Abstract
This study selects balance, order, simplicity and proportion for quantifying to propose a comprehensive aesthetic calculation method for the layout of interface which verified by the music apps.
Xinran Yan, ChengQi Xue (2023). Aesthetic Evaluation of Music Apps Interface Based on Aesthetic Calculation. In: Intelligent Human Systems Integration (IHSI 2023): Integrating People and Intelligent Systems. AHFE Open Access, vol. 69, pp. 577–582. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1002879
Download available citation metadata.
Publisher statistics will load when you open Metrics.
This study selects balance, order, simplicity and proportion for quantifying to propose a comprehensive aesthetic calculation method for the layout of interface which verified by the music apps.
Human-machine interface is the way for users to interact with machines, and its aesthetics have the most direct impact on user experience and work efficiency. In the quantitative search for aesthetics, Ngo proposed 13 mea- surement indicators to objectively evaluate the interface aesthetics, but the indicators are too high. At the same time, the influencing factors and weights among the indicators are not easy to calculate. Zhou Lei. con- structed four interface aesthetic intention structures, and determined their eigenvalues and contribution rates through factor analysis. This paper selects four beauty indicators that affect the layout of interface elements: bala- nce, sequence, simplicity, and proportion, quantifies them, and proposes a comprehensive beauty calculation method for the layout of interface ele- ments. And combined with the subjective evaluation of music apps to verify its objectivity and accuracy, and to guide and improve the interface design.
THEORY After user interviews and designer focus, combined with the characteristics of interface layout design, four relatively objective beauty indicators of balance, sense of order, simplicity and proportionality were selected as the evaluation indicators of interface beauty for quantification.
Measure of Balance Balance refers to the distribution of visual quality in an image, that is, the sense of difference created by the contrast between different objects.
© 2023. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 577
Calculated as follows: BMvertical +
BMhorizontal
Equations and mathematical formulas are available in the original paper PDF.
2 ∈[0, 1] (1) BM vertical, BM horizontal represents the horizontal and vertical balance respectively
Among them, L, R, T and B represent left, right, up and down respectively; aij is the area of object i on side j; dij is the distance between the center line of the object and the frame; nj is the total number of side objects.
Measure of Sequence Sequence in the interface refers to whether the arrangement of elements in the interface conforms to the movement habits of the human eye. The calculation formula is as follows:
qj −vj
qUL, qUR, qLL, qLR When wj is the largest in w, vj takes 4, When wj is the second largest among w, vj takes 3, When wj is the third largest among w, vj takes 2, When wj is the smallest among w, vj takes 1.
w = {wUL, wUR, wLL, wLR} (8) UL, UR, LL and LR represent the upper left corner, upper right corner, lower left corner, and lower right corner respectively; aij is the area of the object i in quadrant j. Each quadrant is weighted with q as the standard.
Measure of Simplicity Conciseness refers to whether the arrangement and combination of interface elements are conducive to user reading and understanding. The calculation formula is as follows:
Aesthetic Evaluation of Interface of Music Apps Based on Aesthetic Calculation 579 SMM = 3 nvap + nhap + n ∈[0, 1] (9)
Where nvap and n hap are the number of alignment points in the vertical and horizontal directions, respectively; n is the number of interface elements.
Measure of Proportion Proportion refers to whether the proportion of interface elements conforms to the aesthetic proportion. The calculation formula is as follows:
PMobject
PMlayout
2 ∈[0, 1] (10) !
n X
1 −min pj −pi
min
pj −playout
0.5 (14)
Where b layout and h layout are the width and height of the layout. pj represents the degree of agreement of the element j with the following ratio.
psq, pr2, pgr, pr3, pds
1, 1 1.414, 1 1.618, 1 1.732, 1 2 Among them sq, r2, gr, r3 and ds represent square, square root of two, golden rectangle, square root of three, and double square respectively.
Comprehensive Beauty Calculation This paper uses the characteristic value of each index obtained by the inter- face beauty factor analysis as the weight of each index to calculate the comprehensive beauty value (As shown in Table 1).
INSTANCE VERIFICATION This experiment uses five popular apps in the current music APP market: QQ Music, NetEase Cloud Music, Kuwo Music, Migu Music, and Xiami Music. The initial home page interface is shown in the Figure 1.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Factor indicator Eigenvalues Contribution % Cumulative contribution rate % Measure of Balance 6.334 42.267 42.267 Measure of Sequence 3.657 24.403 66.670 Measure of Simplicity 1.826 12.185 78.855 Measure of Proportion 1.178 7.861 86.761
Figure available in the original PDF paper.
Figure available in the original PDF paper.
In this experiment, the influence of color and text on the beauty of the overall interface layout is not considered, the interface is decolorized and sim- plified, the interface elements are divided into title bar, information bar and song playback bar according to their functions, and the functional blocks are abstractly represented as Minimized rectangle that can contain its inner ele- ments, and use different colors to distinguish different elements, the title bar uses the highest grayscale, the information bar uses the lowest grayscale, and the song playback bar uses medium grayscale. The processed image is shown in Figure 2. The X coordinate, Y coordinate, total width w, total height h of the starting point of the rectangle, the total width W of the overall layout, the total length H, and six parameters are used to realize the spatial positi- oning of the graphic element in the overall interface; The interface is from left to right, and the positive direction of Y is from top to bottom. As shown in table 2. The comprehensive beauty calculation is arranged in descending order of score: interface 1> interface 2> interface 3> interface 4> interface 5, as shown in Table 3.
The survey shows that the age structure of users of major music lapps tends to be younger, and college students are the main group currently using music
Aesthetic Evaluation of Interface of Music Apps Based on Aesthetic Calculation 581
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Layout Object X Y w h
Fig1(43.82x77.89) 1 1.64 2.94 40.43 3.88 2 1.64 7.88 40.43 3.1 3 1.64 15.99 40.43 12.91 4 1.64 38.15 40.43 29.14 5 1.64 67.29 40.43 4.66 6 0 71.94 43.82 5.95
Fig2(43.82x77.89) 1 1.56 4.1 40.75 4.34 2 1.56 12.47 40.75 2.9 3 1.56 20.82 40.75 6.24 4 1.56 34.69 40.75 36.62 5 0 71.31 43.82 6.59
Fig3(43.82x77.89) 1 1.56 2.62 40.01 3.49 2 1.56 7.59 40.85 14.18 3 1.56 23.93 40.85 5.55 4 1.56 42.84 42.25 25.08 5 0 67.92 43.82 4.76
Fig4(43.82x77.89) 1 11.71 2.41 40.43 4.02 2 1.71 8.44 40.43 15.80 3 0 25.95 43.82 4.86 4 0 39.67 43.82 18.98 5 0 67.8 43.82 5.62 6 0 73.43 43.82 4.47
Fig5(43.82x77.89) 1 0 0 43.81 29.54 2 2.13 2.73 39.65 3.25 3 4.1 31.3 34.3 5.61 4 2.13 44.85 38.88 27.94 5 0 72.79 43.82 5.1
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Sample 1 2 3 4 5 Measure of Balance 1.2139 1.2979 1.0827 1.0872 0.8890 Measure of Sequence 0.7500 0.5000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 Measure of Simplicity 0.2143 0.2500 0.2500 0.2000 0.2308 Measure of Proportion 0.5990 0.7859 0.2991 0.3756 0.5970 Aesthetic Calculation 11.5283 11.4320 11.3238 10.4660 10.4126
apps with a high penetration rate. Therefore, the subjects in this experiment selected 39 non-design art college students aged 21–26, and asked them to compare five grayscale images after processing, and arrange them from high to low according to their beauty, so as to obtain the relative advantage ran- king of its beauty. The results are shown in Table 4, in descending order
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Sample Average composite score
1 3.44 2 2.79 3 2.74 4 2.54 5 2.46
of votes: Interface 1 > Interface 2 > Interface 3 > Interface 4 > Interface 5. Therefore, the subjective and objective evaluation results are consistent.
In this paper, a comprehensive beauty calculation method is proposed and verified by experiments. The difference in subjective scores of some interfaces is not large, which may be related to the similarity of the partitions caused by the similarity of the main functions of the existing apps. Due to the individual differences in aesthetics, apps should start from flat, pay attention to the clear boundaries of the layout and easy retrieval, and on this basis, the stylization of the interface should be improved as much as possible to show distinction.
Chang Yutian., Jiang Subaru., Hu Zhongfang., Wang Zirui., Liu Chaozhou., and Guan Weiyu., 2020. Analysis and evaluation of music apps. Computer Knowledge and Technology. Ngo, D.C.L., Teo, L.S. and Byrne, J.G., 2002. Evaluating interface esthetics. Know-
ledge and Information Systems, 4(1), pp. 46–79. Ren Xiaofan., and Xue Chengqi., 2018. Layout evaluation of Camera Connect APP interface elements based on Mido computing. Design, (4), pp. 142–143. Yin Ting., Li Yang. and Feng Shuangpeng., 2020. Investigation and Analysis
of the Influencing Factors of College Students’ Choice to Use Music Apps— Taking Changsha College Students as an Example. Jiangsu Business Review, (5), pp. 26–32. Zhou Lei., Xue Chengqi., Tang Wencheng., Li Jing. and Niu Yafeng., 2013. The beauty evaluation method of interface element layout design. Journal of Computer Aided Design and Graphics, 25(5), pp. 758–766.

Intelligent Human Systems Integration (IHSI 2023): Integrating People and Intelligent Systems
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-45-2
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional