Gabriella Duca (2022). The Quality of Building Design Between Aesthetics and Usability: a Case Study on Underground Stations. In: Advances in Ergonomics In Design, Usability & Special Populations: Part III. AHFE Open Access, vol. 20. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1001331
This paper presents a research on railway station usability, where Usability Performances Areas (UPA) and Usability Performances Indicators (UPI) have been defined in order to understand the gap between intended design quality and actual quality as perceived by end-users of the building. According with the ISO 9241/11 standard, the definition of usability metrics has been based on the observation of users and tasks in the railway station, resulting in 13 clusters of users, with characterizing behaviours and needs, involved in 15 elementary tasks. UPAs express the general usability requirements common to all tasks, which have been successively elicited in a set of corresponding usability indicators, specifically addressing each task. The full list of UPIs has been applied for the assessment of an underground station of Naples (Italy), belonging to an underground stations network created with the joint work of world-class architects and artists. Usability critical points related to architectural plan, architectural detailing and outfitting which result from poor consideration of end-users in building design process are discussed, together with implications for the effective integration of ergonomic skills in the design process.
For a building, the quality of the design may assume many different meanings according the buildings’ lifecycle stage, the intended stakeholder, the urban and social context where the building is set (Attaianese and Duca, 2005). A way becoming more and more popular for local administrations to express care for citizens’ life quality and for revitalizing urban areas is promoting buildings with a high image value, delivered by the so-called archistar firms. This strategy is based on the assumption that playful, high-tech, evocative buildings bring values in terms of urban quality for citizens and visitors (Hall and Robertson, 2001). But, as end-users of a building often experience, an overall aesthetic quality does not assure effective, efficient and satisfactory accomplishment of their intended goals, so that perceived building quality dramatically decreases once people become actors rather than spectators (La Cecla, 2012; Baird and Penwell, 2012). Therefore, an usability question for building designers arises: how to control design process in order to assure that architectural project will be able to deliver expected quality also under the users’ perspective? Buildings usability is concerned with the effectiveness, efficiency and satisfaction of tasks performed by users in built environment (Jensø, Hansen and Haugen, 2004; Alexander, 2007). This means that building usability represents the suitability of a building for a specific use, that is the ability of the building to help users in achieving their goals in a fully satisfying way ((Maier, Fadel, and Battisto, 2009; Duca, 2012). Therefore, under the users’ point of view, architectural quality actually delivered depend on the extent of designers understanding and consideration of users’ characteristics and expectations (Attaianese and Duca, 2012).
DEFINING USABILITY METRICS FOR RAILWAYS STATIONS Users and task analysis
Under the ISO 9241/11 context of use framework, buildings are the environment whose usability must be assessed considering users, tasks and equipment. For the case of railway station, it has to be considered that passengers do not use tools (as ticketing machines, turnstile or gates usability do not properly pertain to the architectural design, and should be assessed as itself) but they use personal belongings to do actions not functional for the travel scope. Therefore, these items and related actions were considered as an attribute of users. Station users include people with a big variety of scopes, such railway personnel, accessorial services personnel, security and maintenance staff; the presented research focused on passengers and not travelling accompanying persons.
In a first research step, users were observed looking at reasons for their presence in the station, their physical and sensory-cognitive abilities relevant to built environment fruition, assuming that they have different spatial needs to be satisfied (NetworkRail, 2011; CABE, 2001). This analysis lead to 13 users clusters, as reported in Figure 1.
UC 1.1 Commuters UC 1.2 Business travellers UC 1.3 Leisure travellers UC 1.4 Family travellers UC 1.5 Big group travellers UC 1.5 Accompanying persons
UC 3.1 Vision impaired UC 3.2 Partlially vision impaired UC 3.3 Deaf UC 3.4 Anxiety / fair to fall / fait to make mistakes
Figure 1: The 13 clusters of users.
Figure available in the original PDF paper.
Users clusters were characterized looking at how they use the building, in terms of prevailing behaviours and personal activities not directly concerned with the travel. This allowed to elicit needs characterizing the examined cluster, as shown in Table 1. Since a railway station might be used by all or just some users clusters, the list of users’ needs to be matched by designers may vary accordingly.
Table 1: Example of needs elicitation for each users cluster.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
C1 Reasons for using the
Style/type of use of the station Characterizing not functional activities Characterizing needs station High familiarity with the place
Working Optimization of journey times
UC 1.1 Commuters
Short using time
Napping Real time information on service
delays or malfunctioning
Reading (digital/paper)
Reduced use of main services (ticket counter, waiting lounge) and accessorial
Real time information on other
Watching/hearing from
services (coffee shops, ATM, etc)
connected transport services
personal devices
Use of the station in connection with other
Direct access to the platform
short distance transport services and/or
Making personal phone
Expeditiousness of pedestrian flows
and personal transportation means calls
Together with the users analysis, a hierarchical task analysis was drafted, breaking down the two macro-tasks (A) “Take the train”, describing the task flow from the entrance to the boarding, and (B) “Leave the station”, describing the task flow from getting off the train and starting the next part of the travel to the final destination. A total of 6 tasks and 15 sub-tasks were identified.
A3.1 Reaching and using ticket counters A3.2 Reaching and using toilettes
A3.3 Reaching and using waiting lounge
A3 Using
A3.4 Reaching and using customer service
main services
A3.5 Waiting out of platform area/gates
START
A2.1 Monitoring journey updates/information A2.2 Getting to the
platform
END
A2 Catching
A1 Detecting entrance and
the train
stepping in
A2.3 Waiting at the platform A2.4 Boarding
A4.1 Reaching and using restaurant/coffee shops A4.2 Reaching and using
A4 Using accessorial
shops
services
A4.3 Reaching and using facilities (ATM, pharmacy, newspaper kiosk)
Figure 2: Task analysis of the macro-task (A)“Take the train”.
Figure available in the original PDF paper.
Metrics for usability assessment Starting from the whole of users’ needs identified in the previous stage of the study, a set of 7 Usability Performance Areas (UPA) was defined, with the aim to set the framework of overall building characteristics to be assured for any users’ cluster, during any task it might execute in the station (Page, 1960; Afacan and Erbug, 2009; Vischer, 2008; Hedge, 1999; Bluyssen, 2010; ISO, 2011; Haruna, et al., 2011; Kaya, 2004; Stanton et al., 2013). After that, for each of identified sub-tasks, Usability Performances Indicators (UPI) were elicited as further detailing of UPAs (Ahasan et al., 2001; Abdul-Samad and Macmillan, 2004; Sailer et al., 2008; Imrie, 2012; Lehman, 2011; Boomsma and Steg, 2012; Sonmez Turel, Malkoc Yigit and Altug, 2007; Bitgood and Dukes, 2005; Benfield et al., 2014; d’Astous, 2000; Clive et al., 2002; Doku and Erkip, 2000; Howarth, 2006). In both UPAs and UPIs there is no Ergonomics In Design, Usability & Special Populations III explicit reference to accessibility, since users’ needs were formulated under the inclusive design approach, and accessibility was considered as an implicit and transversal requirement. UPIs refer to both technical (materials, technical solutions, etc) and spatial (layout, shapes, lighting, etc.) characteristics of the building.
UPA 4 Travel information
UPA 1 Orientation and way- finding
Travel information (times and platform) available in any station area Adequate environmental contrast between background and information (visual and acoustic) UPA 5 Security Adequate illumination of paths Lack of hidden or isolated pieces in paths
UPA 6 Safety
Platform area detectable from any point of the station Each platform detectable from any point of the platform area Tactile and visual connotation of paths from entrance to each platform Landmark at any point of change of direction Distance to be covered and possible obstacles detectable for each path Lifts and alternative paths detectable from any point of the station UPA 2 Environmental comfort Glazing avoidance Glaring/mirroring surfaces avoidance Low environmental noise Contrast brightness-shadow avoidance Rain protection
Changes of level avoidance Co-planarity and integrity of walking surfaces Availability of resting points not hampering pedestrian flows Availability of guides, handrails and supports Lack of vertical obstacles on trajectories Adequate illumination of paths UPA 7 Aesthetic and cleaning
UPA 3 Capacity Separation of crossing pedestrian flows Pedestrian flows of different speed allowance Adequate capacity of escalators and travolators Adequate capacity of gates /turnstiles
Order and appearance Maintenance management Use of “design” materials, technical solution and architectural details Coherent image for outfitting Dirt resistance / easy cleaning
Figure 3: Usability Performance Indicators for the sub-task A2.2 - Getting to the platform.
Figure available in the original PDF paper.
ASSESSMENT OF AN UNDERGROUND STATION WITH THE UPA & UPI METHOD The Dante station and its users
The station chosen for the experiment is the Dante underground station of Naples (Italy). It was designed, together with the homonymous square restyling, in 1999 by the famous Italian “archistar” Gae Aulenti. The station is part of the “Stazioni dell’Arte” (Stations of Art) project, involving 9 stations of the Naples underground network. These stations host more than 200 works by 100 of the world major contemporary artists and were designed by some of most famous contemporary architects, with the aim to increase attractiveness of public transport bringing contemporary art to passengers and renovating important areas in the city (Cascetta, 2005). Therefore, the Dante station was designed with the explicit aim to deliver high architectural quality to passengers and general public, and represents the ideal case study for understanding if a good architectural project under the architects’ perspective matches implicit and explicit quality expectations by actual users.
The station serves a very rich urban area, with schools, university, a hospital, a theatre and many nightlife venues, offices and residences. Moreover, being the access station to the historical centre, the station is used by tourists; it is also located at the end of a bike lane, and then represents a small multimodal hub. For the above reasons, the Dante station includes all the users clusters previously defined, involved in short-medium distance travels for the whole day timeframe.
Conduct of the usability assessment The usability assessment was conducted examining inside and outside features of the station for each single sub-task with its usability indicators. Therefore a sort of multilayered assessment made of 16 separated inspections (one for the 15 sub-tasks + the “A1 Detecting entrance and stepping in” task), was carried out, obtaining a list of technical solutions and other conditions that were found inadequate for the considered UPIs. Table 2 reports an example of usability investigation results for the “A1 Detecting entrance and stepping in” task.
Table 2: Usability assessment for the “A1 Detecting entrance and stepping in” task.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
UPA Usability conerns
Elevator is not detectable by people, unless
Orientation and
they enter the square deviating from the way-finding main approaching directions
The station is in an empty wide square with black stone flooring, which creates a heat Environmental isle during the hottest summer hours, with
comfort consequent heat stress for users reaching the
entrances
The main staircase crosses the way-out elevator. In rush hours walking out people blocks entering people
Width of walkway part between “M” signage Capacity and elevator does not allow a wheelchair passage with a walking person
aside/crossing Lack of bike stalls
Travel information Lack of travel information on interchanging lines
UPA Usability conerns
The pedestrian square is used as playground by children: station users can be hit by balls/bikes/skates etc.
Security One of the path to the entrances is under-
illuminated because of the streetlamp layout
Shops lights on Via Tarsia entrance create a too high luminance contrast with the stairs, so that black stone steps are not visible
during shops afternoon opening hours Entrance staircases are illuminated with
small radius spot, so that some steps remain in the dark
Step edges are damaged
Safety Slide on walkways are textured for tactile information, but they are not visually
contrasted because they are in black rough stone as the normal flooring.
Decorative use of texture for flooring material produces optical effects which make visible an inexistent floor guide.
People with partially impaired vision might be erroneously guided against a column
Glass walls surrounding stairs are soiled by writers and flyers Aesthetic and
cleaning Top boards covering stairs are damaged by
water seepages
Findings from usability assessment The assessment of the Dante underground station with the Usability Performances Areas and Usability Performances Indicators highlighted usability issues related to all the design scales, from general architectural layout to technological solutions and final outfitting. For what concerns the layout, it has been observed that the plan causes some problems for safety and expeditiousness of pedestrian flows, as well as in accessing external elevator. Technical solutions for walking surfaces and light systems affect either safety, because they produce conditions increasing slip and trip probability, either comfort, since there are inside and outside paths were users suffer too hot and/or too dark environmental conditions; moreover, wall and floor technical details cannot be easily cleaned. Main critical points concerning outfitting are linked to way-finding problems for all services in the ticket hall, the lack of information about the underground connected lines and travel directions, the lack of information for the right exit to choose according the outside final destination, and, finally, insufficient sitting places and acoustic discomfort at platforms. Some more usability problems come from poor maintenance management, which should be more effective against vandalism. As overall assessment result it can be said that major usability issues have been found for all UPAs, whilst all UPIs, when not highly critical, offer not optimal solutions under the users’ expectations perspective.
CONCLUSIONS
The paper has presented an usability case study on a building of high architectural quality. One of the main considerations resulting from this study is that building usability is a crosscutting issue, that can be fully achieved only if usability principles are applied since the earliest design stage, when the whole image and plan are set-up, and continue feeding the design process at all the scales, from technical solutions to architectural details and final outfitting.
It can also be said that the majority of usability problems come from architectural design choices rather than station management or use, since main usability problems originate from the concept of the station in its whole as well as from its technical details. This means that putting in practice usability improvements would require expensive interventions or even a total renovation; only in few cases, reasonable improvements are possible as, for instance, changing the type of light bulbs or advertisement and information boards.
Therefore, a better integration of ergonomics skills in the building design process is needed to avoid the gap between intended building quality and actual quality brought to users, due to the poor consideration of their characteristics and tasks by architects. This can be considered either a problem of design team composition, since rarely ergonomists join architectural design teams, (Dul et al., 2012), either a problem of architects’ education, since human factors competencies are generally disregarded in university courses (Olguntürk and Demirkan, 2009).
For what concerns the usability assessment method formulated in this study, it has to be considered that Usability Performance Areas and Indicators reflect the “key performance” approach, widely used in many technical fields. In this case, the UPIs approach requires that ergonomist in charge of the usability assessment is able to recognize and describe all the architectural aspects involved in a given usability condition, or, on the opposite, that architect in charge of the assessment is aware about any possible effect of built environment on users. Therefore, again, it is clear the need of a specific education topic addressing human – built environment interaction issues, for both designers and ergonomists (Barrett, Barrett and Davies, 2013).
REFERENCES
Abdul-Samad, Z., Macmillan, S. G. (2004), "Improving design quality and value in the built environment through knowledge of intangibles", in: 2004 IEEE International Engineering Management Conference (IEEE Cat. No.04CH37574), pp. 898-902. Afacan, Y., Erbug, C. (2009). “An interdisciplinary heuristic evaluation method for universal building design”, Applied
Ergonomics Volume 40 pp. 731–744. Ahasan, R., Campbell, D., Salmoni, A, Lewko, J. (2001). "Ergonomics of living environment for the people with special needs", Journal of Physiological Anthropology and Applied Human Science, Volume 20 No. 3 pp. 175-185. Alexander, K. (2007). “The application of usability concepts in the built environment”, Journal of Facilities Management Volume
4 No. 4 pp. 262-270. Attaianese, E., Duca, G. (2012) “Human factors and ergonomic principles in building design for life and work activities: an applied methodology”, Theoretical Issues in Ergonomics Science Volume 13 No. 2 pp. 187-202.
Attaianese, E., Duca, G., (2005), “Perceived quality in buildings: human factors in global quality approach”, in Kahkonen, Kalle (Ed.), CIB Combining forces. Advancing Facilities Management and Construction through Innovation, Helsinki, 2005. Baird, G., Penwell, J. (2012). “Designers’ intentions versus users’ perceptions: a comparison of two refurbished office
buildings”, Intelligent Buildings International Volume 4 No.1 pp. 15-33. Barrett, P., Barrett, L., Davies, F. (2013). "Achieving a step change in the optimal sensory design of buildings for users at all lifestages", Building and Environment Volume 67 pp. 97–104. Benfield, J. A., Nurse, G.A., Jakubowski, R., Gibson, A.W., Taff, B.D., Newman, P., Bell, P.A. (2014). “Testing Noise in the
Field: A Brief Measure of Individual Noise Sensitivity”, Environment and Behavior Volume 46 No. 3 pp. 353-372. Bitgood, S., Dukes S. (2005). “Not Another Step! Economy of Movement and Pedestrian Choice Point Behavior in Shopping Malls”, Environment and Behavior, Volume 20 No. 10 pp. 1-12. Bluyssen, P.M. (2010). “Towards new methods and ways to create healthy and comfortable buildings”, Building and
Environment Volume 45 pp. 808–818. Boomsma, C., Steg, L. (2012). "Feeling Safe in the Dark. examining the efefct of entrapment, lighting levels, and gender on feelings of safety and lighting policy acceptability", Enviornment and Behavior Volume 46 No. 2 pp. 193–212. CABE (2002), “The value of good design”, Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment, London
http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20110118095356/http://www.cabe.org.uk/files/the-value-of-good-design.pdf Cascetta, E. (2005), “La sfida dei trasporti in Campania: un sistema integrato per una mobilità sostenibile” (The challenge of public transport in Campania: an integrated system for sustainable mobility), Electa, Naples. d’Astous, A. (2000). “Irritating Aspects of the Shopping Environment”, Journal of Business Research Volume 49 pp. 149–156. Dogu, U., Erkip, F. (2000). “Spatial Factors Affecting Wayfinding and Orientation: A Case Study in a Shopping Mall”,
Environment and Behavior Volume 32 No. 6 pp.731-755. Duca, G. (2012). “Usability requirements for buildings: a case study on primary schools”, Work Volume 41 Supplement 1 pp.
1441-1448. Dul, J., Bruder, R., Buckle, P., Carayon, P., Falzon, P., Marras, W. S., Wilson, R., van der Doelen, B. (2012). "A strategy for human factors/ergonomics: developing the discipline and profession. Ergonomics" Volume 55 No. 4 pp. 377–95. Grönqvist, R., Abeysekera, J., Gard, G., Hsiang, S.M., Leamon, T.B., Newman, D.J., Gielo-Perczak, K., Lockhart ,T.E., Pai, C.Y.
(2001), “Human-centred approaches in slipperiness measurement”, Ergonomics Volume 44 No. 13 pp. 1167-99. Hall, T., Robertson, I., (2001). “Public Art and Urban Regeneration: advocacy, claims and critical debate”, Landscape Research Volume 26 pp. 5-26. Haruna, S.N., Hamida, M.Y., Talibb, A., Rahimc, Z.A. (2011). “Usability Evaluation: Criteria for Quality Architecture In- Use”,
Procedia – Engineering Volume 20 pp. 135-146. Hedge, A., (1999), “Environmental Ergonomics”, in: Encyclopedia of Ergonomics, Karwowski, Waldemar (Ed.), Taylor & Francis, pp. 959-999. Howarth, P. (2006), “Role of vision in falls”, in: Understanding and preventing falls, Haslam, Roger, Stubbs, David (Eds.).,
CRC Press Boca Raton, pp 96-88. Imrie, R. (2012). “Universalism, universal design and equitable access to the built environment”, Disability & Rehabilitation Volume 34 No. 10 pp. 873–882. ISO (2008), ISO 9241 “Ergonomic requirements for office work with visual display terminals (VDTs) -- Part 11: Guidance on
usability”. ISO (2011), ISO 21542 “Building construction - Accessibility and usability of the built environment”. Jensø, M., Hansen, G., Haugen, T. (2004), “Usability of buildings. Theoretical framework for understanding and exploring usability of buildings”, in: CIB W70 Hong Kong International Symposium, Facilities Management & Asset Maintenance, ‘The Human Element in Facility Management’, December 2004. Kaya, S. (2004). "Relating building attributes to end user’s needs: “the owners-designers-end users” equation", Facilities,
Volume 22 No. 9/10 pp. 247–252. La Cecla, F. (2012), “Against Architecture”, PM Press, Oakland. Lehman, M. L. (2011). "How sensory design brings value to buildings and their occupants", Intelligent Buildings International Volume 3 No. 1 pp. 46–54. Maier, J. R. a., Fadel, G. M., Battisto, D. G. (2009). "An affordance-based approach to architectural theory, design, and
practice", Design Studies Volume 30 No. 4 pp. 393–414. NetworkRail (2011), Guide to Station Planning and Design, http://www.networkrail.co.uk/aspx/6368.aspx. Olguntürk, N., Demirkan, H. (2009). “Ergonomics And Universal Design In Interior Architecture Education”, METU Journal of the Faculty of Architecture Volume 26 No.2 pp. 123-138. Page, J. K. (1960). “Some ergonomic problems confronting the building designer”, Ergonomics Volume 3 No. 2 pp. 133-140. Sailer, K., Budgen, A., Lonsdale, N., Turner, A. Penn, A. (2008), "Evidence-Based Design: Theoretical and Practical Reflections
of an Emerging Approach in Office Architecture", in: Undisciplined! Design Research Society Conference 2008, Sheffield Hallam University, Sheffield, UK, 16-19 July 2008. Smith-Jackson, T.L., Hall, T.E. (2002). “Information Order and Sign Design: A Schema-Based Approach”, Environment and Behavior Volume 34 No. 4 pp. 479-492. Sonmez Turel, H., Malkoc Yigit, E., Altug, I. (2007). "Evaluation of elderly people’s requirements in public open spaces: A case
study in Bornova District (Izmir, Turkey)", Building and Environment Volume 42 No. 5 pp. 2035–2045.
Stanton, N., McIlroy, R. C., Harvey, C., Blainey, S., Hickford, A., Preston, J. M., Ryan, B. (2013). "Following the cognitive work analysis train of thought: exploring the constraints of modal shift to rail transport", Ergonomics Volume 56 No. 3 pp. 522– 540 Vischer, J.C. (2008). “Towards a user-centred theory of the built environment”, Building Research & Information Volume 36
No. 3 pp. 231-240.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Advances in Ergonomics In Design, Usability & Special Populations: Part III
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-4951-2108-1
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional