José Vicente, David Camocho (2023). Design for Sustainability Tools: Categories of classification towards practical use. In: Human-Centered Design and User Experience. AHFE Open Access, vol. 114, pp. 41–49. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1004220
Since the emergence of early approaches to design for the environment (such as green design or ecodesign), several tools have been developed to support the design process in the integration of environmental, social and, more recently in a comprehensive way, sustainability and circularity criteria. The vast quantity and diversity of tools have required the creation of ways to organize and classify them to facilitate their identification, selection and use by designers, engineers, and other product development professionals, according to the needs of the design practice objectives, and the specificities of the project.This paper aims to analyze the existing knowledge regarding design for sustainability and circularity tools to identify the main categories used to classify these tools. This was done with the aim of synthesizing the most appropriate classification from the point of view of the product designer who will use the tools. To achieve this, the methodology of literature review was employed, which included scientific papers, theses, and reference books in the field.This analysis gathered a wide diversity of classification forms and organized them into 6 overarching categories. It was also possible to verify that certain forms of classification are not particularly relevant for designers when selecting a tool, as they don’t clarify the feasibility of applying the tool. It is possible to conclude that there is still a need for homogenization and consensus in academia regarding the best way to classify these tools so that the classification is scientifically sound and useful for designers.
The design practice, focused in essence on responding to society’s needs, has within the scope of sustainability a fundamental role in the integration of aspects, considerations and strategies that endow the solutions achieved with an optimization of the sustainability profile of the products and services (Tischner, 2016; Ferreira, 2008) always having a life cycle perspective and the consequent elimination or minimization of impacts.
This integration of sustainability aspects in a holistic way in the design process can be a complex endeavour that is enhanced and supported using different resources and tools to which the design team has access. However, their use is not yet made through a systematized and effective approach in most projects (Camocho, 2022).
In a study of ecodesign tools, Baumann et al. (2002) concluded that there is a surplus of tool development and a scarcity of studies and evaluations of existing tools. This gap is also reflected in the general lack of knowl- edge that design professionals have about the existence and benefits of using sustainability tools in the development of products and services.
To address this need and to enhance designers’ knowledge about tools and their benefits, this paper presents a systematic review of literature. The focus is on the analysis of academic publications, theses and books related to the classification and exploration of sustainability tools that support the design practice and process.
The intention of this work is to advance current knowledge on the subject and foster the development of a shared common language that will allow the development of new tools and guidance aligned with the needs of design professionals and product developers.
When referring to design for sustainability tools in this paper it includes all the narrower approaches that relate design and the environmental and social aspects, like green design, ecodesign, DfX, design for social innovation or design for circular economy.
METHODOLOGY
The literature review was based on the analysis of relevant references iden- tified using Journal of Cleaner Production, Elsevier and other journals databases, internet research and cross references research. This analysis includes peer-reviewed articles, theses and books.
The search of papers was divided in two main stages. Firstly, references focusing on tools related to sustainability, ecodesign, green design, design for sustainability and circular economy were collected. The second stage was based on a deeper analysis and the identification of the references that explore the structure and classification of different types of tools.
This search resulted in the identification of 33 relevant resources that were analyzed in detail which describe ways of classification and explore aspects related to design practice in the context of sustainability.
CLASSIFICATIONS AND CATEGORIES The 33 references that were analyzed set out from very different types of purpose and context, and, because of that, present a large diversity of points of view on the tools, which originated a wide range of classifications. It is possible to cluster these 33 classifications in 6 larger categories (Table 1), according to their content and common characteristics.
The first category (C1 - SCOPE) joins 3 classifications that groups DfS tools according to their scope in the wide context of sustainability, in the effort to separate the ones that respond to the entire criteria of sustainability and the ones that are target to specific sections, like Ecodesign or DfX (Pighini et al., 2002).
The second category (C2 - MORPHOLOGY) aggregates 3 classifications that mainly identify tools according to their morphology, separating them by
Design for Sustainability Tools: Categories of Classification Towards Practical Use 43
their type of structure or form, as checklists or guidelines (Knight & Jenkins, 2009). The third category (C3 - PURPOSE) groups 9 references that have clas- sified according to the purpose of each tool. This presents a large diversity of classification and sub-classification items, where the most common goals are analysis, assessment, evaluation, comparation, prescription, visualization, strategy and, overall, decision support. Several classifications also add the creative and idea generation support to the environmental side (Bhamra & Lofthouse, 2007, Tyl et al., 2013).
After these 3 categories that united the tools through a classification of one simple type of analysis, the remaining categories reflect a more recent and complex way to look at the tools, were the classification is always made through more than on point of view. The fourth category (C4 - MULTI-CATEGORY) groups 9 references that present a detailed, diverse, and in-depth classification and sub-classifications such as: types of data (input, output); complexity; digital/analogue; cost (Gomes & Santos, 2014); and some of the first 3 categories are also included. Category 5 (C5 - CROSS-CATEGORY) adds one other level of complexity and detail to the way we look at and organize DfS tools by using the main classes of C4 - Multy-Category in a cross-referenced approach, were two axes of a matrix help to map out the characteristics of the tools. This approach was first use by Tischner et al. (2000).
The final category (C6 - OTHER / MIX) groups 5 types of classifications, that are different from each other and don’t fit any of the previously described categories.
Table 1. Classification of design tools for sustainability.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
C. REFERENCE CLASSIFICATION SUB-CLASSIFICATION - Ahmad et al., 2018 Sustainable Product Design Tools; Partial Sustainable Product Design Tools
- Pighini et al., 2002 Eco-Design Methods; DfX Techniques for specific eco-problems; Design Methods for Creativity
C1 - SCOPE Lubis et al., 2022 Partial DfS Tools; Full DfS Tools -
- Baumann et al., 2002 Frameworks; Analytical tools; Checklists and guidelines; Software and expert systems; Rating and ranking tools; Organizing tools
Ramani et al., 2010 Tools based on checklists; Tools based on life cycle assessment LCA; Tools based on quality function deployment; Integrated tools - Bhamra & Lofthouse, 2007 Environmental assessment; Strategic design; Idea generation; User-centered design; Information provision
Other Strategic Tools; Sensibilization Tools; Communication Tools Lewis & Gertsakis, 2001
- Marseglia, 2017 Visualization; Quantitatively Measuring; Thinking/ Seeing/ Predicting; Evaluate Qualitatively - Sun et al., 2003 Decision making; Design support; Material flow
- Tyl et al., 2013 Strategy-oriented tools; Idea-generation- oriented tools.
Camacho-Otero et al., 2019
Scope Business model; Service; Product Type of tool (analogue or online) Design tool; Analysis tool; Prioritization tool; Identification tool Expected outcome Designs; Opportunities; Strategies Consumption and consumer aspects Explicit; Implicit Gomes & Santos, 2014 Type of procedure Guideline; Matrix; Checklist; Software; Diagram Type of result Analysis; Recommendation; Comparison Runtime Short; Medium; Large Cost High; Low Input data Qualitative; Quantitative; Both Output data Qualitative; Quantitative; Both Required previous experience High; Low Product Development process phase Information; Concept; Detail; All Prescriptive; Comparative; Analytic Pigosso, 2012 Nature of the main purpose of the method/tool
-
Type of tool used Checklist; Guideline; Matrix; Software Nature of input and output data Quantitative; Qualitative Research area where it was created Ecodesign/Environmental Management; Product Development Process Current level of development Theoretical; Experimental; Consolidated Level of detail of the method/tool Superficial; Brief; Complete Environmental aspects considered - Life cycle stages considered - Environmental impact assessment method
-
C4 - MULTY-CATEGORY
Rossi et al., 2016 Life Cycle Analysis; CAD Integrated tool; Diagram tools; Check List & Guidelines; Design for X Approach; Methods for supporting the company's ecodesign implementation and generation of eco innovation; Methods for implementing the entire life cycle and user-centered design for sustainability; Methods for integrating different existing tools Rousseaux et al., 2017 1st level Regulatory; Non-regulatory 2nd level Mandatory; Voluntary; Normative; Non- normative 3rd level Generic; Sectorial 4th level Environmental; Improvement 5th level Quantitative; Qualitative 6th level Computerized; Non-computerized Royo et al., 2022 Type Methodology; Tool Objective Create; Assess/Improve ideas Medium Cards; Guided questions; Board game; Use of different tools Integrates circularity criteria - Royo et al., 2023 Type of result Quantitative; Qualitative Reference product Absolute comparison; Relative comparison; Does not compare Segregation of results Segregated; Not segregated
Design for Sustainability Tools: Categories of Classification Towards Practical Use 45
Table 1. Continued.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Van Stijn & Gruis, 2020
Level Macro; Meso; Micro Discipline Technical model; Industrial model; Business model Type of support Guidelines or criteria; Step-by-step guide; Design canvas; Design architypes; Design strategies; Design parameters; Design options; Case examples Vicente, 2012 Input type Quantitative; Qualitative Complexity Low; High Software Yes; No Scope Sustainability; Life cycle; End-of-life specific; Other specific Purpose Analysis/Assessment; Setting priorities; Idea generation; Trade-off; Guidance; Cost estimation Sectorial Generalist; Sector specific Bovea & Pérez- Belis, 2012
C5 - CROSS-CATEGORY
Y Axes - Dificulty level/Time required Low; Medium; High X Axes - Process Design Phase Function description; Requirements definition; Design alternatives generation; Design alternatives comparation; Best alternative selection Chiu & Chu, 2012 Y Axes - Type Guideline; Metrics; DfX; LC Costing; Methodology X Axes - Process Design Phase Problem Definition; Conceptual Design; Preliminary Design; Detail Design Tischner et al., 2000 Y Axes - Complexity/Time requirements High; Low X Axes - Purpose of the tools Analysis of environmental strengths and weaknesses; Setting priorities and selecting most important potential improvements; Support for idea generation, design and specifying drafts; Coordination with other criteria Valls-Val et al., 2022 Y Axe – Level Nano (divided in Design e Assessment); Micro; Macro X Axe – Type of tools Assessment (divided in Quantitative e qualitative); Guidelines Birch et al., 2012 Strategy-specific tools Output mechanisms 1, 2 & 3 Product-specific tools Output mechanisms 4 Gómez-Navarro et al., 2005
-
C6 - OTHER / MIX
Design stage Preparing the Project; Environmental Impacts; Improvement Ideas; Conceptual Design; Detail Design; Action Plan; Evaluation of the Process Lyfe cycle stage R.M and Components Elaboration; Production; Distribution; Use and Maintenance; Disposal; All Problem level Ecoinnovation; Ecodesign; Re-design; Adaptation Penty, 2019 Quantitative; Qualitative - Varžinskas et al., 2020 For everyone; For designers, engineers and material engineers; For managers
- Zetterlund et al., 2016 Explicit and original purpose to support sustainability considerations in product development; Already implemented in the general operations of many companies and have a potential to support sustainability considerations in product development
46 Vicente and Camocho
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION From the proposed categorization and from the analysis of Table 1 it is pos- sible to identify very different and scattered forms of classification without a defined harmonization between them. This diversity hinders the develop- ment of a common language and occurs because the tools are developed individually, with a focus on specific objectives. Additionally, all the stud- ies analyzed are from academia and these classifications are typically made from the tool’s standpoint, analyzing its specific features rather than relat- ing them to the potential added value, interest, and feasibility for designers and the design process in specific project contexts. This means the classifica- tions, which are academic, present some distancing from practice of design. Only Varžinskas et al. (2020) classifies tools according to their intended user. Nevertheless, from a designer point of view, the most useful forms of classi- fication are the ones that indicate the purpose (C3) and the ones that cross those other relevant aspects for designers (C5), as is the case of Tischner et al. 2000. The 33 references also suggest two other weaknesses that impede the devel- opment of a robust common language for the classification of tools. One weakness is related to the lack of a clear definition of what constitutes a DfS tool and its boundaries, since only 3 of these references present short and partial definitions (Baumann et al., 2002; Gómez-Navarro et al., 2005; Rousseaux et al., 2017). The other weakness, which follows from the first, is the absence of clearly defined criteria that substantiate the stated classifi- cation and would help establish a link to the design process. Only Bovea & Pérez-Belis (2012) and Byggeth & Hochschorner (2006) indicate the criteria used for classification.
It’s clear that, due to their large number, DfS tools need to be classified to facilitate their communication to designers and enhance their usability in the design process for all types of projects. This classification should be clear and practical for the intended users, rather than solely relying on scientific logic or soundness.
The above-mentioned analysis indicates the need for a better definition of what is a DfS tool and the establishment of its boundaries. Additionally, efforts should be made to determine the optimal criteria for creating a useful classification that caters to both design practitioners and academic require- ments. This undertaking should also be developed to support and steer the development of new tools that are geared for a more circular and sustainable outcome of the design process.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This research is/was funded by of LIDA - Arts and Design Research Lab, UIDB/05468/2020, with the financial support of FCT – Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia, I.P, through National funds.
REFERENCES
Ahmad, S., Wong, K. Y., Tseng, M. L., & Wong, W. P. (2018). Sustainable product design and development: A review of tools, applications and
Design for Sustainability Tools: Categories of Classification Towards Practical Use 47
research prospects. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 132, 49–61. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2018.01.020 Baumann, H., Boons, F., & Bragd, A. (2002). Mapping the green product development field: engineering, policy and business perspectives. Journal of Cleaner Production (10), 409–425. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0959-6526(02)00015-X Bhamra, T., & Lofthouse, V. (2007). Design for sustainability - a practical approach.
Gower. Birch, A., Hon, K. K. B., & Short, T. (2012). Structure and output mechanisms in Design for Environment (DfE) tools. Journal of Cleaner Production, 35, 50–58. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2012.05.029 Bocken, N. M. P., Allwood, J. M., Willey, A. R., & King, J. M. H. (2011). Devel-
opment of an eco-ideation tool to identify stepwise greenhouse gas emissions reduction options for consumer goods. Journal of Cleaner Production, 19(12), 1279–1287. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2011.04.009 Bovea, M. D., & Pérez-Belis, V. (2012). A taxonomy of ecodesign tools for integrating environmental requirements into the product design process. Journal of Cleaner Production, 20(1), 61–71. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2011.07.012 Byggeth, S., & Hochschorner, E. (2006). Handling trade-offs in Ecodesign tools for
sustainable development and procurement. Journal of Cleaner Production (14), 1420–1430. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2005.03.024 Camacho-Otero, J., Selvefors, A., & Boks, C. (2019, 18–20 September 2019). Circular design tools: (how) do they understand the consumer? 3rd PLATE 2019 Conference, Berlin, Germany. https://doi.org/10.14279/depositonce-9253 Camocho, D., Vicente, J., & Ferreira, A. M (2019). Circular Economy – Tools
for designers. Presented at the DDC’19: Transformation – 6Th Design Doctoral Conference, Lisbon, Portugal: IADE Universidade Europeia Camocho, D. (2022). Transition to Circular and Sustainable Economy through Design. Universidade Europeia. Lisboa. https://comum.rcaap.pt/handle/10400. 26/41842 Casamayor, J. L., & Su, D. (2013). Integration of eco-design tools into the devel-
opment of eco-lighting products. Journal of Cleaner Production, 47, 32–42. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2013.02.011 Chiu, M.-C., & Chu, C.-H. (2012). Review of sustainable product design from life cycle perspectives. International Journal of Precision Engineering and Manufac- turing, 13(7), 1259–1272. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12541-012-0169-1 Ferreira, A. M. (2008). Evolução do Conceito e da Prática do Design, Prova Com-
plementar à Dissertação para obtenção do Grau de Doutor em Engenharia de Produção. Universidade da Beira Interior. Gomes, N. S., & Santos, A. d. (2014). Defining criteria selection for environmental dimension tools of sustainable design. Strategic Design Research Journal, 6(2). https://doi.org/10.4013/sdrj.2013.62.04 Gómez-Navarro, T., Capuz-Rizo, S. F., Bastante-Ceca, M. J., & Collado-Ruiz, D.
(2005). Ecodesign function and form. Classification of Ecodesign tools according to their functional aspects 15th International Conference on Engineering Design (ICED), Melbourne. Janin, M. (2000). Démarche d’éco-conception en entreprise. Un enjeu: construire la cohérence entre outils et processus. Institut Conception, Mécanique et Environnement]. Chambéry. https://pastel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00005632 Knight, P., & Jenkins, J. O. (2009). Adopting and applying eco-design techniques:
a practitioners perspective. Journal of Cleaner Production, 17(5), 549–558. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2008.10.002
48 Vicente and Camocho
Lewis, H., & Gertsakis, J. (2001). Design + environment – a global guide to designing greener goods. Greenleaf Publishing, Sheffield. Lubis, P. Y., Shahri, B., & Ramirez, M. (2022). Integration of Human-Centered
Design and Design for Sustainability Tool: Proposal of Design for Amelio- ration Tool. MIX Sustentável, 8(2), 19-30. https://doi.org/10.29183/2447- 3073. MIX2022.v8.n2.19–30 Marseglia, M. (2017). Design Process and Sustainability. Method and Tools. The Design Journal, 20(sup1), S1725-S1737. https://doi.org/10.1080/14606925.2017.1352711 Penty, J. (2019). Product Design and Sustainability: Strategies, tools and practice.
Routledge. Pighini, U., Fargnoli, M., & Accinni, S. (2002). An integrated procedure for the design of sustainable products. DESIGN 2002 The 7th International Design Conference, Dubrovnik. Ramani, K., Ramanujan, D., Bernstein, W. Z., Zhao, F., Sutherland, J., Handwerker, C., Choi, J.-K., Kim, H., & Thurston, D. (2010). Integrated Sus- tainable Life Cycle Design: A Review. Journal of Mechanical Design, 132(9). https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4002308 Rossi, M., Germani, M., & Zamagni, A. (2016). Review of ecodesign methods and tools. Barriers and strategies for an effective implementa- tion in industrial companies. Journal of Cleaner Production, 129, 361–373. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.04.051 Rousseaux, P., Gremy-Gros, C., Bonnin, M., Henriel-Ricordel, C., Bernard, P.,
Floury, L., Staigre, G., & Vincent, P. (2017). “Eco-tool-seeker”: A new and unique business guide for choosing ecodesign tools. Journal of Cleaner Production, 151, 546-577. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.03.089 Royo, M., Chulvi, V., Mulet, E., & Ruiz-Pastor, L. (2023). Analysis of parameters about useful life extension in 70 tools and methods related to eco-design and cir- cular economy. Journal of Industrial Ecology. https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.13378 Royo, M., Pérez-Belis, V., Viñoles-Cebolla, R., & Bastante-Ceca, M. J. (2022, 5th-8th
July). Methods and tools for the generation of ideas that follow circular crite- ria in the early stages of product design 26th International Congress on Project Management and Engineering, Terrassa. Sun, J., Han, B., Ekwaro-Osire, S., & Thang, H.-C. (2003). Design For Environment: Methodologies, Tools, And Implementation. Journal of Integrated Design and Process Science (7), 59–75. Tischner, U., Schmincke, E., Rubik, F., & Prösler, M. (2000). How to do ecodesign?
- A guide for environmentally and economically sound design. Verlag. Tischner, U. (2016). Change by Design (or by Disaster). ökoRAUSCH. Retrieved July, 2023, from https://www.oekorausch.de/en/change-by-design-or-by-disaster/ Tyl, B., Legardeur, J., Millet, D., & Vallet, F. (2013). Adaptation of the cre-
ativity tool ASIT to support eco-ideation phases. In B. e. al (Ed.), Green Design, Materials and Manufacturing Processes (pp. 437-442). Taylor & Francis. https://doi.org/10.1201/b15002 Valls-Val, K., Ibáñez-Forés, V., & Bovea, M. D. (2022). How can organisations measure their level of circularity? A review of available tools. Journal of Cleaner Production, 354. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.131679 Van Stijn, A., & Gruis, V. (2020). Towards a circular built environment. Smart and
Sustainable Built Environment, 9(4), 635–653. https://doi.org/10.1108/sasbe-05- 2019-0063
Design for Sustainability Tools: Categories of Classification Towards Practical Use 49
Varžinskas, V., Kazulyt˙e, I., Grigolait˙e, V., Daug˙elait˙e, V., & Markeviˇci¯ut˙e, Z.
(2020). Eco-design Methods and Tools: An Overview and Applicability to Pack- aging. Environmental Research, Engineering and Management, 76(4), 32–45. https://doi.org/10.5755/j01.erem.76.4.27448 Vicente, J. (2012). Contributos para uma metodologia de design sustentável aplicada à indústria do mobiliário. O Caso Português. Universidade Técnica de Lisboa. Lisboa. http://hdl.handle.net/10400.5/5645 Zetterlund, H., Hallstedt, S., & Broman, G. (2016). Implementation Potential
of Sustainability-oriented Decision Support in Product Development. Procedia CIRP, 50, 287–292. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procir.2016.05.011
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Human-Centered Design and User Experience
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-90-2
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional