INTRODUCTION
Technological innovations are the driving forces for improving farm- production efficiencies: suffice the rising demands for food, high-quality products, management of environmental perturbations, and remain globally competitive. With decreasing access to extensive farming lands, and high risks associated with open field cultivations (droughts, floods, pest attack, high winds, etc.), farm systems are increasingly moving to EC greenhouse-based food production. However, careful scheduling and recordkeeping are neces- sary to efficiently operate and manage a greenhouse. The managers require appropriate education as well as technology-related qualifications and trai- ning. Training starts from planning and overseeing planting to eradicate pests and plant diseases. However, on-site training can be time-consuming, requires high levels of supervision, and may incur damage to crops and equipment,
© 2022. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 198
Student Perceptions of Traditional and Simulated Learning in Greenhouse Management 199
and results in accidents and injuries to trainees. Some are inaccessible for students for the risk of production loss, like in Controlled environment agriculture (CEA) technologies (Gómez, 2019). Therefore, the inclusion of computational tools and machine-to-machine communications, supported by intelligent interfaces, have become an increasingly important topic for many greenhouse production courses (Ray, 2017). This literature review explores the application of emerging technology-based educational approaches in the effective operation and control of greenhouses.
LEARNING BEHAVIOR OF STUDENTS In general, individuals learn and react to teaching, taught either in or outside of the classroom, in many ways, depending on their learning behaviors. For students to succeed in active learning and retaining information, instructors need to be skilled regarding teaching approaches, learning methods, giving feedback, involving students in collaborative learning, and motivating them for independent learning. According to a study by the Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences (Afkhaminia, 2018), there is a meaningful relationship between students’ developed skills (auditory skills, reading, creative thinking, time management, and work planning) and sources of support from the sch- ool. Another study surveying high school students about learning preferences showed students’ desire to learn in technology-mediated interactive environ- ments in conjunction with traditional classroom-based learning (Mills, 2018). Therefore, classrooms should embrace newer technology-based instructional methods for the best education possible for students allying with current and emerging technology. Feedback also needs to be delivered on a technology- based platform (for example, mobile learning environments, desktop-based simulated environments, virtual reality, or augmented reality) to meet the challenges of instructors’ addressing everyone’s question(s) and providing them with timely feedback; by assigning students formative tasks and provide automatic feedback for assessing task performance, provide detailed recor- dings of all the activities performed by students and automatically evaluate student performance, as well as provide training reviews. Therefore, conside- ring the findings, teachers should welcome technology into their classrooms as a means of helping students learn material using an experiential learning approach.
METHODS OF EDUCATION Traditional Learning
Greenhouse operation and management is an applied field of study, so it is mandatory to have hands-on experience aside from classroom-based edu- cation and weekly assignments. The typical traditional training method for greenhouse education expects students to use little to no technology to aid them in completing the time-prohibitive assignments. Without adequate time necessary to experience and successfully respond to the possible pitfalls, it leaves little means to observe or learn to respond to problems without an adverse effect on final crop production. In lab-based courses, accessibility
to physical equipment and query support provides a learner with an oppor- tunity to be involved in an entire crop-production process Akin to student populations, industry agricultural trainees also require opportunities to expe- rience novel production technology. However, project-based learning can be slow and trainee delays will produce ill-effects and results of their actions, and may not be able to correct mistakes made during the production pro- cess. Service-learning is another growing and well-accepted technique where instructors integrate community service into their course curriculum, giving students hands-on experience while students give back to their community. However, appropriate, and effective course contents are pre-eminent as well. Experiential learning encourages reflection about experience and helps stu- dents develop new skills and attitudes (Lewis, 1994). Educators see as an integrated and holistic approach to education that adapts to real-world situ- ations. Experiential learning theory (ELT) is much of the framework for modern education. Integrating ELT into course curriculum allows students to learn, and relearn, material from synergistic transactions between the person and the environment, which aid them in adaptation to real-world situations (Kolb, 2009).
Online Learning Online learning is the teaching method where students learn using electronic technologies to access an educational curriculum. Through online learning, their critical thinking and evaluation skills improve as they find various sources to obtain assistance. Some students are more likely to engage with online learning than traditional teaching methods. However, there is no sin- gle answer of whether it is beneficial or creates more distractions and barriers. A study developed nine interactive e-tutorials. The findings suggest students perceived the tutorials as valuable and that the accessibility, design, and dura- tion were deemed effective in user engagement (McGuinness, 2019). Several studies found the benefits of online learning of student involvement, student engagement, and student independence. A study of Belgrade Metropolitan University revealed students feel they should be challenged outside of the for- mal classroom setting, and those who did, performed better when learning independently (Raspopovic, 2017). Providing prompt feedback to students is vital to compensate for knowledge deficits, especially when online learning calls for an independent interaction. Although there is a lack of research on the long-term effects online learning has on student performance, this resea- rch is promising because it provides insight into what critical tools best serve learning populations.
Learning in Virtual and Augmented Environments The most innovative and helpful technology for learning is virtual reality (VR). VR is a computer technology that facilitates immersion within simula- ted scenarios. It is a fast-growing and popular means for educational training programs. The most recognizable component of VR is a head-mounted display, which allows users to be immersed using display optics positioned in front of their eyes. VR may be effective in instruction as it appeals to learners
Student Perceptions of Traditional and Simulated Learning in Greenhouse Management 201
and opens opportunities for active interaction with components through rea- listic immersion. Due to VR technology becoming more popular and widely available, using it for learning has produced several research opportunities. A VR training system could potentially be used in every classroom or course, such as virtual laboratories, visualizing machines, industrial plants, medical scenarios, and virtual maintenance and assembly. However, lack of training in the use of VR educational tools, lack of effective VR training modules, and inadequate capabilities to support such technology are common reasons VR has not been successfully integrated into classrooms. However, a portion of classrooms found ways to implement VR technology for supplemental instru- ction. SpeakUp, a nonprofit charity dedicated to helping teens communicate openly, surveyed U.S. teachers and students in 2016 and found five percent of instructors are using augmented reality (AR) or VR in their classroom, 11 percent of technology teachers are using AR or VR, and nine percent of stu- dents in grades 6-8 say they have experienced AR or VR in a classroom setting (Speak Up Research Initiative, 2016). While technology may assist educators in providing individualized student attention, a VR training modality also provides students with immediate and targeted feedback and assistance. A VR for horticulture students may assist project visualization without provi- ding the physical resources necessary to complete assignments and projects, help students grow and maintain crops virtually and help with the use of equipment. At the University of Almería in Spain, faculty presented a virtual lab for teaching climatic control in a greenhouse environment. The tool con- sisted of a graphic screen connected to algorithms and a model in MATLAB to understand the issues involved in the climatic control of greenhouses (Ma, D., Carpenter, 2019). The virtual lab aided students in applying their kno- wledge of agriculture learned in the classroom when making changes to the environmental controls without damaging the production outcomes. To bet- ter understand how students react to VR, a study was conducted introducing three different assessment methods (Vesisenaho, 2019). Students showed high positive reactions to the simulations that afforded more significant activity and independence by using self-assessments to gauge emotional involvement, qualitative reporting on the experiments, and brain imaging methods for capturing performance and emotions.
EVALUATING STUDENT LEARNING Survey methods have been used when assessing student engagement and per- formance for different teaching methods. Pre-tests and surveys help establish a baseline for the study and may help determine the appropriate student grou- ping. In contrast, post surveys reveal student engagement in the study, levels of learning, and overall student performance. Surveys have also been used to validate new platforms and methods of teaching. The following measu- res have been collected using surveys in many educational studies to evaluate student learning.
Academic Success Student learning is a primary goal when developing and conducting an edu- cational research study. Grade point average and standardized test scores
such as the SAT are predicted variables for college success. However, there are other success indicators not explained by the standardized variables. The Psychology department at Southern Illinois University investigated the strength of college readiness skills in predicting student GPA (Komarraju, 2013). The college student inventory (CSI), like Student Readiness Inventory Survey (SRI) is intended to act as an early alert system for first-year col- lege students who are at higher risk of challenges at school. Questions are distributed in three scales: Academic Motivation, General Coping, and Rece- ptivity to Support Services (Slanger. 2015). Like SRI and CSI, another tool - the Academic Success Inventory for College Students (ASICS) was deployed to examine undergraduate nursing student strengths and weaknesses (Brown, 2020). Several schools and programs have adopted ASICS as a helpful tool in helping determine how well students will perform in school or on specific tasks. Virtual reality is a newer technology, which is not as widely availa- ble in the classroom alongside traditional teaching methods. Therefore, it is pertinent that research assesses academic success from VR technology. A study looked at the effectiveness of VR in physics whereby students used a virtual reality physics simulation (VRPS) (Kim, 2001). The study population was split into three groups – (i) not using the VRPS program (the control) and instead taught by traditional methods; (ii) using the VRPS with a tea- cher acting as a supplement; (iii) actively engaged in the VRPS without any teaching assistance. Results indicated students were more satisfied with the VR instruction and a teacher to help guide them when they needed help. The study results show a positive impact for the future of VR in education alongside traditional teaching.
Student Engagement Student engagement plays a pivotal role in how well students grasp informa- tion and is a critical factor in academic achievement. The University Student Engagement Inventory (USEI) is a tool developed to identify student involve- ment in learning which focuses on the conceptualization of engagement as a multidimensional construct, including cognitive engagement (CE), behavioral engagement (BE), and emotional engagement (EE) (Maroco, 2016). To assess the impact of immersive VR on learning, a survey tool, Classroom Engage- ment Inventory (CEI) was given to public school students (Schneider, 2019). The survey questions were divided into four sections: Behavioral Engage- ment (BE), Cognitive Engagement (CE), Disengagement (DE), and Affective Engagement (AE), like the USEI. Other studies have used the CEI or have incorporated vital concepts to help with understanding the engagement of students in a VR learning experience.
Quality Metrics of Educational Platforms and Tools It is just as important to validate the training tool itself to validate student engagement and success from different learning methods, whether by vali- dating the labs planned for traditional methods or VR simulations. Here, we examine three metrics for assessing the quality of VR experiences as measured through survey methods: usability, sense of presence, and simulator sickness.
Student Perceptions of Traditional and Simulated Learning in Greenhouse Management 203
System Usability Scale (SUS) is the most widely used standardized questi- onnaire for the VR assessment of perceived usability (Lewis, 2018). Purdue University investigated the usability of two different independent VR systems to validate low-cost, commercially available tools, which could eventually be made available for academics (Webster, 2017). Students participated in one of two VR experiences, and after VR exposures, they responded to SUS. All SUS factor scores across the study were markedly high. The findings suggest a promising future for VR in education. A presence questionnaire (PQ) is ano- ther popular means to assess VR. Presence is a construct of intentional focus, and employment is helpful when determining the level of attention one has when entering virtual environments (VEs). A study aimed to teach students to drive a virtual automobile using VR scenarios (Silva, 2016). Throughout the research period, the students sat in an armchair and were put into the first-person view of the driver’s seat of an automobile in a virtual city. Upon completion of the VR driving, the students completed the PQ. Presence que- stionnaires help researchers determine the quality of the immersion in VEs. The third method of assessing VR educational tools is a simulation sickness questionnaire (SSQ). A well-developed VR simulation will limit the effect of simulator sickness on participants, making the assessment a vital tool to question participants on results when developing VR systems.
CONCLUSION AND FUTURE RESEARCH This paper has summarized many survey studies for educational resea- rch to understand student engagement and success from different teaching platforms and methods. Traditional, online, and VR methods of teach- ing information were discussed and compared to the learning behavior of students. Findings from other studies demonstrate that students prefer engagement through learning, are interested, detail-oriented, receptive to feedback, and want to become confident learners. Engagement in the class- room is significant when introducing students to environments, problems, and assignments unattainable or expensive to establish in real-world trai- ning scenarios such as emerging technology-based education, such as desktop simulation, VR, and AR. Immersive technology may provide more practical learning while reducing distraction. Teachers would likely welcome techno- logy into the classroom as a means of helping students better understand and grasp course materials, especially when training experiences involve high-risk environments and complex hands-on practices.
Developing a successful teaching method also involves its efficacy asses- sment based on students’ perceptions about their learning. This review shows a need for extensive future research and development of content-specific survey tools, especially those which help collect student perceptions of VR- based learning and validate teaching tools. Future research should develop both desktop-based and VR-based simulated environments to train students to operate greenhouse environment controls, manage production and assess the efficacy of such simulated platforms successfully and confidently. Propo- sed assessments may be conducted using validated survey tools developed to (i) understand students’ immersion in the virtual greenhouse environment,
(ii) their interaction with ECs and its interface, (iii) successful understan- ding of operations, and (iv) confidence in effective transfer of knowledge for real-world practices.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This work is supported by FACT Grant no. 2019-69017-29928/project accession no. 1019734 from the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture.
REFERENCES
Afkhaminia, F., Siamian, H., Behnampour, N., Moghimi, A., & Karimpour, S. (2018).
Study of student success indicators based on the viewpoints of the students of Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences. Acta Informatica Medica, 26(3), 175. Brown, J., McDonald, M., Besse, C., Manson, P., McDonald, R., Rohatinsky, N., & Singh, M. (2020). Nursing Students’ Academic Success Factors: A Quantitative Cross-sectional Study. Nurse Educator. Gómez, C., Currey, C. J., Dickson, R. W., Kim, H. J., Hernández, R., Sabeh, N. C.,
... & Lopez, R. G. (2019). Controlled environment food production for urban agriculture. HortScience, 54(9), 1448–1458. Kim, J. H., Park, S. T., Lee, H., Yuk, K. C., & Lee, H. (2001). Virtual reality simulations in physics education. Interactive Multimedia Electronic Journal of Computer-Enhanced Learning, 3(2), 1–7. Kolb, A. Y., & Kolb, D. A. (2009). Experiential learning theory: A dynamic, holi-
stic approach to management learning, education, and development. The SAGE handbook of management learning, education, and development, 42, 68. Komarraju, M., Ramsey, A., & Rinella, V. (2013). Cognitive and non-cognitive predictors of college readiness and performance: Role of academic discipline. Learning and Individual Differences, 24, 103–109. Lewis, J. R. (2018). The system usability scale: past, present, and future. International
Journal of Human-Computer Interaction, 34(7), 577-590. Lewis, L. H., & Williams, C. J. (1994). Experiential learning: Past and present. New directions for adult and continuing education, 1994(62), 5-16. Ma, D., Carpenter, N., Maki, H., Rehman, T. U., Tuinstra, M. R., & Jin, J. (2019).
Greenhouse environment modeling and simulation for microclimate control. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 162, 134-142. Maroco, J., Maroco, A. L., Campos, J. A. D. B., & Fredricks, J. A. (2016). University student’s engagement: development of the University Student Engagement Inventory (USEI). Psicologia: Reflexão e Crítica, 29(1), 21. McGuinness, C., & Fulton, C. (2019). Digital literacy in higher education: A case
study of student engagement with e-tutorials using blended learning. Journal of Information Technology Education: Innovations in Practice, 18, 001–028. Mills, L. A., Baker, L., Wakefield, J. S., & Angnakoon, P. (2018). How do high school students prefer to learn? In Digital Technologies: Sustainable Innovations for Improving Teaching and Learning (pp. 95-110). Springer, Cham. Raspopovic, M., & Jankulovic, A. (2017). Performance measurement of e-learning
using student satisfaction analysis. Information Systems Frontiers, 19(4), 869– 880. Ray, P. P. (2017). Internet of things for smart agriculture: Technologies, practices, and future direction. Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Smart Environments, 9(4), 395–420.
Student Perceptions of Traditional and Simulated Learning in Greenhouse Management 205
Schneider, D. (2019). The impact of immersive virtual reality on learning, post-Hoc; a cautionary tale. Issues and Trends in Educational Technology, 7(1). Silva, G. R., Donat, J. C., Rigoli, M. M., de Oliveira, F. R., & Kristensen, C. H.
(2016). A questionnaire for measuring presence in virtual environments: factor analysis of the presence questionnaire and adaptation into Brazilian Portuguese. Virtual Reality, 20(4), 237–242. Slanger, W. D., Berg, E. A., Fisk, P. S., & Hanson, M. G. (2015). A longitudinal cohort study of student motivational factors related to academic success and reten- tion using the college student inventory. Journal of College Student Retention: Research, Theory & Practice, 17(3), 278–302. Speak Up Research Initiative. (2016). Augmented and virtual reality in K-12
education: Current status and aspirations. Vesisenaho, M., Juntunen, M., Häkkinen, P., Pöysä-Tarhonen, J., Fagerlund, J., Miakush, I., & Parviainen, T. (2019). Virtual reality in education: Focus on the role of emotions and physiological reactivity—Journal of Virtual Worlds Research, 12(1). Webster, R., & Dues, J. F. (2017, June). System usability scale (SUS): Oculus Rift®
DK2 and Samsung Gear VR®. In 2017 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition.