Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Methods and Tools for Optimizing to Avoid Similarity in Graphic Design Content Generated by Artificial Intelligence

Faculty of Innovative Design, City University of Macau, Macau SAR 999078, China ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1007322

Abstract

With the widespread application of generative artificial intelligence in the field of graphic design, the high production efficiency it brings is accompanied by significant risks of content homogenization and stylistic convergence. The fundamental nature of AI models, trained on large-scale datasets, often results in similarities in the composition, elements, and style of their output, severely constraining the originality and commercial distinctiveness of designs. This research focuses on the core challenge of avoiding similarity in AI-generated graphic design content, aiming to develop a systematic solution encompassing both generation methods and tool optimization.The study first provides an in-depth analysis of the technical root causes of similarity, including training data bias, the limitations of prompts, inherent model patterns, and the convergence of generation parameters. Building on this foundation, the paper proposes and explores multi-dimensional avoidance methods. At the technical level, it advocates for a "hybrid generation" strategy that combines different modal models (e.g., image-text, video generation models) for cross-inspiration and re-creation. It also introduces mechanisms for controllable randomness and noise injection to disrupt the model's inherent output patterns, alongside developing deep style transfer and element recombination algorithms based on semantic understanding. At the management and strategic level, it emphasizes building high-quality, diverse, and domain-specific refined datasets and promotes an iterative "human-machine collaboration" workflow. This workflow deeply integrates designers' aesthetic judgment and creative intervention at critical nodes within the generation chain.To effectively implement these methods, the research further outlines pathways for tool optimization. The focus is on developing intelligent "de-homogenization" plugins and platform features. These would integrate modules for multi-model comparative generation, style entropy analysis, and element deconstruction and fusion suggestions, providing designers with real-time similarity assessment and decision support for differentiation adjustments. The goal of tool optimization is to simplify the complex technical process of avoiding similarity into a visual, controllable, and user-friendly design assistant. This aims to ensure and stimulate the uniqueness and innovativeness of designs while enhancing efficiency. This study offers theoretical and practical references for the evolution of AI-assisted design from a mere "production tool" to a "creative partner," contributing positively to the healthy and diversified development of the design industry.Keywords: AI-generated design; content similarity; de-homogenization; method avoidance; tool optimization; human-machine collaboration

INTRODUCTION

Research Background and Significance Generative AI technologies like GANs and Diffusion Models have been widely applied in graphic design, significantly improving efficiency but bringing severe homogenization issues. Similar works infringe intellectual property rights, reduce commercial recognition, and hinder the industry’s creative vitality. This research fills the gap in systematic “de-homogenization” studies, enriching the interdisciplinary theory of AI and design, and providing operable solutions for designers and enterprises to avoid risks and promote in-depth integration of AI and design.

Research Questions and Objectives Core Research Question

How to construct a full-chain solution covering generation methods, process management, and tool support to effectively avoid similarity in AI-generated graphic design content?

Research Objectives

  • Reveal the multi-dimensional technical roots of similarity and establish an analysis framework;
  • Propose a scientific multi-dimensional avoidance system including technical intervention and process reengineering;
  • Design an adaptive tool optimization path and core modules, verifying feasibility through prototypes.

Research Content and Methods Research Content

Following the logic of “root cause analysis—method construction—tool optimization,” the research includes literature review, similarity root analysis, construction of avoidance methods, tool optimization path design, and verification/discussion.

Research Methods Literature analysis, case study, technical path deduction, and prototype design are adopted to ensure comprehensive and reliable research results.

LITERATURE REVIEW

Development and Application of AI-generated Content Technology AI-generated content technology has evolved from GANs to Transformer- based pre-trained models and Diffusion Models. Applied in various graphic design scenarios, it lowers technical thresholds but causes homogenization and originality disputes.

Research Status of Similarity Issues Similarity manifests in composition, elements, and style, rooted in data bias, model “mode collapse,” and convergent operations. De-homogenization technologies focus on model training optimization, generation strategy improvement, and post-processing, but domestic research mainly focuses on originality protection and similarity detection.

Limitations of Existing Strategies and Tools Existing methods lack systematic solutions, with inadequate designer intervention in workflows and no specialized de-homogenization tool modules. Non-technical factors are overlooked, and there is no unified similarity evaluation standard.

ROOTS OF SIMILARITY IN AI-GENERATED DESIGN CONTENT Data-Level Roots: Training Set Bias and Pattern Solidification

Training datasets have style/theme bias, limited quality and copyright compliance, and outdated content, leading to model “preferential memory” and solidified generation patterns.

Regarding the Methods and Tools for Optimizing to Avoid Similarity 105 Model-Level Roots: Inherent Algorithmic Preferences and Output Convergence

Algorithmic preferences and “mode collapse” reduce diversity; models sample from biased data distributions, and their “black-box nature” limits controllability.

Operation-Level Roots: Generalized Prompts and Convergent Parameters Designers use generalized prompts and default parameters, and over-rely on AI tools, resulting in homogenized outputs.

Transformation to Design Creativity Bottleneck Similarity harms brand competitiveness, triggers intellectual property disputes, and dampens original designers’ enthusiasm, conflicting with design’s core value of innovation.

CONSTRUCTION OF MULTI-DIMENSIONAL AVOIDANCE METHODS Methodology Overview: Dual-Track Approach

The “technical intervention + process reengineering” framework addresses data/model and operation-level issues respectively, forming a full-chain avoidance system of “source optimization—process control—result improvement.”

Technical Intervention Methods

  • Hybrid generation and cross-modal inspiration: Integrate multiple models and use multi-modal data for creative inspiration;
  • Controlled randomness and noise injection: Introduce moderate randomness and noise to break inherent patterns;
  • Deep style transfer and semantic element recombination: Achieve unique style fusion and innovative element combination.

Process Reengineering Methods

  • Refined dataset construction: Adhere to niche, high-quality, timely, and copyright-compliant principles;
  • Iterative human-computer collaboration workflow: Include creative conception, initial generation/screening, creative intervention/iteration, and manual refinement to ensure designer-led creativity.

Method Effectiveness Technical methods have different applicability based on scenarios; process reengineering methods require corresponding resources and capabilities. Compared with existing methods, the proposed system is more systematic, practical, and innovative.

TOOL OPTIMIZATION PATH Optimization goal: From “Production Tool” to “Creative Partner”

Transform AI design tools into active collaborators that enhance diversity, controllability, and usability, stimulating creativity.

Core Functional Modules

  • Multi-model comparative generation: Integrate mainstream and custom models, supporting one-click generation, result comparison, and hybrid fusion;
  • Style entropy analysis and similarity visualization: Quantify style uniqueness, visualize similar areas, and provide adjustment suggestions and copyright warnings;
  • Element decomposition, mixing, and re-creation: Decompose elements, build personalized libraries, and support intelligent mixing and interactive editing.

Regarding the Methods and Tools for Optimizing to Avoid Similarity 107 Prototype and Application Demonstration

A tool prototype with four functional areas is designed. Demonstrated through commercial poster design, it effectively reduces similarity and improves uniqueness.

Advantages and Challenges The optimized tool has stronger differentiation, usability, and copyright protection, but faces technical complexity, algorithm accuracy, element library construction, and user adaptation challenges, which can be addressed through cooperation, iterative optimization, and user guidance.

DISCUSSION AND OUTLOOK Research Summary

The research systematically analyzes similarity roots, proposes a dual-track avoidance system, and designs a tool optimization path, promoting AI-assisted design transformation from “efficiency-oriented” to “creativity-oriented.”

Research Innovations It constructs a multi-dimensional root analysis framework, proposes a dual- track methodology, and designs innovative practical tool modules.

Future Outlook Future research will strengthen empirical verification, deepen algorithm optimization, expand application scenarios, and promote the integration of AI and design education, advancing the healthy development of the design industry.

REFERENCES

Cheng, K. & Gu, C. (2024). Collaborative Design of AI Generation and Human: A Case Study of Interactive Customized Products Integrating Central Asian Culture into Han Mural Patterns. Hunan Packaging, 39(03), 176–179. https:// doi.org/10.19686/j.cnki.issn1671-4997.2024.03.044. Gong, L. (2026). Challenges and Resilient Governance Paradigms in the Cognitive

Domain in the Era of Artificial Intelligence. Qin Zhi, (03), 105–107. https://doi. org/10.20122/j.cnki.2097-0536.2026.03.026. Jiang, B. (2026). Resilient Governance of Data Risks in the New Generation of Generative AI. Credit, (02), 41–52. Li, C., Dai, Q., Zhou, J., Wang, D. & Wang, X. Research on User Dialogue

Optimization Behavior Mechanism in the Context of Generative AI. Li, X. & Zheng, L. (2026). Risks and Advanced Approaches of Generative AI’s Involvement in Network Ideological Governance. Theory Monthly, (03), 44-56+159. https://doi.org/10.14180/j.cnki.1004-0544.2026.03.005. Liu, Z. (2026). Research on the Developer’s Liability for Copyright Infringement

in the Data Training Stage of Generative AI. Information and Computer, 38(05), 24–29.

Tao, F. (2024). Research on Methods for De-homogenization of Scientific Logo Design. Screen Printing, (19), 53–56. https://doi.org/10.20084/j.cnki.1002-4867. 2024.19.016. Wang, G. Cognitive Erosion and Authenticity Crisis: The Risk Logic Chain of AI

Deception. Wang, Y. Common Issues and Response Strategies in Global AI Governance. Wu, F., Guo, Z. & Wang, Z. (2026). Innovative Classroom Teaching with Generative AI: Concepts and Models. Information Technology Education in Primary and Secondary Schools, (03), 45–47. Xu, H. (2026). Research on the Synergistic Innovation of AI-Generated Content and

Visual Communication Design. Journal of Putian University, 33(01), 81–87. Yang, M. (2026). Memetic Analysis and AI-Generated Design Path Research of Miao Ethnic Group’s Thread Counting Embroidery in the Digital Context. China Packaging, 46(02), 104–107.

Cover of the proceedings volume Artificial Intelligence and Social Computing

Explore the complete digital volume

Artificial Intelligence and Social Computing

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-964867-79-3

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →