Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Driver Monitoring Systems: Design Considerations for Aging Drivers

Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University, Daytona Beach, FL 32114, USA ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1003828

Abstract

A number of automotive manufacturers including General Motors and Tesla offer vehicles with advanced semi-autonomous driving functions that the driver is expected to monitor. Monitoring by the human driver is essential given that these systems are known to have difficulty handling driving situations that human drivers negotiate easily. The human operator must, however, adjust to this new supervisory role of monitoring system operations rather than traditional driving. Additionally, drivers may trust the automation too much, believing the systems are more capable than they are and not actively monitor the operation of the semi-autonomous systems. This belief may be engendered by the use of terms like “self-driving” or “drive pilot” in vehicle marketing materials. In response to these concerns, automotive manufacturers have developed driver monitoring system(s) (DMS) that assesses the driver’s attentional engagement in the driving process and alerts them when it determines they are not attending to the vehicle’s operation. Driver attention is assessed by monitoring their eye-gaze direction, head pose, steering wheel torque input, and facial action units. During the aging process, there are many changes in perceptual, cognitive, and musculoskeletal systems that may not have been addressed in the design of the DMS. An example of these limitations include hearing or vision impairments, which could make perceiving warnings presented by the DMS more difficult. The potential limitations of DMS will be discussed, as well as ideas for future research, which encourages consideration of older adults in interface design and discusses trends in technology adoption by older adults.

INTRODUCTION

Vehicles are increasingly equipped with a range of Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS). Some of these features include lane keeping assist system (LKAS), adaptive cruise control (ACC), and automatic emergency bra- king (AEB). The LKAS aids the driver by providing steering assistance so the car does not depart from its lane. ACC works by adjusting the speed of the vehicle to match a driver defined target speed and automatically slows and maintains a specific following distance if it detects a car ahead that is dri- ving more slowly. AEB forces the vehicle to stop when an obstruction enters the vehicle’s driving path. Users are often unfamiliar with the operation and limitations of these systems, leading drivers to reduce their monitoring of

© 2023. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 429

the roadway because they believe the systems are more capable than they are (Parasuraman and Riley, 1997). Marketing materials that use terms like “drive pilot” and “self-driving” give drivers a false impression that the car has the ability to drive itself (Abraham, et al., 2017). In response, manu- facturers have developed Driver Monitoring Systems (DMS) that evaluates the driver’s behaviour to infer their attentional engagement with the driving task and preparedness to take manual control of the vehicle in the case of an ADAS failure.

The effectiveness of a DMS may vary for users of different ethnic or demo- graphic groups. For instance, a recent study found that several state-of-the-art object detection models showed uniformly poorer performance when dete- cting pedestrians of darker skin tones (Wilson et al., 2019). The possibility exists that object detection algorithms used in ADAS and DMS might exhibit similar limitations. Similarly, the performance of facial recognition applica- tions have also been shown to vary depending on the ethnicity of the faces (Grother, Ngan & Hanaoka, 2019). Understanding current DMS limitations such as these detection errors is valuable when evaluating future system desi- gns and upgrades. The hope is to develop an inclusive system that can cater to all drivers.

The ADAS technology can increase safety and functionality for older dri- vers and drivers with disabilities. However, aging adults represent a segment of the user population that is not always considered when designing modern systems, such as ADAS, even though they might stand to benefit the most from the use of this technology. This is problematic because many aging adults experience a range of age related physical, sensory, and cognitive chan- ges. Consideration of these changes increases the likelihood that these systems will perform more accurately for the users regardless of their ethnicity, age, and gender. In this paper, we will explore important design considerations for aging adults, provide suggestions for future research such as improved interface design, and discuss trends in technology adoption by older adults.

DRIVER MONITORING SYSTEMS (DMS) The design and operation of a DMS varies by manufacturer, relying on sen- sors to detect steering movement or visual features such as the driver’s head and eyes to calculate parameters such as head position, eyelid closure, and eye gaze direction. The sensors are often installed in the A-pillars—the stru- ctural pillars on either side of the windshield—or on the instrument cluster (Ford Motor Company, 2022; GMC, 2022; Khan & Lee, 2019; Nissan, 2022; Volvo, 2019). Smart Eye is an example of one company that provi- des hardware (such as cameras) and software used by original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) in the design of DMS. These sensors can identify the presence and position of the driver, detect dangerous behaviors such as eating, drinking, or mobile phone use, use facial expression analysis to identify the driver’s mood, use key body points to track driver interactions with objects in the vehicle, detect distraction and drowsiness, and even detect drivers states such as unconsciousness or intoxication (Driver Monitoring System, 2023). Aside from visual sensors, another common sensor type is pressure sensors

Driver Monitoring Systems: Design Considerations for Aging Drivers 431

in the steering wheel that can detect the driver’s hands and torque sensors on the steering column which detect steering inputs. Both of these inputs are believed to reflect driver engagement with the driving task by ensuring that the driver has their hands on the steering wheel (Ford, 2022; GMC, 2022). Nissan uses an advanced form of torque monitoring by monitoring steering wheel torque inputs for several minutes upon reaching a target speed, then continually comparing the driver’s input to this baseline to detect driver dro- wsiness as indicated by an increase in sudden sharp steering inputs (Nissan, 2022). If driver inattention is detected, the systems use different types of alerts to prompt the driver to re-engage attention on the driving task. Commonly employed alerts include visual alerts like flashing lights, verbal auditory alerts and tones, and haptic feedback (Huang & Pitts, 2020).

Each DMS has operational challenges or limitations. Systems monitoring driver eye and head position can be adversely affected by environmental con- ditions such as bright sunlight and drivers wearing sunglasses or eyeglasses which may impair the system’s ability to detect the drivers’ eyes. Similarly, systems that rely on localizing facial features to identify head position are less robust when the driver is engaged in conversation, wears eyeglasses, clo- ses their eyes, or rotates their head (Jo et al., 2011). Finally, the reliability of the systems can also be affected by driver ethnicity as previously noted. Additionally, it is not clear if driver eye health or presentation affects the performance of DMS. This is of concern as drivers, especially older adults, may be monocular, strabismic, experience nuchal rigidity, or wear corrective lenses.

The conditions noted above vary in frequency across the population and some are more common with age. Below we discuss how changes in physical, cognitive, and musculoskeletal function associated with aging may impact the use of a DMS by older drivers.

DMS INTERACTIONS WITH AGING Interactions With Vision Changes

Changes in visual ability and function with age are ubiquitous. These changes include reduced near and distance visual acuity and contrast sensitivity (Stone et al., 2018). Visual acuity reflects the ability to resolve fine high contrast details like small black text on a white background. Distance visual acuity is typically assessed by eye care professionals using letter acuity charts for view- ing distances equivalent to 20 ft. Near acuity refers to visual acuity measured at a viewing distance of approximately 12–16 inches. The ability to see near objects clearly relies on accommodation or changes in the shape of the lens to bring the image into focus on the retina. However, the range of accom- modation decreases with age as the lens in the eye hardens and becomes less malleable, reducing the clarity of objects positioned closer to the observer. Consequently, text and icons appearing on displays positioned more proxi- mal to the driver, such as the dashboard, may appear blurry to older adults despite appearing in focus for a younger driver.

Contrast sensitivity refers to the ability to discriminate subtle differences in shading between say a white background and a target that is a light shade

of gray. Age-related changes in acuity and contrast are relevant to the design of visual DMS warnings, alerts or cautions and are particularly important to ensure said stimuli are detectable and legible for older adults. For example, the visual presentation of DMS warnings pertaining to lane deviation or an alert about driver drowsiness may not be detected if it has low contrast and if it is detected it may not be legible if it is too small to resolve. Larger text and higher contrast will improve the legibility and visibility of the visual war- ning for all users and more robust to the effects of changing environmental conditions (e.g., bright sunlight, low illumination).

Older adults might also experience hazy or blurry vision due to catara- cts that are more common with age. Cataracts are found in the lens of the eye and scatter light, reducing the contrast of visual scene while also increa- sing an individual’s susceptibility to visual glare especially at nighttime and in the presence of on-coming vehicle headlights (Wood & Chaparro, 2011; Wood, Chaparro, Carberry, & Chu, 2010). Older driver are more likely to wear corrective lenses with bifocals that allow them to see near objects more clearly. Wearers of corrective lenses may assume head postures that impact reliability of a DMS. Also, research on eye tracking technology has shown that errors may occur when the user is wearing corrective lenses (Dahlberg, 2010). The DMS uses similar technology and may experience difficulties tra- cking the eyes of drivers wearing corrective lenses and hence assessing their attentional state.

Interactions With Hearing Changes Older listeners often require sounds to be louder in order to be able to easily detect them. This is especially true in the presence of background noise, such as road and car noise. For younger adults, the recommended sound level when designing auditory displays is 70 dB, but this recommendation increa- ses to 85–90 dB when designing for older adults (McLaughlin & Pak, 2020). Even if older adults do not have documented hearing loss, it may still be diffi- cult for them to perceive some sounds common to speech, due to age related changes in the inner ear and reduced sensitivity to higher sound frequencies (McLaughlin & Pak, 2020). Therefore, it is important to consider the proper- ties of auditory alarms to ensure their detection by older drivers, especially in the presence of background noise.

Auditory stimuli may be used in conjunction with redundant visual cues or haptic cues to alert the driver of their inattentiveness. General Motors’ SuperCruise, a driver assistive technology feature, escalates its alert types if the driver fails to respond by assuming control of the vehicle or attending to the driving scene ahead. Upon first detection of inattentiveness, a green bar found on the steering wheel will begin to flash. If the driver does not respond, the bar will begin to flash red and is accompanied by auditory beeps or Safety Alert Seat vibrations. If no response is detected after the first two series of alerts, a voice will prompt the driver to take over control of the vehicle, and if nothing is done the vehicle will begin to slow down and brake while contacting an Onstar advisor to advise them of an emergency (How to use super cruise, n.d.). This multimodal approach to DMS warnings has the

Driver Monitoring Systems: Design Considerations for Aging Drivers 433

potential to help older drivers better detect messages, however due to changes in hearing, vision, and sensation normal to aging, older adults may still have difficulty perceiving these warnings.

Interactions With Changes in Cognition The research literature documents important changes in attentional abilities with age; particularly, changes in divided and selective attention. Divided attention concerns the ability to attend to multiple concurrent stimuli, while selective attention concerns the ability to detect a target in the presence of distractors or other forms of visual clutter (Ball et al., 1993; Wood et al., 2006). The speed and performance of visual search (i.e., percent detection) declines with age (Karthaus & Falkenstein, 2016). These changes may impact the driver’s ability to manage multiple tasks (Salthouse et al., 1984; Chaparro, Wood & Carberry, 2005), such as responding to navigational instructions, answering incoming calls or detecting the presence of an alert or warning under demanding driving conditions. Older drivers may be disadvantaged if the DMS warnings require them to shift attention away from the road to search for the warning and respond to it.

Interactions With Musculoskeletal Changes Response time is affected by age, increasing approximately 25% by age 65 (McLaughlin & Pak, 2020). Additionally, older drivers may experience restricted range of motion including decrease of motion of the head and neck, which limits the area they can see and interact with objects (Isler et al., 1997). Arthritis can further restrict movement such as turning or manipulating obje- cts (Yang & Coughlin, 2014; Chaparro et al., 1999) and may affect older adults’ ability to respond promptly to a warning, or their ability to turn or press a button.

Other Interactions With Aging The introduction and acceptance of the new technology by older adults must also to be considered. The learning styles of older adults and younger adults can differ, as younger adults have grown up utilizing and adapting to new technological advancements. Accommodating learning styles or preferences should be reflected in the creation of learning materials and user manuals to facilitate learning, use, and adoption of safety features that might reduce their crash risk. Older adults take longer to learn how to properly use adva- nced features such as a DMS compared to younger adults (Yang & Coughlin 2014; AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety, 2008; Caird, 2004). Also, the lack of intuitiveness of these features and perceived utility may dissuade older adults from using the technologies. Some of the best sources for learning about the operation of the vehicle’s features, such as the cars owner’s manual, are seldomly consulted by drivers (Mersinger & Chaparro, 2022) and do not support the learning styles that are preferred by older users.

Positive Interactions With Aging The DMS has the potential to reduce crashes due to driver distraction or inat- tention. In the case of older drivers, it may detect unsafe driving behaviors before they become problematic, allowing them to maintain their transpor- tation independence and reduce social isolation. Social isolation is associated with significant negative health consequences and reduces quality of life in older populations (Newman-Norlund, et al., 2022). In the case of self-driving vehicles, a DMS may be capable of taking over the car if an older adult expe- riences health related difficulties while driving. In the near future cars may be equipped with real-time in-car health monitoring systems that can detect health abnormalities, such as a stroke, using cushion and heart rate sensors embedded in the car seat (Park et al., 2019). In this scenario, the DMS may be able to switch the car control to an autonomous driving mode and safely maneuver the vehicle to a safe parking location.

CONCLUSION

With aging comes many physical, cognitive, and musculoskeletal changes. These changes may affect a broad range of daily activities including driving and interacting with systems in a vehicle. The ubiquity of DMS equipped veh- icles highlights the importance of considering older drivers when designing these systems. Poor design may result in frequent and unnecessary alerts. To date, little research has been done to examine the interactions between DMS and older users.

FUTURE RESEARCH This paper reviewed how the design of a DMS may interact with common age-related changes. Future research should assess how DMS might be desi- gned to improve accessibility for older drivers who experience a diverse set of physical, motor, cognitive, and sensory changes. Researchers should examine whether a DMS can assess driver attention reliably, and how interface design considerations can improve user interaction with these systems. Future rese- arch should assess how the use of these systems impact older driver behavior, specifically whether drivers with DMS equipped vehicles are in fact more attentive. Finally, it is important to assess whether older adults will adopt this technology. Research has shown that older adults are less likely to adopt new technology, due to both perceptions of competence in learning new tech- nology, as well as perceptions of perceived value or change in quality of life (Berkowsky et al., 2018).

REFERENCES

AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety. 2008 Use of Advanced In-Vehicle Technology by Young and Older Early Adopters. AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety Report. DOT-HS-810-828. Abraham, H., Seppelt, B., Mehler, B. and Reimer, B., 2017, September. What’s in a

name: Vehicle technology branding & consumer expectations for automation. In

Driver Monitoring Systems: Design Considerations for Aging Drivers 435 Proceedings of the 9th international conference on automotive user interfaces and interactive vehicular applications (pp. 226–234). Ball, K., Owsley, C., Sloane, M. E., Roenker, D. L. and Bruni, J. R 1993. Visual

attention problems as a predictor of vehicle crashes in older drivers. Investigative Ophthamology & Visual Science, 34(11), pp. 3110–3123. Berkowsky, R. W., Sharit, J. and Czaja, S. J. 2017. Factors Predicting Decisions About Technology Adoption Among Older Adults. Innovation in aging, 1(3), pp. 1–12. Caird, J. 2004 In-vehicle intelligent transportation systems. Transportation in an

Aging Society, pp. 236. Chaparro, A., Bohan, M. Fernandez, J., Choi, S. D., & Kattel, B. 1999. The impact of age on computer input device use: Psychophysical and physiological measures. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 24(5), pp. 503–513. Chaparro, A., Wood, J. M., & Carberry, T. 2005. Effects of age and auditory

and visual dual tasks on closed-road driving performance. Optometry and vision science, 82(8), pp. 747–754. Dahlberg, J. 2010. Eye tracking with eye glasses. (Unpublished masters dissertation).

Umea University, Sweden. Driver monitoring system 2023 Smart Eye. Available at: https://smarteye.se/solution s/automotive/driver-monitoring-system/ (Accessed: February 1, 2023). Ford Motor Company. 2022 What is Ford BlueCruise* (formerly Active Drive

Assist)?. https://www.ford.com/support/how-tos/ford-technology/driver-assist-f eatures/what-is-ford-bluecruise-hands-free-driving/ GMC. (2022) What is Super Cruise?. https://www.gmc.com/connectivity-technolog y/super-cruise Grother, P., Ngan, M., & Hanaoka, K. 2019. Face recognition vendor test (fvt): Part

3, demographic effects. Gaithersburg, MD: National Institute of Standards and Technology. How to use super cruise. Super Cruise: Hands-Free Driving, Cutting Edge Technology. (n.d.). Retrieved December 9, 2022, from https://www.cadillac.com/owner ship/vehicle-technology/super-cruise. Huang, G. and Pitts, B., 2020. Age-related differences in takeover request modality

preferences and attention allocation during semi-autonomous driving. In Human Aspects of IT for the Aged Population. Technologies, Design and User Experi- ence: 6th International Conference, ITAP 2020, Held as Part of the 22nd HCI International Conference, HCII 2020, Copenhagen, Denmark, July 19-24, 2020, Proceedings, Part I 22 (pp. 135–146). Springer International Publishing. Isler, R. B., Parsonson, B. S. and Hansson, G. J. 1997 Age Related Effects of Restricted Head Movements on the Useful Field of View of Drivers. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 29(6), pp. 793–801. Jo, J., Lee, S. J., Jung, H. G., Park, K. R. and Kim, J. 2011 Vision-Based Method

for Detecting Driver Drowsiness and Distraction in Driver Monitoring system. Optical Engineering, 50(12), pp. 127202–127202. Karthaus, M. and Falkenstein, M. 2016 Functional Changes and Driving Performance in Older Drivers: Assessment and Interventions. Geriatrics, 1(2), p. 12. Khan, M. Q. and Lee, S. 2019 A Comprehensive Survey of Driving Monitoring and

Assistance Systems. Sensors, 19(11), p. 2574. McLaughlin, A. and Pak, R. 2020. Designing displays for older adults. CRC press. Mersinger, M. C., & Chaparro, A. (2022) Semi-Autonomous Vehicle Crashes: An Exploration of Contributing Factors. Human Factors in Transportation, 60, pp. 394–401. Newman-Norlund, R. D., Newman-Norlund, S. E., Sayers, S., McLain, A. C.,

Riccardi, N., & Fridriksson, J. 2022. Effects of social isolation on quality of life in elderly adults. Plos one, 17(11), p. e0276590.

Nissan. (2022) What is Nissan’s ProPILOT Assist?. https://www.nissanusa.com/ex perience-nissan/news-and-events/nissan-propilot-assist.html. Parasuraman, R. and Riley, V., 1997. Humans and automation: Use, misuse, disuse,

abuse. Human Factors, 39(2), pp. 230–253. Park, S. J., Hong, S., Kim, D., Hussain, I. and Seo, Y. 2019 Intelligent In-Car Health Monitoring System For Elderly Drivers In Connected Car. In Proceedings of the 20th Congress of the International Ergonomics Association (IEA 2018) Volume VI: Transport Ergonomics and Human Factors (TEHF), Aerospace Human Factors and Ergonomics 20, pp. 40–44. Springer International Publishing. Salthouse, T. A., Rogan, J. D. and Prill, K. A. 1984 Division Of Attention: Age

Differences On A Visually Presented Memory Task. Memory & Cognition, 12, pp. 613–620. Stone, N. J., Chaparro, A., Keebler, J. R., Chaparro, B. S., & McConnell, D. S. 2017 Introduction to human factors: Applying psychology to design. CRC Press. Volvo. 2019 Volvo Cars To Depoloy In-Car Cameras And Intervention Against Intoxication, Distraction.https://www.media.volvocars.com/global/en- gb/media/pressreleases/250015/volvo-cars-to-deploy-in-car-cameras-and- intervention-against-intoxication-distraction. Wilson, B., Hoffman, J. and Morgenstern, J. 2019 Predictive Inequity in Object

Detection. arXiv preprint arXiv:1902.11097. Wood J. and Chaparro A., 2011 Night driving: How low illumination affects driving and the challenges of simulation. In: Handbook of Driving Simulation for Engi- neering, Medicine and Psychology (Fisher DL, Rizzo M, Caird JK & Lee JD, eds), CRC Press/Taylor & Francis: Boca Raton, FL, Chapter 28, 2011; pp. 1–12. Wood, J., Chaparro, A., Carberry, T. an Chu, B. S., 2010. Effect of simulated visual

impairment on nighttime driving performance. Optometry and vision science, 87(6), pp. 379–386. Wood, J., Chaparro, A., Hickson, L. Thyer, N., Carter, P., Hancock, J., Hoe, A., Le, I., Saphetapy, L. and Ybarzabal, F., 2006. The effect of auditory and visual distra- cters on the useful field of view: Implications for the driving task. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, 47(10), pp. 4646–4650. Yang, J. and Coughlin, J. F. 2014 In-Vehicle Technology For Self-Driving Cars:

Advantages And Challenges For Aging Drivers. International Journal of Auto- motive Technology, 15, pp. 333–340.

Cover of the proceedings volume Human Factors in Transportation

Explore the complete digital volume

Human Factors in Transportation

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-71-1

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →