Yunmeng Zhao, Ding-Bang Luh, Yue Sun (2022). Transforming the Elderly‘s Disadvantage into Advantage in Creativity Activities. In: Human Factors in Aging and Special Needs. AHFE Open Access, vol. 38, pp. 136–143. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1001673
Due to the crystal intelligence accumulated in life, the elderly have their unique advantages in creativity. However, in creativity activities, the elderly often lack self-confidence and motivation to participate because they are often perceived as lacking creativity, this phenomenon related to the degree of intersection of crystal intelligence between the evaluators involved in creativity evaluation and the older creators involved in creativity activities. The cross degree of crystal intelligence is closely related to the age difference. It is hypothesized that the lower the age intersection between the evaluator and the older respondent on Stenberg's writing domain creativity test, the higher the score of "originality" from the evaluators for the older respondent on the test. The creativity test in the writing domain proposed by Robert J. Sternberg is selected as the tool for this experiment. First, 6 elderly people aged 65 years and above with similar life experiences were recruited to take the creativity test in the domain of writing. Then 30 evaluators were recruited to evaluate the writing of 6 elderly people. The evaluators were divided into three equal groups, The first group of evaluators were 14 years old, the second group of evaluators were 31 years old, and the third group of evaluators were 48 years old. The lower the age intersection between the evaluator and the older respondent on Stenberg's writing domain creativity test, the higher the evaluation of "originality" from the evaluator for the older respondent on the test. The results of this study can provide a corresponding reference for constructing a creativity activity for the elderly, allowing the elderly to get more positive evaluation in creativity activities.
Society often positions the elderly as a vulnerable group, but overlooks that they also have unique advantages that other age groups do not. For example, the elderly are often considered to be lack of creativity, but is that really the case? There are many discussions on the relationship between age and crea- tivity. Research has proven that aging leads to a decline in divergent thinking skills and a decline in creativity influenced by divergent thinking (McCrae and Arenberg, 1987). Some scholars considered that compared with age, the creativity of the elderly is more affected by factors such as environment, working time, and the differences of individual and field (Simonto, 1990). Then, other scholars analyzed real cases and concluded that creativity will not decline with individual aging (Hickson and Housley, 1997). It was further
Transforming the Elderly’s Disadvantage into Advantage in Creativity Activities 137
suggested that knowledge and experience are the main factors affecting crea- tivity, and people of any age have the potential of creativity (Cohen, 2005). It was pointed out that professional age has a greater impact on creativity than chronological age (Kong and Rowena, 2016). To sum up, creativity does not decline or disappear with the increase of age, and the elderly are not a group lacking creativity.
For the elderly, exertion creativity can reduce stress and negative emoti- ons, strengthen the immune system and enhance social participation (Cohen, 2005). In the global context of population aging, encouraging the elderly to participate in creation is not only beneficial to their physical and mental health and reduce social medical costs, but also helps to stimulate the vitality of the elderly in their later years and give more positive impact to the society. Therefore, this paper aims to study how to transform the weakness of the elderly into an advantage in creativity, so that the elderly can get better per- formance in creative activities. In order to encourage the elderly to actively participate in creative activities, help the elderly see the value and significance of their old age, and improve the stereotype of the society for the elderly.
Starting from Sternberg’s creativity test, we highlights the crystal intellige- nce advantage of the elderly by formulating the evaluation strategy of the test, so that the elderly can reasonably obtain better evaluation scores in the test, so as to enhance their self-confidence, and provide corresponding reference for the construction of creativity games for the elderly.
CREATIVITY TEST IN THE FIELD OF WRITING A number of creativity measurement tools have been developed that are auth- oritative in the field of creativity research (Sternberg, 2006; Urban, 2005; Barbot, 2011). Among them, Sternberg proposed a creativity test in the field of writing, which was recognized by the academic community. . In this test, participants need to write stories based on one of the titles provided: “A Fifth Chance,” “2983,” “Beyond the Edge,” “Saved,” “Under the Table,” “Between the Lines,” “The Keyhole,” “The Octopus’s Sneakers,” “It’s Moving Backw- ards,” and “Not Enough Time”. The stories were assessed by a team of judges in reference to originality, complexity, emotional evocativeness, and descri- ptiveness (Lubart and Sternberg, 1996; Xue GUI, 2001; Sternberg, 2006). We sent an email to Robert J. Sternberg in June 2021 to ask for his explanation of the above four evaluation angles, and the reply was “these days we only rate novelty and usefulness.” This word is similar to the original “originality”, so we use “originality” as the evaluation angle of creativity test in writing field. We selected Sternberg’s creativity test in the field of writing to explore how to transform the weakness of the elderly in the test into an advantage, so that the elderly can get a better evaluation score in the creativity test.
CREATIVITY IN THE ELDERLY It was proposed that there are three main components of creativity, inclu- ding domain related skills, creativity relevant skills and task motivation (Amabile, 1983). Domain related skills depend on innate cognitive and motor abilities and acquired knowledge and skills. creativity relevant skills mainly
depend on experience and personality. Task motivation mainly depends on the external environment. In conclusion, innate cognitive and motor abili- ties, external environment, acquired knowledge, skills and experience which can also be summarized as crystal intelligence, and personality are important factors affecting creativity.
HIGHLIGHTING THE CRYSTAL INTELLIGENCE OF THE ELDERLY If we want to highlight the advantages of the elderly in the creativity test, we should pay more attention to the consideration and evaluation of crystal intelligence when evaluating the test results. A person’s age, living environ- ment, class, education level and occupation will affect the composition of this person’s crystal intelligence, thus affecting the story written in the crea- tivity test in the field of writing. A story makes the evaluator who reads the story feel “original”, usually because the story text is new to the evaluator, and there is little or no intersection between the story text and the evaluator’s crystal intelligence accumulated in the past.In order to reduce the intersection of the crystal intelligence of the evaluator and the subject as much as possible, it is necessary to control the background factors that will affect the crystal intelligence of the evaluator and the subject as little as possible. Among many background factors, age is an important factor affecting crystal intelligence. Therefore, it is hypothesized that the lower the age intersection between the evaluator and the older respondent on Stenberg’s writing domain creativity test, the higher the evaluation of “originality”from the evaluator for the older respondent on the test.
METHOD
Participants There were two types of subjects in this study: those who took the creativity test in writing field, that is, the writers, and those who evaluated the creativity test in the writing domain, that is, the evaluators.
Writers of Creativity Test in the Field of Writing A combination of national definitions of old age, people aged 60 or 65 years or older are generally referred to as elderly. Therefore, six senior citizens aged 65 years or older with similar living area, education, occupation, and marital history were selected. In this experiment, these writers were all from Wenzhou, China. They are all teachers with education above high school. And they have been married and have children.
Evaluator of Creativity Test in Writing Field The evaluators were divided into 3 groups, each containing 10 people,they were all from Wenzhou, China. The age difference between the evaluators of the three groups was 17. The first group of evaluators were 14 years old, the second group of evaluators were 31 years old, and the third group of evaluators were 48 years old.
Transforming the Elderly’s Disadvantage into Advantage in Creativity Activities 139
Instrument Creativity Tests in the Field of Writing The writer chooses one of the ten keywords given as the title and creates a story that is on topic within 30 minutes. The keyword list includes the following 10 terms:”A Fifth Chance,” “2983,” “Beyond the Edge,” “Saved,” “Under the Table,” “Between the Lines,” “The Keyhole,” “The Octopus’s Sneakers,” “It’s Moving Backwards,” and “Not Enough Time”. The stories of the six writers in this study are shown in the table below (see Table 1).
Consensus Assessment Technique (CAT) The Consensus Assessment Technique (CAT) involves organizing a evalua- tion panel and having the panelists score the creative work based on their own understanding of creativity. It has existed as the definitive method for creativity evaluation since its introduction by Amabile (Amabile, 1982), and many studies, and others have confirmed the reliability of CAT for creati- vity evaluation(Charles, 2015; Stefanic, 2014;Barth and Stadtmann,2020). In this study, the evaluators were divided into three age groups to evaluate the “originality” of the writers’ work on the Writing Domain Creativity Test.
Likert 7-Point Scale Scoring was on a likert 7-point scale, with 7 points for very creative, 6 points for very creative, 5 points for relatively creative, 4 points for generally cre- ative, 3 points for relatively uncreative, 2 points for very uncreative, and 1 point for very uncreative.
Procedure In order to prevent the influence of handwriting on the evaluation, all writers’ stories will be collected and sent to the evaluator in electronic format. The evaluation panel members were required to go through all the subjects’ works and then evaluate them in random order, with each member completing the evaluation independently.
CONCLUSION
The average of each evaluator’s rating of the six stories in each group is recor- ded as score in the table 2(see Table 2). It is known that average 1> average 2> average 3. The Test of Homogeneity of Variances was used to test the hypothesis of chi-square, and the test results are shown in Table 3 (see Table 3). p = 0.153 > 0.05, which is highly significant and can be considered as the variance is chi-squared, so the next step of one-way ANOVA can be performed.
The results of the analysis of variance (ANOVA) were used to show that the differences in scores between the three age groups were statistically signi- ficant (p<0.05) (see Table 4). The LSD method was used for the two-by-two comparison between the three groups, and the specific results are shown in Table 5 (see Table 5), which shows that the differences between any two age groups were statistically significant.
At that time, we had to wear new clothes for New Year’s Eve, there were delicious
food and firecrackers every New Year’s Eve, and we looked forward to the next New
Year’s Eve just after the New Year. Now it’s New Year’s Day every day, without
worrying about food and clothing. When I was a kid, I was so happy to have a good
pair of new shoes for the New Year, I didn’t care about the brand, I was satisfied with
the shoes, even though there were no socks at all. Now firecrackers are not even
allowed. But there is one thing, in the past, eating inside the consciousness does not
even consider hygiene, is not toxic, is not genetically modified products. We were
jumping rope, jumping pommel horse, playing marbles, boys jumping pommel horse,
playing water floating. But this era of the elderly can not keep up, the force can not
keep up with the times. Now for us the times are advancing, the body is lacking in
retrogression. We have not caught up with the good times, but society is moving
forward, so young people should cherish the present. We had to worry about food and
clothing, and you young people are worried about how to have fun.
In 1971, there was a person who did not have a job. She had a schedule assignment
form but couldn’t get into a unit. Jobs were hard to find, so she found a man, married
him in ‘78, and he brought her into the permanent lock factory. Having a job was the
same as being saved. It was a hard time, and the reason she didn’t have a job was that
her family had a bad status, otherwise she would have joined the state unit a long time
ago. Later she could only enter the collective unit, but it was a kind of salvation.
When he didn’t have a family and wanted to start a business, he opened a factory
called Deer City Plate Welding Factory. Then, he was outside the project, earned a
batch of money thus married a wife. But then the plate welding factory closed down
and lost a large amount of money. Fortunately, at this time, his factory again solicited a
big project, the factory needs to complete the six large equipment of Anyang Brewery,
that is, stainless steel tanks for fermentation. Immediately after that, he took on a
chemical dye factory project in the citric acid warehouse factory in Handan County,
Hebei, and a large project in a fertilizer factory in Xingtai, Hebei. He thanked himself
for being able to suffer at the age of thirty and daring to go out and start his own
business, as well as for the opportunity after opportunity.
过年
现在是天天过年,不为吃穿发愁
我小时候,过年有一双好的新鞋
虑卫生,是不是有毒,是不是转基因的产品
我们那时候跳绳,跳鞍马,打
弹子,男孩子跳鞍马,打水飘
但这个时代老人都跟不上了,力不从心跟
上好时代,但社会是前进的,所以年轻人要珍惜现在
我们曾为吃穿而
愁,而你们年轻人是为了怎样玩得开心发愁
他,他把她带进了永久锁厂
有工作就等同于获救
那时候很苦,她没工
作的原因还包括家庭身份不好,不然老早就会进国营单位,后来她缺只
能进了集体单位,但也算是一种获救了
了工程,赚了一批钱,娶了老婆
但后来板焊厂倒闭了,亏了一大笔钱
天
无绝人之路,这时他的厂又揽上了一个大的工程,厂子需要完成安阳啤
酒厂的六个大型设备,那就是发酵用的不锈钢罐
紧接着,他又在河北
邯郸魏县柠檬酸仓厂,接了一个化工染料厂的工程,和一个河北邢台化
肥厂的大工程
他感谢三十岁能吃苦,敢出去创业的自己,也感谢一次
又一次的机会
就开心的不得了,不讲究什么牌子,有鞋子就已经满足了,袜子根本没
有
现在鞭炮都不让打了
不过有一点,以前吃东西意识里面根本不考
不上时代
现在对于我们来说时代在前进,身体缺在倒退
我们没有赶
Table 1. The stories of the six writers in this study.
Transforming the Elderly’s Disadvantage into Advantage in Creativity Activities 141
In 1964, in response to the call of the Party, I went to the countryside to substitute
teaching at Longwan Primary School, and later retired due to illness and returned to
the Wenzhou Defense Department. Account is fate, because at that time there is no
account, there is no work, children’s account can not be registered, can not be
reported. I remember clearly that at that time, the birth of a child to buy brown sugar,
need brown sugar tickets, no account brown sugar tickets can not get. 1972 I moved
back to the household registration, with cinder block tickets, cloth tickets, cotton
tickets, national mobile tickets. At that time, there was not enough food to eat, you
could only sell the cinder blocks to buy food to eat and collect firewood to burn. So
the sick retirement is also a sense of being saved.
After I graduated from Normal School, I was assigned to teach in a rural elementary
school for forty years, during which many things happened, one of which I will never
forget. Once, after a meeting at school, it was already more than ten o’clock at night,
and I went home alone. At that time, the rural economy was difficult, there were no
roads, no electricity, only rugged paths, so I had to walk home, and there was no other
means of transportation. There was only a flashlight to illuminate the darkness, and a
mountain road to pass. Halfway, I followed the flashlight light to look forward, more
than ten meters in front of the roadside actually squatting a beast, with a pair of big
round turquoise eyes. At that time I was dumbfounded, I was so scared that I could not
make a sound. There were no pedestrians passing by and no phone calls for help at this
time. I thought that I must be the prey of the beast tonight and would not be able to
see my family or my students again. At this critical moment, remembering the words of
the old man in the countryside, I followed the words of the old man in the countryside:
“If you encounter a fierce beast such as a hunting dog on the road, a person crouches
down and smashes it over with a stone, it will escape.” Sure enough, I squatted for a
few minutes, when I stood up, open the flashlight to see, it has gone to the woods, no
trace. I ran home in one breath, after a long time still can not be quiet, heart pounding.
When my daughter was first born I opened a noodle shop with two partners , not only
cooking noodles, more like a restaurant, and sometimes catering in the store, business
is very good. The store has three eight immortal tables, can sit a lot of people, but also
can not sit down to the next store. Basically, the customers are workers from the
fishery. I need to clean the tables in the store every day, busy under the table.
Sometimes I met sloppy customers, throwing garbage everywhere under the table;
sometimes I also met demanding customers, asking for this and that, but in order to
make a living, I still gritted my teeth and went on. After more than ten years of
operation, the store was finally closed because of an accident in the family of one of
the partners, so it could not continue.
了,我太害怕了以至于无法发出声音
这时既没有行人经过也没有电话
求救
我想我今晚一定是猛兽的猎物,无法再见到家人,见不到自己的
一件让我终身难忘
有一次,我在校开会后,已经是晚上十点多钟了,我
独自一人回家
当时农村经济困难,没有公路,没有电,只有崎岖的小
道,回家只能步行,也没有其他的交通工具
黑夜里只有手电筒照明,还
要通过一条山路
半路上,我顺着手电筒的光向前看,前面十多米远的
路旁竟蹲着一头猛兽,睁着一对圆圆的碧绿色的大眼睛
当时我就傻
学生
在这关键时刻,想起农村老人的话,我就按照农村老人的话去
做:”如果路上碰到猎狗等猛兽,人蹲下来用石头砸过去,它就会逃走
糖,需要红糖票,没有户口红糖票就拿不到
1972年我迁回了户口,有了
煤球票,布票,棉花票,全国流动票
当时饭都吃不饱,都只能把煤球票卖
掉买粮食吃,捡柴火烧
所以病退也是某种意义上的获救
的
”果然有效,我蹲了几分钟,站起来的时候,打开手电筒看去,它已经
走到树林里去,无影无踪了
我就一口气跑回家,过了好长时间还静不
下来,心脏怦怦直跳
在店里承办酒席,生意火爆
店里有三张八仙桌,能坐很多人,也有坐不
下去到隔壁店的
基本上客人都是渔场里的工人
我每一天都要打扫
店里的桌子,忙碌于桌上桌下
有时会遇到邋遢的客人,垃圾扔得桌下
个,但为了谋生,还是咬咬牙干下去
开了十几年的店面,最后因为一个
搭伙的同伴家中出事了,所以没能继续下去,关闭了店铺
户口也登不起来,报不上去
我记得很清楚的是当时生小孩要买红
到处都是;有时也会遇到要求高的客人,一会儿要这个一会儿要那
Table 1. Continued
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Title Original story Meaning
Saved 1964年,响应党的号召,我下乡去龙湾小学代课,后来户口政策病退,回 到了温州市防卫处
户口是命运,因为当时没有户口,就没有工作,小孩
Saved 我从师范学校毕业后,被分配到乡村小学任教,一干就是四十年,其中有
Table 女儿刚出生我和两个伙伴开了一家面馆,不仅是烧面,更像饭店,有时会
Under the
Table 2. Average scores.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
The first group The second group The second group (14-year-old) (31-year-old) (48-year-old) Number of score Number of score Number of score evaluator evaluator evaluator
This paper studies the relationship between the age of raters and their ratings of older writers’ stories in Sternberg’s writing field creativity test by one-way ANOVA. The greater the age difference between the evaluator and the older respondent on Stenberg’s writing domain creativity test, the higher
Transforming the Elderly’s Disadvantage into Advantage in Creativity Activities 143
the evaluation of “originality” from the evaluator for the older respondent on the test. The results of this study can provide a corresponding reference for constructing a creativity activity for the elderly, allowing the elderly to get more positive evaluation in creativity activities, thus enhancing their self- confidence, improving the social stereotype of the elderly, and helping the elderly see the value and meaning of their later life.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Supported by the Research Center for Design Science and Art.
REFERENCES
Amabile,T.(1983). The Social Psychology of Creativity. Springer-Verlag New York. Barbot, B., Besançon, M., & I Lubart, T. (2011). Assessing creativity in the classroom.
The Open Education Journal, 4(1). Cohen, G. D. (2005). The mature mind: The positive power of the aging brain. Basic Books (AZ). Hickson, J., & Housley, W. (1997). Creativity in later life. Educational Gerontology:
An International Quarterly, 23(6), 539-547. Kong, & Rowena. (2016). Does creativity decline with age?. Scientific American Mind, 27(2), 70–70 Mccrae, R. R. , Arenberg, D. , & Jr, C. P. . (1987). Declines in divergent thinking
with age: cross-sectional, longitudinal, and cross-sequential analyses. Psychology & Aging, 2(2), 130. Simonton, & D., K. . (1990). Creativity in the later years: optimistic prospects for achievement. Gerontologist, 30(5), 626–631. Sternberg, R. J. . (2006). The rainbow project: enhancing the sat through assessments
of analytical, practical, and creative skills. Intelligence, 34(4), 321–350. Sternberg, R. , & Lubart, T. . (1996). Defying the crowd: cultivating creativity in a culture of conformity. American Journal of Psychotherapy, 50. Urban, K. K. (2005). Assessing Creativity: The Test for Creative Thinking-Drawing
Production (TCT-DP). International Education Journal, 6(2), 272–280. Xue, G., Dong, Q., Zhou, L. F., Zhang, H., & Chen, Chuan-Sheng. (2001). A study of the relationship between internal motivation, external motivation, and creativity. Psychological Development and Education, V17(1), 6–11.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Human Factors in Aging and Special Needs
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-14-8
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional