INTRODUCTION
As technology advances, the market is flooded with a variety of electric too- thbrushes, prompting many parents to consider purchasing them for their children. Studies have suggested that electric toothbrushes may be more effective in cleaning children’s teeth than manual brushing. However, upon researching and analyzing the children’s electric toothbrushes available, we found that many of them are simply adult electric toothbrushes scaled down in size, without taking into account children’s grip strength and usage habits.
Therefore, in order to address this issue, we will conduct a literature review and specific design studies to explore how to create an electric toothbrush that is truly tailored to children’s grip strength and usage habits.
EXISTING PRODUCT ANALYSIS We examined the existing designs of children’s electric toothbrushes, with a focus on the brush handle and grip, and found that most available options are simply scaled-down versions of adult toothbrushes without specific con- sideration for children’s grip ability. There are some designs that feature a cupped grip or increased thickness, but their effectiveness is limited. Addi- tionally, we analyzed and integrated various technologies including pressure
© 2023. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 490
Design of Spherical Handle for Children’s Electric Toothbrush 491
Technical Analysis Design Applications Technology Name
Pressure sensors
When applied to the toothbrush, this technology detects whether the pressure applied to the teeth is appropriate. If the pressure is too high, the system can provide an indication.
By utilizing a pressure chip, the resistance value changes when pressure is exerted on the diaphragm, resulting in a linear output signal that is proportional to the amount of pressure applied.
Acceleration sensor
The sensor can be utilized in toothbrushes to accurately record the number of times the teeth are brushed, and to motivate children to brush their teeth more effectively by enabling them to clock in their brushing routine.
This sensor operates on the same principle as a gravity sensor, and it determines the acceleration direction in three dimensions. Although it consumes low power, its accuracy is relatively low.
The gravity sensor can be incorporated into toothbrush design to detect the horizontal direction and adjust the angle for optimal cleaning.
Gravity sensors The gravity sensor includes an internal weight that is integrated with a piezoelectric sheet. This sensor measures the magnitude of the voltage generated in two orthogonal directions to calculate the horizontal square and determine the orientation of the toothbrush.
Gyroscope Gyroscopes are able to measure angular velocity along one or multiple axes of motion, and are an ideal technology to complement the functionality of accelerometers.
If combined with two sensors, an accelerometer and a gyroscope, it can track and capture the complete movement in 3D space. This provides the end user with a more realistic user experience, as well as an accurate navigation system and other advanced features.
sensors, acceleration sensors, gravity sensors, and gyroscopes, and explored how to apply them in a reasonable and scientific manner during the design process.
After analyzing and integrating existing technology, we discovered that current technology can already provide effective adjustment and assistance for children’s brushing. As a result, the most critical aspect of designing a children’s electric toothbrush is to ensure that it has an ergonomic grip that enables children to comfortably and securely hold the vibrating toothbrush during use.
USER NEEDS ANALYSIS During our research, we observed that children’s toothbrushes are not only used by children but also by parents. Therefore, we considered the different needs of both parents and children. Parents prioritize safety, cleanliness, and
comfort when choosing an electric toothbrush, while children focus on the attractiveness and comfort of the toothbrush. To create a successful design, we needed to create a toothbrush that satisfied both parties.
Through our research, we discovered that the design of children’s tooth- brush handles is still in its infancy. The current toothbrush handle design is not user-friendly for children due to their limited hand grip ability. Parents are concerned about their children’s ability to brush their teeth effectively and the resistance and difficulty in developing brushing habits. By integrating these pain points, we focused on designing a grip that caters to children’s needs while addressing the concerns of parents through information feedback, resistance elimination, and habit formation.
DESIGN Design Objectives
Based on our research and data analysis, we have established five design goals for our product: to make tooth brushing appealing to children, to ensure com- fort while brushing, to promote cleanliness, to develop healthy habits, and to provide peace of mind for parents. We have developed specific solutions to address each of these goals.
Design Options The issue with electric toothbrushes for children available in the market is that they are not sufficiently comfortable for children to grip, and this discomfort may lead to reduced safety and cleanliness. Thus, our focus is on the goal of “comfortable brushing.” The design of the electric toothbrush is mainly divided into two parts: the brush handle and the brush head. In our research, we found that the most natural grip for children is a spherical grip, based on literature that suggests that the human palm muscles and palm form a groove that can reduce pressure on the palm. Additionally, we obse- rved that when children use a toothbrush, their palm and grip positions are typically close together, which increases contact surface and friction, redu- cing pressure and leading to a more relaxed and comfortable experience. For the brush head, we used national standards and oral measurement data to determine the most suitable size for children’s mouths and teeth.
Modeling Once we had established the “spherical grip” as our main design element, we began the process of modeling and verification. We started with a sketch model, which we created in adult size to allow the designer to gain a better understanding of the grip’s features and compare them to their own expe- rience. After experimenting with a variety of brush handle shapes, we were able to determine a shape that was more comfortable and better suited to the needs of children. We made minor adjustments to the length and width ratio based on comparisons between different designs.
To gain a better understanding of the size of children’s palms in different age groups, we reviewed literature and conducted hands-on research. We
Design of Spherical Handle for Children’s Electric Toothbrush 493
asked children between the ages of three and six to make handprints on an electronic hand-printing board, then created molds of their palms using ultra- light clay and marked key points for measurement. We then scaled the models to adult size to facilitate the experience and feedback of the design team.
Modeling Verification We selected an appropriate age group of children, observed their subconsci- ous behavior while using the model, and verified if the modeling guidance achieved the desired effect. We provided the children with the design sketch model and a commercially available electric toothbrush to hold at the same time, and asked them to simulate the posture they used while brushing their teeth with an electric toothbrush to compare the grip comfort. We collected their feedback and experience. Additionally, we asked parents to hold the adult-size model for a similar experience and comparison.
Following the experience, the children generally found the novel tooth- brush shape more interesting and expressed a willingness to use it. They found the spherical grip more comfortable and easier to hold than the nor- mal grip, and parents also found it more effortless to grip. We also had the children compare models with slight differences in the length and width ratio of the spherical grip, analyzed the most suitable modeling ratio, refined the model, and established the final shape by considering accessibility, hand-fit, and overall fit.
Various shapes and scales of models
Children’s comparative experience with models
Model verification of the final shape Experiment content Results
Children can follow the shape to guide the correct grip.
Observe how children subconsciously use the spherical grip model after they get it Collect children’s experience and feedback on the use of ball grips
Find the most suitable size ratio
1. Feel new and interesting 2. Considered easier to grip than traditional brush handles Adjust the shape of the clay grip in real time based on feedback, and compare children’s experience and feedback on different spherical grips with slight differences in proportions All in line with expectations Conducting accessibility, fit, and fit analysis
Collect feedback from parents on ball grips (adult size)
Parents find it easier to grip than regular brush handles
CONCLUSION
This paper examines the design of electric toothbrushes for children, with a focus on creating a grip that is more comfortable for children. The study takes into account both the experiences of children and their parents and pro- vides insights into how to design products that are suitable for both groups. Through usability testing, the effectiveness and practicality of the spherical grip design were confirmed, providing new inspiration and guidance for the design of children’s appliances that require a comfortable grip.