Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

The Influence of Visual Balance of Interface Elements Layout on the Attractiveness of APP Guide Pages

School of Mechanical Engineering, Southeast University, Nanjing 211189, China ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1002899

Abstract

Guide page design is an important part in APP design. A good guide page can attract users' interest and attention in a short time and effectively transmit information. Therefore, attractiveness is a key factor in evaluating design of APP guide pages. In the actual design activities, most of the interface elements in guide pages are arranged in the form of high balance. In order to explore the relationship between attractiveness of APP guide pages and this arrangement, this study collected samples of 40 guide page design and the corresponding user access data from zcool.com (a well-known Chinese design social website). Interface aesthetic evaluation method is applied to calculate the value of the three indicators (balance, equilibrium and symmetry) associated with visual balance, SPSS analysis results show that visual balance has an important potential impact on improving the attractiveness of APP guide page.

INTRODUCTION

With the popularity of smart phones, a large number of apps appear in peo- ple’s life. Whether an app can successfully attract users’ attention in a large number of apps is an important prerequisite to determine the success of this app (Xing et al., 2021). In the design of app interface, guide pages plays a crucial role in improving its attractiveness. The guide page, which usually appears when starting to use the app, is short in duration and contains ima- ges and concise text information. The aim of guide pages is to introduce the basic functions and features of the product to the user, which determines the user’s first impression of the entire app.

The content of the guide page is usually fixed: an illustration or other image, a set of key words, and a short explanatory sentence. The arrange- ment of these elements affects users’ aesthetic experience of APP guide pages to a certain extent. Since guide pages only appears for a few seconds during the use of the APP, it is necessary to effectively attract users’ attention. The- refore, the aesthetic measurement of the interface layout plays a key role in the design of guide pages. Ngo et al. proposed a calculation method to measure interface aesthetic and proved its practical value (Ngo et al., 2003). Lai et al. confirmed a high correlation between visual balance and aesthe- tic experience in image layout (Lai et al., 2010). Zhou et al. constructed an

© 2023. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 763

764 Wang and Zhang

interactive interface aesthetic evaluation method and verified its effectiveness through experiments (Zhou et al., 2013). Wang et al. demonstrated the effect of visual aesthetic factors on users’ emotions through experiments (Wang et al., 2020). This study applies the interface aesthetic evaluation method to evaluate the aesthetic of the interface elements layout of APP guide page cases on Zcool.com, and proves the key role of balance and equilibrium among visual aesthetic facets in improving the attractiveness of APP guide pages.

BASIC CONCEPT According to previous studies, The facets to measure the aesthetic of interface layout mainly includes Balance, Equilibrium, Symmetry, Sequence, Cohesion, Unity, Proportion, Simplicity, Density, Regularity, Economy, Homogeneity, Rhythm, etc (Zhou et al., 2014). The measurement of interface balance aesth- etic is mainly reflected in Balance, Equilibrium and Symmetry (Tsi et al., 2013). Balance refers to the visual weight of interface elements distributed on the left-right and on the top-bottom. The corresponding visual weight of an element is positively correlated with its size; Equilibrium is related to the coincidence degree between the overall visual center of each element in the interface and the center of the interface. A higher coincidence degree can increase the visual stability of the interface; Symmetry reflects the similarity and repeatability of elements in the interface according to horizontal central axis, vertical central axis and geometric center point of the interface. The higher the similarity and repeatability, the higher the aesthetic experience of symmetry of the interface layout (Moshagen and Thielsch, 2010).

Balance Balance is a measure of visual weight, which depends on the integrated value of the visual distribution of elements in the APP interface. For any one dimen- sion, the visual weight balance of the distribution of elements is determined by the size of the area of the elements on either side of the axis and the dista- nce from the axis (Schmidt, 2009). The equation of balance is expressed as follows:

wL−wR max(|wL|,|wR|)

Equations and mathematical formulas are available in the original paper PDF.

wT−wB max(|wT|,|wB|)

2 ∈[0, 1] nj X

aii is the area of element i in j; dii is the distance between the central lines of element i and the interface; ni is the number of elements in j; L is the left side of the interface; R is the right side of the interface; T is the top side of the interface; B is the Bottom side of the interface.

The Influence of Visual Balance of Interface Elements Layout on the Attractiveness 765

Equilibrium Equilibrium depends on the degree of coordination between the center of the distribution of elements and the center of the entire interface. In APP interface, if the center of the entire interface and the center of the distribution of elements has a high degree of coincidence, or is relatively close, then the interface has a high degree of equilibrium. Its formula is as follows:

Pn

Pn

i ai(xi−xc) nbframe

i ai(yi−yc) nhframe

i ai

i ai

2 Pn

(xi, yi) is the coordinate of element i; (xc, yc) is the coordinate of the interface; bframe and hframe are the width and height of the interface; n is the total number of elements.

Symmetry Similarity refers to the similarity degree of distribution of elements in APP interface on both sides of the coordinate axis, or the symmetry degree of elements on both sides of the coordinate axis. The measurement and calcu- lation of similarity depends on the size and distance comparison of elements distributed on both sides of the coordinate axis (Ben-Bassat, 2006), and the calculation method is as follows: SyV

SyH

SyR

3 ∈[0, 1] X′UL −X′UR + X′LL −X′LR + Y′UL −Y′UR +

Y′LL −Y′LR

+ H′UL −H′UR

H′LL −H′LR

B′UL −B′UR

B′LL −B′LR

+ θ′UL −θ′UR

θ′LL −θ′LR

R′UL −R′UR

R′LL −R′LR

X′UL −X′LL

X′UR −X′LR

Y′UL −Y′LL

Y′UR −Y′LR

+ H′UL −H′LL

H′UR −H′LR

B′UL −B′LL

B′UR −B′LR

+ θ′UL −θ′LL

θ′UR −θ′LR

R′UL −R′LL

R′UR −R′LR

X′UL −X′LR

X′UR −X′LL

Y′UL −Y′LR

Y′UR −Y′LL

+ H′UL −H′LR

H′UR −H′LL

B′UL −B′LR

B′UR −B′LL

+ θ′UL −θ′LR

θ′UR −θ′LL

R′UL −R′LR

R′UR −R′LL

yij −yc

766 Wang and Zhang

yij −yc xij −xc

xij −xc

yij −yc

i UL is the upper-left area of the interface; UR is the upper-right area of the interface; LL is the lower-left area of the interface; LR is the lower-left area of the interface; (xii, yii) is the coordinate of element i in j; (xc, yc) is the coordinate of the interface; bii and hii are the width and height of the element i in j; ni is the total number of elements in j; X′i, Y′i, H′i, B′i, θ′i, R′i are respectively the normalized values of Xi, Yi, Hi, Bi, θi, Ri.

METHODOLOGY

In this study, 40 guide page design cases and the corresponding popularity and recommendation numbers were collected from zcool.com. zcool is a Chi- nese website that provides a platform for designers to share and communicate their works. The popularity of a work is determined by the number of times the work is clicked and viewed, which reflects the attraction degree of the work to website users among many other works. The number of recommen- dations refers to the number of people who choose to recommend a work after browsing it, which is similar to the number of “likes”. It reflects the degree of liking of website users for the work. In the top 80 works accor- ding to the default sort of the website, 40 works were randomly selected as samples, and their corresponding popularity and recommendation number were recorded. Samples and corresponding data were collected on March 25, 2022. The obtained guide page samples are then processed. Through experi- ments, Ngo et al. found that the content of interface elements are not affecting users’ overall aesthetic perception (Ngo et al., 2003); Tsai et al. ‘s study demonstrated that when the text elements are involved in the experiment, the two methods of calculating the background area of the whole text and the sum of the background area of each character are equally feasible and effective (Tsai et al., 2013). Therefore, in this study, image elements in guide page samples are transformed into rectangles according to their boundaries, and continuous text elements are also transformed into rectangles according to their overall boundaries through Photoshop. As shown in Table 1.

The width and height of the interface and the width, height and coordinates of elements in the interface are measured in pixels in Photoshop.

The Influence of Visual Balance of Interface Elements Layout on the Attractiveness 767

Table 1. Part of the results of balance values of samples collected.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Facets Sample 01 Sample 02 Sample 03 Sample 04 Sample 05 ...

Balance 0.72898 0.74742 0.74477 0.73373 0.77103 ... Equilibrium 0.98535 0.98511 0.97972 0.98933 0.99022 ... Symmetry 0.66710 0.66776 0.66841 0.66882 0.66761 ...

CONCLUSION

According to the aesthetic evaluation method of interface layout, this study evaluates the collected 40 guide page samples based on Matlab, and obtains the aesthetic value of each sample in 3 facets. Part of the results are as follows: After obtaining the aesthetic evaluation results of 40 groups of sample data, the data was imported into SPSS for regression analysis. Among them, the prediction variables are balance, equilibrium and symmetry, and the regression analysis is carried out on the two dependent variables of popularity and recommendation respectively.

R-Squared Value and Significance By comparing the analysis results of two different dependent variables, the adjusted R-square value of the three balance measurements for the popula- rity is 0.783, while for the recommendation degree is 0.170. Generally, if the value of R square is greater than 0.7, it means that the prediction variables can describe the dependent variable accurately. Therefore, the aesthetic eva- luation indexes related to the balance degree has a high correlation with the popularity of APP guide page, while the correlation with the recommendation degree is not obvious.

In addition, for the dependent variable of popularity, the significance of balance and equilibrium indexes are 0.000 and 0.010 respectively, both of which are less than 0.05, indicating that these two indexes have a significant impact on popularity. The significance of symmetry index is 0.585, so the influence of symmetry index on popularity is not obvious.

Durbin-Watson Value and VIF Value For the dependent variable popularity, the Durbin-Watson value of the three prediction variables is 1.844, which is close to 2, proves that the autocor- relation among the three variables of balance, equilibrium and symmetry is within the acceptable range. The VIF values of the three prediction variables of balance, equilibrium and symmetry are 3.206, 3.358 and 1.116, respecti- vely. VIF values below 5 indicate that the data of the three prediction variables don’t have strong collinearity.

Discussion

According to the results of regression analysis, balance, equilibrium and sym- metry, which reflect the visual balance measurement, largely determine the popularity of the APP guide page, that is, the degree to which users are attra- cted by the first impression in a short period of time; However, for another

768 Wang and Zhang

dimension of user attractiveness, recommendation, there is no great corre- lation, because recommendation reflects the decision made by users after observing all aspects of interface design details for a long time. At this time, the impact of visual balance on the overall aesthetic becomes relatively minor. To sum up, for APP guide pages whose main purpose is to attract users’ atten- tion in a short period of time, a sense of balance in the interface layout is particularly important, which is why the majority of design cases follow this rule.

REFERENCES

Ben-Bassat, T. Meyer, J. Tractinsky, N. (2006). Economic and Subjective Measures of the Perceived Value of Aesthetics and Usability”. ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction, 13(02), pp. 210–234. Lai, C. Y. Chen, P. H. Shih, S. W. Liu, Y. Hong, J. S. (2010). Computational models and

experimental investigations of effects of balance and symmetry on the aesthetics of text-overlaid images. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 68(1-2), pp. 41–56. Moshagen, M. Thielsch, M. T. (2010). Facets of Visual Aesthetics. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 68(10), pp. 689–709. Ngo, D. C. L. Teo, L. S. Byrne, J. G. (2003). Modelling interface aesthetics.

Information Sciences, 152, pp. 25–46. Schmidt, K. E. Liu, Y. S, Sridharan. (2009). Webpage Aesthetics, Performance and Usability: Design Variables and Their Effects. Ergonomics, 52(06), pp. 631–643. Tsai, M. T. Wang, K. A. Liu, Y. Hong, J. S. (2013). Perceived Visual Aesthetics of Text-

Overlaid Images: Computational Models and Experimental Research for White- Space Fraction. International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction, 30(01), pp. 1–23. Wang, J. Hsu, Y. (2020). The Relationship of Symmetry, Complexity, and Shape in Mobile Interface Aesthetics, from an Emotional Perspective—A Case Study of the Smartwatch. Symmetry, 12(09), 1403. Xing, B. Si, H. Chen, J. Ye, M. Shi, L. (2021). Computational model for predicting

user aesthetic preference for GUI using DCNNs. CCF Transactions on Pervasive Computing and Interaction, 3(02), pp. 147–169. Zhou, L. Xue, C. Tang, W. Li, J. Niu, Y. (2013). Aesthetic Evaluation Method of Interface Elements Layout Design. Journal of Computer-Aided Design & Computer Graphics, 25(05), pp. 758–766. Zhou, L. Xue, C. Tang, W. Li, J. Niu, Y. (2014). User Perceptual Prediction Model

of Product Information Interface. Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems, 20(03), pp. 544–554.

Cover of the proceedings volume Intelligent Human Systems Integration (IHSI 2023): Integrating People and Intelligent Systems

Explore the complete digital volume

Intelligent Human Systems Integration (IHSI 2023): Integrating People and Intelligent Systems

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-45-2

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →