Li Hui, Zhan Xuewen (2023). Evaluation Method of Modeling Beauty of Construction Machinery Based on Analytic Hierarchy Process. In: Kansei Engineering. AHFE Open Access, vol. 101, pp. 14–22. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1002987
Based on the current research on the beauty evaluation of construction machinery, the analytic hierarchy process is introduced to establish the evaluation system and method for the beauty of construction machinery. Build a hierarchical structure model, extract construction machinery beauty evaluation factors, such as proportion, structure, color, material, surface technology and brand image, which as the criterion layer of the hierarchical structure mode, and the criterion layer is divided into fourteen index layers. Experiments show that the extraction model of impact factors of construction machinery beauty is feasible, and the model is repeatable. With the help of AHP, the preference of users' perception of the beauty of construction machinery is obtained, which provides a theoretical basis for construction machinery design.
As a typical complex industrial product, construction machinery products are different from traditional consumer products, and their appearance depends largely on their functions, structures and working environment. Appearance modeling, as a media channel for emotional communication between users and products, also serves as a bridge between users, designers and enterpri- ses, which is very important for improving the market competitiveness of construction machinery products. However, the evaluation of construction machinery products is full of uncertainty and subjectivity, and it is often impossible to get objective and accurate evaluation results by relying entirely on the judgment of specialists. AHP (analytic hierarchy process) is suitable for dealing with multi-level, multi-factor and complex evaluation problems, and is widely used in product design evaluation at present. In this study, AHP is introduced to evaluate the modeling beauty of construction machinery pro- ducts, which not only helps to improve design efficiency, but also helps to make more standardized, objective and accurate evaluation results.
EVALUATION MODEL OF MODELING BEAUTY OF CONSTRUCTION MACHINERY PRODUCTS Principle of analytic hierarchy process. AHP (analytic hierarchy process) is a multi-objective evaluation method combining qualitative analysis with
Evaluation Method of Modeling Beauty of Construction Machinery Products 15
quantitative analysis, which was put forward by American scholars in 1970s. The key point of the implementation of AHP is to compare different factors (Chen and Wu, 2007), so as to get their weight relations and establish a set of weight judgment matrix (Tan, 2012). Using AHP to analyze the problem, it is usually necessary to divide the judgment object into three levels, namely, the target level, the criterion level and the index level, which is called the eva- luation system of this problem (Xu, 1988; Han et al., 2004). Among them, the target layer is the ultimate goal and summary of evaluation at all levels, the criterion layer is the further structural refinement of the target layer, and the index layer is the refinement and disassembly of each criterion layer. The determination of the evaluation system needs to be considered according to the actual problems in order to be objective and accurate. For the compara- tive judgment between different levels, it is necessary to carry out semantic quantization, thus obtaining the comparative weight and calculating the final evaluation matrix.
Construction Machinery Product Modeling Beauty Evaluation System Determining an accurate and operational beauty evaluation system is the most important thing in AHP analysis and evaluation. Compared with other kinds of products, construction machinery products have more structural parts, and the functions of each part are clearly divided, which makes the modeling beauty system of construction machinery products more compli- cated. Chen Xi et al. (2015) proposed that users should establish the image cognition of mechanical products through visual perception of appearance, color and material. Dai Mingyuan (2016) believes that users perceive and understand the shape of mechanical products from the aspects of volume, shape, linearity and color. Yi Jun and Li Xue (2021) thinks that the field of construction machinery needs to solve the specific problems of product concept, modeling, color, structure, function, man-machine interface and so on. To sum up, proportion, structure, shape, color, coating and material are important factors to evaluate the beauty of construction machinery pro- ducts. Based on the user’s observation of construction machinery products, combined with the discussion with many industry experts, according to the principle of construction machinery product hierarchy, the evaluation system is shown in Table 1.
Evaluation Indicators Proportional beauty index. Proportion refers to a ratio between measures such as length or area, that is, the relationship between parts or parts and the whole (Hu and Li, 2009). In product design, the beauty of proportion is usu- ally the key consideration of designers, which is related to the contrast and coordination of overall modeling and detailed modeling. A good proportion can enhance the aesthetic feeling of modeling. The beauty of modeling pro- portion of construction machinery products can be expressed through the coordination and rationality of proportion. Proportional harmony reflects the volume ratio coordination of all parts in the overall modeling, which is related to the proportional aesthetic feeling of product modeling.
16 Hui and Xuewen
Table 1. Construction machinery product modeling beauty evaluation system.
Coating conforms to the overall style(F11) Simple coating(F12) Steady coating(F13)
Structural beauty index. Structural beauty is the external modeling expres- sion of the internal structure of construction machinery products, and it is the basis of the modeling beauty of construction machinery products. The structure of construction machinery products is not always reflected in the external modeling, but some exposed structure has a significant impact on the overall aesthetic feeling. Structural beauty has multiple aesthetic levels, and the evaluation corresponding to structural beauty can be decomposed into functional rationality, formal appropriateness, feasibility and coordination of structure.
Shape and surface beauty index. Form surface. Shape feature is the most direct way to convey the information of modeling (Hsiao and Huang, 2002). The shape and surface characteristics of construction machinery products refer to the ups and downs of the external structure coverage and the con- nection between surfaces. The size, curvature and shape changes of the surface give users different visual impacts and feelings, which affect the user’s perception experience in the most intuitive way. The shape of construction machinery products is largely determined by their functional structure. How- ever, as construction machinery products tend to be large-scale, light-weight and intelligent, users’ perception needs for shape are more diverse.
Color beauty index. Color is one of the important elements of constru- ction machinery products modeling design, which affects users’ judgment on the beauty of modeling. It can change the living environment, create diffe- rent atmosphere, and create different design styles by combining different elements (Li, 2006). Different colors of construction machinery products have different visual feelings under the same appearance. Successful con- struction machinery products color design is characterized by beautiful and harmonious colors, that is, colors are not abrupt.
Coating beauty index. Coating of construction machinery products inclu- des color coating and pattern coating (Zhang et al., 2018). As the first element of users’ visual perception, the different types and areas of colors trigger dif- ferent visual impact, which in turn affects users’ psychological feelings and
Evaluation Method of Modeling Beauty of Construction Machinery Products 17
emotional reactions. Due to the particularity of the working environment of construction machinery, reasonable color configuration can coordinate the relationship between the machine and users, alleviate the fatigue and bore- dom caused by users’ long-term operation in harsh environment, and at the same time improve work efficiency and ensure safety. The purpose of pat- tern characters is to convey information, and whether users can accurately perceive information will also affect the safety of the operation process. The particularity of the operation type of construction machinery products deter- mines that its coating design can not blindly pursue novelty, ignoring the objective needs of the environment and users.
Material beauty index. Material is the material basis of form. The user’s perception of the material forms the texture, which is the psychological response made by the user to the physiological stimulation caused by the visual and tactile perception of the material’s attributes. Different materials have different perceptual characteristics, and different surface treatments will bring different visual effects and psychological feelings to users. The main material of construction machinery products is steel, which not only meets the structural and functional requirements, but also enhances the user’s sense of security; Auxiliary materials are mostly glass, rubber, plastic, etc., which enhances the overall sense of science and technology and modernity.
Calculation of Evaluation Index Weight AHP constructs a hierarchical analysis structure model by analyzing the factors and related relationships contained in a complex system. By compa- ring the elements of each level with each other according to a certain scaling theory, a comparison scale of relative importance degree is obtained, and a judgment matrix is established to calculate the maximum eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the judgment matrix, so as to obtain the importance order of the elements of each level to a certain element of the upper level, and then a weight vector is established. The main steps are as follows:
According to scaling theory, a pairwise comparison judgment matrix A is constructed:
Equations and mathematical formulas are available in the original paper PDF.
Normalizing each column of the judgment matrix A:
Find the sum of the elements in each row of the judgment matrix A:
18 Hui and Xuewen
According to Aw=λmaxw, the maximum characteristic root and its chara- cteristic vector are obtained.
Consistency test:
1) calculate the consistency index C.I=(λmax −−n)/(n −1); 2) Find out the corresponding average random consistency index R.I; 3) calculating the consistency ratio C.R=C.I/R.I; When C.R < 0.1, the consistency test can be accepted, otherwise, A is corrected.
Because there are generally many indicators in indicator layer F, it is too much to compare all indicators in pairs. Therefore, in practice, the weight of the index layer is often calculated under a single criterion. Proceed one by one until it is completed, and the specific calculation steps are the same as those in the previous section. It should be noted that if there are too few indicators under a certain criterion, such as only two indicators, it can also be directly normalized according to the weight relationship of the questionnaire as a weight vector. Second order orthogonal Matrix can pass the consistency test.
Practical Research on Modeling Beauty of Construction Machinery Products In this study, user evaluation data are collected by issuing questionnaires, and the weight of each evaluation index is determined by using the calculation method of analytic hierarchy process. The topic of the questionnaire adopts semantic differentiation method to help users compare the important relati- onships of indicators in the evaluation system (Li et al., 2018). More than half of the respondents are college experts related to the construction machinery industry, practitioners in the product design industry, and graduate students and undergraduates majoring in design. They have a better understanding of the modeling design process of construction machinery products and can better understand the product concepts contained in the semantics of the eva- luation system. The important relationship of each index can be obtained by collecting user evaluation data and analyzing the weight by AHP method.
AHP Method to Determine the Weight of Criterion Level According to the survey results, the orthogonal Matrix is obtained (as shown in Table 2).
Maximum eigenvalue λ = 6.152, Weight vector (feature vector): w = (0.1718, 0.2699, 0.1178, 0.2582, 0.1178, 0.0647)
Evaluation Method of Modeling Beauty of Construction Machinery Products 19
Table 2. Orthogonal matrix.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Proportion Beauty
Structural Beauty
Color Beauty
Coating Beauty
Material Beauty
Shape and Surface Beauty
Proportion Beauty
Structural Beauty
Shape and Surface Beauty Color Beauty 3.0000 1.0000 2.0000 1.0000 2.0000 4.0000 Coating Beauty 0.5000 0.5000 1.0000 0.5000 1.0000 2.0000 Material Beauty 0.3330 0.3330 0.5000 0.2500 0.5000 1.0000
Saaty’s random consistency index RI table (as shown in Table 3). The consistency ratio is: C.R=C.I/R.I = 0.0240<0.1
The consistency test shows that the data obtained in this study are more accurate and the judgment matrix of the evaluation index is reliable.
According to the calculation of index weight vector in the criterion layer, six criteria can be obtained: structure, color, proportion, shape, coating and material.
In the bid, the structural beauty has the highest weight value, and the others are in descending order: color beauty, Proportion beauty, shape and surface beauty, coating beauty and material beauty.
Calculation of Relative Weight of Index Level Under a Single Criterion Calculate the weight of the index layer under a single criterion layer, and the weight of each index layer can be obtained as shown in Table 4. The results after normalization are shown in Table 5. Comparing the weights of the third-level indicators, the following conclusions can be drawn:
Under the single criterion of proportional beauty, the weight of “propor- tional coordination” is greater than that of “reasonable proportion”; Under the single criterion of structural beauty, the weight of “reasonable function of structure” is the highest, followed by “simple and feasible structure” and “coordination of structure”is the lowest; Under the single criterion of beauty
20 Hui and Xuewen
Table 4. Weight of index level under a single criterion.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Index score
Proportion Beauty 4.2500 4.0000 Structural Beauty 4.3500 4.1500 4.2000 Shape and Surface Beauty 4.1000 3.9500 3.9000 Color Beauty 4.1000 4.2500 Coating Beauty 3.9500 4.0500 4.0000 Material Beauty 3.9000 3.9500
Table 5. Index layer weights under a single criterion after normalization.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Index score
Proportion Beauty 0.5150 0.4850 Structural Beauty 0.3430 0.3270 0.3300 Shape and Surface Beauty 0.3430 0.3300 0.3260 Color Beauty 0.4910 0.5090 Coating Beauty 0.3290 0.3370 0.3330 Material Beauty 0.4970 0.5030
of form and surface, “smoothness of form and surface” has the highest wei- ght, followed by “combination and coordination of form and surface” and “proper density of form and surface”. Under the single criterion of color beauty, the weight of “beautiful color” is greater than that of “unobtru- sive color”; Under the single criterion of coating beauty, “simple coating” has the highest weight, followed by “stable coating” and “coating conforms to the overall style”. Under the single criterion of material beauty, the wei- ght of “reasonable material distribution” is greater than that of “exquisite material”.
Comprehensive Index Weight Value and Evaluation Results After combining and normalizing the above calculated criteria and index wei- ghts, the final index weight calculation result is obtained: the weight of each indicator on the same evaluation level can be obtained, that is, the indicators under different criteria layers can also be compared with each other according to the weight values (Table 6).
Table 6. Comprehensive index weight.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Weight after indicator combination Comprehensive weight of criterion layer Proportion Beauty 0.0886 0.0834 0.1720 Structural Beauty 0.0926 0.0883 0.0891 0.2700 Shape and Surface Beauty 0.0405 0.0389 0.0385 0.1179 Color Beauty 0.1268 0.1315 0.2583 Coating Beauty 0.0388 0.0397 0.0393 0.1178 Material Beauty 0.0322 0.0325 0.0647
Evaluation Method of Modeling Beauty of Construction Machinery Products 21
From the comparison of the weights of the criterion layer, it can be seen that the comprehensive weight of structural beauty is the largest, so special attention should be paid to the reasonable function, simplicity and coordi- nation of the structure in the modeling design of construction machinery products. Secondly, the beauty of color and the beauty of proportion are the higher weights, which shows that beautiful colors and reasonable and coor- dinated proportion can greatly improve the modeling beauty of construction machinery products. The comprehensive weight value of material beauty is the smallest, which shows that the influence of material is weaker than the proportion, structure, shape, color and coating of appearance in the modeling of construction machinery products, and it is the most unimportant consi- deration index in the modeling design of construction machinery products. From the comparison of the weights of the index layers, it can be seen that “beautiful color” and “unobtrusive color” are the most important indexes, which are the details that need to be given priority in the modeling design of construction machinery products; “reasonable function of structure” in the beauty of structure is also the important index, which reflects the important influence of the function of construction machinery products on modeling, while “exquisite material” is the least important index, which is relatively less considered in the modeling design of construction machinery products.
CONCLUSION
Based on AHP, this paper explores a new method for modeling evaluation of construction machinery products, establishes an evaluation system for mode- ling beauty of construction machinery products, and calculates the weight values of each index, which can be directly applied to the modeling evalu- ation practice of construction machinery products. Comprehensive analysis of the final calculated index weights at all levels shows that the evaluation system conforms to the design experience and can accurately reflect the real evaluation results. In this paper, the evaluation system based on the beauty of construction machinery product modeling can be expanded according to the continuous development of construction machinery product modeling, with strong maneuverability and transformation. The application of analy- tic hierarchy process improves the design efficiency and helps designers to design construction machinery products that are more in line with consumers’ favorite.
REFERENCES
Chen Ming, Wu Zhihui. A Study of AHP-Based Furniture Conceptive Design Evaluation System [J]. Furniture and Interior Decoration, 2007(01): 69–71. CHEN Xi, ZHOU Yi-qi. Research on Visual Image Design of Engineering Machinery
Products Based on User Cognition [J]. Construction Machinery and Equipment, 2015, 46(1): 32–36. DAI Ming-yuan. Research on Modeling Design Evaluation of XCMG Excavator Based on BP Neural Network [D]. Beijing: China University of Mining and Technology, 2016.
22 Hui and Xuewen
Han Li, Mei Qiang, Lu Yumei et al. Analysis and Study on AHP-Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation [J]. Chinese Journal of Safety Science, 2004, 14(7): 86–89. HSIAO S W, HUANG H C. A Neural Network Based Approach for Product Form
Design [J]. Design Studies, 2002, 23(1): 67–84. Hu Jingchu, Li Minxiu. Dictionary of Furniture Design [M]. Beijing: China Forestry Press, 2009. Li Liangzhi. Color Design [M]. Beijing: Higher Education Press, 2006 Li Senran, Li Hongjun, Geng Xiaojie. Research on Evaluation Method of the Beauty
of Chair Furniture [J]. Furniture and Interior Decoration, 2018, (12): 20–23. Tan Yuejin. Quantitative Analysis Methods [M]. Beijing: Renmin University of China Press. 2012. Xu Shubai. Principle of Analytic Hierarchy Process [M]. Tianjin: Tianjin University
Press, 1988. Yi Jun, Li Xue. Engineering Machinery Modeling Evaluation Based on User Perception [J]. Packaging Engineering, 2021, 42(24): 161–168. ZHANG Ye, JIANG Liang, XIAO Jiang-hao, et al. Industrial Design Ideas in
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-77-3
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional