Nick Woodier, Charlotte Burnett, Paul Sampson, Iain Moppett (2022). Improving healthcare-system safety through near misses: learning from transport industries. In: Healthcare and Medical Devices. AHFE Open Access, vol. 51, pp. 202–208. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1002117
The aim of this study was to understand how the transport industries of aviation, rail and maritime have implemented near-miss management systems, and the impact of their learning from near misses. Grounded Theory, augmented by a scoping review, was used to generate the theory and principles behind how the industries manage near misses. The paper summarises the key findings from the scoping review and the themes identified through interviews with safety/human factors leads across various transport organisations. The findings provide insights into how healthcare might better manage near misses. However, the findings also challenge healthcare perceptions that other industries have perfected safety, and the specific value of near misses if used in isolation. The paper finishes by recommending safety management systems in healthcare.
Patients may come to unintended harm through the care processes that are meant to help them (for example, Balen, 2004). Healthcare is regularly chal- lenged that it fails to learn from significant harm incidents, meaning those incidents reoccur (for example, Peerally et al. 2017). In attempts to address gaps in safety management, healthcare often turns to other industries to gather insights (for example, Gordon et al. 2013). The literature refers to the safety advances of Safety-Critical Industries (SCIs). SCIs have complex soci- otechnical systems and risks of significant harm from failure (Wears, 2012). Examples include aviation, rail and nuclear energy.
The healthcare literature has long described how SCIs have embraced and learnt from near misses to make their industries safer; there are calls for healthcare to learn and do the same (Barach and Small, 2000). A near miss in English healthcare is thought to have occurred where an incident was prevented (NPSA, 2004). However, there are several different definiti- ons for near misses in healthcare, many with different functional meanings (Marks et al. 2013).
Improving Healthcare-System Safety through Near Misses 203
It is believed that effective reporting, investigation and learning from near misses will prevent harmful incidents (Aspden et al. 2004). The literature regularly cites Heinrich’s ‘safety pyramid’ to describe how near-miss rates relate to incident rates (Heinrich et al. 1980). The ‘pyramid’ has led to a hypothesis that by addressing near misses, incidents may be prevented due to the same underlying causes (Manuele, 2011). Therefore, there is believed to be value in healthcare developing near-miss management systems to improve patient safety. The question is how?
This research aimed to understand how transport SCIs (aviation, rail and maritime) have implemented near-miss management systems and their value. Findings were used to develop principles for healthcare to improve the management of near misses.
METHODS
A Grounded Theory (GT) methodology, augmented by a scoping review, was used. Data collection included interviews, field notes and the literature. The review protocol is accessible online (Woodier, 2022) and included all SCIs (Saunders, 2015).
The GT aimed to develop theories about how SCIs manage near misses, their maturity in that management and the value of learning from them. It was not realistic to engage with all SCIs and achieve theoretical saturation, so transport industries were selected (aviation, rail and maritime). Organisa- tions were approached for interviews with safety and/or human factors leads. Sampling was purposive and then theoretical.
All data were anonymised and collated using NVivo. Analysis used open, axial and selective coding, and the constant comparative method (Glaser, 1965). Analysis was undertaken independently by two of the authors. To ensure rigor, data was triangulated and verified with participants. Memos were written as research progressed, acknowledging the authors’ roles in the research (reflexivity).
RESULTS
The scoping review findings were incorporated into the GT. 83 papers (and further grey articles) were included. Literature was published between 2000 and 2018, most commonly in North America (n = 40). Chemical (n = 24) was the commonest industry, with others including rail (n = 13), maritime (n = 12), and aviation (n = 7). SCIs rarely used the term ‘near miss.’ Other terms included close call and precursor, but there was debate over whether these were synonymous with a near miss (Gnoni and Saleh, 2017; Sheridan et al. 2004; Smith and Borgonovo, 2007). There was debate about the defini- tion of a near miss with variation between operational and research settings (Bliss et al. 2014). Dillon et al (2014) described two types of near miss where they could be seen as vulnerabilities (something almost happened) or resilie- nce (got away with it). ‘Barriers’ often came into definitions, particularly in nuclear (IAEA, 2020).
For management of near misses, industries had different reporting systems. Some included automated detection, such as aircraft proximity detection (Brooker, 2005). To support reporting the need for the following was descri- bed: usable reporting systems, right safety culture, feedback, commitment, and training. Anonymity was contentious with some advocating for it (for example in maritime, Köhler, 2010), while others found it challenged learning (for example, Multer et al. 2013).
SCIs used various, but no consistent method for analysis (examples included HFACS, TRACEr and barrier analysis). Most prioritised high-risk near misses for investigation (for example, Gnoni and Lettera, 2012). It was impractical to analyse all near misses and so aggregation was used (Hughes et al. 2015). Various coding frameworks existed, some including ‘recovery codes’ to aggregate learning around how incidents were avoided (for example, Wright and van der Schaaf, 2004).
There were examples of changes made following investigation of near mis- ses. However, detail was limited and rarely considered impact. Perceived improvements in safety were described, but only a few showed evidential impact (for example, Saks et al. 2004; Wincek, 2016) More commonly redu- ctions in incidents were assumed (for example, Hodges and Sanders, 2014), generalising from Heinrich’s pyramid.
For the GT, 28 interviews were undertaken across aviation (n = 12), rail (n = 9) and maritime (n = 7). These were supplemented by the scoping review, field notes and research memos. Table 1 provides a summary of the themes from selective coding.
Table 1. Selective coding findings from the grounded theory.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
1 SCIs have organisation and industry-wide structured and regulated safety management systems. These include near misses. 2 SCIs strive to prioritise safety, but reporting, learning and levels of safety vary across organisations and industries. 3 SCIs recognise the importance of and strive for the right safety culture, with a preference for ‘just.’ Cultures vary across organisations and industries. 4 There is no standard term or definition for a near miss. SCIs refer to near misses in relation to interceptions where something almost happened. 5 Underreporting of near misses exists across all SCIs. 6 Reporting systems for near misses vary, but often include multiple and simple routes for reporting. Confidential and anonymous systems exist. 7 It is impossible to analyse all near misses and so prioritisation of high-risk near misses for analysis is undertaken. The rest are aggregated. 8 There are no standard or near-miss specific analysis tools, but barrier-based tools are common. 9 SCIs make changes following learning from near misses but have limited evidence of impact on safety; impact is often assumed. 10 Significant harm events lead to a greater impetus to improve. However, they are rare in SCIs, allowing a focus on other events, such as near misses.
Improving Healthcare-System Safety through Near Misses 205
DISCUSSION
The findings provided insights into the management and value of near misses in the transport SCIs from perspectives of operational, policy, research and investigation providers. The authors felt that they had reached theoretical saturation. The GT therefore sought to identify the theory, the principles behind, how SCIs improve safety using near misses. Key principles found are described in turn.
Near Misses Contribute to Safety Improvements Through Embedded Safety Management Systems (SMS) SCIs had organisational and industry-wide SMSs. An SMS is an organised approach to safety through processes that identify safety hazards and manage safety risks (HSIB, 2021). Near misses were one form of intelligence infor- ming these SMSs, contributing to safety improvements. It was not evident that near misses alone had led to improvements in safety, rather they con- tributed. SMSs are not widely used in healthcare and are not regulated for, unlike in SCIs (Dixon-Woods et al. 2014).
Safety Culture Must be Developed and Protected to Support Learning and Improvement; a Just Culture is Preferential SCIs described the importance of developing and nurturing a safety culture. Reason (1997) suggested that a safety culture has five elements inclu- ding being ‘just.’ Organisations agreed that ‘just’ was needed to encou- rage reporting, but without absolving individuals of their responsibilities (Macrae, 2014).
It was evident that the maturity of safety, and of safety cultures, varied across industries, within industries and within organisations. Safety was not homogenous and describing a single industry as ‘safe’ was felt to be inaccu- rate. For example, differences were heard about across passenger, freight, military and general aviation.
A Near Miss is Characterised by the Intervention of Human Controls Leading to a Safety Event That Almost Happened SCIs suggested that near misses should be thought of in terms of controls. Controls are measures expected to prevent incidents. Barriers are controls that are robust and reliable to prevent an incident; safeguards are controls that support barriers, but are not robust (CIEHF, 2016). SCIs suggested that a near miss has occurred when a human safeguard has intervened, and where no barriers exist. Barriers acting as intended are not near misses as they represent the system working as designed.
Reporting Routes are Designed With the User in Mind Supported by Simplicity SCIs demonstrated examples of reporting routes that accounted for the way in which workforces functioned. This included multiple avenues for repor- ting, internal to and external to organisations. Whether anonymous or confidential systems were most beneficial was unclear. Maritime felt that
they required anonymity because of their safety cultures, but others felt confidential allowed follow-up for further information.
Not all Near Misses can be Investigated, With Prioritisation of Those for in Depth Analysis Based on Risk, and the Rest Aggregated for Trend Tracking SCIs reviewed each near miss and, in certain cases, investigated them to the same depth as harmful incidents. Near misses were prioritised using risk matrices (for example, Gnoni and Lettera, 2012). Where there was felt to be significant risk, learning or limited barriers, in-depth investigations occurred. All near misses were coded for aggregation, using frameworks that included causal and recovery codes.
Significantly Harmful Events Lead to Greater Attention and Change, They Therefore Currently Have Greater Value for Learning SCIs described the challenges of gaining momentum with safety improve- ments resulting from near misses. Rather, more attention was paid to where significant damage or harm had occurred. Harm led to emotive responses and more resources allocated. There was felt to be value in investigating significant harm incidents.
CONCLUSION
SCIs use near misses as intelligence for their SMSs. Due to the low occurrence of harmful incidents in these industries, they can spend time and resource managing near misses. However, the value of managing near misses is unclear with no clear evidence of positive safety impact from solely focusing on near misses; rather it is the inclusion of near misses in a comprehensive SMS that is more likely to support improvements. Healthcare may therefore benefit from developing SMSs to which near misses contribute through the principles identified in this study.
The study also found assumptions that by addressing near misses, inci- dents can be prevented (Manuele, 2011). However, no evidence was found to support this hypothesis, rather the assumptions were based on historical data that has since been challenged. There is a need for further research to test the hypothesis across various industries; some have already commenced this (Wright and van der Schaaf, 2004).
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors would like to acknowledge Mrs. Carol Appleby for her support transcribing interviews for analysis.
REFERENCES
Aspden, P., Corrigan, J. M. and Wolcott, J. (2004) “Near-Miss Analysis”, in Aspden, P. (ed) Patient safety: Achieving a new standard for care, Washington, DC, National academic Press.
Improving Healthcare-System Safety through Near Misses 207
Balen, P. (2004) “Gross negligence manslaughter: Wayne Jowett (deceased).” Clinical Risk, 10(1), 25–27. Barach, P. and Small, S. D. (2000) “Reporting and preventing medical mish-
aps: lessons from non-medical near miss reporting systems.” BMJ, 320(7237), 759–763. Bliss, J. P., Rice, S., Hunt, G. and Geels, K. (2014) “What are close calls? A proposed taxonomy to inform risk communication research.” Safety Science, 61, 21–28. Brooker, P. (2005) “STCA, TCAS, Airproxes and Collision Risk.” Journal of Naviga-
tion, 58(3), 389–404. CIEHF (2016) “Barrier Management.” Chartered Institute of Ergonomics & Human Factors. Available at https://archived.ciehf.org/learn/barrier-management/ (Accessed 22 October 2021). Dillon, R. L., Tinsley, C. H. and Burns, W. J. (2014) “Near-misses and future disaster
preparedness.” Risk Analysis, 34(10), 1907–1922. Dixon-Woods, M., Martin, G., Tarrant, C., Bion, J., Goeschel, C. and Provonost, P. (2014) “Safer Clinical Systems Evaluation Findings.” The Health Foundation. Available at https://www.health.org.uk/sites/default/files/ SaferClinicalSystemsE- valuationFindings_fullversion.pdf (Accessed 16 January 2022). Glaser, B. G. (1965) “The Constant Comparative Method of Qualitative Analysis.”
Social Problems, 12, 436–445. Gnoni, M. G. and Lettera, G. (2012) “Near-miss management systems: A methodological comparison.” Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, 25(3), 609–616. Gnoni, M. G. and Saleh, J. H. (2017) “Near-miss management systems and
observability-in-depth: Handling safety incidents and accident precursors in light of safety principles.” Safety Science, 91, 154–167. Gordon, S., Medenhall, P. and O’Conner, B. B. (2013) “Beyond the checklist: What else health care can learn from aviation teamwork and safety.” Ithaca, NY, ILR Press. HSIB (2021) “National learning report A thematic analysis of HSIB’s first 22
national investigations.” Healthcare Safety Investigation Branch. Available at https://hsib-kqcco125-media.s3.amazonaws.com/assets/documents/HSIB_A_th ematic_analysis_of_HSIBs_first_22_national_investigations_Report_V10.pdf (Accessed 15 January 2022). Heinrich, H. W., Petersen, D. C. and Roos, N. (eds) (1980) “Industrial accident prevention: A safety management approach.” 5th edn, New York, McGraw-Hill. Hodges, M. S. and Sanders, C. E. (2014) “Nuclear criticality accident safety, near
misses and classification.” Progress in Nuclear Energy, 76, 88–99. Hughes, P., Figueres-Esteban, M. and van Gulijk, C. (2015) “Learning from textbased close call data.” Proceedings of the 25th European Safety and Reliability Conference, Zürich, Switzerland. Boca Raton, CRC Press, pp. 31–38. IAEA. (2020) “Nuclear Power Plant Operating Experience from the Iaea/Nea Inter-
national Reporting System for Operating Experience 2015-2017.” International Atomic Energy Agency. Available at https://www.oecd-nea.org/nsd/pubs/2020/ 7482-npp-operating-experience.pdf (Accessed 28 November 2021). Köhler, F. (2010) “Barriers to Near-miss Reporting in the Maritime Domain.” Thesis, Institutionen för datavetenskap Linköpings universitet. Available at http: //www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:381821/FULLTEXT01.pdf (Accessed 11 May 2020). Macrae, C. (2014) “Close Calls: Managing risk and resilience in airline flight safety.”
London, Palgrave Macmillan UK.
Manuele, F. A. (2011) “Heinrich: Dislodging Two Myths from the Practice of Safety.”
Professional Safety, 56, 52–61. Marks, C. M., Kasda, E., Paine, L. and Wu, A. W. (2013) “That Was a Close Call: Endorsing a Broad Definition of Near Misses in Health Care.” Joint Commission journal on quality and patient safety, 39(10), 475–479. Multer, J., Ranney, J., Hile, J. and Raslear, T. (2013) “Developing an effective corre-
ctive action process.” In Dadashi, N., Scott, A., Wilson, J. and Mills, A. (eds) Rail Human Factors, Taylor & Francis, 659–668. NPSA. (2004) “Seven steps to patient safety: The full reference guide.” National Patient Safety Agency. Peerally, M. F., Carr, S., Waring, J. and Dixon-Woods, M. (2017) “The problem with
root cause analysis.” BMJ quality & safety, 26(5), 417–422. Reason, J. T. (1997) “Managing the risks of organizational accidents.” London, Routledge. Saks, J., Multer, J. and Blythe, K. (2004) “Proceedings of the human factors work-
shop: improving railroad safety through understanding close calls.” Available at https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/9350. Saunders, F. (2015) “Safety–critical industries: definitions, tensions and tradeoffs.”
Available at http://fionasaunders.co.uk/safety-critical-industries-definitions-tensi ons-and-tradeoffs/ (Accessed 10 January 2022). Sheridan, T., Cardosi, K. and Hannon, D. (2004) “Rating the Severity of Close- Call Events.” Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 48(16), 2050–2054. Smith, C. L. and Borgonovo, E. (2007) “Decision making during nuclear power plant
incidents: a new approach to the evaluation of precursor events.” Risk analysis, 27(4), 1027–1042. Wears, R. L. (2012) “Rethinking healthcare as a safety—critical industry.” Work, 41 Suppl 1, 4560–4563. Wincek, J. C. (2016) “Amiss, a miss, a near miss.” Process Safety Progress, 35(2),
137–142. Woodier, N. L. (2022) “Using near misses to improve safety in healthcare through learning from safety-critical industries: a scoping review.” Open Science Framew- ork. Wright, L. and van der Schaaf, T. (2004) “Accident versus near miss causation: a cri-
tical review of the literature, an empirical test in the UK railway domain, and their implications for other sectors.” Journal of hazardous materials, 111(1), 105–110.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Healthcare and Medical Devices
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-27-8
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional