INTRODUCTION
According to Eurostat (2011, p. 11-12) in 2008 there were 20 million of enterprises in EU (27)including 20,5 million SMEs. The firms employ 135,8 million people including 90,6 million employed by SMEs and deliver 6,176 billion EUR value added including 3,617 billion EUR generated by SMEs (table 1). At the same time there were 1556 thousand enterprises in Poland including 95,5 % Micro, 3,3% small, 1,0% Medium-size and 0,2% large firms.
Table.1. Enterprise size class analysis of key indicators, nonfinancial business economy, EU-27, 2008 Number of enterprises Persons employed Value added Apparent labour
Source: Eurostat 2011, p.11
The SMEs, when being entrepreneurial, have strong influence on an economy’s strength and stability. They affect the economy by innovations and job creation (Barringer, Ireland, 2012, p.47; Bjerke, 2007, p16). To these two effects Safin (2008, p.50-61) adds influence on: ecology, macro economy, stability, regional deconcentration, mobilization of capital and economy transformation. The importance of SMEs to the economy makes interest about their survival rate. The survival rate in chosen economics is presented in figure 1.
100,00% 90,00%
80,00% 70,00%
60,00%
Italy
50,00%
Korea
40,00%
US
30,00% 20,00%
10,00% 0,00%
1 year 2 years 3 years 4 years
Figure.1. Enterprise survival rate (2006 cohort) Source: OECD, 2013, p.52-53
According to PARP (2013, p.22) survival rate in 2011 in Polish SMEs was: 76,6% (1 year), 54% (2 years), 32% (5 years). It seems that such rapid decrease of the rate can be slowed down when the ability of SMEs to identify the opportunities is improved.
OPPORTUNITY AND ENTREPRENUARSHIP As reported by Davidson, there are, in principle three different ways to define entrepreneurs and entrepreneurship:
1. Using those skills characterizing entrepreneurs. 2. Using those processes and events which are part of entrepreneurship. 3. Using those results that entrepreneurship leads to (Bjerke, 2007, p.16).
The first way defining entrepreneurship is presented by authors who stress on features of entrepreneurship and traits. Example giving Bridge, O’Neill and Cromie identified the following features (Bjerke, 2007, p.82-83): achievement motivation, risk-taking propensity, locus of control, need for autonomy, determination, initiative, creativity, self- confidence and trust. Timmons, Delmer, Zimmer and Scarorugh and Allen list traits (Bjerke, 2007, p.83-84): responsibility, opportunity obsession, desire for immediate feedback, future orientation, tolerance and ambiguity, over-optimism, high commitment and leadership.
Barringer and Ireland (Barringer, Ireland, 2012, p.35-42) mentioned the following characteristics of successful entrepreneurs: passion for the business, product/customer focus and execution intelligence. The authors list also such traits as: a moderate risk taker, a networker, achievement motivated, alert to opportunities, creative, decisive, energetic, a strong work ethic, lengthy attention span, optimistic disposition, persuasive, promoter, resource assembler/leverage, self-confident, self-starter, tenacious, tolerant and ambiguity and visionary.
Dominiak et al (2005, p.22-25) has divided the operational competencies of the owner/manager of small or medium enterprise into entrepreneurial, managerial and technical competencies. To the first category the authors count: perseverance, tendency to risk taking, creativity and flexibility.
Some kind of summarization of the above traits are the following statements: “Entrepreneurs see opportunity where other people only see problems if anything at all” (Bjerke, 2007, p.83), “…the identification and exploitation of (technological) opportunities are what distinguish entrepreneurs, i.e. innovation”(Braunerhjelm, 2011, p.165), “The entrepreneur is innovative, i.e. perceives and creates new opportunities..”.
The second way of defining the entrepreneurship can be illustrated by sentences like:
- Entrepreneurship is “the cognitive process by which… entrepreneurial behavior” (: Audretsch, Heblich, 2011, p.245);
- Entrepreneurship is “some kind of creative process, as grabbing an opportunity or exploiting a possibility” (Bjerke, 2007, s.98).
Third way of defining entrepreneurship is focused on the effects it leads to. For example Kirzner says that entrepreneurship leads to finding new market niches for existing or adopted products (Stam, Nooteboom, 2011, p.429) and Barringer and Ireland (2012,p.33-35) among the reasons of becoming entrepreneurs list “pursue financial rewards” although they add that typically it is secondary to reasons like to be their own boss” and “to pursue their own ideas”.
Most definitions are a mix of these three way. An example can be definition by Coulter. An entrepreneurship is the process whereby an individual or a group of individuals use organized efforts and means to pursue opportunities to create value and grow by fulfilling wants and needs through innovation and uniqueness, no matter what resources are currently controlled (Bjerke, 2007, p.16).
No matter in what way an entrepreneurship is defined, usually the entrepreneurship is connected with opportunities. In fact the opportunity is defining factor of entrepreneurship. There are a lot of examples of this. Some of them are:
- Entrepreneurship is about opportunity – recognizing it, seizing it and exploiting it – but it is also about failing sometimes (Bjerke, 2007, p.184),
- Entrepreneurship is a response to opportunities created by investment in new knowledge (Acs, 2011, p.238).
- Opportunity entrepreneurship is a kind of entrepreneurship in which a perceived opportunity is exploited (Lowe, Marriott, 2007, p.243).
Although opportunity is a defining factor of entrepreneurs it is rater rarely defined itself by the authors writing on entrepreneurship. Some exception is the definition by Barringer and Izreland (2012, p.69). According to them an opportunity is a favorable set of circumstances that creates a need for a new product, service, or business. In this paper an opportunity is as a situation appearing in the environment of the enterprise that favors the achievement of the enterprise’s intented goal or desirable effects (Trzcielinski, Trzcielinska, 2011, p.12). Comparing with the definition by Barringer and Ireland it extends the domain of opportunities from the needs of the external stakeholders to include the needs of the enterprise, e.g. access to cheaper suppliers, more competent labor forces or more attractive loans. Because the opportunities favor to achieve the business goals it is important to enhance the enterprise’s ability to perceive the opportunities. As Barringer (2012, p.81) states an opportunity cannot be pursued until it’s recognized.
The literature provides some recommendation how to increase the enterprise’s opportunities recognition. Baron and Shane recommend following (Bjerk, 2007, p.92-95): build a broad and rich knowledge base, organize your knowledge, increase your access to information, create connections between the knowledge you have, build your practical intelligence, mix your eagerness for hits with wariness of false alarm. Barringer and Ireland (2012, p.81- 83) give the personal characteristic of the entrepreneur. It includes: prior experience, cognitive factors, social networks and creativity. They also distinguish three approaches that can be used to identify an opportunity (Barringer, Ireland, 2012, p.70-80):
- Observing trends in cross section of PEST analysis,
- Solving a problem after it is recognized by observation the challenges that people encounter in their daily lives and through more simple means, such as intuition, or chance,
- Finding gaps in the marketplace.
In this paper some preliminary results of investigation how Polish SMEs search for opportunity is presented.
THE RESEARCH The subject of the research
The research has been focus on finding if Polish SMEs identify opportunity using:
1. Methods of strategic analysis. These methods can be divided into two groups: used to analyze the macroenvironment and the industry environment. In the first group the following methods were investigated: SWOT, trends extrapolation, Delphi method, scenarios methods. In the second group the interest was about: strategic group analysis, Porter’s Five Forces, sector attractiveness and white intelligence of economy. 2. Marketing methods like: satisfaction of customer, product preferences, market share, brand trust, effectiveness of price policy and effectiveness of promotion. 3. Try and fail approach to find the gaps in the market place.
The subject of the research is presented at Figure 2.
Methods of Environment analysis
Marketing research methods
Observation and analysis of the
Market research
environment
Knowledge of the environment and its changes
Entrepreneurial behavior
Events and situations in the environment
OPPORTUNITY Resources Goals
Figure.2. The method of collecting date Source: Trzcielińska J. 2013, p. 189 – 201
The method of collecting data The data were collected by direct interview of owners or managing directors of enterprises located in different regions of Poland. The firms belong to manufacturing and service industries. The data concerning the first subject of investigation where collected from 218 firms including 51 small, 89 medium and 78 big enterprises. The data concerning the second and third research subject were obtained from 68 firms including 6 small, 29 medium and 33 big enterprises. The data were collected in the period from 2011 to 2013.
The results Recognition of opportunities should be supported by use of methods that are used to analyze the business environment. Usually the authors point out on methods like PEST analysis and trends identifications (Barringer, 2012, p.70,80; Lambing, 2003,p.112). In this paper more systematic approach to analysis of the enterprise’s environment has been implemented. The author’s interest was about the object of the recognition for opportunities as well as the methods which are dedicated to analyze both the macroenveronment and the industry environment. Also the interest included if the enterprises use the methods systematically themselves or use external consultants to analyze the environment.
45,1% small, 65% of medium and 82,1% of big enterprises analyze the business environment either systematically or occasionally. Table 2 presents the percentage of firms that observe the changes at the markets of customers and suppliers as well as financial and labor markets.
Table.2. Observation of business environment – percentage of firms
Source: own research
The most popular method used to analyze the environment is SWOT (56,0%), following by scenarios methods (52,3%) and Porter’s % forces (50,9%). The frequency of use of these and other methods is presented in Table 3.
Table.3. The use of the methods of analysis business environment - percentage of firms Occasional and systematic use
Source: own research
To recognize who is the customer and what are his needs and next to adjust the product to the customer’s expectations the marketing methods are used. According to the author findings 76,3% of firms are involved in marketing research including 37,3% of small and medium enterprises. The percentage of firms which lead the marketing research is presented in Table 4.
Table.4. Percentage of firms which systematically leads the marketing research Marketing methods used to research: S + M B
The biggest portion of enterprises often promote the products by recommendation of their customers (40,7%) and very often by their websites (35,6%). 40,7% firms never promotes their product with use of electronic mail, 66,1% never use the internal blogs and 62,7% never use the social media like Twitter or Facebook. Table 5 presents what kind of promotion is often and very often used by the enterprises.
Table.5. Ways of product promotion used frequently by firms Used often Used very often Way of promotion
Source: own research
According to the firm’s promotion 84,7% of them are strongly customer oriented. This concerns 90,3% of small and medium and 78,6% of big enterprises. From the other side in 50,8% of firms only the inquisitive customer can learn the advantages of the product (Table 6.).
Source: own research
In case of 20,3% firms the customer can learn himself the functionality and the product operating although it rather difficult. However 54,2% of firms help their customers (Table 7.).
Table.7. Possibility of learning about functionality and the product operating Learning the functionality and the product operating All firms S+M B
Source: own research
Entrepreneurship is understood as an art of turning an idea into a business. Entrepreneur firms are proactive, innovative and risk taking. Typically it tries something new and therefore the failure rate associated with their efforts is naturally high (Barringer, Ireland, 2010, p.32,37). These symptoms of entrepreneurship consist on “try and fail” approach that the firms apply. The author has found that 20,3% enterprises often launch new product to the market and 8,5% of them do this very often. From the other side 20,3% of enterprises introduce the new product seldom and 10,2% very seldom (Table 8.).
Table.8. Percentage of firms that introduce of new product to the market How often the firm launches the new product All firms S+M B
Source: own research
32,2% of firms implement seldom and 13,6% very seldom new technology that is much more than these that do this often or very often (Table 9).
Table.9. Percentage of firms that implement of new technology How often the firm implements the new technology All firms S+M B
Source: own research
32,2% of firms enter the new market seldom and 13.6% very seldom compering with those that do this often (18,6%) or very often (6,8%) (Table 10.).
Table.10. Percentage of firms that enter new markets How often the firm enters a new market All firms S+M B
Source: own research
Discussion of the results The above data (Table 2 to 10) let us to conclude that small and medium enterprises are moderated in systematic observation of the business environment and communication with the market as well as they are rather careful about talking the risk to introduce both new products and technologies and enter new markets. Does it mean that SMEs behave in irrational way? To contribute in answering to this question the author checked the reliability (international consistency) of the criteria that were implement to measure that firms involvement in above activities and then has analyzed if the involvement is correlated with effectiveness of the firms. The reliability was checked with use of the coefficient of Cronbach’s alpha.
Table. 11. Internal consistency of criteria used in the research Criteria Cronbach's alpha Standarized Cronabach's alpha α Internal consisancy Observation of business environment; observation
Source: own research
The Cronbach’s alpha indicato confirms high internal consistency of the criteria and therefore high reliability of the data can be used to investigate if there is a remarkable difference in effectiveness of SMEs that in terms of the criteria are more or less entrepreneurial. In the current stage of the research the effectiveness is measured by:
- Time of existence of the enterprise. Longer time suggests bigger ability to run the business effectively.
- Extent of geographic coverage. The wider scope of the market suggests more entrepreneurial energy of the enterprise that can leads to higher effectiveness of acting.
- Level of income. The higher income creates more opportunities that can be used.
CONCLUSIONS
The presumption of the research was that more entrepreneurial are SMEs, better their results and longer time of their existence. The entrepreneurship of the firms has been estimated by their involvement in observing the environment, use of methods to analyze the environment market research and communication with the market as well as the “try and fail” approach to search and try market opportunities. The research has shown that Polish SMEs are moderately involved in such activities. The percentage of firms that undertake such actions systematically, often or very often very from 5,9% (small firms observe systematically the market of suppliers) to 64,5% (SMEs are systematically involved in investigating the customer’s satisfaction. One of characteristic of SMEs is innovativeness and risk taking. The research has shown that Polish SMEs are rather conservative. The percentage of these that often or very often innovate the product or process vary from 0% (SMEs very often implement new technology) up to 16,1% (SMEs often launch new product to the market). Only 9,7% of them often or very often enter new market while 22,6% and 25,8% do this very seldom or seldom.
The result can be a little bit unreliable as the author still continues the research. This particular concerns the small enterprises. However it seems sure that SMEs absorb knowledge too slowly. The art of state is much better in engineering knowledge than in managerial and organizational knowledge. Of course SMEs have very simple organizational structures and limited human resources. Therefore it can be not expected that SMEs will have deeply and narrowly specialized staff responsible for observing the environment and looking for opportunities. All the more the engineers in SMEs should combine the professional knowledge with the managerial and organizational one.
Table. 12. Pearson correlation coefficient
Source: own research
The analysis of correlation has sown not significant dependence between the measures of effectiveness and observation of the business environment (Table 12).
The only significant relationship exists between involvement of the enterprises in observation of particular markets and implementation of different methods to analyze the environment. However because only a small percentage of SMEs is involved in such activities (particular in systematic way) therefore there is not statistically significant influence of these activities on the enterprises effectiveness.
REFERENCES
Acs, Z. (2011), “Innovation, entrepreneurship and the search for knowledge spillovers”, in: Handbook of Research on Innovation and Entrepreneurship, Audretsch D., Falck O., Heblich S., Lederer A., Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc., USA. Audretsch, D., Falck, O., Heblich, S., Lederer, A. (2011), “Handbook of Research on Innovation and Entrepreneurship”, Edward
Elgar Publishing, Inc., USA. Barringer, B., Ireland, R (2012), “Entrepreneurship. Successfully launching new ventures”, Pearson, England. Bjerke, B. (2007), “Understanding Entrepreneurship”, Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc., USA. Braunerhjelm, P. (2011), “Entrepreneurship, innovation and economic growth: interdependencies, irregularities and regularities”, in:, Handbook of Research on Innovation and Entrepreneurship, Audretsch D., Falck O., Heblich S., Lederer A., Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc., USA. Lowe, R., Marriott, S. (2007), “Enterprise: Entrepreneurship and Innovation. Concepts, Contexts and Commercialization”,
Elsevier. Stam, E., Nooteboom, B. (2011), “Entrepreneurship, innovation and institutions”, in: Handbook of Research on Innovation and Entrepreneurship, Audretsch D., Falck O., Heblich S., Lederer A., Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc., USA. Trzcieliński, S., Trzcielińska, J. (2011), “Some Elements of Theory of Opportunities”, Human Factors and Ergonomics in
Manufacturing & Service Industries. Trzcielińska, J. (2013), „Metody analizy strategicznej jako narzędzie identyfikacji okazji”, in: Red. Trzcieliński S.???, Wydawnictwo Politechniki Poznańskiej, Poznań