© 2023. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 85
INTRODUCTION
Due to demographic change, predicted shortage of professional caregivers is a challenge for societies as a whole (Spillman, Allen and Favreault, 2021). In Germany, family members provide care regularly and are even legally cal- led upon to assist in home care. The integration of informal caregiving into everyday life can lead to burdens that negatively affect health and psycholo- gical well-being. More and more older people prefer to remain living in their own homes, even if they urgently need support in coping with activities of everyday life. In many cases, informal caregivers, such as family members and friends choose to take responsibility to fulfill their loved one’s desire to age in place (Chattopadhyay, 2020). Coordinating various health care pro- viders, managing medications, and even performing medical tasks for which few are trained often becomes a daily routine for the informal actors (Price et al., 2020; Reinhard et al., 2019). In order to balance caregiving and other responsibilities, some leave the workforce, and hobbies or social relationsh- ips are often neglected, leading to feelings of isolation and loneliness (Lee et al., 2022; Price et al., 2020). Additionally, the life-changing experience of needing to care for a loved one is often accompanied by increased emotional distress caused by symptoms of the care recipient (Jansen et al., 2019; Queluz et al., 2020). Many family caregivers themselves are older and with insuf- ficient (sometimes missed) support from government agencies, they struggle from financial problems or helplessness in finding relevant information regar- ding support options (Chattopadhyay, 2020; Novais et al., 2017). Digital technology is key to enable aging in place and enhance care (Kim, Gollamudi and Steinhubl, 2017). However, to relieve the burden on family caregivers, a reliable network is needed that provides active support and social assistance.
Care communities can offer a solution to reduce family caregiver burden. According to Kricheldorff (2018) a good coexistence of the generations and the involvement of a wide variety of local actors are essential for a successful good life when designing structures close to home. Proven approaches for a cultural change in the social area and neighborhood are moderated, pro- fessionally controlled on-site participation processes. The mixture of forms of action that are consistently approachable, participation-oriented, close to the living environment and anchored in the neighborhood has proven successful too (Kricheldorff, 2018). Different actors in care communities can involve relatives, professional caregivers, volunteering neighbors, part-time or full-time laypersons and, depending on the situation, even other care reci- pients. These informal and professional actors form a dynamic network and need to cooperate in close coordination.
The existing care community model “QuartierPflege” developed by a non- profit organization (Gesellschaft für Gemeinsinn e.V.) in Leipzig, Germany envisions support in everyday assistance, housekeeping and basic care via a network of trusted neighbors. For this purpose, networks are to be developed, in which an average of three to six neighbors support one care recipient. To ensure a sense of familiarity, these networks are little clusters in neighborho- ods with approx. 1000 to 1500 residential units. Supporting neighbors can do as much work as their time allows, from voluntary work to full-time employ- ment. An appropriate payment can be funded by the German care insurance
Digital Support Requirements for the Care Community QuartierPflege 87
fund. Some tasks of everyday assistance, housekeeping and basic care require training by professionals, which is organized by QuartierPflege. Medical care activities continue to be carried out by professional caregivers. The local case management developed in QuartierPflege as a new coordinative role structure serves to coordinate all actors in the neighborhood centrally. For example, it manages the training sessions between neighbors and professio- nal caregivers so that tasks can be taken over successively without any issues. It also organizes network care activities for care recipients. In addition, family caregivers have a similar role as caring neighbors. However, a different level of responsibility and sensitivity is required when dealing with family care- givers. Rewarding them appropriately for the work, they do anyway and partially relieving them through the network of caring neighbors is one of the aims of QuartierPflege. If family caregivers and their care recipients wish so, they can also be assigned a focal network position.
QuartierPflege does not intend to cover up all needs of care recipients with every type of care degrees. Rather, it intends to provide active basic support and social assistance that can actually be implemented by neighbors. Digital support tailored to the specific networks needs could open up the opportu- nity for all actors in QuartierPflege to interact more quickly and easily, to record their daily work, to organize themselves, to gain further qualificati- ons, to commit themselves over a longer period of time, and to be relieved of workload. This gives rise to the immediate need for efficient coordination including digital support, which can enable active participation by all actors.
Currently, various Apps for family caregivers are available (Bidenko and Bohnet-Joschko, 2022; Grossman, Zak and Zelinski, 2018; Sala-González et al., 2021). The most common features of these Apps provide different kinds of information, (professional) services for caregivers or support in organiza- tional matters. These App features have a supportive character, but mainly relate to the care activities (Bidenko and Bohnet-Joschko, 2022). Recent findings indicates that available Apps poorly match the personal needs of family caregivers (Sala-González et al., 2021). For example, Bidenko and Bohnet-Joschko (2022) could not find any App addressing the family care- givers’ need for free time and leisure activities. Overall, Apps for family caregivers focus less on their health and quality of life by failing to offer sufficient specific features for this purposes (Bidenko and Bohnet-Joschko, 2022; Grossman, Zak and Zelinski, 2018). Beyond that, there is no App holistically supporting daily work in care communities consisting of infor- mal and professional actors. Therefore, the aim of this research paper is to fill this gap identifying specific App requirements for coordinating daily work in such care communities using a user-centric approach. The future obje- ctive is to develop an App or App extension as a practically effective and transferable innovation to improve the quality of life and health of family caregivers.
METHOD
In total, N = 16 participants were interviewed in Germany during November and December 2022. One person did not answer the demographic question- naire and was therefore excluded in the descriptive analysis. On average, the
eight women and seven men were 57 years old (SD = 14.5). At the time of the interviews, two-thirds were involved in home care (66%), married (67%), and held a graduate degree (60%). Half of the interviewees were employed (53%) and worked a mean of 31.25 hours per week (SD = 7.91).
Interviewees provided informed consent and agreed to audio recording of the interview. In order to extend the existing care community model of Quar- tierPflege by means of an App in a user-centered way, structured personal interviews were conducted with involved actors (family caregivers, neighbors, volunteers, professional caregivers). The interviews covered three thematic blocks. The first section asked about the burdens of family caregivers and possible reliefs (example: “How has your everyday life changed as a result of caring for your relative? What changes do you perceive as particularly stres- sful?”). The concept of QuartierPflege and the processes within this network were discussed in the second section (example: “Please imagine that there is a person in your neighborhood who is responsible for organizing the support provided by the network described: What would be particularly important for you in this regard?”). The last section included questions about the use of digital technology, which App functions participants consider important in QuartierPflege, as well as questions about privacy issues (example: “Please imagine to have an App on your smartphone, in which you could see how the network is organized or how the tasks are planned. What features would you like to see in such an App?”). After the interview, participants answered a short demographic questionnaire.
On average, the interviews lasted 1.5 hours, for which participants received a remuneration of 10€ per hour. The interviews were audio-recorded and then literally transcribed using f4x automatic speech recognition software. These automatic transcripts were reviewed for accuracy and completeness. The sof- tware MaxQDA 2022 for qualitative data analysis was used to process all transcripts and analyze them by structured qualitative content analysis accor- ding to Kuckartz (2018). Results presented in this research paper only contain quotes by family caregivers and professional caregivers. The findings are illu- strated with direct quotes with references to the coded segments in MaxQDA. A specific format was used, such as “B_01_PA, 126,” where “B_01” denotes participant 01 and “PA” denotes the role as a family caregiver. Professio- nal caregivers are represented with “PR”. The following number (“126”) indicates the paragraph number of the respective interview in MaxQDA.
RESULTS
The results presented in this paper focus on specific App requirements for coordinating daily work in care communities. Therefore, burdens of family caregivers are presented very briefly. Specific outcomes related to the care community QuartierPflege will be discussed in the conclusion.
Specific Burdens of Family Caregivers Most family caregivers reported that time spent on care is a major cause of multiple stressors. Due to the time commitment, some participants emph- asized that friendships were neglected and expressed feelings of loneliness.
Digital Support Requirements for the Care Community QuartierPflege 89
The time spent on household maintenance and work activities had to be reduced as well. Others felt that their life is basically centered around the care recipient, “So everyday life changes tremendously, because things that you used to like to do so much, they just fall away now. It really focu- ses now more or less on all these things that have to do with these people [care recipients].” (B_10_PA, 5). Psychological impact of caregiving resulted from the responsibility one has for the well-being of the other. Some parti- cipants also highlighted the emotional burden and loss caused by symptoms of their family member, “And so in the end there’s basically nothing left of my husband. Nothing... So he doesn’t get dressed by himself anymore, he doesn’t eat by himself anymore.” (B_01_PA, 9). Besides hiring costly profes- sional caregivers, participants emphasized the need for active local support as a possible way to reduce burden. In particular, household support or short- term accompaniment of the care recipient were frequently mentioned, “What would help relieve the pressure would be someone who goes shopping, who runs certain errands. […] So doing errands, just being there for the person, having a conversation, that kind of thing.” (B_01_PA, 87). Furthermore, par- ticipants wished for more information that is accessible on specific diseases and treatment concepts as well as local support opportunities in general.
Digital Support Requirements Participants named a variety of App requirements in order to support the coordination in care communities digitally that consequently reduces bur- dens of family caregivers. These requirements were divided into four major categories: (1) operational planning, (2) information, (3) communication and (4) human resources. In addition, participants addressed aspects of pri- vacy, usability and user experience as well as backend App requirements. Many of the interviewees’ statements were a conglomerate of interdepen- dent requirements, so that a one-to-one code assignment was rarely possible. The following sections illustrate the interdependencies of the required App functions.
Operational Planning Most App requirements related to operational planning issues. Primarily, the submission of care needs was emphasized here, followed by the documenta- tion of care activities, and a calendar function. To submit care needs it should be possible to specify which basic support in everyday assistance, houseke- eping and basic care is needed on which day, time, and in which frequency. In addition, participants mentioned, “There must be a daily calendar where people can see who is coming when, for what purpose, and there must be contact details so that people can get in touch with them.” (B_07_PR, 110). Participants frequently highlighted the importance of personal contact. It would be necessary to fulfill normal, human needs or special requests, such as, “One is not allowed to eat certain things. […] Does he go shopping in general, or how does the person who goes shopping for me get my bucket list? That
should be part of the App.” (B_01_PA, 126). Such important basic infor- mation could be stored in an information section about the care recipient. Contact details should be accessible in a personal staff profile.
Another essential part of the App should be an effective and efficient documentation of care activities by the network of neighbors. For many par- ticipants some kind of a handover book is crucial for caring activities to be comprehensible for the network, “Then it’s called “accompaniment to the ophthalmologist”. Now this can be a regular test, […] or the person is blind or has something significant. […] Then the neighbor can transmit the infor- mation or the diagnosis to the caring relative, something can be written in and the other person can read it. So, some things are critical.” (B_03_PA, 93). Family caregivers also highlighted their need for some kind of notificati- ons as reassurance that their loved ones are doing well and that the assigned caring neighbors are doing their job, “That I know this will be read on the other end in a certain time frame.” (B_03_PA, 113). For this purpose, it would also be conceivable to synchronize the profiles of family caregivers and care recipients. Documentation features should also support the administration of human resources, which could also enhance the quality of care activities and personal contact, “She has additional needs, maybe today is her husband’s day of death, maybe it would be nice to stay a little longer. So that this can also be documented. [...] and becomes a billable service. A working time recording within the App is not bad at all.” (B_08_PR, 143-145).
Depending on the role in the network, the calendar function should include relevant appointments, for example: the roster of caring neighbors or doctor appointments of the care recipient. Family caregivers emphasized that it is equally important for the network to know “[…] when the family caregiver intends to take a vacation for his or her own recreation, so that I can organize a replacement.” (B_02_PA, 120).
Information and Communication Participants imagined the App as an extensive information tool, adapted to the role each one has in the network (very complex for the local case manage- ment, but tailor made for neighbors, family caregivers, and care recipients). When referring to the information tool, participants often underlined a clear user interface, “That you can find your own area in a graphically simple way with the information: ‘What’s important for me right now?”’ (B_01_PA, 113). Important basic information of the care recipient could be stored in a personal information section, already mentioned above. According to one family caregiver, this basic information may seem to be less relevant but could make a huge difference. For example, whether the care recipient wishes to be addressed by first or last name, “Some people no longer hear their first name. [... but] it is also nice for some people if they can still hear their first name. These are all such subtleties.” (B_03_PA. 79).
Another major App requirement mentioned by participants was an App internal chat function to communicate within the network of caring neighbors or one to one. For the network being able to organize themse- lves and to be independent of the local case management to some extent, a
Digital Support Requirements for the Care Community QuartierPflege 91
general availability of the involved was essential for the participants, “In the best case, you know who is doing it, if there are any problems. So that you can communicate with them in an uncomplicated way, specifically via this App, without having any phone numbers and without knowing whether they are on WhatsApp or not.” (B_01_PA, 113). One participant noted a speech- to-text-function would be a nice communication feature to reduce efforts for documentation but also enhance usability for older people (B_08_PR, 157).
Human Resources Human resource management tools should be implemented in an App in order to digitally support the daily work in care communities. Some examples were already mentioned above (contact details, personal staff profile, hando- ver book, record working time within the App, rosters). As outlined, these requirements were often closely related to operational issues, information, and communication features. In addition, participants frequently highlighted their desire to be independent of the local case management to some extent. To fulfill this need, a handover book and personal staff profiles were two major features that should be implemented in the App. Especially, perso- nal staff profiles are expected to offer a great potential for guaranteeing the quality of caring activities. They could improve the fit between the caring neighbors and the care recipients, “Well, for my sake, that you say: ‘Well, I need someone who has a lot of patience’ or [...] ‘I don’t really understand everything’ [...] in other words, someone who is sensitive to such handicaps.” (B_03_PA, 79). Soft-skills like patience, empathy, sensitivity, or respectful communications skills should therefore be available in the personal staff profiles. However, participants emphasized, “At the latest, after the first or second visit, they know anyway if it fits.” (B_01_PA, 126).
Additional Aspects Digital support for daily work in care communities via an App requires spe- cial aspects of privacy, usability and user experience as well as backend App requirements, which were also mentioned by participants. Since sensitive data is sometimes used, participants explained which data should be stored digi- tally and which should rather remain private. Personal data such as name, age, gender, address, phone or e-mail-address could be stored for every per- son of the network. The (professional) experience or completed trainings of the caring neighbors should be provided. It would be all right to provide the most important physical limitations of the care recipients as well as their care degree. However, data like financial matters, mourning stories, or special medical diagnosis should not be digitally stored. Nevertheless, participants often considered that it depends on the role in the network, which data are available and which not, “Specific patient data are needed by the profes- sional care provider, but not by the neighborhood. It depends on the role.” (B_01_PA, 126). Therefore, it would be essential to implement different hori- zontal and vertical App permissions. Additionally, participants talked about requirements like encrypted data transmission, server location, an automatic logout, and consent forms of network members.
Participants’ reflections on usability and user experience showed, that the App should “be very coherent and quite simple and for old people” (B_03_PA, 99). However, the App should not be developed just for older peo- ple. Instead, “it has to be manageable for everyone.” (B_02_PA, 126). More- over, an easy and intuitive usage, logical structure, and clear arrangement of the App functions were mentioned fundamental. Likewise, participants wished a visually appealing design with good adjusted contrasts. To submit caring needs and document caring activities in an effective and efficient way, various types of assisting functions were proposed. One example was the speech-to-text-function noted by one participant (B_08_PR, 157). Another example mentioned by a participant was to integrate a route description for caring neighbors visiting the care recipients for the first time (B_03_PA, 99). This could also be connected to a navigation App.
During the interviews, all participants recognized that the system to be developed might be very complex. Coordinating the daily work in care com- munities by means of an App entails a high level of planning complexity, which needs to be covered by the system. Different horizontal and vertical App permissions depending on the role within the network were only one part of this concern. Contact details, profiles, calendar functions, handover books (as examples mentioned above), and other operational and admini- strative tools have to be linked to one another. To make the system work, participants noted the importance of participatory development, “[…] that’s why you always have to look at it from the point of view of those who mainly work with it.” (B_08_PR, 197).
CONCLUSION
The burdens of family caregivers were largely consistent with those found in a previous literature review. Relief potential could be found in the care commu- nity QuartierPflege, particularly in the areas of housekeeping and everyday assistance, as these tasks could be taken over by caring neighbors of various age groups. In addition, this could provide some free time to family caregi- vers because their own time spent on these care activities would be reduced. This would also be in the spirit of QuartierPflege. As a new model of care communities, QuartierPflege offers a holistic, but consequently also com- plex approach to improve the quality of life and health of family caregivers. Mutual trust in the caring neighborhood, personal responsibility of all netw- ork actors as well as the ability to organize themselves independently are key factors to success. Thus, the resulting software requirements for digital sup- port are complex. One example is the digital submission of care needs and matching them with the available network of caring neighbors: Imagine a caring neighbor has to cancel his or her appointment contrary to expecta- tions. The care recipients’ request is then returned to the network of caring neighbors. Another neighbor qualified for the activity can now accept the task. Thus, the requested care need remains guaranteed without any inte- rvention of the local case management. If no neighbor can take over the task, the local case management is notified and organizes a professional caregiver
Digital Support Requirements for the Care Community QuartierPflege 93
or the family caregiver. At the end of the day, the required care needs remain assured.
The approach of digitally coordinating an entire care community is alre- ady a unique selling point. Nevertheless, far more App requirements besides submitting care needs have been identified to successfully coordinate a care community of informal and professional actors. However, the small, incon- spicuous App functions would seemingly make the big difference compared to existing Apps (e.g., directions linked to the navigation App, profile synch- ronization of family caregivers and care recipients, personal profiles of caregiving neighbors and care recipients). To gain further insights in required App features and possible reliefs by the new care community QuartierP- flege, the interviews are currently still ongoing (expected end: March 2023). Especially, the group of care recipients is focused in upcoming interviews.
Because there is a wide range of support and relief potential overall, the target group of future App users could be wide. Therefore, the App should be usable and appealing to all possible users. Accordingly, the usability and user experience of the future App need to be evaluated with the diverse tar- get group. Furthermore, it should be evaluated whether the care community QuartierPflege offers a reliable network for caring activities and a sustainable improvement of the quality of life and health of family caregivers.
In addition, it is necessary to ensure data protection and privacy, because the App to be developed will work with highly sensitive personal data. Among other things, internal protection could be ensured by different hori- zontal and vertical App permissions. The complete list of requirements for a QuartierPflege-App can be received on request to the author.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors would like to acknowledge all the interviewees who shared their experiences and personal stories with us. The Federal Ministry of Education and Research funded the research project QuartierPflegeApp under grant no. 16SV8959.
REFERENCES
Bidenko, K. and Bohnet-Joschko, S. (2022) “Supporting family care: a scoping app review,” BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, 22(1). Available at: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12911-022-01906-6. Chattopadhyay, J. (2020) “Political Impediments to Aging in Place: The Example of
Informal Caregiving Policy,” Public Policy & Aging Report. Edited by M. Lepore, 30(2), pp. 56–61. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1093/ppar/praa002. Grossman, M. R., Zak, D. K. and Zelinski, E. M. (2018) “Mobile Apps for Caregivers of Older Adults: Quantitative Content Analysis,” JMIR mHealth and uHealth, 6(7), p. e162. Available at: https://doi.org/10.2196/mhealth.9345. Jansen, L. et al. (2019) “You never walk alone: An exploratory study of the needs
and burden of an informal care group,” Health & Social Care in the Community, 27(2), pp. 375–382. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1111/hsc.12655. Kim, K., Gollamudi, S. S. and Steinhubl, S. (2017) “Digital technology to enable aging in place,” Experimental Gerontology, 88, pp. 25–31. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.exger.2016.11.013.
Kricheldorff, C. (2018) “Aktuelle Herausforderungen für die Profession Soziale Arbeit in der Altenhilfe und im Sozialraum,” in Alter und Pflege im Sozial- raum: Theoretische Erwartungen und empirische Bewertungen. Springer VS, pp. 113–125. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-658-18013-3. Kuckartz, U. (2018) Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse. Methoden, Praxis, Computerunter-
stützung (Grundlagentexte Methoden). 4th edn. Beltz Juventa. Lee, J. et al. (2021) “Themes describing social isolation in family caregivers of people living with dementia: A scoping review,” Dementia, 21(2), pp. 701–721. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1177/14713012211056288. Novais, T. et al. (2017) “How to explore the needs of informal caregivers of indi-
viduals with cognitive impairment in Alzheimer’s disease or related diseases? A systematic review of quantitative and qualitative studies,” BMC Geriatrics, 17(1). Available at: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-017-0481-9. Price, M. L. et al. (2020) “Experiences and support needs of informal caregivers of people with multimorbidity: a scoping literature review,” Psychology & Health, 35(1), pp. 36–69. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/08870446.2019. 1626125. Queluz, F. N. F. R. et al. (2020) “Understanding the needs of caregivers of per-
sons with dementia: a scoping review,” International Psychogeriatrics, 32(1), pp. 35–52. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1017/S1041610219000243. Reinhard, S. C. et al. (2019) “Valuing the Invaluable: 2019 Update: Charting a Path Forward,” AARP Public Policy Institute [Preprint]. Available at: https://doi.org/ 10.26419/ppi.00082.001. Sala-González, M. et al. (2021) “Mobile Apps for Helping Informal Caregivers: A
Systematic Review,” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 18(4), p. 1702. Available at: https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18041702. Spillman, B. C., Allen, E. H., and Favreault, M. (2021) “Informal caregiver supply and demographic changes: Review of the literature,” Office of the Assistant Secre- tary for Planning and Evaluation Report. Available at: https://aspe.hhs.gov/repor ts/informal-caregiver-supply-demographic-changes-review-literature-0