Huang Fei-Hui, Wen-chou Huang (2023). Analyzing user experience of e-scooter usage: A human-computer interaction perspective on personal vs shared e-scooters. In: Human-Centered Design and User Experience. AHFE Open Access, vol. 114, pp. 563–569. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1004276
In response to urgent environmental sustainability and carbon reduction issues, the global transportation sector is actively promoting the use of electric vehicles to replace high-carbon emitting fuel vehicles. In the Taiwan two-wheeler market, for example, electric-scooter (e-scooter) products are increasingly meeting the needs of consumers due to their continuous lightweight and aesthetically designed improvements, as well as the provision of convenient battery swapping services. By the end of 2022, 2% of consumers in the overall scooter market had opted for e-scooters instead of fuel scooters, indicating that their needs were being satisfied. To further meet the consumer demand for e-scooters, Taiwan launched shared e-scooter services in 2018, enabling consumers to ride e-scooters by paying reasonable vehicle usage fees in a "rent-to-own" model to meet their transportation needs. As of the end of 2022, more than 8,000 e-scooters were made available for the public to share, satisfying the needs of consumers requiring short-distance transportation using e-scooters. From another perspective, the usage rate of private e-scooters is not high in Taiwan, with an average usage time of 54 minutes per private e-scooter. Since shared e-scooters are available for all users to consume, they can effectively reduce the idle rate of e-scooters and increase their usage rate, further meeting consumer needs. The primary goal of launching these products and services is to focus on sustainable transportation, as the simultaneous provision of these two service models can meet the needs of consumers with different transportation and usage habits, ultimately aiming to replace fuel vehicles.This research aims to gather subjective feedback from consumers through a rating scale to understand the extent to which e-scooters and shared e-scooters are meeting consumer needs, as well as the issues encountered during their usage, while prioritizing user experience and satisfaction by exploring the perceived feelings of users in their interaction with e-scooter products or shared e-scooter services. Participants with prior experience of using e-scooters or shared e-scooters will be recruited to complete the questionnaire. The final results of this study aim to provide recommendations for enhancing the services based on consumer feedback and gain insights into the demand for e-scooters and shared e-scooters, including analyzing the differences in demand for these products and proposing suggestions to better meet consumer needs. By addressing the challenges faced by consumers in using e-scooters and shared e-scooters, the results of this research will contribute to the development of more user-friendly and efficient transportation solutions, ultimately promoting the adoption of sustainable transportation options in Taiwan and globally, and supporting the reduction of carbon emissions while improving the quality of life for the public.
In its 2007 assessment report, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) emphasized that human activities, particularly the com- bustion of fossil fuels, are the primary drivers behind the escalating levels of atmospheric greenhouse gases (Royer et al., 2007; Nakicenovic et al., 2000). Among these activities, the transportation sector stands out as respon- sible for nearly half of the world’s fossil fuel consumption and approx- imately one-quarter of total CO2 emissions linked to fossil fuels (IEA, 2010). The resulting environmental and health consequences from road transportation have prompted the formulation of various international pol- icy frameworks. Notably, the global shift towards cleaner air and low-carbon economies aligns with the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), which offer a unified blueprint for harmonizing people, the planet, and profit (UN, 2017).
In response to these environmental challenges, electric vehicles (EVs) have emerged as a promising solution due to their significantly cleaner emis- sions profile compared to traditional internal combustion engine vehicles (MIT Energy Initiative, 2019). Consequently, there has been a notable transition from conventional internal combustion engines to EVs as a key component of low-emission mobility strategies (Husain, 2010). In the two- wheeler sector, this transition to environmentally friendly solutions has also extended to electric scooters. These electric scooters have gained signifi- cant popularity, especially through e-scooter sharing services, which have rapidly transformed urban transportation. These services provide short to medium-distance travelers with an alternative mode of transportation that is convenient, cost-effective, and promotes environmental sustainability.
With the introduction of shared economy models, the approach to two- wheeler transportation has shifted from traditional ownership to a pay-per- use model. Instead of solely owning an e-scooter, users now have the option to choose between purchasing or renting one through shared e-scooter services. However, the overall user experience of e-scooter usage can still vary based on various factors, including whether they own the scooter or are using a shared service. As electric two-wheeler products are still in the process of market penetration, this research aims to focus on user-centric concepts and con- duct a subjective assessment through a questionnaire study, evaluating user experience through four main dimensions: aesthetic quality, hedonic quality, pragmatic quality, and overall satisfaction. By exploring these dimensions, the study aims to understand the differences in subjective user experiences when riding a privately-owned e-scooter compared to using a shared e- scooter. The goal is to identify the strengths and weaknesses of e-scooter products and provide recommendations for enhancing the user experience.
ELECTRIC SCOOTER SERVICE AND USER EXPERIENCE The sharing economy (SE) is a revolutionary concept that revolves around the efficient utilization of underutilized assets to promote sustainability and optimize resources. It encompasses various activities such as bartering, lend- ing, renting, trading, swapping, and transportation (Heo, 2016). SE can be broadly classified into three main components: the access economy, platform economy, and community-based economy (Acquier et al., 2017). Each of these components plays a crucial role in facilitating the seamless sharing of resources, fostering a sense of community, and promoting collaboration.
Among the components of the sharing economy, the shared motorcycle service primarily falls under the Access Economy category. The access econ- omy focuses on providing individuals with access to products and services without requiring ownership. This model enables temporary use or access to goods, allowing people to enjoy the benefits without committing to the long-term costs associated with ownership. For instance, popular rideshar- ing services like Uber and home-sharing platforms like Airbnb exemplify the access economy by offering convenient transportation and accommo- dation options without necessitating personal ownership of a vehicle or property.
Analysing User Experience of E-Scooter Usage 565
The sharing economy offers numerous advantages, making it an appeal- ing and transformative concept. Some of its key benefits include resource optimization, sustainable resource utilization, cost-effectiveness, flexibility, convenience, and social engagement. The sharing economy represents a fun- damental shift in how resources are accessed, used, and valued in society. By leveraging underutilized assets and encouraging collaborative consumption, it contributes to a more sustainable and efficient society.
In recent years, there has been a growing interest in user experience (UX) research within the context of shared mobility services. UX evolves from an unconscious state to a cognitive one and eventually becomes “an experience” – something memorable that can be shared and discussed in social interactions (Forlizzi and colleagues, 2004). Users’ experiences develop over time, and as they become more familiar with a product, it is expected that they will encounter fewer frustrating but also fewer excit- ing moments. Consequently, the perceived quality of a product is likely to change. Perceived quality can be categorized into pragmatic and hedo- nic aspects (Hassenzahl, 2004). Pragmatic quality refers to the product’s ability to support the achievement of behavioral goals, such as useful- ness and ease-of-use. On the other hand, hedonic quality is related to stimulation, reflecting the product’s ability to foster personal growth and identification, indicating its capacity to address the need for self-expression through owned objects. Research has shown that pragmatic quality is a better predictor of user satisfaction, whereas perceptions of a product’s aes- thetics are better predictors of pleasant experiences (Tractinsky and Zmiri, 2006). Even if a product’s design meets specifications and is technologically advanced, studies indicate that if it fails to fulfill users’ true needs (28%) or is solely driven by users’ remorse (20%) (Den Ouden et al., 2006), there is a possibility of product returns. This underscores the importance of consumer-oriented product design in the consumer market, where both technical specifications and users’ actual product usage needs must be met. Therefore, this study focuses on exploring user experiences, emphasizing products’ aesthetics, pragmatic quality, hedonic quality, and overall user satisfaction after product use.
METHODS
To assess the user experience (UX) of e-scooter usage, a mixed-method approach comprising quantitative surveys and qualitative interviews was employed. For this study, e-scooter riders were selected using convenience sampling, targeting individuals who either owned a personal e-scooter or had utilized shared e-scooters. Participants were asked to rate their experiences on a 10-point Likert scale, providing subjective evaluations for four dimensions: aesthetic quality, hedonic quality, pragmatic quality, and overall satisfaction. Moreover, in-depth interviews were conducted with owners of personal e- scooters to gain deeper insights into the underlying factors influencing their decision to purchase an e-scooter, as well as the perceived disadvantages of owning private e-scooters.
566 Huang and Huang
RESULTS
In this study, a total of 506 valid questionnaires (293 male; 213 female) were collected from users of personal e-scooters, and 275 valid questionnaires (131 male; 144 female) were collected from users of shared e-scooters. The results of the reliability analysis indicate high reliability for both the UX of private e-scooters (α = 0.830) and the UX of shared e-scooters (α = 0.814), with Cronbach’s alpha coefficients exceeding 0.8. The average values and stan- dard deviations of the UX for both private e-scooters and shared e-scooters are presented in Table 1. All values fall within the “very satisfied” range, indicating that both riding private e-scooters and shared e-scooters lead to highly satisfactory user experiences. Furthermore, the results of the one-way ANOVA indicate that there is no significant difference in the UX between private e-scooters and shared e-scooters for aesthetic quality (F = 0.098, p = 0.754), hedonic quality (F = 0.179, p = 0.672), pragmatic quality (F = 0.275, p = 0.600), and overall satisfaction (F = 0.401, p = 0.527).
Table 1. Means and standard deviations (SDs) of private e-scooters and shared e-scooters.
Among the 506 respondents, a significant 51.6% of them indicated that the availability of convenient charging services was the primary factor influ- encing their decision to purchase e-scooters. Following closely behind were various subsidy programs (41.3%) that helped reduce the overall cost of acquiring the vehicle, along with effective marketing strategies (33.4%). They believed that brand-driven promotional activities increased their awareness of e-scooter products, and government initiatives promoting net-zero car- bon policies and their connection to e-scooters made them realize how their transportation choices impact global environmental quality, all contributing to their decision to choose e-scooters (see Table 2 for detailed information).
Table 2. Reasons for choosing e-scooters.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Items Frequency Percentage Convenience of Charging 261 51.6% Subsidies 209 41.3% Product Promotion 107 21.1% Government Promotion 62 12.3%
Analysing User Experience of E-Scooter Usage 567
The 506 respondents also shared their perceived disadvantages of purchas- ing e-scooters. Among them, 17.4% considered the high purchase price of e-scooters as the primary drawback. Additionally, 11.1% pointed out the relatively lower top speed of the vehicles, 6.5% expressed concerns about the vehicle’s load-carrying capacity and climbing performance, while 5.9% mentioned the range anxiety associated with electric vehicles (see Table 3 for detailed information).
Table 3. Disadvantages of private e-scooters.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Items Frequency Percentage Price 88 17.4% speed 56 11.1% Performance 33 6.5% Range Anxiety 30 5.9%
DISCUSSION
This study employed a subjective measurement approach to assess the user experience (UX) of individuals using private e-scooters and shared e-scooters in Taiwan. There are notable distinctions in the usage of these two types of e-scooters, particularly regarding charging requirements, vehicle availabil- ity, and parking arrangements. Private e-scooter riders have the flexibility to charge their vehicles at home, workspaces, charging stations, or battery swap- ping stations based on their individual needs. On the other hand, for shared e-scooters, the responsibility for charging lies with the operating teams. Therefore, the primary concern for shared e-scooter users is whether they can find available e-scooters nearby when needed and locate legal parking spots for returning the scooters. In contrast, private e-scooters are typically parked in fixed locations known to their owners, eliminating the need to search for available vehicles when required. Surprisingly, the research find- ings indicate that there were no significant differences in the user experience between the two modes of transportation. Both private e-scooter and shared e-scooter riders reported a highly satisfactory experience.
Regarding private e-scooters, respondents shared their reasons for being willing to purchase e-scooters:
Convenience of Charging: As of the end of June 2023, Gogoro oper- ates 2,041 battery swapping stations known as Gostations, while Kymco Ionex 3.0 has a total of 1,068 stations. Together, there are 3,109 bat- tery swapping stations across Taiwan. Private e-scooter users benefit from the option to conveniently charge their vehicles at home or use battery swapping stations, making it a practical and hassle-free transportation choice compared to shared e-scooter users, who can only access the battery swapping service.
Subsidies: Governments and local authorities offer subsidies or finan- cial incentives to encourage the adoption of electric vehicles, including
568 Huang and Huang
e-scooters. These subsidies make e-scooters more affordable and attractive to potential buyers.
Product Promotion: The marketing and promotion of e-scooters can posi- tively influence consumers’ transportation choices. As manufacturers and distributors promote the benefits and features of e-scooters, consumers become more aware of their advantages and are more likely to consider them a viable alternative for personal transportation.
Government Promotion: With the global focus on achieving net-zero car- bon emissions, governments actively promote sustainable and eco-friendly transportation solutions, such as e-scooters. They often implement policies that support the use of electric vehicles to reduce pollution and ease traffic congestion, further driving the demand for e-scooters among travelers.
Respondents who owned private e-scooters also pointed out some draw- backs of owning personal e-scooters:
Price: The initial investment for private e-scooters, which involves a one- time payment for the vehicle, can be relatively expensive compared to the one-time usage fee for shared electric scooters. This cost difference becomes even more apparent, especially when consumers opt for models with advanced features or higher build quality.
Speed: Private e-scooters have a lower top speed compared to other per- sonal mobility options like scooters and cars. This might not be ideal for individuals who need faster transportation for longer distances.
Performance: E-scooters may have limitations in handling certain ter- rains, such as steep hills or rough roads. As a result, users with spe- cific route requirements may find that e-scooters cannot fully meet their transportation needs.
Range Anxiety: E-scooters have a limited range per charge, leading to range anxiety – the fear of running out of battery power during a journey. This limitation impacts both the acceptance of shared e-scooters and the decision to own a private e-scooter.
CONCLUSION
This study aims to investigate the user experience of e-scooter usage. The research findings indicate that respondents are highly satisfied with the current e-scooter products and shared services offered in the market. Addi- tionally, there are no significant differences in user experience between the two transportation modes. However, it is important to note that e-scooter vehicles currently constitute only 2% of the market share in Taiwan, as opposed to traditional motorcycles. To encourage broader adoption, effec- tive market promotion should be based on understanding the reasons why consumers choose e-scooters. Factors such as convenient charging services, subsidy programs, and effective marketing strategies are key considerations. Moreover, addressing concerns related to Price, Speed, Performance, and Range Anxiety, which may trouble consumers, can be tackled by promoting shared e-scooter services, exploring other alternative transportation options, and advancing e-scooter product technology.
Analysing User Experience of E-Scooter Usage 569
REFERENCES
Acquier, A., Daudigeos, T., & Pinkse, J. (2017). Promises and paradoxes of the sharing economy: An organizing framework. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 125, pp. 1–10. Den Ouden, E., Yuan, L., Sonnemans, P. J., & Brombacher, A. C. (2006). Quality and
reliability problems from a consumer’s perspective: An increasing problem over- looked by businesses?. Quality and Reliability Engineering International, 22(7), pp. 821–838. Forlizzi, J., & Battarbee, K. (2004, August). Understanding experience in interactive systems. In Proceedings of the 5th conference on Designing interactive systems: processes, practices, methods, and techniques. pp. 261–268. Hassenzahl, M. (2004). The interplay of beauty, goodness, and usability in interactive
products. Human–Computer Interaction, 19(4), pp. 319–349. Heo, Y. (2016). Sharing economy and prospects in tourism research. Annals of tourism Research, 58, pp. 166–170. Husain, I. (2010). Electric and Hybrid Vehicles: Design Fundamentals, second ed.
CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA. IEA. (2010). Sustainable Production of Second-Generation Biofuels. IEA Information Paper, Paris. Insights into Future Mobility (MIT Energy Initiative, 2019). https://energy.mit.edu/i
nsightsintofuturemobility Nakicenovic, N., Alcamo, J., Davis, G., Vries, B. D., Fenhann, J., Gaffin, S., ... & Zhou, D. (2000). Special report on emissions scenarios. Royer, D. L., Berner, R. A., & Park, J. (2007). Climate sensitivity constrained by CO2
concentrations over the past 420 million years. Nature, 446(7135), pp. 530–532. Tractinsky, N., & Zmiri, D. (2006). Exploring attributes of skins as potential antecedents of emotion in HCI. Aesthetic computing, 405, 422. UN. (2017). United nations environment annual report. https://www.unenvironment.
org/annualreport/2017/index.php?page1/41&lang1/4en. (Accessed 20 June 2022).
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Human-Centered Design and User Experience
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-90-2
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional