Samuel Adekunle, Nyiko Chauke, Matthew Ikuabe, Clinton Aigbavboa, Beauty John (2023). Achieving Circular Economy Adoption In The Construction Industry: Hurdles To Cross In A Developing Country. In: Sustainable Construction in the Era of the Fourth Industrial Revolution. AHFE Open Access, vol. 107, pp. 106–113. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1003097
Sustainability and the ability to manage waste in the construction industry are critical to the construction industry efficiency. It is also important as it preserves the environment. The study adopted a quantitative approach via a well-structured questionnaire to identify the barriers to achieving the circular economy in the south African construction industry. Data was collected from construction industry professionals. The data collected was analysed, and the findings reveal that lack of education and awareness, lack of penalties on illegal dumping, and lack of knowledge of CE principles are the three most significant barriers to achieving CE in the construction industry. The study is important as it provides insight into the hurdles to overcome in achieving CE.
The construction of new structures and the rehabilitation and refurbish- ment of existing systems produce a lot of waste which must be combated to promote sustainability. The usage of material resources increases with population growth and threatens the availability of such resources for future generations; the application of circular economic principles promotes sustai- nability. The construction industry is increasingly under pressure to produce an adequate infrastructure to cater to the ever-growing world population with limited resources. During the construction industry activities, major environmental concerns include land degradation, landfill depletion, car- bon and greenhouse gas emissions, water pollution, high energy usage, and resource depletion through construction and demolition waste creation and the manufacturing of building materials. The circular economy concept has been shown to provide sustainability gains and achieve substantial econo- mic gains, thereby causing economic growth (Korhonen, Honkasalo and Seppälä, 2018).
The concept promotes utilisation, waste prevention, resource efficiency, reusability and recyclability. The circular economy concept has not been given a singularly accepted definition globally. Various researchers and institutions have adopted diverse definitions and perspectives to explain it; however, the
Achieving Circular Economy Adoption in the Construction Industry: Hurdles to Cross 107
crux concerns sustainability, efficiency and resource management. Several studies have proposed definitions; for instance, Nobre and Tavares, (2021) describe it as an economic system targeting zero waste and pollution through- out the material lifecycle. For Prieto-Sandoval, Jaca and Ormazabal, (2018) irrespective of the perspective of the author, the definition of the circular economy must include four components; these are recirculation of resources and energy, the importance for achieving sustainability, must state the close relationship with the innovation of the society and the approach must be multi-level. Similarly, Merli, Preziosi and Acampora, (2018) opined about the multi-dimensional nature of the circular economy concept. They are of the opinion that it consists of various subdivisions which must be aptly captu- red. Geissdoerfer et al., (2017) defined the circular economy as a regenerative system whereby the minimisation of resource waste, emission and energy lea- kage is ensured through slowing, closing and narrowing material and energy loops. Therefore, the continuous evolvement of this concept requires a stan- dardised definition that captures its scope and communicates its essence in a simplified manner. However, the absence of this definition does not affect its adoption’s inherent benefits.
The inherent benefits in the circular economy concepts thus provide the construction industry with the needed solution by reducing the usage of raw materials, safeguarding material resources, and lowering the carbon foot- print: it allows construction materials, goods, and components to be reused and recycled while preserving their value. In achieving its adoption throu- ghout the building lifecycle, Rahla, Mateus and Bragança, (2021) presented a framework throughout the product stage, construction process stage, use stage and end of life stage. The framework incorporates the use of BIM at the use stage. This was well explored by Charef, (2022) where the author made a case for the use of BIM in the circular economy concept.
This study is aimed primarily at investigating the barriers to the ado- ption of a circular economy in the construction industry in a developing country. The next section explores existing literature on barriers to the ado- ption of circular economy, the methodology section, findings and conclusion follow this.
BARRIERS TO CIRCULAR ECONOMY ADOPTION Hart et al., (2019) categorised the barriers to achieving circularity in the built environment into cultural, regulatory, financial and sectoral. Cultural barri- ers are concerned with the social, behavioural and managerial contexts, while the study identified the regulatory barriers as those concerned with policy and regulations. Other classifications based on financial and market-related (financial barriers) and the sectorally peculiar barriers unique to the constru- ction industry are classified as sectoral barriers. Through a literature review, Charef, Morel and Rakhshan, (2021) classified it into economical, sociologi- cal and environmental based on the tripod basis for sustainable development. Other classifications adopted by the study are technical, organisational and political. Other barriers include knowledge among stakeholders, CE evalu- ation methodology, Uncertainty and risk (Hossain et al., 2020). In a study
on prioritising the barriers to circular economy in construction and demoli- tion waste management, Mahpour, (2018) identified agency and ownership issues, a lack of integration of sustainable construction and demolition waste management, among others, as barriers.
In understanding the barriers to circular economy in the construction indu- stry, it has thus been researched from different perspectives and contexts. The aforementioned studies explored the barriers from diverse perspectives. They tried to categorise and identified these barriers in a bid to provide deeper insights. Some provided barrier-tailored drivers and solutions; the various solutions are thus based on the individual barriers identified. It is worthy of note that a recurring barrier is the challenge of regulation and policy.
METHODOLOGY
The study adopted a quantitative approach to achieve its objectives. A questionnaire well structured was distributed to construction industry pro- fessionals. Table 1 provides background information on these professionals. The data was collected from 103 respondents within the South African con- struction industry. The quantitative approach is a proven approach that researchers in the construction industry have widely adopted to provide a good understanding of various challenges in the construction industry in dif- ferent subject areas(Oladiran and Onatayo, 2019; Aliu and Aigbavboa, 2020; Aghimien et al., 2022; Akinradewo et al., 2022; Ikuabe et al., 2022; Adekunle et al., 2022). To understand the data collected, different analyses were perfor- med. The reliability was tested using the Cronbach Alpha, a value of 0.970 was achieved, showing that the instrument is reliable. The normality of the data set was tested using the Shapiro-Wilk test. The results revealed that the significance value (p) was less than 0.05 (Table 2). This indicated that the data did not follow a normal distribution. Furthermore, a Kruskal Wallis test was conducted to compare the responses based on the professional groups. The results indicated that there is no significant difference in the responses of the professionals as the value achieved are all greater than 0.05 (Pallant, 2010; Aliu et al., 2022).
FINDINGS Respondents Background Information
Table 1 shows that 46.6% of the respondents possess a bachelor’s degree, 6.8% possess a diploma, and 33% possess an honours degree. In comparison, 7.8% possess a master’s degree, and 5.8% have other qualifications. From the respondents, 3.9% were construction supervisors, 20.4% were engineers, 1.9% were environmentalists, 3.9% were health and safety agents/managers, 2.9% planners, 16.5% were project/construction managers, 41.7% were quantity surveyors. In terms of industry experience, 40.8% possess 1 to 5 years of experience, 7.8% had an experience between 11 and 15 years, 3.9% of the respondents had an experience between 16 and 20 years, 20.4% had an experience of 6 to 10 years while 3.9% of them had an experience of more than 20 years, 23.3% had an experience of under one year. The table
Achieving Circular Economy Adoption in the Construction Industry: Hurdles to Cross 109
Profession Frequency Percent Quantity surveyor 43 41.7 Construction supervisor 2 1.9 Engineer 21 20.4 Environmentalist 2 1.9 HSE professional 15 14.6 Planner 3 2.9 Project/Construction manager 17 16.5 Years of Experience Frequency Percent Under one year 24 23.3 1–5 years 42 40.8 6–10 years 21 20.4 11–15 years 8 7.8 16–20 years 4 3.9 More than 20 years 4 3.9
also shows that 25.2% work in a consulting environment, 50.5% work for a contractor, 10.7% for the government, 3.9% are self-employed, and 9.7% for other types of organisations not listed. The study was based in South Africa; respondents were asked to state the province in which the organi- sation they work is located. 3.9% of the respondents are in Eastern Cape, 1% are in Free State, 73.8% in Gauteng province, 3.9% in KwaZulu-Natal,
Statistic Sig Asymp.
Sig. Shapiro-Wilk Mean Std. Deviation Rank Wallis
H
Table 2. Analysis of barriers.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Barriers Kruskal-
Lack of circular economy construction-based education and awareness 5.794 0.122 0.806 0.000 4.12 0.932 1 Lack of understanding of the potential of CE principles 4.463 0.216 0.822 0.000 3.91 0.876 2 Lack of penalties/sanctions on illegal dumping 5.551 0.136 0.843 0.000 3.89 0.959 3 Lack of interest, knowledge, and engagement 0.900 0.825 0.838 0.000 3.84 0.988 4 High upfront costs 2.033 0.566 0.858 0.000 3.84 1.073 5 Lack of regulations and laws 3.552 0.314 0.866 0.000 3.83 1.043 6 Lack of collaboration between businesses and business functions 4.083 0.253 0.865 0.000 3.83 0.961 7 Lack of regulatory mechanism 2.841 0.417 0.860 0.000 3.8 1.013 8 Absence of cooperation and information sharing among stakeholders 3.340 0.342 0.870 0.000 3.79 0.967 9 Inadequate financial resource 1.039 0.792 0.867 0.000 3.78 1.047 10 No statutory frameworks for material recovery 4.947 0.176 0.877 0.000 3.77 0.982 11 Stakeholder perception of CE products being inferior to virgin products 4.998 0.172 0.854 0.000 3.76 0.913 12 Lack of standards on the quality of secondary products 2.594 0.459 0.878 0.000 3.75 0.947 13 Fragmented nature of the construction industry 2.453 0.484 0.856 0.000 3.75 0.947 14 Lack of standardisation 2.081 0.556 0.843 0.000 3.73 0.842 15 Lack of guidelines and manuals for sorting and collection 4.532 0.209 0.865 0.000 3.73 1.031 16 Lack of effective CE-based knowledge management systems in the construction industry 5.280 0.152 0.871 0.000 3.73 0.931 17 Waste management legislation and government regulatory measures for CE are not
binding or not enforced. 3.320 0.345 0.846 0.000 3.73 0.92 18
Insufficient environmental-friendly instruments 2.098 0.552 0.869 0.000 3.71 1.016 19 The technical challenge related to material recovery 3.372 0.338 0.877 0.000 3.71 0.903 20 Fragmented supply chain 2.389 0.496 0.885 0.000 3.7 0.998 21 Administration and planning expenses are high. 1.698 0.637 0.885 0.000 3.69 1.039 22 Lack of international agreement and a lack of goals like energy efficiency 1.094 0.778 0.863 0.000 3.66 1.062 23 Deconstruction is more complex than demolition. 2.690 0.442 0.876 0.000 3.66 0.913 24 Low virgin material prices 0.442 0.931 0.876 0.000 3.5 0.948 25
Achieving Circular Economy Adoption in the Construction Industry: Hurdles to Cross 111
3.9% in Limpopo, 3.9% are in Mpumalanga, 2.9% in Northern Cape, 1.9% in Northwest and 4.9% are in Western Cape.
Barriers to Circular Economy Adoption The results (Table 2) presents the analysis of the barriers. It is noteworthy that all barriers presented to the respondents are significant as they all achieved a value above 3.00. From the table, the top three ranked barriers are lack of circular economy-based education and awareness had a mean of 4.12 and a standard deviation of 0.932. Lack of understanding of the potential of circu- lar economy principles had a mean of 3.91 and a standard deviation of 0.876. The lack of penalties/ sanctions on illegal dumping had a mean of 3.89 and a standard deviation of 0.959. The least ranked barriers include deconstruction is more complex than demolition, which was indexed number twenty-three with a mean of 3.66 and a standard deviation of 0.913. Lack of international agreement and a lack of goals like energy efficiency had a mean of 3.66 and a standard deviation of 1.062. The least ranked barrier, low virgin material prices, had a mean of 3.50 and a standard deviation of 0.948.
The result suggests that the most significant barrier to the adoption of a circular economy is the lack of awareness and education among stakeh- olders. This is described as the crux and overarching barrier (Hart et al., 2019). Without adequate construction-based circular economy education among the industry stakeholders, it will be difficult to achieve the ado- ption. It is difficult to adopt or use anything without adequate knowledge. An industry-wide (vertical and horizontal) circular economy is important to inform stakeholders of the circular economy principles. The introduction of circular economy education in the curriculum and continuous professional development courses is also essential.
Also, there is a need for a regulatory framework whereby responsibilities, obligations, penalties and rewards are clearly defined. This framework must affect waste management and adequately penalise defaulters. Like other inno- vations adopted in the construction industry, respondents also ranked cost as a critical aspect in the adoption of the circular economy. It thus points to the financial and investments aspect of the adoption. It also introduces the aspect of government support through fiscal incentives or support in achieving circular economy.
CONCLUSION
The adoption of circular economy is critical to achieving sustainability in the construction industry. It provides resource efficiency through reduce, reuse, and recycle principles. It thus provides circularity and ensures that there is low consumption and high efficiency in terms of resources consumed in the construction industry. This also speaks to the limited resources available to the construction industry and lowers the negative environmental impact through industry activities. The findings of this study reveal that the most significant barrier is the lack of circular economy awareness and education in the construction industry. Other barriers include the lack of circular eco- nomy regulatory framework/ policies. There is a need for proper awareness
of circular economy among industry stakeholders. Furthermore, an imple- mentation plan affecting the supply chain is required. Supporting this is the fiscal incentives by the government.
REFERENCES
Adekunle, S. et al. (2022) ‘A principal component analysis of Organisational BIM Implementation’, Modular and Offsite Construction (MOC) Summit Proceedings, pp. 161–168. doi: 10.29173/MOCS278. Aghimien, D. et al. (2022) ‘Help, I am not coping with my job!-A work-life
balance strategy for the Eswatini construction industry Strategies required for improved WLB’, Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management. doi: 10.1108/ECAM-11-2021-1060. Akinradewo, O. I. et al. (2022) ‘A principal component analysis of barriers to the implementation of blockchain technology in the South African built environment Principal component analysis of barriers’, Journal of Engineering, Design and Technology. doi: 10.1108/JEDT-05-2021-0292. Aliu, J. et al. (2022) ‘Developing emotionally competent engineers for the ever-
changing built environment’, Engineering Construction and Architectural Mana- gement. doi: 10.1108/ECAM-08-2022-0806. Aliu, J. and Ohis Aigbavboa, C. (2020) ‘Employers’ perception of employability skills among built-environment graduates’, Journal of Engineering, Design and Technology, 18(4), pp. 847–864. doi: 10.1108/JEDT-06-2019-0162. Charef, R. (2022) ‘The use of Building Information Modelling in the circular eco-
nomy context: Several models and a new dimension of BIM (8D)’, Cleaner Engineering and Technology, 7, p. 100414. doi: 10.1016/J. CLET.2022.100414. Charef, R., Morel, J. C. and Rakhshan, K. (2021) ‘Barriers to implementing the circular economy in the construction industry: A critical review’, Sustainability (Switzerland), 13(23). doi: 10.3390/SU132312989. Geissdoerfer, M. et al. (2017) ‘The Circular Economy – A new sustaina- bility paradigm?’, Journal of Cleaner Production, 143, pp. 757–768. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.12.048. Hart, J. et al. (2019) ‘Barriers and drivers in a circular economy: The case of
the built environment’, Procedia CIRP, 80, pp. 619–624. doi: 10.1016/J. PRO- CIR.2018.12.015. Hossain, M. U. et al. (2020) ‘Circular economy and the construction industry: Existing trends, challenges and prospective framework for sustaina- ble construction’, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 130. doi: 10.1016/J. RSER.2020.109948. Ikuabe, M. et al. (2022) ‘Hindering factors to the utilisation of UAVs for constru-
ction projects in South Africa’, Modular and Offsite Construction (MOC) Summit Proceedings, pp. 154–160. doi: 10.29173/MOCS277. Korhonen, J., Honkasalo, A. and Seppälä, J. (2018) ‘Circular economy: the concept and its limitations’, Ecol Econ, 143, pp. 37–46. doi: 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2017.06.041. Mahpour, A. (2018) ‘Prioritizing barriers to adopt circular economy in construction and demolition waste management’, Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 134, pp. 216–227. doi: 10.1016/J. RESCONREC.2018.01.026. Merli, R., Preziosi, M. and Acampora, A. (2018) ‘How do scholars approach the
circular economy? A systematic literature review’, Journal of Cleaner Production, 178, pp. 703–722. doi: 10.1016/J. JCLEPRO.2017.12.112.
Achieving Circular Economy Adoption in the Construction Industry: Hurdles to Cross 113
Nobre, G. C. and Tavares, E. (2021) ‘The quest for a circular economy final definition: A scientific perspective’, Journal of Cleaner Production, 314. doi: 10.1016/J. JCLEPRO.2021.127973. Oladiran, O. and Onatayo, D. (2019) ‘Labour productivity: Perception of site mana-
gers on building projects’, LAUTECH Journal of Civil and Environmental Studies, 2(Issue 1). doi: 10.36108/LAUJOCES/9102/20(0110). Pallant, J. (2010) SPSS Survival Manual. 4th edn. McGraw-Hill Companies. Prieto-Sandoval, V., Jaca, C. and Ormazabal, M. (2018) ‘Towards a consensus on the circular economy’, Journal of Cleaner Production, 179, pp. 605–615. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.12.224. Rahla, K., Mateus, R. and Bragança, L. (2021) ‘Implementing Circular Economy
Strategies in Buildings—From Theory to Practice’, Applied System Innovation, 4(2), p. 26. doi: 10.3390/ASI4020026.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Sustainable Construction in the Era of the Fourth Industrial Revolution
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-83-4
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional