Şura Toptanci (2023). An integrated FUCOM-ARAS model for ergonomic risk assessment. In: Physical Ergonomics and Human Factors. AHFE Open Access, vol. 103, pp. 15–23. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1003030
Many workers suffer from occupational musculoskeletal disorders and mental burdens in workplaces. A number of ergonomic risk factors such as human-related, cognitive, and physical contribute to inducing these burdens in the workplaces. Thus, ergonomic risk assessment is conducted to determine these risk factors and to reduce their negative effects by providing safer and healthy working environments. The aim of this study is to introduce a new ergonomic risk assessment approach for revealing the most important ergonomic risk factors and the worker who is most affected by these risk factors while performing tasks in a distribution center. For this reason, an integrated multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) model which consists of the Full Consistency Method (FUCOM) and Additive Ratio Assessment (ARAS) methods to achieve the purpose of the study has been developed in this study. The FUCOM method is applied to calculate the weights of human-related, cognitive, and physical risk factors, separately. Then, the ARAS method is used to determine which worker has more exposed to ergonomic risks. This study can contribute to occupational safety managements of the companies to conduct more systematic ergonomic risk assessment activities and prepare effective ergonomic improvement programs.
Occupational musculoskeletal disorders and high-level of mental burdens are serious health problems. Besides, many workers suffer from these problems in the workplaces every year. These problems cause losses in terms of workday, time, income, job, productivity and so on. The economic costs of these problems are also high. Many ergonomic risk factors may induce occupational musculoskeletal disorders and high-level mental workload. Thus, it is essential to conduct ergonomic risk assessment studies in the workplaces to analyze the current situations, measure the exposure levels of workers to ergonomic risks and determine the necessity of the ergonomic improvements.
Many factors and workers are included in ergonomic risk assessment process. Therefore, in recent years, it is considered as a multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) problem in the literature. There are many MCDM techniques to solve decision problems. In the literature, these techniques have been successfully used in a variety of fields. However, in literature, to the best our knowledge, a few studies have been conducted using MCDM methods in the ergonomic risk assessment processes (see Table 1).
Table 1. Research studies using MCDM methods in ergonomic risk assessment process.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Author (year) Sector Method(s) Aim(s) of the study Talapatra et al. (2022) Fuzzy AHP Prioritization of risk factors Khan et al. (2021) Manufacturing Fuzzy DEMATEL
Prioritization of risk factors Upadhyay et al. (2021)
Online education Fuzzy AHP Prioritization of risk factors Kılıç Delice and Can (2020)
Tube manufacturing
KEMIRA-M, BWM and MOORA
Prioritization of risk factors and ranking workers Adar and Kılıç Delice (2020)
Local public transportation
AHP-COPRAS Prioritization of risk factors and ranking workers Mamak Ekinci and Can (2018)
Juice manufacturing
CRITIC- MAIRCA Entropy Prioritization of risk factors
Prioritization of risk factors and ranking workers Khandan et al. (2016)
Arc Opal dishes manufacturing company
The aim of this study is to perform an ergonomic risk assessment activity in a different application field using a new integrated MCDM model. In this study, a MCDM-based ergonomic risk assessment model is developed to assess human-related, cognitive and physical ergonomic risk factors in a distribution center. Musculoskeletal and repetitive motion disorders are frequently occurred in distribution centers due to performing manual handling tasks, awkward working postures and other related tasks (Zhao et al. 2022). Thus, ergonomic risk exposures of workers who performing warehouse activities in a distribution center are evaluated by using Full Consistency Method (FUCOM) and Additive Ratio Assessment (ARAS) methods in the present study. The FUCOM method is utilized to find the importance weights of ergonomic risk factors in the workplace and the ARAS method is used to rank exposure levels of the workers to ergonomic risks.
The following sections present the methodology used, the application of the proposed model, the results obtained, and the conclusion part of the study, respectively.
METHODOLOGY
FUCOM Method The criteria do not have the same degree of importance in real decision- making problems. Besides, determining the relative criteria weights is a significant problem since it also affects the final results. The weights of criteria can be calculated utilizing MCDM methods. In this study, the FUCOM method as a new MCDM method developed by Pamuˇcar et al.
An Integrated FUCOM-ARAS Model for Ergonomic Risk Assessment 17
(2018) is proposed to obtain the criteria weights. The FUCOM method is summarized in the following steps (Pamuˇcar et al.; 2018).
Equations and mathematical formulas are available in the original paper PDF.
C1, C2, . . . , Cn
are ranked. If C1 is more important than C2, this judgement is demonstrated as C1(k = 1) > C2(k = 2). Here, j shows the number of criteria and k indicates the rank of criteria.
Step 2. The comparative priority of the criteria is computed using 1–9 scale (1: the lowest, 9: the highest). To determine the comparative priority, the rank of each criterion is compared with the rank of the next criterion. The comparative priorities are expressed as ϕ =
ϕ1/2, ϕ2/3, . . . , ϕk/(k + 1) Step 3. The final relative weight values of the criteria (w1, w2, . . . , wn)T are computed. These values should satisfy the conditions given below.
Condition 1. The ratio of the weight values is equal to the comparative priority among the criteria
Condition 2. The final relative weight values of the criteria should satisfy the !
. Based
feature of mathematical transitivity
⊗ϕ (k + 1)
ϕ k (k + 1) on this feature, another condition is obtained as follows:
(k + 2) (1)
wk wk + 1
The final relative weight values of the criteria can be determined using the following mathematical model:
−ϕk/(k + 1)
wj(k) wj(k + 1)
min χ
wj(k) wj(k + 2)
The final weight values of the criteria (w1, w2, . . . , wn)T and deviation from the full consistency (DFC:χ) are obtained by solving model in Eq. (2). If there is a maximum consistency, the DFC value is 0. Besides, the sum of weights is 1.
18 Toptancı
ARAS Method A finite number of alternatives are ranked by evaluating them under various predefined criteria in decision-making problems. There are many MCDM methods used to sort alternatives and select the most appropriate one in the decision problem. ARAS method introduced by Zavadskas and Turskis in 2010 is suggested to rank the alternatives in this study. This method computes the utility degree of each alternative in the problem. The steps of ARAS method are described as follows:
xij
mxn is constructed and optimum values of criteria (x0j) are calculated. Here, xij indicates the assessment values of alternative i against criterion j. In addition, m and n show the number of alternatives and criteria in the decision problem. If there is no information for the optimum values of criteria, Eqs. (3) and (4) are utilized based on the type of criteria.
Step 2. The decision matrix is normalized. Eqs. (5) and (6) are used based on the type of criteria.
for benefit criteria (5)
1 xij Pm
1 xij
dij
mxn is constructed.
dij
where wj indicates the weights of criteria.
Step 4. The optimality function values (Si) are computed.
where Si shows the optimality function value of ith alternative.
Step 5. Utility degrees (Ki) and rankings of alternatives are determined.
where S0 shows the value of optimality function of dummy alternative. Ki are ranked from the highest to the lowest values.
An Integrated FUCOM-ARAS Model for Ergonomic Risk Assessment 19
Proposed Ergonomic Risk Assessment Model The proposed MCDM model has two stages as obtaining the importance weights of ergonomic risk criteria, and ranking workers considering their ergonomic risk exposure levels through using FUCOM and ARAS methods. The methodology of the proposed ergonomic risk assessment model is given below.
First stage: Determination of ergonomic risk criteria sets and calculation of criteria weights.
Ergonomic risk factors were categorized into three main different criterion sets namely human-related (MC1), cognitive (MC2), and physical (MC3) risk criteria considering their different contents. There are three ergonomic risk factors in HR as age (RF1), body mass index (RF2), and musculoskeletal pain level (RF3). CR includes six factors of the NASA Task Load Index (NASA- TLX) method which are mental demand (RF4), physical demand (RF5), temporal demand (RF6), performance (RF7), effort (RF8), and frustration (RF9) factors. Besides, PR consists of three factors of the Rapid Entire Body Assessment (REBA) method which are total musculoskeletal risk score on neck, trunk, and leg segments (RF10), total musculoskeletal risk score on arms and wrist segments (RF11), and load weight (RF12).
The occupational safety expert group evaluates the importance of each criterion set in consensus. The weights of the main criteria and sub-criteria are calculated via the FUCOM algorithm. In this process, a total of four- dimensional FUCOM model is constructed. MS Excel Solver is used to solve these models.
Second stage: Computation of ergonomic risk exposures of alternatives and ranking alternatives with ARAS method.
Workers are the alternatives of the ergonomic risk assessment problem. A questionnaire is prepared and video records are utilized to obtain data needed for the analysis. The questionnaire includes individual and NASA- TLX workload assessment questions and it is implemented to the workers after they complete their task. Nevertheless, the video records are taken while the workers are performing the tasks. These records are used to calculate the risk scores of the three components of the REBA method. The NASA-TLX workload assessment and REBA methods are widely utilized and well-known techniques in the area of ergonomics. Thus, the implementation steps of these techniques are not presented in this study.
After obtaining data, ergonomic risk exposures level for each worker are computed using ARAS algorithm. Then, the rankings of workers respect to their ergonomic risk exposure level are determined. Later, ergonomic improvements are suggested to minimize the effect of the ergonomic risks on the worker who is most at risk.
APPLICATION OF THE PROPOSED MODEL FOR A DISTRIBUTION CENTER In this study, the applicability of the proposed ergonomic risk assessment model is presented with a real application. The data was obtained from five
20 Toptancı
workers who perform warehouse activities in a distribution center in Türkiye. Ergonomic risk factors were determined based on the literature review and the opinions of occupational safety expert group who work in this center. The ergonomic risk factors were considered as criteria of this ergonomic risk assessment problem. The workers were asked to respond the questions in the questionnaire prepared considering their individual and working conditions in the workplace. Video records were also taken to obtain related REBA risk scores.
The occupational safety expert group assessed the importance of all criteria in consensus in this study. The rankings of the main criteria (MC1, MC2, and MC3) and sub-criteria of each main criterion according to the opinion of expert group are shown in Table 2.
Table 2. Rankings of the main criteria and sub-criteria.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Criteria Ranking Main criteria MC3 > MC2 > MC1 Sub-criteria of MC1 RF3 > RF2 > RF1 Sub-criteria of MC2 RF5 > RF8 > RF6 > RF7 > RF4 > RF9 Sub-criteria of MC3 RF12 > RF10 > RF11
Pairwise comparisons of criteria were performed by the experts for second step of the FUCOM algorithm according to the most important criterion in each set. The evaluation results of the main criteria and sub-criteria are demonstrated in Table 3.
Table 3. Evaluation scores of the main criteria and sub-criteria.
An Integrated FUCOM-ARAS Model for Ergonomic Risk Assessment 21
The comparative priorities of the main criteria and sub-criteria are calculated as follows, respectively: ϕMC3/MC2 = 2/1 = 2; ϕMC2/MC1 = 5/2 = 2.5; ϕRF3/RF2 = 3/1 = 3;
ϕRF12/RF10 = 2/1 = 2; ϕRF10/RF11 = 5/2 = 2.5 The conditions explained in the third step of FUCOM algorithm were checked for main criteria and their sub-criteria. As an example, the results of two conditions obtained for main criteria were demonstrated as follows, respectively:
wMC3 wMC2
wMC3 wMC1
wMC1
Then, four mathematical models for all criteria were constructed and solved to determine their weights. As an example, the model constructed for main criteria was given as follows:
wMC3 wMC2
wMC2 wMC1
wMC3 wMC1
min χ
The final weight values of main criteria and the DFC (χ) were computed as (0.118, 0.294, 0.588)T and χ= 0.000, respectively through solving above model. After constructing and solving other models, the final weight values of sub-criteria were also obtained. The weight values of each criteria are shown in Table 4.
According to the result, it can be concluded that MC3: physical ergonomic risk criteria set is the most important main criteria and RF12: load weight is the most important sub-criteria.
Table 4. Final weight values of main criteria and sub-criteria.
After determining weight values of criteria, the workers are assessed based on these ergonomic risk criteria. The assessment results are depicted in Table 5.
All ergonomic risk factors are considered as benefit criteria since it is aimed to sort the risk exposure levels of the workers in this study. The ARAS algorithm was used to determine the ergonomic risk exposures of workers. Table 6 presents the exposure levels and ranking results of the workers.
The rankings of workers based on the ergonomic risk exposure level were obtained as Worker1 > Worker3 > Worker2 > Worker5 > Worker4. As a result, the fourth worker is exposed to much more ergonomic risks than others. Therefore, ergonomic improvements should be made to reduce the exposure level to ergonomic risks in the workplace. Otherwise, many health problems, especially musculoskeletal disorders, may occur. For this purpose, break intervals at the workplace can be rearranged based on the workload, work area can be redesigned considering anthropometric measurements of workers, auxiliary equipment can be utilized for manual materials handling tasks, and an ergonomics awareness training program can be organized for workers in order to carry out the manual handling works accurately and to know right working posture while performing their tasks.
CONCLUSION
In this study, it is aimed to present a new ergonomic risk assessment model for determining the importance of ergonomic risk factors and the worker who are most exposed to ergonomic risks. Therefore, an integrated MCDM model consists of FUCOM and ARAS methods is developed in this study. The FUCOM method is proposed to obtain the weights of ergonomic risk criteria. In this process, four
An Integrated FUCOM-ARAS Model for Ergonomic Risk Assessment 23
mathematical models depending on criterion sets are constructed to obtain optimum weights. In addition, ARAS method is proposed to rank the workers based on their exposure level to ergonomic risks in the workplace. This study has contributed to ergonomics literature since very few studies in the literature use MCDM models in ergonomic risk assessment process. In future studies, the model used in this study and the results obtained can be considered in the ergonomic improvement activities organized by the occupational safety managements of companies to reduce the impacts of ergonomic risk factors. Besides, other MCDM methods can be used to make comparison analyses and uncertainty issues can be taken into account to cope with subjectivity in the ergonomic assessment process.
REFERENCES
Adar, T. and Kılıç Delice, E. (2020). ¸Sehir içi toplu ta¸sıma ¸soförlerinin toplam i¸s yüklerinin fiziksel ve zihinsel i¸s yükü ölçütlerine göre yeni bir yakla¸sımla kar¸sıla¸stırılması. PAMUKKALE UNIVERSITY JOURNAL OF ENGINEERING SCIENCES Volume 26 No. 1. Delice, E. K. and Can, G. F. (2020). A new approach for ergonomic risk assessment
integrating KEMIRA, best–worst and MCDM methods. SOFT COMPUTING. Khan, N. Z., Siddiquie, R. Y., Shihab, S. K., Siddiquee, A. N., Khan, Z. A. (2021).
Analyzing the Important Factors Causing Fatigue in Industrial Workers Using Fuzzy MCDM Technique. In: Muzammil, M., Khan, A. A., Hasan, F. (Eds.) Ergonomics for Improved Productivity. Design Science and Innovation. Springer, Singapore. Khandan, M., Nili, M., Koohpaei, A. and Mosaferchi, S. (2016). Integrating the ergonomics techniques with multi criteria decision making as a new approach for risk management: An assessment of repetitive tasks-entropy case study. JOURNAL OF RESEARCH IN HEALTH SCIENCES Volume 16 No. 2. Mamak Ekinci, E. B. and Can, G. F. (2018). Algilanan i¸s yükü ve çali¸sma duru¸slari
dikkate alinarak operatörlerin ergonomik risk düzeylerinin çok kriterli karar verme yakla¸simi ile de˘gerlendirilmesi. ERGONOMICS Volume 1 No. 2. Pamuˇcar, D., Stevi´c, Ž. and Sremac, S.. (2018). A New Model for Determining Weight Coefficients of Criteria in MCDM models: Full Consistency Method (FUCOM), SYMMETRY Volume 10 No. 9. Talapatra, S., Parvez, M. S., Saha, P., Kibria, M. G. and Hoque, A. S. M. (2022).
Musculoskeletal risk factors assessment based on exploratory factor analysis and fuzzy analytical hierarchy process, THEORETICAL ISSUES IN ERGONOMICS SCIENCE. Upadhyay, H., Juneja, S., Juneja, A., Dhiman, G. and Kautish, S. (2021).
Evaluation of ergonomics-related disorders in online education using fuzzy AHP, COMPUTATIONAL INTELLIGENCE AND NEUROSCIENCE. Zavadskas, E. K. and Turskis, Z. (2010). A new additive ratio assessment (ARAS) method in multicriteria decision-making. TECHNOLOGICAL AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OF ECONOMY Volume 16 No. 2. Zhao, Y. S., Jaafar, M. H., Mohamed, A. S. A., Azraai, N. Z. and Amil, N. (2022).
Ergonomics Risk Assessment for Manual Material Handling of Warehouse Activities Involving High Shelf and Low Shelf Binning Processes: Application of Marker-Based Motion Capture. SUSTAINABILITY Volume 14 No. 10.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Physical Ergonomics and Human Factors
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-79-7
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional