Sandra Frings, Holger Kett, Jürgen Falkner (2022). Essential Areas of Action for the Smartification of Traditional Products and Services Considering the Capabilities of SMEs. In: The Human Side of Service Engineering. AHFE Open Access, vol. 62, pp. 302–311. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1002571
One way for small and medium sized (SMEs) enterprises developing traditional physical products to follow the digital transformation is to smartify their products and develop smart services according to business or customer needs. The process to set up a smartification strategy for the first time covers many different organizational, human, technical and business process related aspects. With our research we provide a decision framework to support CEOs in identifying, which areas of action should be focused upon and enterprise-specifically further developed for the smartification of selected products. This paper derives the areas of action, which build the base for the decision framework’s underlying capability and maturity model.
INTRODUCTION AND CHALLENGES Digital transformation, nowadays, is a very broad subject and surely discus- sed in each small and medium sized (SMEs) enterprise developing and possi- bly manufacturing traditional physical products. Their relevant success and competitive factors – like cost efficiency and effectiveness through process optimization, adaption to the market through reaction to customer needs, as well as having skilled and motivated employees (Schmidt and Tritschler 2021) – do not really differ from those of large companies. Nevertheless, the ability to participate in the digital transformation may be very different due to aspects like company budget, length of the decision paths and the fact that SMEs often are stronger niche experts with only little competences in complementary areas of expertise such as digitalization (Lindner and Leyh 2019). Especially this last characteristic and the high potential for improving the internal process to plan and build smart products makes the resea- rch on SMEs developing and selling a traditional physical product lacking smart attributes like data processing in the Cloud, automation, autonomy, self-learning, or the like, very interesting.
Usually, the SME’s ultimate aim is to develop and sell competitive products. But over time every product looses its competitiveness (Engeln 2020). The
Essential Areas of Action for the Smartification 303
SME could create more value and make the product physically “smart(er)” thus being able to add a more attractive, as well as more viable product. By doing so, it could add smart services to the company’s offer (Porter and Heppelmann 2014).
However, the question, which digitalization path is the most promising and should be taken, can keep the SME in a state of “smart product paralysis” (sirris 2021). One of the reasons is the uncertainty by the SME’s top mana- gement about the strategic digitalization decisions in general before going into detail about the smart product and service design and implementation. Therefore, preparation for digitalization turns out difficult and lengthy in the jungle of a great variety of different options.
Those options are not only comprised of purely technical aspects of digital transformation. More than that, many aspects on different levels of the SME need to be taken into account. This covers vision/mission development, strategy/goals development, change/innovation management, needs-definition, cost-benefit analysis, requirements-definition, smart produ- ct/smart service (re)design, data management/ architecture, business model, IT-architecture/system-landscape, IT-security and legal aspects, to name the most important ones (see the references in the next chapter).
To help SMEs out of this smart product paralysis state, our research work proposes an approach, which covers the early strategic planning phases of smartifying a traditional physical product, including delivering a product- service-offer and not just to transform a product. In previous work (Frings and Kett 2021) we outlined the methodical framework for this approach. In this paper, we cover the essential areas of action as base for the underlying capability and maturity model.
METHODICAL APPROACH AND RELATED WORK Crucial competencies of a CEO are being a visionary and having the ability to think competitively, to translate customer’s need and make appropriate deci- sions (Barton et al. 2018). These factors are essential in constantly searching for new ways to keep or make the SME more successful especially during digi- tal transformation. Generally, once a vision is stated, the logical next steps would be to define goals, to detail the vision, to prepare a strategy, how to reach the defined goals and then to plan activities within this strategy to be able to help the vision come to life (Timinger and Seel 2018). But since the topic of smartification may be very new for the CEO, the exact strategy and the associated tasks are not yet clear in detail.
Starting with our methodical framework (Frings and Kett 2021) and existing maturity models, as well as systematic literature reviews on those models (Software Engineering Institute 2010; Becker et al. 2019; Röglin- ger et al. 2012; Berger et al. 2020; de Bruin and Rosemann 2005; Dymond 2002; Frings and Kett 2021; Gollhardt et al; Achi et al. 2016; Adrodegari and Saccani 2020; Angreani et al. 2020; Katuu 2021; Ochoa-Urrego and Peña-Reyes 2021; Sadiq et al. 2021; Santos-Neto and Costa 2019; Schallmo et al. 2021; Williams and Lang 2019), we dove deeper into the necessary subject areas from the strategic viewpoint of a CEO leading a SME, which
develops traditional physical products like for example a walker for people having walking disability. Based on our literature reviews and the experie- nce we already have on the smartification topic, we identified the following six necessary steps the SME’s CEO needs to go through to be able to make appropriate strategic decisions: 1) Determination of the strategic importance of smartification; 2) definition of relevant use case(s) for the smart product and product-specific smart service-bundles; 3) identification of characteri- stics for the future smart product and identification of relevant smart services; 4) rough determination of available capabilities for the smartification; 5) rough comparison of target and current capabilities; 6) rough estimation of cost and benefit through smartification. These steps could be combined with methods like the Business Canvas Model (Osterwalder and Pigneur 2010) or other business model analysis methods to cover the topics defi- ned there within and to get a broader view. In our research we focus on very specific smartification questions, which will be further detailed in future publications.
Our hypothesis is, that once theses steps are taken, the CEOs have a better understanding of, which challenges are waiting for them as well as, which benefits they will profit from. Our literature review’s result is that none of the publicly available solutions, approaches, or scientific work covers all these necessary steps within one framework for the smartification of tradi- tional products. Therefore, we decided to pick relevant areas of action from divers existing models, concepts and approaches (see the most relevant litera- ture references in Table 1) and structured our framework and the underlying maturity and capability model accordingly.
AREAS OF ACTION FOR SMARTIFICATION Within our framework, the underlying capability and maturity model covers all relevant areas of action for smartification. As described above, there could be different goals within a vision. For this paper, we use the vision “Smarti- fication of a traditional physical product” and the associated concrete goal “Functional expansion of an existing well established traditional, physical product with intelligent components and services (new smart product-service offers)”.
To make it more plausible, we selected the following realistic example: A traditional, non-smart walker is to be made smart for people having full control of their vision and being mentally healthy, but lacking confidence in walking without aid. Previous work (Merlet 2010; Wachaja et al. 2017; Alves et al. 2018; Aristizabal-Aristizabal et al. 2022) focusses on unhealthy elderly having different impairments, which calls for other functions to be provided by a smart walker. Our example fulfills the vision and goal stated above. For a minimal functional expansion, a simple GPS tracker and an emergency button would be sufficient to fulfill a subgoal of being able to track the person using the smart walker in case the emergency button is pushed. For an extensive functional expansion, the following possibilities are realistic: Addition of information sources like weather and radio, medically relevant functions like heart rate or blood pressure monitoring, further emergency
Essential Areas of Action for the Smartification 305
Table 1. Areas of action.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Area of action Relevant questions and references Strategy What is the maturity of relevant strategies (e.g. enterprise/digitalization/ IoT/data/smartification strategy)? Which strategic drivers influence the smartification vision and thus strategy the most (e.g. product/services drivers, technical drivers (e.g. artificial intelligence, data processing, process automation), market drivers, customer drivers)? (Henderson 1989; Software Engineering Institute 2010; Koldewey et al. 2019b; Pierenkemper and Gausemeier 2021; Yu 2021; Gausemeier and Plass 2014)
Smart Service On which feature related characteristics (e.g. monitoring, control, optimization, prediction, automation, autonomy, criticality/product as a safety device) and, which context related characteristics (e.g. data processing, communication, mobility, data security, sustainability, location) should the focus of the new services be put? (Porter and Heppelmann 2014; Westermann 2017; Strobel et al. 2019; Britze and et al 2020; Falkner 2020; Winkler 2020; Neuhüttler et al. 2020; Frank et al. 2020; Kett et al. 2021; Freitag and Wiesner 2018; Grohmann et al. 2021)) Smart Product Which device related characteristics (e.g. sensors, actuators, communication, connectivity, scalability, data storage, security, information sources, integrated business systems, human computer interaction) are relevant within the planned smart services and where should the focus be put? (Porter and Heppelmann 2014; Porter and Heppelmann 2015; Westermann 2017; Strobel et al. 2019; Britze and et al 2020; Falkner 2020; Winkler 2020; Neuhüttler et al. 2020; Frank et al. 2020; Kett et al. 2021)
Stakeholder Which stakeholders with respect to the new smart services and smartified product are mostly relevant to which degree and why? (e.g. customer, dealer, development partners, supplier, ecosystem participants) (Gausemeier and Plass 2014; Falkner 2020; Neuhüttler et al. 2020; Frings et al. 2021) Data Which key data-related issues are needed to be able to deliver the intended smart services (e.g. data acquisition/collection/generation, data analysis, data aggregation, data integration, data transmission, data storage, data security, data sources, data architecture, data quality)? (Software Engineering Institute 2010; Porter and Heppelmann 2014; Bernerstätter 2020; Kutzias et al. 2019)
Business model What is relevant regarding the new/adapted business model (e.g. product as a service, shared usage model, product driven, system solution driven, service driven, value driven, data driven, stakeholder driven); which business model pattern may be relevant (e.g. addon, direct selling, flat rate, freemium, pay per use, subscription, two sided market)? (Koldewey et al. 2019a; Gassmann et al. 2021; Nagl and Bozem; Osterwalder and Pigneur 2010; Müller et al. 2020) Continued.
Table 1. Continued.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Area of action Relevant questions and references IT Which key information technology related issues are to be dealt with to realize the intended smart product/service bundle (e.g. infrastructure (IoT platform, ecosystem platform), connection, network, communication, product cloud, architecture, integration with business systems/external sources, IT security, technological trends (e.g. artificial intelligence, machine learning, block chain, virtual/augmented reality)? (Software Engineering Institute 2010; Porter and Heppelmann 2014; Kutzias et al. 2019)
Development Which key development related issues are to be dealt with during strategic decision making to realize the intended smart product/service-bundle (e.g. within product development, service development, software development)? (Software Engineering Institute 2010; Lindemann 2016; Engeln 2020) Operation Which key operational issues are to be included in the strategic decision making when operating the smart product/service-bundle (e.g. ordering, helpdesk/ customer service, billing/invoicing, maintenance, infrastructure)? (Software Engineering Institute 2010; Gausemeier and Plass 2014; Yu 2021)
Organization Which key issues are relevant from an organizational point of view when developing the smart product/service-bundle (e.g. innovation management, change management, collaboration, cooperation with relevant business departments, culture, leadership, responsibilities, compliance and governance, quality management, documentation, business processes definition)? (Software Engineering Institute 2010; Gausemeier and Plass 2014; Frank et al. 2020) Project management Which project management specific factors are relevant to be able to realize the intended smartification (e.g. project management method/approach, project initiation, planning, execution, documentation, project monitoring and controlling, closing)? (Software Engineering Institute 2010; Ziółkowski and Dere˛gowski 2014; Kuster et al. 2018; Timinger and Seel 2018)
functions like tilt or acceleration sensors, socializing functions like find and meet other persons. Nowadays, this list is nearly endless.
The above mentioned capability and maturity model of our decision fra- mework is made up of eleven “areas of action”, which are listed in Table 1 including the most relevant references. They cover questions, as well as aspe- cts and drivers, which are generally relevant to be dealt with for setting up a smartification strategy.
Upcoming publications will cover details of the six steps of our framework mentioned in the previous chapter, all of which fall back on the underlying
Essential Areas of Action for the Smartification 307
capability and maturity model, which builds upon those eleven areas of action.
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION The set of identified areas of action relevant for the smartification of tradi- tional physical products builds the basis for an evaluation method, which supports not only the identification of the essential aspects, which need to be further developed in a SME, but provides the different degrees of effort for advancing these aspects. Our work will support SMEs during their strategical efforts to design future service business, with this being able to use the advan- tages of digitalization, taking necessary steps towards sustainability and thus strengthening its resilience to competitors.
REFERENCES
Achi, Abdelkader/Salinesi, Camille/Viscusi, Gianluigi (2016). Information Systems for Innovation: A Comparative Analysis of Maturity Models’ Characteristics. In: John Krogstie/Haralambos Mouratidis/Jianwen Su (Eds.). Advanced Information Systems Engineering Workshops. Cham, Springer International Publishing, 78–90. Adrodegari, Federico/Saccani, Nicola (2020). A maturity model for the servitization
of product-centric companies. Journal of Manufacturing Technology Manage- ment (Volume 31 Issue 4), 775–797: https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/ -doi/-10.1108/-JMTM-07-2019-0255/full/html. Alves, Joana/Santos, Cristina P./Seabra, Eurico/Silva, Luis F. (2018). ASBGO*: A echatronic improved smart walker. In: J. F. Silva Gomes/Shaker A. Meguid (Eds.). IRF2018. Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Integrity-Reliability- Failure: Lisbon, Portugal, 22–26 July 2018. Porto, INEGI-Instituto de Ciência e Inovação em Engenharia Mecânica e Gestão Industrial. Angreani, Linda Salma/Vijaya, Annas/Wicaksono, Hendro (2020). Systematic
Literature Review of Industry 4.0 Maturity Model for Manufactu- ring and Logistics Sectors. Procedia Manufacturing 52, 337–343. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.promfg.2020.11.056. Aristizabal-Aristizabal, Julián/Ferro-Rugeles, Rubén/Lancheros-Vega, María/Sierra M., Sergio D./Múnera, Marcela/Cifuentes, Carlos A. (2022). Fundamentals for the Design of Smart Walkers. In: Carlos A. Cifuentes/Marcela Múnera (Eds.). Interfacing Humans and Robots for Gait Assistance and Rehabilitation. Cham, Springer International Publishing, 121–141. Barton, Thomas/Müller, Christian/Seel, Christian (Eds.) (2018). Digitalisierung
in Unter-nehmen. Von den theoretischen Ansätzen zur praktischen Umsetzung. Wiesbaden, Springer Vieweg. Becker, Wolfgang/Eierle, Brigitte/Fliaster, Alexander/Ivens, Björn Sven/Leischnig, Alexander/Pflaum, Alexander/Sucky, Eric (Eds.) (2019). Geschäftsmodelle in der digitalen Welt. Strategien, Prozesse und Praxiserfahrungen. Wiesbaden, Germany, Springer Gabler. Berger, Stephan/Bitzer, Michael/Häckel, Björn/Voit, Christian (2020). Approach-
ing digital Transformation - Development of a muli-dimentional maturity model. Association for Information Systems Association for Information Systems / ECIS 2020 Proceedings.
Bernerstätter, Robert (2020). Reifegradmodell zur Bewertung der Inputfaktoren für datenanalytische Anwendungen-Konzeptionierung am Beispiel der Schwach- stellen-analyse. Dissertation: https://pure.unileoben.ac.at/portal/files/4130152/ AC15467285n01.pdf. Britze, Nils/et al (2020). Reifegradmodell Digitale Geschäftsprozesse. Leitfa- den: https://www.bitkom.org/Themen/Technologien-Software/Digital-Office/Rei fegradmodell-Digitale-Geschaeftsprozesse.html. de Bruin, Tonia/Rosemann, Michael (2005). Application of a Holistic Model for
Determining BPM Maturity. BPTrends: https://www.researchgate.net/publication /27481630. Dymond, Kenneth M. (2002). CMM® Handbuch. Das Capability Maturity Model® für Software. Berlin/Heidelberg, Springer. Engeln, Werner (2020). Methoden der Produktentwicklung. Technische Produkte
kundenorientiert entwickeln. 3rd ed. Essen, Vulkan-Verlag GmbH. Falkner, Jürgen (2020). Leitfaden zur Entwicklung von intelligenten Diensten und Produkten. Mittelstand 4.0-Kompetenzzentrum Stuttgart. Frank, Maximilian/Gausemeier, Jürgen/Cardinal von Widdern, Nils Hennig von/Kol-
dewey, Christian/Menzefricke, Jörn Steffen/Reinhold, Jannik (2020). A reference process for the Smart Service business - development and practical implications. ISPIM Connects Bangkok: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/339536205. Freitag, Mike/Wiesner, Stefan (2018). Smart Service Lifecycle Management: A Framework and Use Case. In: Ilkyeong Moon/Gyu M. Lee/Jinwoo Park et al. (Eds.). Advances in Production Management Systems. Smart Manufacturing for Industry 4.0. Cham, Springer International Publishing, 97–104. Frings, Sandra/Kett, Holger (2021). Towards a Capability Based Approach to Streng-
then the Strategic Decision Making Process for Developing Smart Products and Services in SMEs. In: Christine Leitner/Walter Ganz/Debra Satterfield et al. (Eds.). Advances in the Human Side of Service Engineering. Cham, Springer International Publishing, 189–196. Frings, Sandra/Kett, Holger/Härle, Julia/Meyer, Olga/Stock, Daniel/Mietzner, Rudolf/Mateja, Deborah/Halckenhäußer, André (Eds.) (2021). Innovation durch Koo- peration. Cloud Computing als Wegbereiter gemeinsamer Leistungsangebote und verbesserter Wert-schöpfungs-ketten. Gassmann, Oliver/Frankenberger, Karolin/Choudury, Michaela (2021). Geschäft-
smodelle entwickeln. 55+ innovative Konzepte mit dem St. Galler Business Model Navigator. 3rd ed. München, Hanser. Gausemeier, Jürgen/Plass, Christoph (2014). Zukunftsorientierte Unternehmensgestaltung. Strategien, Geschäftsprozesse und IT-Systeme für die Produktion von morgen. 2nd ed. München, Hanser. Gollhardt, Torsten/Halsbenning, Sebastian/Hermann, Andreas/Karsakova, Aleksan-
dra/Becker, Jorg. Development of a Digital Transformation Maturity Model for IT Companies. In: 2020 IEEE 22nd Conference, 94–103. Grohmann, Alexander/Jungmann, Michael/Wambacher, Roman (2021). Smart Products und Smart Services entwickeln - Herausforderungen und Erfolgsfaktoren. In: Arndt Borgmeier/Alexander Grohmann/Stefan F. Gross (Eds.). Smart Services und Internet der Dinge: Geschäftsmodelle, Umsetzung und Best Practices. München, Carl Hanser Verlag GmbH & Co. KG, 29–44. Henderson, Bruce D. (1989). The Origin of Strategy. Harvard Business Review:
Essential Areas of Action for the Smartification 309
Katuu, Shadrack (2021). An overview of maturity models – perspectives on a research data management maturity model. Presentation (DIRIS). DIRIS. https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.13087.48807. Kett, Holger/Evcenko, Dimitri/Falkner, Jürgen/Frings, Sandra/Neuhüttler, Jens
(2021). Künstliche Intelligenz als Veränderungstreiber für Geschäftsmodelle. In: Manfred Bruhn/Karsten Hadwich (Eds.). Künstliche Intelligenz im Dienstleistung- smanagement. Wiesbaden, Springer Fachmedien, 51–75. Koldewey, Christian/Echterfeld, Julian/Gausemeier, Jürgen/Reilender, Meikel (2019a). Business Model Portfolio Planning for Smart Servi- ces. ISPIM Connects Fukuoka – Building on Innovation Tradition: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/329034262. Koldewey, Christian/Gausemeier, Jürgen/Dumitrescu, Roman/Evers, Hans Heinrich- /Frank, Maximilian/Reinhold, Jannik (2019b). Development Process for Smart Service Strategies - Grasping the Potentials of Digitalization for Servitization. The ISPIM Innovation Conference. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-69380-0_12. Kuster, Jürg/Bachmann, Christian/Huber, Eugen/Hubmann, Mike/Lippmann, Robert/Schneider, Emil/Schneider, Patrick/Witschi, Urs/Wüst, Roger (2018). Handbuch Projektmanagement. Agil – Klassisch – Hybrid. 4th ed. Berlin, Springer Berlin. Kutzias, Damian/Falkner, Jürgen/Kett, Holger (2019). On the Complexity of Cloud
and IoT Integration: Architectures, Challenges and Solution Approaches. In: Pro- ceedings of the 4th International Conference on Internet of Things, Big Data and Security, 4th International Conference on Internet of Things, Big Data and Secu- rity, Heraklion, Crete, Greece, 02.05.2019 - 04.05.2019. SCITEPRESS - Science and Technology Publications, 376–384. Lindemann, Udo (Ed.) (2016). Handbuch Produktentwicklung. München, Hanser. Lindner, Dominic/Leyh, Christian (2019). Digitalisierung von KMU – Fragestellungen, Handlungsempfehlungen sowie Implikationen für IT-Organisation und IT-Servicemanagement. HMD Praxis der Wirtschaftsinformatik 56 (2), 402–418. https://doi.org/10.1365/s40702-019-00502-z. Merlet, J.-P. (2010). Preliminary Design of ANG, a Low-Cost Automated Walker for
Elderly. In: Doina Pisla/Marco Ceccarelli/Manfred Husty et al. (Eds.). New Trends in Mechanism Science. Dordrecht, Springer Netherlands, 529–536. Müller, Julian/Lassnig, Markus/Klieber, Karin (2020). Digitale Geschäfts- modelle und Smart Services. Digitales Transferzentrum Salzburg: https: //www.salzburgresearch.at/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Digitale-Geschaeft smodelleSmart-Services_DTZ-Whitepaper_final.pdf. Nagl, Anna/Bozem, Karlheinz. Geschäftsmodelle 4.0. Business Model Building mit Checklisten und Fallbeispielen. Neuhüttler, Jens/Kett, Holger/Frings, Sandra/Falkner, Jürgen/Ganz, Walter/Urmetzer,
Florian (2020). Artificial Intelligence as Driver for Business Model Innovation in Smart Service Systems. In: Jim Spohrer/Christine Leitner (Eds.). Advances in the Human Side of Service Engineering. Cham, Springer International Publishing, 212–219. Ochoa-Urrego, Rafael-Leonardo/Peña-Reyes, José-Ismael (2021). Digital Maturity Models: A Systematic Literature Review. In: Daniel R. A. Schallmo/Joseph Tidd (Eds.). Digitalization. Cham, Springer International Publishing, 71–85. Osterwalder, Alexander/Pigneur, Yves (2010). Business model generation. A hand-
book for visionaries, game changers, and challengers. Hoboken, NJ, Wiley.
Pierenkemper, Christoph/Gausemeier, Jürgen (2021). Developing Strategies for Digital Transformation in SMEs with Maturity Models. In: Daniel R. A. Schall- mo/Joseph Tidd (Eds.). Digitalization. Cham, Springer International Publishing, 103–124. Porter, Michael E./Heppelmann, James E. (2014). How Smart, Connected Products
Are Transforming Competition 2014: https://hbr.org/2014/11/how-smart-connec ted-products-are-transforming-competition. Porter, Michael E./Heppelmann, James E. (2015). How Smart, Connected Products Are Transforming Companies: https://hbr.org/2015/10/how-smart-connected-pr oducts-are-transforming-companies. Röglinger, Maximilian/Pöppelbuß, Jens/Becker, Jörg (2012). Maturity models in
business process management. Business Process Management Journal 18 (2), 328–346. Sadiq, Raghad Baker/Safie, Nurhizam/Abd Rahman, Abdul Hadi/Goudarzi, Shidrokh (2021). Artificial intelligence maturity model: a systematic literature review. PeerJ. Computer science, https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj-cs.661. Santos-Neto, João Batista Sarmento dos/Costa, Ana Paula Cabral Seixas (2019).
Enterprise maturity models: a systematic literature review. Enterprise Information Systems 13 (5), 719–769. https://doi.org/10.1080/17517575.2019.1575986. Schallmo, Daniel R. A./Lang, Klaus/Hasler, Daniel/Ehmig-Klassen, Katharina/Williams, Christopher A. (2021). An Approach for a Digital Maturity Model for SMEs Based on Their Requirements. In: Daniel R. A. Schallmo/Joseph Tidd (Eds.). Digitalization. Cham, Springer International Publishing, 87–101. Schmidt, Oliver/Tritschler, Tobias (2021). Digitalisierung ist ein entscheidender
Effizienztreiber. Zeitschrift für wirtschaftlichen Fabrikbetrieb 116 (9), 632–638. https://doi.org/10.1515/zwf-2021-0143. Sirris (2021). The what, why and how of digital servitisation. Casebook digital servitisation 2021: https://portal.sirris.be/digital-servitisation-casebook-form (accessed 2/5/2022). Software Engineering Institute (2010). Capability Maturity Model® Integration for
Development (CMMI-DEV), Version 1.3. Improving processes for developing better Improving processes for developing better products and services (Techni- cal Report). https://resources.sei.cmu.edu/asset_files/technicalreport/2010_005_ 001_15287.pdf Strobel, Gero/Paukstadt, Ute/Becker, Jörg/Eicker, Stefan (2019). Von smar- ten Produkten zu smarten Dienstleistungen und deren Auswirkung auf die Wertschöpfung. HMD Praxis der Wirtschaftsinformatik 56 (327), 494–513. https://doi.org/10.1365/s40702-019-00520-x. Timinger, Holger/Seel, Christian (2018). Vision und Reifegradmodell für digitalisiertes Projektmanagement. In: Thomas Barton/Christian Müller/Christian Seel (Eds.). Digitalisierung in Unternehmen. Von den theoretischen Ansätzen zur praktischen Umsetzung. Wiesbaden, Springer Vieweg, 159–175. Wachaja, Andreas/Agarwal, Pratik/Zink, Mathias/Adame, Miguel Reyes/Möl-
ler, Knut/Burgard, Wolfram (2017). Navigating blind people with walking impairments using a smart walker. Autonomous Robots 41 (3), 555–573. https://www.doi.org/10.1007/s10514-016-9595-8. Westermann, Thorsten (2017). Systematik zur Reifegradmodell-basierten Planung von Cyber-Physical Systems des Maschinen- und Anlagenbaus. Dissertation. Heinz Nixdorf Institute Universität Paderborn.
Essential Areas of Action for the Smartification 311
Williams, Christopher A./Lang, Klaus (2019). Digital Maturity Models for Small and Medium-sized Enterprises - A Systematic Literature Review. Proceedings ISPIM Innovation Conference: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334108295. Winkler, Tibor (2020). Systematische Entwicklung von Smart Products – Konzeption
eines Reifegradmodells. Studienarbeit am Institut für Arbeitswissenschaften und Technologiemanagement (IAT) der Universität Stuttgart. Studienarbeit. Stuttgart, Universität Stuttgart: unpublished. Yu, Xiu-bao (2021). The Fundamental Elements of Strategy. Concepts, Theories and Cases. Singapore, Springer Singapore. Ziółkowski, Artur/Dere˛gowski, Tomasz (2014). Hybrid Approach in Project Mana-
gement – Mixing Capability Maturity Model Integration with Agile Practices. Social Sciences 85 (3). https://doi.org/10.5755/j01.ss.85.3.8416.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
The Human Side of Service Engineering
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-38-4
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional