Xinxiong Liu, Wei Du (2023). User experience elements of data visualization large screen: The example of electricity industry. In: Usability and User Experience. AHFE Open Access, vol. 110, pp. 180–188. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1003190
Industrial Design Department, School of Mechanical Science and Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, Hubei Province, China ↗
In the era of big data, all sectors of society pay more and more attention to data value. Data visualization, as the most effective way to present data value, has been given an important position.The electricity industry has many sources of data, complex dimensions and large scale. It is necessary to present massive data clearly, scientifically and accurately through the visualization system. Therefore, it is very important to establish a set of data visualization large screen product evaluation element model based on user experience to improve user satisfaction. This paper mainly collects the user experience elements of the large screen of electricity industry data through user interviews, and uses the card sorting method to establish the element model, which is convenient to quantify the user experience of the large screen of electricity industry data visualization, and realize scientific evaluation of user experience results.
As one of the intuitive display forms of data visualization technology, data visualization large screen can display complex multi-source data in a vivid and friendly way through real-time transmission and dynamic interaction within a limited window. By extracting effective information and mining hidden business associations, business scenarios are presented in a reasona- ble layout.Its technical difficulties lie in the rationalization of data display, the logic of information presentation modes, and the convenience of user understanding. Therefore, the purpose of this paper is to establish the user experience element model of data visualization large screen in the electricity industry, and provide examples and references for the quantitative research of user experience of data visualization large screen products.
CORE CONCEPTS Data Visualization Large Screen
Data visualization is a technology that makes the correlation between big data content and data easier to understand and analyze by means of charts, maps, videos and other data representation forms. Its presentation forms can
User Experience Elements of Data Visualization Large Screen 181
be divided into descriptive, mining and interactive (Lina et al., 2020). As the display carrier of data visualization, data large screen has become the essential basic core system of data visualization (Guangwei, 2018).
User Experience Research User Experience Overview
According to ISO 9241-210, user experience is “people’s cognitive impression and response to the products, systems or services they use or expect to use” (User experience, 2018). Although the concept of user experience itself is subjective and vague, from the perspective of evaluation, it is necessary to explore the dimensions of user experience evaluation and divide a complex system into multiple indicators to reflect the comprehensive situation.
User Experience Elements As for the constituent elements of user experience, Robert Rubinoff belie- ves that user experience elements include usability, functionality, content and brand. These elements are not only related but also affect each other (Rubi- noff, n.d.). Moeslinger believes that user experience factors include user’s behavior, sense and emotional experience, and have a great correlation with the use environment (Fanfan, 2012).
EPI User Experience Element Model The EPI user experience model was proposed by Professor Xin Xiangyang of Jiangnan University. The EPI model requires the user experience desi- gner to consider the user experience as a whole.When designers think about interaction design and user experience, they no longer only focus on whe- ther the product is easy to use, intuitive, simple, natural and other aspects. Experience can be divided into expectation, progression and influence accor- ding to the process (Xin, 2016). The data visualization large screen of the electricity industry includes hardware systems, supporting software, peo- ple, space environment and platforms, etc. It emphasizes personalized and customized data visualization user experience, focuses on different business segments.Data visualization large screen can connect business content story lines through visual perspective, reflects core links, and provides users with different experiences.
(a) Expectation: The expectation is the first stage of user experience. The user’s expectation of the product is directly related to the product’s qua- lity of the experience. The final user experience index is higher than the user’s expectation, and the user will feel happy. The final user experience is lower than the user’s expectation, and users will show disappointment, dissatisfaction and other emotions.According to the EPI model, in expe- ctation stage, the secondary experience elements include three: needs, first impressions and expectations. (b) Progression: The progression is the second stage of the user experience. It mainly refers to various experiences generated by users directly using a
182 Liu and Du
product, and the research on usability is also based on this stage. Accor- ding to the EPI model, there are many secondary experience factors in progression stage: path, presentation mode, feedback, interaction mode, duration, goal, etc. (c) Influence: The influence is the last stage of user experience. When a user experiences products or services, the experience will continue to accom- pany the user for a period of time, and even transform into a permanent memory. According to the EPI model, there are four secondary elements in influence stage: memory, emotional fluctuation, self-perception and self-change.
Overview of Electricity Industry Business Development Status of Electricity Industry Business
The electricity industry has the characteristics of instant production and sales, numerous fields, geographical dispersion and huge organization (Hu, 2019). With the wide application of information technology, a large amount of high- value, multi-type, large-scale and cross-domain data has been accumulated in many application fields such as electricity. How to make full use of big data to realize the industrial structure upgrading of China’s electricity industry will be an important topic for the development of electricity informatization in the future. The main characteristics of business data in the electricity industry are: large volume, multiple types, fast speed and security.
Data Types in the Electricity Industry The main types of electricity industry data are as follows:
(a) Basic data: This type of data is mainly related to electricity equi- pment such as transformers and generators, which is the basis of decision-making of the dispatching center. (b) Real-time data: This kind of data is generated in the whole operation process of the electricity industry, and needs to be equipped with large storage space to display the operation of the electricity industry (Kang, 2017). (c) Daily management data: This kind of data mainly includes the data after handling the problems sorted by each department. It is generated in the specified range and provides real-time feedback on the operation status of electricity equipment. (d) External data: This kind of data mainly generated from the Internet of Things, primary energy network, Internet and other networks connected with the electricity industry.
Existing Problems of Data Visualization in Power Industry In terms of data visualization in the electricity industry, there are mainly the following problems:
(a) Data integration: Electricity transaction data are scattered in various business systems without effective unified management.
User Experience Elements of Data Visualization Large Screen 183
(b) Content release:The needs of regional information release and supervision can not be fully meet.It is urgent to access relevant basic data according to the current regulatory requirements, and increase the display content. (c) Release method: Although the amount of data in the system is huge, it lacks multi-dimensional information presentation, and is poorly matched with user needs. A large amount of data does not really play its role. (d) Display form: Each independent electricity system has different display modes, which are difficult to handle. The interaction between the system and the service object is poor.
Classification of Large Screen Users in Electricity Industry By analyzing the core users of the data visualization large screen in the electri- city industry, it is convenient to carry out specific user interviews. Through research, the following three core user types are summarized:
(a) Department managers: They pay attention to the business value and brand sense of the big data screen, the improvement of the coordination efficiency of department work, the mining and analysis of data, and the identification of data trends and potential risks. (b) Daily business personnel of the department: They pay attention to the connection between the big data screen and daily work, and the convenience of data search and access. (c) External visitors: They pay attention to the experience process of large screen visit, the relevance of large screen and department business content, and the visual display effect of large screen.
RESEARCH METHODS AND PROCESS Research Methods
(a) Literature research: Literature research mainly refers to the method of collecting, identifying and sorting out documents, and forming a scien- tific understanding of facts through the study of documents (Shu et al., 2009). (b) User interview: User interview is a research method to study the beha- vior habits of users and understand the views and attitudes of intervie- wees through face-to-face conversation with interviewees. This method is used to collect data describing the experience (such as the quality and reason of the experience, the content of the experience, etc.). (c) Card sorting: Card sorting is a method for planning and designing user experience hierarchy. In this paper, it is mainly used to classify the factors that affect the experience and help sort out their logical relationship.
Detailed Research Process According to the previous desktop research and the electricity business con- tent, an interview questionnaire for the electricity industry personnel using the large screen of data was prepared. The semi-structured user interview
184 Liu and Du
method was used to collect the users’ views on the existing data visualization big screen, as well as the use experience and feedback when using the big screen to complete business needs.
User Interview 6 employees and leaders from a business department of the electricity industry in Wuhan were selected and invited to answer the following 8 questions (see Table 1). The answers obtained from the interview will be used to study the user experience influential elements in the process of user experience data visualization.
Refinement of User Experience Elements By analyzing the first-hand information by sentence, the effective information is extracted and the obtained content is re-induced. Part of the interview content of a user is selected to show the refining process of user experience elements (see Table 2).
Through refining the experience elements of 6 recordings (8 questions each), the EPI element experience table of the data visualization screen (see Table 3) is finally summarized, and the tertiary elements correspond to the specific elements of the user experience.
The Table 3 combines the user interview conclusions. It is a simple sum- mary of the experience elements that should be paid attention to when considering the user experience of the general data visualization large screen.
Card Sorting The card sorting method can meet the user’s classification of information as much as possible in a structured way.This study selected five user experience researchers to classify the collected user experience element cards.
From the collected user experience elements, at different stages of the user experience, the elements that affect the user experience of the large screen of
Table 1. Interview outline for large screen users of data visualization.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Stage Problem Expectation - What is the data visualization large screen in your imagination? - What problem do you want the data visualization large screen to help you solve? - Tell me about your first impression of the data visualization large screen. Progression - Talk about your use process. - Do you encounter any confusion during use? Which processes confuse you? - What do you think of the existing data visualization large screen? Influence - What do you think is the greatest significance of this product for you? - Are you willing to recommend the data visualization large screen to other department personnel?
User Experience Elements of Data Visualization Large Screen 185
Table 2. Example of experience element extraction.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Time: May 18, 2022 Place of interview: In a business department of electricity industry in Wuhan Interviewee: Mr. Ye Position: Department managers Background information: Mainly responsible for coordinating the business work of the electricity industry First-hand information Element extraction
Q: What do you think is the greatest significance of this product for you? A: The data visualization large screen can display the highlights of the department in a very scientific and cool way.This product can integrate the data of each business section, display the data in multi-dimension, improve the efficiency of work coordination, and facilitate data mining.It can well display the department’s work achievements, honor and brand culture.
Table 3. EPI user experience elements list of data visualization large screen.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Tertiary element
Stage Secondary element Expectation Need Users have requirements for products First impression
Adapt to space environment, Impression of interface and vision Forecast An estimate of the condition of the product, Cognition of similar products Progression Task path The operation steps conforming to the user’s mental model, Functional layout conforming to user habits Objective Complete core task objectives, give full play to data value, and highlight department strength and work achievements Feedback The system feedback is timely, Users are less confused, Easy to use, The form of feedback is interesting, Presentation Storyline architecture, Cool visual performance, In line with the corporate culture, Sense of technology, Brand sense Interactive mode
The operation mode conforms to the use scenario, Interactive mode of users and products System performance
Fulfillment, Identity
Data security, The system is stable and controllable, Rationality of system response time Influence Mood swings Cause emotional pleasantness Memory Product and experience differences are prominent, Emotional resonance Self- perception Self-change Make life and work more convenient
186 Liu and Du
data visualization are different. The data visualization large screen belongs to the business technology product, and has its targeted adaptation scenarios. Both subjective and objective factors will comprehensively affect the user experience. Through the classification and analysis of these collected ele- ments, combined with the characteristics of business technology products in the electricity industry, and based on the effectiveness of helping users achieve their goals, the user experience of large screen data in the electricity industry is divided into four levels: user emotion, user behavior, functional utility, and system performance. The specific screening criteria are shown in Table 4. By dividing the sorted user experience elements according to different experie- nce levels and experience dimensions, the user experience element level and dimension classification of data visualization large screen in the electricity industry is obtained (see Table 5).
Table 4. Screening criteria for user experience elements of data visualization large screen in electricity industry.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Experience level Screening criteria User emotion It can enables users to achieve goals with pleasantness User behavior It can provide users with interactive ways that conform to their cognitive rules Functional utility It can enables users to complete core tasks and achieve busi- ness objectives System performance
It can provide users with a reliable, efficient and stable hardware environment
Composition of Data Visualization Large Screen’s User Experience Elements in Electricity Industry Organize the user experience elements around the four levels of user emotion, user behavior, functional utility and system performance.It is found that the experience elements mainly involve six dimensions: pleasantness, influence, interactivity, usability, operational efficiency and reliability. These six aspects can also be used as a reference classification method for data visualization product card sorting. By integrating the experience elements under different experience dimensions, the user experience elements of electricity industry data visualization large screen are summarized (see Table 6).
CONCLUSION
Through the research on the user experience elements of the current data visualization screen in electricity industry, the following conclusions are obtained: (a) The problems of data visualization in electricity industry in data inte- gration, content release, release mode and display form are analyzed. (b) The paper collects user experience elements of each stage in the process of user’s data visualization large screen experience. With the help of the
User Experience Elements of Data Visualization Large Screen 187
Table 5. The user experience element level and dimension classification of data visualization large screen in electricity industry.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Experience level
Stage Experience element Experience dimension Expectation The product can meet the business function requirements
Pleasantness User emotion
Usability Functional utility Product can match space environment Pleasantness User emotion Expectation of product visual sense
Interactivity User behavior
Progression Easy to operate without written instructions Timely feedback on operation Interactive User behavior Completing business objectives and core tasks effectively Usability Functional utility Story line architecture of products
Interactivity User behavior
Usability Functional utility Less confusion and mistakes during use Easy to operate and use Interactivity User behavior It meets my business needs Usability Functional utility It can be used successfully every time
Usability Functional utility Interesting to use Pleasantness User emotion Data is safe and trustworthy Reliability System performance The system is stable and controllable with fast response
Operating efficiency Influence User emotion
System performance Influence It feels particularly cool. I will recommend it to other departments
Influence User emotion
Impressive Pleasantness User emotion Enjoy using Pleasantness User emotion In line with corporate culture and strong sense of brand
EPI experience element model, the EPI experience element table of data visualization large screen products is summarized. (c) The card sorting method is used to classify and summarize the elements that affect the user experience of large screen data visualization in the electricity industry. Around the four experience levels of user emotion, user behavior, function experience and system performance, the expe- rience elements mainly involve six dimensions: pleasantness, impact, interactivity, availability, operating efficiency and reliability.Finally the paper forms the data visualization large screen user experience element table suitable for the technical product characteristics of the business electricity industry. It is convenient to quantify the user experience of
188 Liu and Du
Table 6. User experience elements of data visualization large screen in electricity industry.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Experience element
Experience level
Experience dimension User emotion Pleasantness - Beautiful interface and cool animation effects - High user satisfaction - Good experience of space environment Influence - Good brand style and impression perception - Presentation of enterprise value - Willing to share products User behavior Interactivity - Users can easily identify data indicators and key information - Easy to operate and use - Less misoperation Functional utility
Usability - Clear story line structure - Completing core tasks System performance
Operating efficiency
- Stable system performance and timely feedback - Fast page animation rendering and short response time Reliability - The system is safe, reliable and confidential
the data visualization large screen in the electricity industry in the later stage, transform qualitative problems into quantitative research, and realize the visualization of user experience results.
REFERENCES
He Guangwei. Big Data Visualization [M]. Beijing: Electronic Industry Press, 2018 Li Kang. On the application of big data technology in electricity system [J]. China’s strategic emerging industry, 2017(44):87+89 Li Shu, Chen Dabo, Li Meng. Using the method of literature to study music [J]. Music
exploration, 2009, 04:50-52+32 Nie Hu. Energy data visualization application Electronic Technology and Software Engineering. 2019, (21) Robert Rubinoff. How to Quantify the User experience [EB/OL]. User experience - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User-experience, last
accessed 2018/1/20 Wu Fanfan. Research on user experience oriented smart phone application software interface design [D] Shanghai: East China University of Technology, 2012 Xin XY. From UX to EX: A Framework For Understanding Design[Lecture][M].
IXDA. Helsinki, Finland. 2016 Yang Lina, Ma Zhaoting, Zhu Lining, et al. Research on spatiotemporal data visualization [J]. Mapping and spatial geographic information, 2020, 43(5):140-149. http://www.sitepoint.com/print/quantify-user-experience,2013-02-26
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Usability and User Experience
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-86-5
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional