Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Interface Evaluation Method of Medical Equipment Based on Aesthetics Measures

School of Mechanical Engineering, Southeast University, Nanjing, China ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1002169

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to provide an effective method to evaluate the interface design of medical equipment to improve user experience. Ngo proposed the calculation method of fourteen aesthetic indexes and tested the method in the layout design of the website. However, he counts the proportion of each index into the same value, which is obviously inconsistent with people's cognitive habits. This paper extends Ego’s research to the application level. We creatively introduce the analytic hierarchy process and redistribute the values to make it consistent with human cognitive habits. The method can help designers quickly pick up the optimal design scheme.In order to construct an effective evaluation system, five indexes that balance symmetry economy regularity and rhythm were selected from ego's 14 aesthetic measures for interface elements displays based on five basic interface design principles, user research and experiences of professional designers. AHP (Analytic Hierarchy Process) that has five steps: 1. Build a hierarchical structure model 2. Construct a judgment matrix 3. Hierarchical single sort 4. Hierarchical total order 5. Consistency check. was used to calculate the weight of each index. An expert was invited to value the indexes and the valued data successfully passed the consistency test.In order to quickly get the calculation results, we programmed all the calculation methods and processed the data of interface elements into matrices. The evaluation method is constructed through MATLAB programming to provide an objective evaluation method for the improvement of the user experience of the interface design of medical equipment.We assume that the model could benefit designers in selecting the optimal design plan and improving the efficiency of using the interface. Then we started empirical research to validate the method. The operating interface of a certain brand of medical pathology product freezing microtome was selected as a sample. For experimentation, we chose five different design schemes of the interface, and processed the interface elements into rectangles. We got the position and area data of the rectangle on the surface from adobe xd.The result is that the evaluation method can well reflect the aesthetics of the medical equipment interface design, play a guiding role in the interface design of the medical equipment, and can improve and enhance the user experience of the medical equipment interface. Due to time reasons, this article does not include more elements that affect the usability of the interface, such as the visual weight of the elements, the purity of the hue, and so on. All the interfaces used have been decolorized because color will affect human evaluation during the research. We will consider including color in the evaluation system in the future research.

INTRODUCTION

The interface design of medical equipment affects the efficiency of the doctor’s work. When designing an interface, designers often rely on sub- jective experience to judge the quality of the interface design. The level of designers varies, and their subjective experience does not represent the opi- nions of most users. There have been many discussions on the evaluation criteria of design evaluation and aesthetic measures. Hentati et al. (2018) argued that the usability evaluation could be calculated on some basic usa- bility attributes. Moshagen and Thielsch (2010) validated that aesthetics can be identified by four measures.

The German Fechner established the aesthetic theory of Experimental Aesthetics by introducing some experimental methods in the field of psych- ology into the field of aesthetics. Later scholars created many new domains along this path. The aesthetic measures of the interface are one of the bra- nches. Tullis (1981) argue that the aesthetic measures are calculated by quantitative numerical calculation of the objects on an interface to analyze the relationship between interface elements and user perception. Later, Ngo et al. (2002) proposed 13 aesthetic measures based on Tullis’s research.

© 2022. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 298

Interface Evaluation Method of Medical Equipment Based on Aesthetics Measures 299

They verified the effectiveness of the evaluation measures used to measure the aesthetic of the screen interface through experiments. However, there is a problem that the weight of each aesthetic measure in the research is the same, which is obviously not in line with human cognitive ability.

Based on the design principles of the interface and the characteristics of the interface design of medical equipment, we select several basic aesthetic mea- sures from the evaluation system to create a measuring method of medical device interface. The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) was used to assign value on each selected aesthetic measure to construct an interface design eva- luation method. Quantitative evaluation of the interface design of medical equipment could help designers create better works and provide an objective evaluation basis for the interface design of medical equipment.

SELECTING AESTHETICS MEASURES Based on five basic interface design principles, user research and experiences of professional designers five measures that are balance symmetry economy regulation and rhythm were selected from Ngo’s 14 aesthetic measures for graphic displays. As the basic element of constructing the evaluation method, the selected measures are weighted and assigned to construct the evaluation system through the analytic hierarchy process.

Measure of Balance The balance is calculated as the difference in the visual weight of the objects on both sides along the horizontal axis and the vertical axis. The formula is as follows

Equations and mathematical formulas are available in the original paper PDF.

WT−WB max(|wT|,|wB|)

i

L, R, B and T are the upper, lower, left and right regions in the figure respectively. aij represents the area of object i in region j. dij represents the distance between the central lines of the object and the frame. nj is the total number of objects on the side.

Measure of Symmetry Symmetry, by definition, refers to the degree of symmetry on screen in three directions: vertical, horizontal and diagonal type as shown in the following (Ngo and Byrne 2001). Bauerly and Liu (2006) proposed that users preferred symmetric over non-symmetric interfaces.

300 Duan and Wang

As shown in the following formula SYMvertical + SYMhorizontal +

SYMradial

3 ∈[0, 1]

′ UR−Y

′ LR

′ UL−Y

′ LL

′ UR−X

′ LR

′ UL−X

′ LL

Y

Y

X

X

′ UR−B

′ LR

′ UL−B

′ LL

′ UR−H

′ LR

′ UL−H

′ LL

H

H

′ UR−R

′ LR

′ UL−R

′ LL

′ UR−θ

′ LR

′ UL−θ

′ LL

R

R

θ

θ

′ UR−X

′ LL

′ UL−X

′ LR

′ UR−Y

′ LR

′ UL−Y

′ LL

Y

Y

X

X + ′ UL−H ′ LL

′ UR−H

′ LR

′ UL−B

′ LL

′ UR−B

′ LR

H

H

′ UL−θ

′ LL

′ UR−θ

′ LR

′ UL−R

′ LL

′ UR−R

′ LR

θ

θ

R

R

′ UL−X

′ UR

′ LL−X

′ LR

′ UL−Y

′ UR

′ LL−Y

′ LR

X

X

Y

Y

′ UL−H

′ UR

′ LL−H

′ LR

′ UL−B

′ LR

′ LL−B

′ LR

H

H

′ UL−θ

′ UR

′ LL−θ

′ LR

′ UL−R

′ UR

′ LL−R

′ LR

θ

θ

R

R

X

′ i θ

′ i Y

′ i H

′ i B

′ i R

′ i are, respectively, the normalized values of nj X nj X

xij−xc

yij−yc

i

i nj X nj X nj X q

2 +

2

xij−xc

yij−yc

UL, UR, each represent upper left, upper right, LL, LR each represent lower left, lower right. bij is the width of the object and hij is the height of the object, xij yij and xc yc represent the co-ordinates of the centers of object i on quadrant j and the frame. nj is the total number of objects on the quadrant. aij is the area of the element.

Measure of Economy Economy refers to the use of small-size interface elements to convey more information as much as possible. The calculation formula of economy is as follows

Interface Evaluation Method of Medical Equipment Based on Aesthetics Measures 301

∈[0, 1] nsize

where nsize is the number of sizes.

Measure of Rhythm The calculation method of rhythm is shown in the following formula

′ UL−A

′ UL−A

′ UR

′ UR

′ UL−Y

′ UL−Y

′ UR

′ UR

′ UL−X

′ UL−X

′ UR

′ UR

Y

Y

X

X

′ UL−A

′ UR−A

′ LL

′ LR

′ UL−Y

′ UR−Y

′ LL

′ LR

′ UL−X

′ UR−X

′ LL

′ LR

Y

Y

X

X

′ UR−A

′ LR−A

′ LL

′ LL

′ UR−Y

′ LR−Y

′ LL

′ LL

′ UR−X

′ LR−X

′ LL

′ LL

Y

Y

X

X

18 ∈[0, 1]

nj X

nj X

xij−xc

yij−yc

i

i

UL, UR, each represent upper left, upper right. LL, LR represent lower left, lower right. xij yij and xc yc represent the co-ordinates of the centers of object i on quadrant j and the frame. nj is the total number of elements on the quadrant. aij is the area of the elements.

Measure of Regulation The degree of regulation is usually judged by calculating the number of align- ment points of the interface elements in the horizontal and vertical directions (Ngo et al., 2002).

2n otherwise

2 ∈[0, 1]

nvap, nhap, nspacing respectively represent the number of alignment points in the horizontal and vertical directions, and the number of starting points with different distances between rows and columns. n represents the number of elements in the entire interface layout.

CONSTRUCTION OF EVALUATION METHOD BASED ON ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS (AHP) There are many methods for assigning weight values to measures. The analytic hierarchy process was used in the research.

Build a Hierarchical Structure Model The judgment matrix of target layer and measure layer is constructed according to the expert scoring.

302 Duan and Wang

Table 1. Measures layer judgment matrix and W the weight value of each measure.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Measures Balance Symmetry Economy Rhythm Regulation W Balance 1 1 3 5 4 0.2996 Symmetry 3 1 5 6 7 0.4980 Economy 1/4 1/4 1 2 1 0.0851 Rhythm 1/8 1/8 1/2 1 1/2 0.0425 Regulation 1/4 1/7 1 2 1 0.0749

First perform normalization by column and then use arithmetic average method to find W that is the weight value of each measure W according to Sipahi and Timor (2010). Make consistency judgments. The consistency ratio is

C.R. less than 0.1 is acceptable. The calculation method of the comprehensive aesthetic value of the interface is

si are the five aesthetic measures discussed above.

EMPIRICAL STUDY Selecting Samples

For experimentation, we chose five different design schemes for the home- page of the operation interface, and processed the interface elements into rectangles. And get the position and area data of the rectangle through adobe xd. Frame width and frame height of samples are 656 and 392.

The weight value of each indicator has been calculated Wb = 0.2996 Ws = 0.4980 We = 0.0851 Wr = 0.05 Wre = 0.0749

By comparison, we can see that the comprehensive C value (the compreh- ensive aesthetic value of each interface) in interface 2 is the highest.

Validation of the Results The “design look” of Web sites Has clearly prominent effects on Web-site usability (Fogg, B et al. 2003). A questionnaire survey was conducted with 30 students and asked them to rank the four interface design samples above and vote in descending order from the beautiful to the ugly. The results show that

Interface Evaluation Method of Medical Equipment Based on Aesthetics Measures 303

Table 2. Elements data.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Interface element data

Interface1 R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 R6 R7 xi 0 137 245 403 504 137 445 yi 3 17 39 20 6 116 282 wi 119 83 115 56 141 283 54 hi 364 133 86 117 243 168 54 Interface2 R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 R6 R7 xi 0 126 180 161 268 472 yi 0 37 51 256 256 256 wi 111 12 460 78 163 168 hi 392 331 162 112 112 112 Interface3 R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 R6 xi 65 343 595 65 346 0 yi 44 44 7 194 194 291 wi 244 222 248 163 125 656 hi 113 113 11 42 42 101 Interface4 R1 R2 R3 R4 xi 18 297 297 540 yi 47 53 127 7 wi 244 185 221 106 hi 109 41 41 301

C2>C3>C1>C4

The voting result is consistent with the MATLAB calculation results, which shows that the method can effectively calculate the overall aesthetics of the interface design.

CONCLUSION

The research combines the analytic hierarchy process and the aesthetic mea- surement method to construct the interface aesthetic evaluation method of medical equipment through MATLAB programming. An experiment was conducted to verify that people’s evaluation is consistent with the score given by the method. This evaluation method can provide a quick and efficient interface evaluation feedback for the interface designer of medical equipment, and help the designer to improve the deficiencies of the interface.

REFERENCES

Bauerly, Michael & Liu, Yili, 2006. Computational modeling and experimental investigation of effects of compositional elements on interface and design aesthetics. International journal of human-computer studies, 64(8), pp. 670–682. Ben-Bassat, Tamar, Meyer, Joachim & Tractinsky, Noam, 2006. Economic and subje-

ctive measures of the perceived value of aesthetics and usability. ACM transactions on computer-human interaction, 13(2), pp. 210–234. Fogg, B et al., 2003. How do users evaluate the credibility of Web sites? Proceedings of the 2003 conference on designing for user experiences, pp. 1–15.

304 Duan and Wang

Hentati, Marwa et al., 2018. MoTUO: An Approach for Optimizing Usability Within Model Transformations. Arabian journal for science and engineering (2011), 44(4), pp. 3253–3269. Moshagen, Morten & Thielsch, Meinald T, 2010. Facets of visual aesthetics.

International journal of human-computer studies, 68(10), pp. 689–709. Ngo, D.C.L & Byrne, J.G, 2001. Application of an aesthetic evaluation model to data entry screens. Computers in human behavior, 17(2), pp. 149–185. Ngo, David Chek Ling, Teo, Lian Seng & Byrne, John G, 2002. Evaluating Interface

Esthetics. Knowledge and information systems, 4(1), pp. 46–79. Sipahi, Seyhan & Timor, Mehpare, 2010. The analytic hierarchy process and analytic network process: an overview of applications. Management decision, 48(5), pp. 775–808. Tullis, Thomas S, 1981. An Evaluation of Alphanumeric, Graphic, and Color

Information Displays. Human factors, 23(5), pp. 541–550.

Cover of the proceedings volume Human Factors and Systems Interaction

Explore the complete digital volume

Human Factors and Systems Interaction

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-28-5

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →