INTRODUCTION
There is no need to justify the theorem: science is one, and we know its many disciplines and specialties; only a number of those detailed sciences yet to be created is unknown. Innovative agonology (IA) is such a detailed science, created with the participation of an increasing number of experts. In this paper we base on the definition of scie- nce by Tadeusz Kotarbi´nski (1886-1981), a prominent representative of
© 2023. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 307
308 Kalina and Bagi ´nska
the Lviv-Warsaw school of logic and methodology of sciences (the foun- der of modern praxeology): “science is everything that is worth to be the subject of intellectual teaching at universities, and only at univer- sities, as a separate specialty” (Kotarbi´nski, 1958). This definition was announced by Kotarbi´nski at the University of Łód´z (Poland, Octo- ber 19, 1957) during the presentation of an honorary doctorate degree to him.
Although innovative agonology is not taught at any university, the latest published detailed theory of struggle - a theory of combat sports - (Kalina, 2000) was one of the subjects at the Josef Pilsudski University of Physical Education in Warsaw; soon it will be taught at other universities in Poland. Following this initiative, students at these universities acquired practical skills in the subject “Combat sports propaedeutics - basics of judo” (Kalina et al. 2003). Using Ockham’s razor as a methodological frame of reference for inno- vative agonology created as a new science, we adopt the language of the representatives of the Lviv-Warsaw school while being aware of the differe- nce of opinion between representatives of this school. For those interested in this new science, it should not matter much that, for example, Wojciech Gasparski (1936-2022) claimed that “methodology is the science of scie- nces,” and “saying that methodology is a branch of logic in its broadest sense does not say much, since ‘logic’ may be understood in various ways” (Gasparski, 1987). Tadeusz Kotarbi´nski understands methodology in rela- tion to logic in three ways, and argues that each one is valid (Kotarbi´nski, 1986). Adam Nowaczyk and Zenobiusz ˙Zołnowski, in their “Logic and Methodology of Scientific Research for Physicians”, following Kotarbi´nski’s reasoning, argue that: “Methodology of scientific research is a branch of logic in the broadest sense... it is a theory of efficient achievement of cogni- tive goals... a particular case of general methodology, thus praxeology” (Nowaczyk, ˙Zołnowski, 1974). Kazimierz Ajdukiewicz (1890-1963), inspi- red by T. Kotarbi´nski’s works on praxeology, promoted the view that the methodology of sciences is not only a part of logic, but also of praxeology (Ajdukiewicz, 1985). Unfortunately, praxeology (Kotarbi´nski, 1982; first edition 1955,) is not a well-known science, and the reason for this is the tragic fate of Poland after the aggression of Germany and the Soviet Union in 1939 – September 1 and 17, respectively. The symbolic date of Septem- ber 17, 1993, when Russian troops (heirs of the USSR) left Poland, can be considered the opening of the Iron Curtain to outstanding, little-known ach- ievements, including the Lviv-Warsaw school of logic and methodology of sciences.
The same term means different things in everyday language, but also some- times in science, or used by various authors. According to Maria (1896-1974) and Stanislaw (1897-1963) Ossowski, the methodology of science is merely a branch of the philosophy of science (Ossowskis, M and S, 1935).
The aim of this paper is to justify, on two examples, the importa- nce of precise language from the perspective of effectively respecting the supreme value criteria of global civilization, without ignoring the micro scale.
Language of Innovative Agonology: A Guide in Combining Micro 309
THE CRITERIA FOR THE VALUE OF GLOBAL CIVILIZATION IMPLY THE SUBJECT OF INNOVATIVE AGONOLOGY RESEARCH The supreme value criteria of global civilization are only a hypothesis: survi- val of humans and nature in a non-degenerate form and responsibility for coming generations. This hypothesis is based on premises derived from Jaro- sław Rudnia´nski’s definition of supreme value criteria (Rudnia´nski, 1989). Justifying why it is only a hypothesis, contrary to appearances, is not diffi- cult. A question would first have to be answered publicly: what else needs to happen, beyond the COVID-19 pandemic and Russia’s aggression against Ukraine, for those entities with supreme influence on the fate of the world to engage in a public debate on this hypothesis in a way that is freed from all division and prejudice? Probably also the subsequent questions will not please many people, including scientific circles. So, first of all, who will popu- larize the hypothesis, articulated above, in the global space? Secondly, will a competing hypothesis emerge, and if so, who will be its author and what will be its content?
One possible competing hypothesis (unfortunately, an extremely pessi- mistic one) is posed by Pawel Adam Piepiora, along with the first author of this paper, in the presentation “Hypothesis on the supreme value cri- teria of the global civilization,” included in the 37th session of AHFE 2023. However, the basic implication of the optimistic hypothesis is the theorem that the objects of concern and effort of every responsible entity (individual and group), from micro to macro scales, are development and survival. A misleading and untrue theorem, however, would be that the subject of IA research is development and survival.
The object of innovative agonology research is the phenomenon of struggle in a broad sense, dedicated precisely (to put it somewhat more figuratively) to the defence of development and survival of humans and nature in a non- degenerate form against destructive factors. The simplest examples are the phenomena of the necessary “fight against disease” and “self-defence against physical aggression.” These examples highlight that defence in the broad sense (that is, one of the varieties of struggle) fills the areas of prevention (education) and therapy (if the subject accumulates the trauma of previous experiences of violence or aggression, or past illnesses). Moreover, the range of application of IA products is possible in a great many, even distant, sci- entific disciplines and can be implemented into areas of practice (medicine, education, defence, etc.).
Precisely because of the possible applications of IA, especially at the inter- face with other scientific disciplines and upon solving the most pressing problems of development and survival, precise language is one of the basic conditions for successfully practicing the just-born complementary research methodology.
Innovative agonology (IA) is an applied science dedicated to promotion, prevention and therapy related to all dimensions of health and regarding the optimization of activities that increase the ability to survive (from micro to macro scales).
310 Kalina and Bagi ´nska
BETWEEN THE LANGUAGES OF THE SCIENCES AND THE EVERYDAY LANGUAGE One of the basic standards of scientific correctness, in addition to a defi- ned object of research, is to make the language of the discipline as precise as possible. Even in sciences dominated by formal language (logic, mathe- matics, chemistry, computer science, etc.), it is necessary to use words of the common language, among other things, in defining key terms. What is more, difficulties in communicating accurately between language users of different sciences, precisely within each of these sciences, arise when at least one key word of a given science has extensive use in colloquial language. This is pre- cisely the case with the words ‘development’ and ‘survival’; in the field of innovative agonology – the former word to an even greater extent. It would be rather meaningless to use both of these keywords with the abbreviation GC (which would stand for global civilization): GC DEVELOPMENT and GC SURVIVAL would sound remarkably bizarre.
The word ‘development’ and its synonyms have been used in colloquial communication between people for thousands of years. The word ‘survival’ (abstracting from the analysis of individual sources), although identified with 21 synonyms, antonyms, and words related to survival, such as: continuity, durability, endurance, and continuance, is clearly associated with either a broad (example Chomsky, 2007) or narrow meaning. In the second case: with an extreme form of physical activity in various environments of human activity, with an element of military training, with one of the activities of scouts, etc. Therefore, regardless of the context of survival (broad or narrow), and because of its proximity to the subject of IA research (the phenome- non of struggle in a broad sense), the term ‘self-defence’ is more suitable for acceptance as a keyword of IA.
TWO KEY WORDS OF INNOVATIVE AGONOLOGY Development
One Polish-language source lists more than 190 synonyms for ‘development’ and 39 word groups using these synonyms while the English Thesaurus lists 80 synonyms for the word. ‘Development’ is a subject of consideration mainly in the field of philo- sophy. It is also a phenomenon that remains within the limited scope of study of parts of the humanities and social sciences: education, ethics, peda- gogy, psychology (psychology of development), sociology, theology, etc., and theory (axiology), but also biology. For an agonologist, the closest is the posi- tion presented mainly by philosophers. Although different philosophers use different words to define the term ‘development,’ the sense is similar, and in many cases even identical. However, such an assumption would be an oversimplification.
Philosophers of science make a distinction between the terms ‘develo- pment’ and ‘advance,’ although in common usage these words are perhaps the clearest synonyms. Development – understood as a collective view of vari- ous philosophical orientations – “is a sequence of directed transformations,
Language of Innovative Agonology: A Guide in Combining Micro 311
proceeding from less complex to more complex structures, in particular to qualitatively higher structures, i.e., those whose internal processes and connections with the environment proceed according to laws that at lower structural levels did not operate. The basic indicator of the development of a system is the growth of its diversity” (Cackowski, 1987, p. 613). In the languages of cybernetics and information theory, the measure of a system’s development is an increase in its information capacity. In biology, the term development is associated with adaptation to a changing environment, a richer, more diverse one. However, the passage of time falsifies this philosoph- ical approach. Alarming reports from ecologists, are forcing a redefinition not of the concept of “adaptation to the environment,” but of adaptation to the circumstances. In many circumstances, this adaptation is a necessary defence (so one variation of struggle) against progressive environmental degradation.
Similarly, the concretization of the term ‘advance’ took place in the areas of exploration of various phenomena, especially biological and social.
It is different with the terms ‘internal development,’ ‘moral development,’ ‘spiritual development,’ and ‘moral degradation,’ ‘moral decline,’ etc. With- out development whether internal, moral or spiritual (and indeed they are almost the same thing), decent survival will become an unattainable goal. It will remain realistic as long as this kind of development affects three genera- tions simultaneously. Disturbing this order (especially by excluding the oldest generation from social life in any way) will inevitably lead to the degradation of social health, and this and this regression will not bypass the macro scale.
For the purpose of this work, let the recommendation for the definition of ‘spiritual development’ be the fact that it was published in Poland at the hei- ght of Solidarity’s struggle against communist dictatorship. It means “first and foremost, the moral improvement of man: that to an ever-increasing extent — and with ever-increasing efficiency — he acts morally well..., that is, in accordance with the supreme criteria of values recognized by the majo- rity of honest people, which are also contained in the moral programs of all great philosophical and religious systems and in independent ethics... We will say that someone has reached a high spiritual level when we reasonably assume that he will realize the supreme moral values in every situation — both through his life and through his death” (Murawski, 1987). Despite the passage of nearly 40 years, the importance of such a resounding spiritual development has not only not lost its relevance, but to ignore this pheno- menon would be counterproductive – instead of the global goal (survival), humanity would achieve its negation (self-destruction).
In the case of these largely equivalent concepts of ‘development’ (spiritual, internal, moral), neither redefinition nor analysis of the differences is nee- ded. The opposite of these terms is ‘moral degradation’ and any other name that would mean the same thing. Thus, these two words and any equivalent term are sufficient, without justification, to fulfil the function of accurately conveying meaning both in science and in everyday language.
It will be a discredit for science and, more broadly, ‘people of the word,’ to duplicate the example scheme of outright absurdity: “the positive effect of the struggle against the development of civilization diseases is the development of health care institutions.”
312 Kalina and Bagi ´nska
In the language of innovative agonology, the word development is consi- stently used only in a positive sense, in relation to any of the phenomena, and it does not matter whether it is on the micro or macro scale, or intermediate levels (Kalina, 2020).
Self-Defence In the everyday language the most common perception of the term ‘self- defence’ concerns the variety of hand-to-hand combat that has to do with effectively countering physical aggression by an individual or group. In the field of innovative agonology, it is only one aspect of self-defence, associ- ated with the micro scale, and has to do with promotion, prevention and therapy related to all dimensions of health and regarding the optimization of activities that increase the ability to survive. Perspective on prevention and therapy from ancient to modern times is presented by Artur Kruszewski in the opening paper of a series of articles dedicated to “Martial Arts and Combat Sports in Health Prevention and Modern Therapy” (Kruszewski, 2023).
In a sense, at the opposite pole of the broadest possible understanding of self-defence, one can place logical self-defense as envisioned by Johnson and Blair (2006), and this concept already covers every scale of action – from micro to macro. In their logical self-defense, the weapon is the intellect. John- son and Blair, however, do not explicitly say that the methods and means described are applicable to defence against the camouflage of power and the camouflage of violence. The phenomena they deal with are described in languages that do not belong to any of the detailed theories of struggle. Moreover, they use English, while Rudnia´nski — the creator of the metho- dology of defence against camouflage of violence and camouflage of power (Rudnia´nski, 1989) — wrote in Polish.
OTHER LINGUISTIC DILEMMAS OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENCE In any intellectual circles, there should be no doubt that due to the social mission of science, it can only be about its development. The simplest example of basic dilemmas are language barriers, and only seemingly any part of it can get away with being unimportant.
One of the concepts originating from the Lviv-Warsaw school of the meth- odology of sciences is the term ‘wiedzotwórczy’ (Nowaczyk and Zolnowski, 1974), which has no equivalent in English. In many significant methodo- logical arguments edited in Polish, it is a convenient combination of the words ‘knowledge’ and ‘creative’. Future IA professionals will undoubtedly face similar semantic dilemmas (it is possible that the neologism “knowledge- creating” will be widely accepted). Identifying, interpreting and formulating algorithms for phenomena that need to be effectively addressed (from micro to macro scales) in the areas of prevention, and therapy, call for undertaking a strong defence and require unambiguous language that is understandable to experts in even distant fields.
The following example, with its unique symbolism, already goes beyond just linguistics. It is in natural languages that knowledge of exceptional
Language of Innovative Agonology: A Guide in Combining Micro 313
importance is contained from the perspective of fulfilling the social mission of science across all divides. The dilemmas of the limited possibility of sharing this knowledge with a multilingual society are still significantly influenced by the mental remnants of the Iron Curtain. A joint publication by Ukrai- nian and Polish authors, made available in the global science space at the beginning of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, addresses the issue of analy- sis of Russian-language scientific resources in the context of prevention and treatment of Alzheimer’s disease (Iermakov et al., 2022).
THE ISSUES OF NECESSARY SELF-DEFENCE AND GROUP DEFENCE OF THE FREEDOM OF SCIENCE, IN SCIENCE AND FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENCE However, according to the authors of this work, two important issues escape attention, not only among many intellectuals. The first, of the necessary self- defence within the community of scholars to ensure the freedom of science, which is and can be increasingly threatened and involve a variety of aspe- cts (Kalina, 2016a). The second, of the necessary group defence against the use of science (scholars) for purposes contrary to the value criteria of global civilization. The history of scientific exploration of the second issue, more or less implicitly, began long before the start of the Cold War (e.g., Whiteh- ead, 1925), and intensified with even greater force in that period (Katz et al., 1954, Doob, 1956, Rudnia´nski, 1975). Science is not passive and clearly formulates the basics of defence: “Inno- vative self-defence involves using verbal and/or behavioural methods and means along with available items in counteracting each attack on any good of an individual (honour, dignity, life, health, property, etc.), whereas a defen- der submits his/her actions to the criteria of prophylactic and therapeutic agonology, considering the most general directive of efficient leading of any struggles and also universal assumption of self-defence training as absolutely paramount.” (Kalina, 2016b, p. 341).
In this work, we merely hint at both of these issues. Their solution is not possible while ignoring both the complementary research methodology and the already available knowledge of innovative agonology, which can be an important part of creating and developing this much needed methodology.
CONCLUSION
Still, whether both the hypothesis on the supreme value criteria of the global civilization and the keywords of innovative agonology will be replicated in the global learning space (and with what effect) will be determined primarily by the community of scholars. Here, Whitehead’s visionary warning about the questionable competence of social affairs coordinators since the method of training professionals was discovered (Whitehead, 1925), shines through. This warning rings out especially sarcastically against the backdrop of the experience of a global pandemic and a full-scale war in Europe, the largest since the end of WWII.
314 Kalina and Bagi ´nska
Although thousands of scientific publications are published every day, and although the implementation of artificial intelligence is dizzying, there is no way to make an ongoing, meaningful selection of the content of these publi- cations in terms of scientific and application value. One factor is the hermetic nature of many specific disciplines, and thus mainly their language. However, we are neither calling for the monitoring of the latest scientific knowledge through a coordinating global-level institution, nor for the unification of the language of science. We are merely pointing out to the need to imple- ment complementary research methodology in a prudent and flexible manner. This necessary prudence is mandated by the awareness of the threat of total annihilation, which has not been present before. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the keywords of innovative agonology will focus the attention of most positive forces concerned, unfortunately, with the distant prospect of a dignified survi- val. The authors of this work feel that they are fulfilling the social mission of science in the best way they can currently afford.
REFERENCES
Ajdukiewicz, K. (1985) Je˛zyk i poznanie. Tom II. Warszawa: PA ´NSTWOWE WYDA- WNICTWO NUKOWE (in Polish). Cackowski, Z. (edited) (1987) Filozofia a nauka. Zarys encyklopedyczny. Wrocław-
Łód´z: OSSOLINEUM (in Polish). Chomsky, N. (2007) Hegemony or Survival. London: PENGUIN BOOKS LTD (UK). Doob, L. W. (1956) Public Opinion and Propaganda. New York: Gasparski, G. (1987) Metodologia nauk. In: Filozofia a nauka. Zarys encyklopedyczny (edited by Cackowski, Z.) Wrocław-Łód´z: OSSOLINEUM pp. 357–371 (in Polish). Iermakov, S., Podrigalo, L., Podrigalo, O., Yermakova, T., Jagiełło, W. (2022) Means
and methods of physical activity in the context of prevention and treatment of Alzheimer’s disease (analysis of Russian-language scientific resources) and the per- spective of implementing the unique achievements of the “Polish School of Safe Falling”. ARCH BUDO 18: pp. 121–143. Johnson, R. H., & Blair, J. A. (2006) Logical Self-Defense. New York- Amsterdam – Brussels: INTERNATIONAL DEBATE EDUCATION ASSOCIATION. Kalina, R. M. (2000) Teoria sportów walki. Warszawa: CENTRALNY O´SRODEK
SPORTU (in Polish). Kalina, R. M. (2016a) Agonology – the prospect of an effective defence of peace and unrestricted freedom of scientists. ARCH BUDO 2016; 12: 1–13. Kalina, R. M. (2016b) Innovative agonology as a synonym for prophylactic and
therapeutic agonology – the final impulse. ARCH BUDO 12 pp. 329–344. Kalina, R. M. (2020) Language and methods of innovative agonology as a guide in interdisciplinary research on interpersonal relationships and people with the environment – from micro to macro scale ARCH BUDO; 16: pp. 271–280. Kalina, R. M., Kruszewski, A., Jagiełło, W., Włoch, G. (2003) Combat sports propa-
edeutics – basics of judo. Warszawa: WYDAWNICTWA AKADEMII WYCHO- WANIA FIZYCZNEGO. Katz, D., Cartwight, D., Eldersvdel, S., Lee McClung. (1954) Public Opinion and Propaganda. New York: Kotarbinski, T. (1958) My´sl o nauce. KULTURA I SPOLECZE ´NSTWO; 2/1:
pp. 13–23 (in Polish).
Language of Innovative Agonology: A Guide in Combining Micro 315
Kotarbinski, T. (1982) Traktat o dobrej robocie. Wroclaw-Lód´z: ZAKŁAD NARO- DOWY IMIENIA OSSOLINSKICH WYDAWNICTWO, Wyd. 7, (In Polish, summary in English and Russian). Kotarbinski, T. (1986) Elementy teorii poznania, logiki formalnej i metodologii
nauk. Warszawa: 3rd edition; PA ´NSTWOWE WYDAWNICTWO NAUKOWE (in Polish). Kruszewski, A. (2023) From Ancient Patterns of Hand-to-Hand Combat to a Unique Therapy of the Future. INT J ENVIRON RES PUBLIC HEALTH, Volume 20, 3553. https:// doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20043553 Murawski, K. (1987) Ja´z´n i sumienie. Filozoficzne zagadnienia rozwoju duchowego
człowieka w pracach Yunga i Ke˛pi´nskiego. Wrocław: ZAKŁAD NARODOWY IM. OSSOLIN’SKICH (in Polish). Nowaczyk, A., ˙Zołnowski, Z. (1974) Logika i metodologia bada´n naukowych dla lekarzy. Warszawa: PA ´NSTWOWY ZAKŁAD WYDAWNICTW LEKARSKICH (in Polish). Ossowscy, M. and S. (1935) Nauka o nauce. NAUKA POLSKA (in Polish). Rudnia´nski, J. (1975). Homo cogitans. O my´sleniu twórczym i kryteriach warto´sci.
Warszawa: WIEDZA POWSZEHNA (In Polish, summary in English and Russian). Rudnia´nski, J. (1989) Kompromis i walka. Sprawno´s´c i etyka kooperacji pozytywnej i negatywnej w ge˛stym otoczeniu społecznym. Warszawa: INSTYTUT WYDAWNICZY PAX (in Polish). Whitehead, A. N. (1925) Science and the Modern World. Lowell Lectures. Cambrige
at the University Press.