Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Occupational health and safety and sustainable return to work management in small and medium-sized enterprises

Institut de recherche Robert-Sauvé en santé et en sécurité du travail, Montreal, QC, H3A 3C2, Canada ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe1002653

Abstract

BackgroundThe sustainable retention of workers after a work-related injury poses particular challenges for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). Although studies on SMEs have multiplied over the past 30 years and some of them have led to the emergence of new concepts and theories in occupational health and safety (OHS), little is known about what can be done in SMEs to improve the OHS management of absences caused by work-related injuries. The objective of this presentation will be to overview strategical elements (resources, structures, activities) that could also benefit to the sustainable return-to work (SRTW).MethodA scoping review (Levac et al. 2010) on OHS management in SMEs was conducted in a reflective, iterative and collaborative manner. The methodological approach includes searching for relevant publications from the 2000 year in scientific (e.g., SCOPUS, ProQuest) and non-scientific (e.g., NHSE, NIOSH) databases, combining several key concepts related to OHS management and SRTW. Criteria for the selection of the studies were: 1) focus on OHS management, generally (review), or empirically (workplace intervention study); 2) focus on SMEs globally or in a specific context (size of enterprise, sectors of activities). Two reviewers using an iterative consensus-based approach performed article selection, extraction of data, and analyses.ResultsThree groups of strategic elements are beneficial for OHS management in SME: diffusion of information, support to implement integrative adapted systems of management and training programs, and especially designed for SME or intermediaries.Diffusion of information about legislation for SMEs, and guidelines for compliance with regulations, provide SME motivation and resources to intervene on the proper factors on SRTW. External support to OSH interventions, provided by control authorities, associations and networks of companies, and external consultants allow sharing knowledge and OSH-related resources, promoting best practices in SME. The availability of knowledge of effective OSH interventions could also help to replication or adaptation in particular contexts of SME, helping the achievement of proper conditions for SRTW. This kind of collaborative support to SME, combined with the continual engagement of employers and communication between management and employees and among employees, play an essential role in all phases of preventive or corrective interventions. Finally, training programs specially designed for SMEs foster interventions by increasing the awareness and the knowledge of the personnel, who are more motivated to intervene or correctly behave. DiscussionOverall, the strategies, resources, structures and activities in the SME, seem to be specific to the legislation in place and the different levels of actions. Even if generally they do not explicitly have an aim to promote sustainable retention of workers after a work-related injury, they present some opportunities to do so, modalities being different depending on the size of enterprise, and the level of risk of work activities in the sector. The results of this scoping review provide input for methodological and conceptual thinking for future policies or programs, as well as some information about integration of SRTW to OHS approaches and intervention modalities.

INTRODUCTION

The growing importance of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) for our society and in the economy in general has been recognized and has led to an increase in the number of studies devoted to them. Over the last thirty years, such studies have addressed all sorts of subjects (competitiveness, total quality, technological innovation, environmental sustainability, etc.), either globally or in specific sectors of activity (construction, manufacturing, etc.). Studies on occupational health and safety (OHS) in SME show that manage- ment of such issues is quite different from large companies. One of the reasons is that SME employers perceive OHS as representing a substantial economic cost (Haslam et al. 2010). Since SMEs have fewer financial and human resou- rces than large companies (Masi and Cagno 2015, Page, 2009), and being under more economic pressure, they are more reluctant to dedicate resources to solve exceptional problems such as OHS and disability management issues (MacEachen et al. 2010).

Sustainable return to work practices, which are an intrinsic part of OHS and disability management, pose particular challenges for SMEs, although studies have already established the main principles of disability manage- ment, which promote sustainable return to work after injury (Franche et al. 2005; MacEachen et al. 2006, IWH, 2010). Subsequent research has been

© 2022. Published by AHFE Open Access. All rights reserved. 7

8 Nastasia and Rives

dedicated to putting these principles into practice and to describing the best practices for promoting sustainable return to work (RTW) (Cullen et al. 2018, Durand et al. 2017, Nastasia et al. 2017, Durand et al. 2014, Nasta- sia et al. 2014). However, the vast majority of these studies were conducted in large firms (Kristman et al. 2016, Main et al. 2016) and little is known about how these practices could be applied in SME. This paper highlights some preliminary results from a scoping review (Arksey and O’Malley, 2005) conducted in order to describe the main OHS strategies, and envisage oppor- tunities to integrate resources, structures, and activities related to disability management and return to work.

STRATEGIC ELEMENTS IN OHS MANAGEMENT Overall, four main strategies for improving the OHS in SME are identified from the literature consulted. These strategies consist in the adaptation of OHS management to the context of SMEs (legislation, size, sector, risks, and unionization), the diffusion, dissemination, and exchange of information on OHS, the use of a collaborative or participative approach and the acquisition of OHS knowledge, skills and abilities. As can be seen in Table 1, diffe- rent resources, structures and activities are each associated with one or more of these strategies and imply interactions between the different stakeholders involved within SME (initiator, intermediaries, and workplace) (Sinclair et al. 2013). Strategies for improving OHS outcome in SME cannot simply be a copy and paste of what is recommended in terms of legislation or guidelines for actions in large companies. Therefore, it seems important to adapt OSH management and the regulations designed for large companies in a more informal way. This may result in the assignment of responsibilities for OHS in the company to different actors and the development of simpler procedu- res to identify OHS risks, leaving room to resolve problems when they arise (Barbeau et al. 2004).

In addition, the outreach of SMEs through the diffusion and dissemina- tion of information on OHS issues also seems important. Means of diffusion and dissemination include postal letters, advertising, social networks (Parker et al. 2015; Sinclair et al. 2013), but the best way to reach SMEs seems to remain telephone contact or even meeting in person (Olsen, 2015). More- over, SME owner-managers prefer OHS information and advice specific to their organization rather than general information (Mayhew, 2000; Nielsen, 2013). Furthermore, SME owner-managers appreciate having easy access and support in assessing OHS risks and conducting simple, cost-benefit-ratio interventions (Parker et al. 2012, 2015). Even a minimalist approach could produce interesting results for improving OHS management in SME (Walker and Tait, 2014, Walaski, 2017). Particularly interesting in terms of resou- rces in assessing OHS risks are the intermediaries (organizations providing goods or services to SMEs, associations, consultants, experts, accountants etc.), as distribution and exchange channels between initiating organizations

Occupational Health and Safety and Sustainable Return 9

Table 1. Main strategic elements for improving OHS management in SMEs.

Table available in the original PDF paper.

Strategies Resources Structures Activities Adapt OHS management to SMEs context (legislation, size, sector, risks, unionization) Disseminate and exchange information on OHS regulations, services, and interventions to and for SMEs Collaborative support for OSH assessment and intervention Acquisition of OHS knowledge, skills and abilities Investigation of causes of injury Recognition of OHS efforts in SMEs Financing the activities of intermediaries Technical support (advice, networ- king, information, maintenance of installation safety) Assessment of OHS risks and simple intervention Engagement of managers and workers Dialogue betw- een managers, intermediaries workers Educational and training activities Mandatory/ voluntary courses Legislation Regulations Guidelines Publications messages, guidelines Networks of companies with a similar profile Databases for sharing solutions OHS policy Organizational procedures with roles and responsibilities for all structures and actors Participative or collaborative structures: OHS committee/ representative Tools (checklist, methods of OHS risk evaluation, intervention support) Awareness Training

Initiators: government, stakeholders organisations Intermediaries: Organisations/ associations of enterprises (same activity sector/ administrative region), chamber of commerce, business development centers Inspectors, consultants practitioners, experts (accounting, industrial hygiene, human resources, engineering, ergonomics, administration) Workplace: Employers, managers, supervisors, workers, union representatives

(often governmental, public health/safety organizations) and SMEs (Hasle and Refslund, 2018).

For OHS management within the company, a collaborative and partici- pative approach seems effective in SMEs. According to Masi and Cagno (2015), the participatory approach corresponds to the search for the active participation of the company’s internal actors in OHS management, and the collaborative approach corresponds to the involvement of actors from out- side the company. If we focus on the participation of internal actors, three types of actors stand out: managers, workers, and personnel responsible for OHS issues (Masi and Cagno, 2015). However, not all companies have personnel specifically assigned to the management of OHS issues. In some companies, particularly the smallest ones, the owner or manager takes charge of OHS problems themselves (Champoux and Brun, 2003; Walker and Tait, 2014). There are therefore two aspects to the participatory approach. On the one hand, we find the importance of joint participation of managers

10 Nastasia and Rives

and workers in OHS management (Champoux and Brun, 2003; Nielsen, 2013; Torp, 2008). An open and constructive dialogue between managers and employees makes it possible to clarify and rectify possible disagreements (Kines et al. 2013; Nielsen, et al. 2013). Such exchanges also allow the crea- tion of a positive culture within the company (Nielsen et al. 2013). In order to implement significant changes in the management of OHS in the com- pany, workers’ involvement is needed because their knowledge of the field is essential, and managers’ involvement is equally important because they are responsible for allocating resources (Dale, 2016). The second aspect of the participatory approach is the importance of the involvement of all workers in the company. The inclusion of workers with different work experiences must be sought during the different stages of the process, whether it is the search for safety problems, the implementation of solutions, or the evaluation of their impact (Gravel et al. 2011). If all the workers in a company cannot be included at all stages of an OHS intervention for reasons of ease and effe- ctiveness, the workers’ representatives must nevertheless ensure that all of the company’s workers are included at a given point in the process to ensure that the chosen measures are implemented (Gunnarsson, 2010). Management commitment is essential for the success of an OHS intervention, although it alone cannot guarantee success (Nielsen et al. 2013). Management commi- tment to improving OHS in the company is perceived positively by workers who see it as evidence of management support for their work (Torp, 2008).

To go further than simply informing SMEs, the acquisition of OHS know- ledge, skills and abilities on OHS issues is essential. Educational and training activities, initiated by outside resources and addressed to managers/owners, have been found effective in developing better OHS management systems, and thus in improving employees’ work environment (Torp, 2008). Coaching and workshop sessions organized to improve supervisors’ skills in managing OHS issues and to favor workers’ commitment have resulted in positive cul- ture changes within the company (Nielsen et al. 2013). However the content should be simple, short, easy to follow, adapted to the work schedule and to the seasonal or economic fluctuations of activities (Cunningham and Sinclair, 2015; Gravel et al. 2011), as well inexpensive or with possibilities of subsi- dies (Cunningham and Sinclair, 2015; Farina et al. 2015). Finally, training activities initiated by an external resource and directed to third-party compa- nies acting as intermediaries (e.g., accountants, local chambers of commerce) seem valuable for bringing OHS-related knowledge to the SMEs (Hasle and Refslund, 2018; Sinclair et al. 2013).

CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR SUSTAINABLE RETURN TO WORK Analyses from the scoping review led to the understanding that SMEs do not appear to distinguish practices specifically linked to RTW from other efforts in preventing OHS injuries. In fact, few strategic elements that touch on disability management and sustainable RTW practices were mentioned in the literature consulted. However, OHS strategical elements, presented in the previous section, share work disability management’s foundational

Occupational Health and Safety and Sustainable Return 11

principles for reducing the human and economic costs for both individu- als and organizations. In Canada, the Institute for Work and Health (IWH) established seven principles for successful RTW: (1) strong workplace com- mitment to health and safety; (2) offering job modification; (3) supporting the returning worker without disadvantaging co-workers and supervisors; (4) training supervisors in work disability prevention and including them in return-to-work planning; (5) caring employer contact with injured or ill workers; (6) return-to-work coordination; and (7) communication between employers and workplace health care providers (IWH, 2010). Although such principles are now generally acknowledged by larger workplaces and profes- sionals, practices observed in SMEs do not seem to reflect their application in a consistent or optimal manner (Nastasia et al. 2017, Audet et al. (in press)).

Challenges in the application of disability management and sustainable RTW practices in SMEs seem to be related to employers’ beliefs that impor- tant costs will need to be put in place to make appropriate resources and structures available (Haslam et al. 2010). Focused primarily on production (Stave et al., 2008), employers and even employees may not perceive OHS and disability management issues as part of the core business in the same way as sales, planning, or finance (Olsen and Hasle, 2015). Consequently, any work time lost due to the disability management of an occupational injury may be seen as having a negative impact on the enterprise’s productivity, which could entice the use of less optimal practices (Nastasia et al. 2017). Therefore, there is a risk of aggravating the injury or prolonging the work disability, in so doing essentially increasing the financial cost of an occupational injury in the mid to long term (Durand et al, 2014). Workplace practices, such as inquiring about accident causes and evaluating, planning, offering organizational and physical job modifications, could be integrated in OHS policies, procedures and strategies, and their scope could be increased by conducting educatio- nal and training activities. Less optimal practices also seem related to the scarcity of resources that SMEs are able to devote to disability management and to the absence of appropriate collaborative supportive structures. As a way to overcome the problem of resource scarcity, models of networking for reaching and consulting SMEs with OHS information and supporting servi- ces show promising results through the adoption of collaborative strategies (Cunningham and Sinclair 2015, Sinclair et al. 2013, Hasle and Refslund, 2018; Olsen and Hasle, 2015). Structures promoting OHS outcome, such as stakeholder’s organizations or intermediaries (associations, experts, pro- fessionals, etc.) could help to disseminate guidelines and support disability management, and sustainable RTW.

Because of the emergence of advanced technologies, new societal values, changing demographics, and globalization, new business structures yield organizational opportunities and create levers for improving disability mana- gement and sustainable RTW in SMEs. Flexible work arrangements (e.g., temporary employment, remote work, virtual work) create opportunities for developing resource-efficient production (Ekberg et al. 2016) and solve the problem of lack of work force in several sectors of activity. Further- more, the proximity between managers and employees in SMEs and the support of external intermediaries providing advisory and support services to

12 Nastasia and Rives

employers and employees in SMEs facilitate effective communication and col- laboration between all stakeholders, and enhance realistic appropriate work arrangements (Ekberg et al. 2016).

CONCLUSION

The paper highlights some OHS strategies and strategic elements (resources, structures, activities) used in SME, and discusses their common foundati- onal principles with disability and sustainable RTW management and their potential to promote sustainable RTW in SMEs. Future studies on workplace disability and RTW management should be designed in different contexts to reflect the multiple work patterns that currently exist across SMEs. In par- ticular, flexible work arrangements (temporary employment, virtual work, etc.) should be explored in more detail as a possible mechanism for installing appropriate practice in SMEs. In addition, government laws, policies, and procedures need to be adapted to fit the needs of flexible work arrangements in SMEs.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

This research is granted by the Institut de recherche Robert-Sauvé en santé et en sécurité au travail (IRSST). The authors thank Sarah Marena Gaspard for the content and English revision of the paper. The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

REFERENCES

Arksey, H., O’Malley, L. (2005) Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework. International Journal of Social Research Methodology: Theory & Practice, 8, 19–32. Audet, J., Lecours, A., & Nastasia, I. (2022) Experiences in the Return-to-Work

Process of Workers Having Suffered Occupational Injuries in Small and Medium Size Enterprises (in press). Barbeau, E., Roelofs, C., Youngstrom, R., Sorensen, G., Stoddard, A., LaMontagne AD. Assessment of occupational safety and health programs in small businesses. Am J Ind Med. 2004 Apr;45(4):371-9. Champoux, D. and J.-P. Brun (2003). Occupational health and safety management

in small size enterprises: an overview of the situation and avenues for intervention and research. Safety science 41(4): 301–318. Cullen, K. L., Irvin, E., Collie, A., Clay, F., Gensby, U., Jennings, P. A. Amick, B. C.

(2018). Effectiveness of workplace interventions in return-to-work for musculo- skeletal, pain-related and mental health conditions: An update of the evidence and messages for practitioners. Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation, 28(1), 1–15. Cunningham, T. R. and R. Sinclair (2015). “Application of a model for delivering occupational safety and health to smaller businesses: Case studies from the US.” Safety Science 71: 213–225. Dale, AM., Jaegers, L., Welch, L., Gardner, BT., Buchholz, B., Weaver, N., Eva-

noff BA. (2016) Evaluation of a participatory ergonomics intervention in small commercial construction firms. Am J Ind Med. 59(6):465-75

Occupational Health and Safety and Sustainable Return 13

Durand, M.-J., Corbière, M., Coutu, M.-F., Reinharz, D., Albert, V. (2014). A review of best work-absence management and return-to-work practices for workers with musculoskeletal or common mental disorders. Work, 48(4), 579–589. Durand, M.-J., Nastasia, I., Coutu, M.-F., Bernier, M. (2017). Practices of return-

to-work coordinators working in large organizations. Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation, 27(1), 137–147. Farina, E., Bena, A., & Dotti, A. (2015). Impact on safety of a preventive intervention in metalworking micro-enterprises. Safety Science, 71: 292–297. Franche, RL., Cullen, K., Clarke, J., Irvin, E., Sinclair, S., Frank, J. (2005). Workplace-

based return-to-work interventions: A systematic review of the quantitative literature. Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation, 15(4), 607–631. Gravel, S., Rhéaume, J. and Legendre, G. (2011) Strategies to develop and maintain occupational health and safety measures in small businesses employing immigrant workers in metropolitan Montreal. International Journal of Workplace Health Management, 4(2): 164–178. Gunnarsson, K., et al. (2010). “Systematic Work Environment Management: experi-

ences from implementation in Swedish small-scale enterprises.” Ind Health 48(2): 185–196. Haslam, C., Haefeli, K., & Haslam, R. (2010). Perceptions of occupational injury and illness costs by size of organization. Occup Med 60:Occupational Medicine, 60(6), 484–490. Hasle P., Kines P., Kines, Peter L., Andersen L.P. (2009). Small enterprise owners’

accident causation and prevention. Safety Science 47:9-19 Hasle, P. and Refslund, B., 2018. Intermediaries Supporting Occupational Health and Safety Improvements in Small Businesses: Development of Typology and Discus- sion of Consequences for Preventive Strategies, Annals of Work Exposures and Health, 62: 65–71 Hughes, M. C., Patrick, D. L., Hannon, P. A., Harris, J. R., & Ghosh, D. L. Hasle,

P., Kvorning, L. V., Rasmussen, C. D., Smith, H. et Flyvholm, M.-A. (2012). A model for design of tailored working environment intervention programmes for small enterprises. Safety and Health at Work, 3(3), 181–191. Institute for Work & Health. (2007). Seven ’principles’ for successful return to work. Tiré de https://www.iwh.on.ca/tools-and-guides/seven-principles-for- successful-return-to-work INRS (2019) Bilan récent sur les actions entreprises par l’institution pour ces unités

particulières : ≪Évaluation des différentes stratégies et actions de l’INRS vers les TPE/PME sur la période 2007-2017 ≫ Kines, P., et al. (2013). “Improving safety in small enterprises through an integrated safety management intervention.” J Safety Res 44: 87-95. Kristman, V. L., Shaw, W. S., Boot, C. R. L., Delclos, G. L., Sullivan, M. J., Ehrhart, M.

G. et Hopkinton Conference Working Group on Workplace Disability Prevention. (2016). Researching complex and multi-level workplace factors affecting disa- bility and prolonged sickness absence. Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation, 26(4), 399–416. Levac D, Colquhoun H, O’Brien KK, 2010. Scoping studies: advancing the methodology. Implementation Science 2010, 5:69 Limborg, H. J., Grøn, S., & Flensborg Jensen, M. (2014). Research Note: Netw-

orking Among Small and Medium-sized Enterprises: Meeting the Challenge of Promoting Safety and Health . Small Enterprise Research, 21(2), 214–222.

14 Nastasia and Rives

MacEachen, E., Clarke, J., Franche, R.-L. et Irvin, E. (2006). Systematic review of the qualitative literature on return to work after injury. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health, 32(4), 257–269. Main, C. J., Shaw, W. S. et Mitchell, J. (2016). Towards an approach to return to

work interventions in musculoskeletal disorders. I. Z. Schultz and R. J. Gatchel (Ed.), Handbook of return to work (pp. 439–457). New York, NY: Springer. Masi, D. et Cagno, E. (2015). Barriers to OHS interventions in small and mediumsized enterprises. Safety Science, 71 226–241. Nastasia, I., Coutu, M.-F. et Tcaciuc, R. (2014). Topics and trends in research

on non-clinical interventions aimed at preventing prolonged work disability in workers compensated for work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WRMSDs): A systematic, comprehensive literature review. Disability and Rehabilitation, 36(22), 1841–1856. Nastasia, I., Durand, M.-J., Coutu, M.-F., Collinge, C. et Cibotaru, A. (2017). Pratiques des milieux de travail pour assurer un retour au travail sain et durable (Rapport no R-983). Montréal, QC: IRSST. Nielsen, K. J., et al. (2013). “A multi-case study of the implementation of an integra-

ted approach to safety in small enterprises.” Safety Science 71(PB): 142–150. Olsen, K. B., & Hasle, P. (2015). The role of intermediaries in delivering an occupational health and safety programme designed for small business - a case study of an insurance incentive programme in the agriculture sector. Safety Science, 71(Part C), 242–252. Page, K. (2009). Blood on the coal: The effect of organizational size and diffe-

rentiation on coal mine accidents. J Saf ResJournal of Safety Research, 40:(2), 85–95. Parker, DL., et al. (2012). “A qualitative evaluation of owner and worker health and safety beliefs in small auto collision repair shops.” Am J Ind Med 55(5): 474–482. Parker, D. L., et al. (2015). “The Collision Auto Repair Safety Study (CARSS): a

health and safety intervention.” Am J Ind Med 58(1): 88–100. Sinclair, RC., et al. (2013). “A model for occupational safety and health intervention diffusion to small businesses.” Am J Ind Med 56(12): 1442–1451. Stave C., Pousette A., Törner M., 2008 Risk and safety communication in small

enterprises–how to support a lasting change towards work safety priority Journal of risk research, Taylor & Francis. Torp, S. (2008). “How a Health and Safety Management Training Program May Improve the Working Environment in Small-and Medium-Sized Companies.” Journal of occupational and environmental medicine 50(3): 263-271. Tremblay, A. and A. Badri (2018). “A novel tool for evaluating occupational health

and safety performance in small and medium-sized enterprises: The case of the Quebec forestry/pulp and paper industry, Safety science 101: 282–294. Walker, D. and R. Tait (2004). “Health and safety management in small enterprises: an effective low cost approach.” Safety science 42(1): 69-83. Walaski, P. (2017). “Rightsizing Risk Management: For Small & Medium Enterpri-

ses.” Professional Safety 62(6): 62–69.

Cover of the proceedings volume Social and Occupational Ergonomics

Explore the complete digital volume

Social and Occupational Ergonomics

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-958651-41-4

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →