Human Error, Reliability, Resilience, and Performance

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-964867-08-3

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →