Hiromi Masunaga, Tianni Zhou (2022). Reasons why students decide to leave a university. In: The Human Side of Service Engineering. AHFE Open Access, vol. 62, pp. 49–54. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1002540
This project was designed to expand our understanding about (1) who drops out, and (2) what predicts student attrition in the first two years at a university. The university where this project has been conducted is a 4-year Hispanic Serving institution in California. The university currently involves approximately 34,000 undergraduate students, 44% of whom are from Hispanic/Latino background. Other groups are Asian (20%), White (16%), and African-American, American Indian and others (15%). We invited freshmen and sophomores to participate in this project when they had no registered courses two months after the registration period started (i.e., approximately three weeks before the start of the following semester). Our understanding was that the delay in the registration reflected cognitive and non-cognitive factors that would seriously and negatively impact continuous enrollment. A series of surveys and focus groups examined students’ decision-making motives and non-cognitive factors that would inhibit their academic progress, retention, and success. Non-cognitive reasons examined are:1. Financial problems, 2. Poor secondary school preparation, 3. Undecided/ Unsatisfactory majors, 4. Conflict with work and family commitments, 5. Increasing difficulty in academic success/progress, 6. Lack of quality time with faculty and counselors, 7. De-motivating school environment, 8. Undesirable experiences in classes, and 9. Lack of student support (Bownan et al., 2019; Goldrick-Rab, 2018; Kim, 2019; Kirp, 2019ab; Moody, 2019; Sagenmuller, 2019; Saunders-Scott, et al., 2018; Silver Wolf et al., 2017; Yool, 2019). This project additionally examined the impact from COVID-19. As compared to those participants who intended to return to the university, those who indicated that they would not return to the university presented a wider range of inhibiting factors, including: •Financial difficulties •Undecided, Undeclared, Undesirable, & Unsuitable Majors•Difficulties in maintaining good Academic Progress•Not being in contact with faculty & counselors•Not being connected with faculty & advisors•Perceived non-support - “Please reach out to me!”•Intimidation - Difficulty in reaching out to instructors or counselors•Low levels of awareness, access and use of University Support Services•Lack of understanding/support for college education from family•Lack of support on family needs that conflict with academic pursuit•Multitudes of obligations (e.g., financial, caregiving)•Some self-regulatory factors (e.g., time management, procrastination, goal setting)•Difficulty in online modalities of instruction during COVID-19The findings suggest a strong need to systematically support students who struggle. The majority of struggling students are first-time college students in the family, and low-income and under-represented students who have been strongly affected by COVID-19. When struggled, those students were not necessarily aware of campus resources or did not utilize the existing support services even when they were aware. Students sought individualized advising and wanted to be reached out. In order to promote students’ success, a holistic system must be built. For instance, it might be helpful if we try to: (1) unite financial aid, career advising, physical and mental health support, counseling, and academic support in order to ease access by students, and (2) promote student sense of belonging and connectedness as soon as they start their college lives.
The university where this project has been conducted is a 4-year Hispanic- Serving and Asian American and Native American Pacific Islander-Serving institution in Southern California. The university currently enrolls appro- ximately 34,000 undergraduate students, 44% of whom are from Hispa- nic/Latino background. Other groups are Asian (20%), White (16%), and African-American, American Indian and others (15%). We have invited fre- shmen and sophomores to participate in this project when they had no registered courses for the following semester two months after the registra- tion period started. Our understanding was that the delay in the registration reflects cognitive and non-cognitive factors that would seriously and nega- tively impact their continuous enrollment. Reflecting on prior findings by researchers in the field, the following non-cognitive reasons were selected to be examined in this study:1. Financial problems, 2. Poor secondary sch- ool preparation, 3. Undecided/Unsatisfactory majors, 4. Conflict with work and family commitments, 5. Increasing difficulty in academic success/pro- gress, 6. Lack of quality time with faculty and counselors, 7. De-motivating school environment, 8. Undesirable experiences in classes, and 9. Lack of student support (Bownan et al. 2019; Goldrick-Rab, 2018; Kim, 2019; Kirp, 2019ab; Moody, 2019; Sagenmuller, 2019; Saunders-Scott, et al. 2018; Silver Wolf et al. 2017; Yool, 2019). In addition, this project also examined the impact from COVID-19.
CHARACTERISTICS OF STUDENTS WHO DECIDE TO LEAVE A UNIVERSITY How Students Were Approached
A 64-item online survey was developed to (1) determine if the students plan to register for the following semester, (2) identify issues that they need to resolve, if any, before they are able to register for the courses in the follo- wing semester, (3) identify non-cognitive factors that inhibit their academic progress, if any, (4) determine what support they would seek from the univer- sity in order to enable their continued enrollment, (5) determine their overall educational plans and experiences at the university, and (6) closely examine reasons why they do not plan to return if they indicate that they will not regi- ster for courses in the following semester. The majority of questions involved the 5-point Likert Scale response options. To exemplify, a couple of questions in the survey are: “I know my major is the right one for my skills and inte- rests,” and “My advisor and instructors care about my academic success.” Both questions had the five response options ranging from strongly disagree to strongly agree. Some open-ended questions were also included in order to ask respondents to describe the difficulties they had faced in more detail.
The project is currently ongoing. The results reported in this paper are from the survey administered in January 2021, which preceded Spring 2021. Students who completed the survey in January 2021 were also given the opportunity to participate in a focus group to discuss their enrollment situa- tion and academic performance in more depth. Due to COVID-19, the data collection in focus groups was completed using an online whiteboard and zoom. Given a unique modality utilized in a focus group, the interviews were completed on an individual basis to provide a secure and private discussion (approximately 15 minutes/session). When students agreed to participate in focus group discussion, the following preliminary questions were sent to them to allow them to prepare their thoughts for the live discussion:
What factors affected you in the last semester you enrolled in the university?
Was COVID-19 a big factor in why enrollment was difficult?
What can the university do to make enrollment easier?
Tell us about the struggles you have had at the university.
What can the university do to make your academic experience better?
What Was Revealed On January 8, 2021, a link to the survey was sent to 1,391 students, and 188 students responded to the survey by the end of January. Data were analy- zed after excluding 53 respondents who remained “in progress” through the survey administration period. This provided us with 134 participants whose responses were analyzed. The majority of respondents indicated that they had not registered for Spring 2021 courses because they faced difficulties in: successfully completing course work; financial security; selecting major/ca- reer goals; being connected with faculty/advisors; and seeking help & using university services.
Reasons Why Students Decide to Leave a University 51
Table 1. Non-cognitive factors.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Factors Examples: Student Perceptions Financial Problem Persisting financial difficulties Lack of quality time with faculty and counselors
Not being connected with faculty & advisors Not being in contact with faculty & counselors Intimidation (e.g., difficult or not ready to reach out to instructors or counselors) Lack of student support Perceived non-support (e.g., “Please reach out to me!”) Low levels of awareness, access, and use of University Support Services Conflict with work and family commitments
Lack of understanding/support for college edu- cation from family Lack of support on family needs that conflict with academic pursuit Student self-regulation Some self-regulatory factors (e.g., time mana- gement, procrastination, goal setting) Pandemic-related Multitudes of obligations (e.g., financial, care- giving)
Table 2. Cognitive factors.
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Factors Examples: Student Perceptions Undecided/unsatisfactory college majors Undecided, undeclared, undesirable, & unsui- table majors Increasing difficulty in academic success/progress
Difficulty in maintaining good academic pro- gress Difficulty in catching up after failing Pandemic-related Difficulty in online modalities of instruction during COVID-19
One of the crucial goals of the survey data analyses was to reveal what differentiate “those who ultimately drop out” from “those who do not” even when the students encounter similar challenges (e.g., low GPA, fina- ncial difficulties). Sixty-six percent of the survey respondents indicated that they were either “extremely” or “somewhat” likely to return to the univer- sity, and the remaining 34% indicated either “extremely” or “somewhat” unlikely to return. Our data indicated that as compared to those who had an intention to return to the university, those who would not return to the university had more intense difficulties related to the inhibiting factors, which included Financial Problems, Lack of quality time with faculty and counselors, Lack of student support, Conflict with work and family com- mitments, Their own unsatisfactory levels of self-regulation, Undecided/un- satisfactory majors, Increasing difficulty in academic success/progress, and Pandemic-related difficulties.
52 Masunaga and Zhou
Supportive Framework for Student Retention and Success The findings suggest a strong need to systematically support students who struggle. The majority of struggling students are first-time college stu- dents in the family, and those who come from low-income and under- represented families and demographic groups that have been severely affected by COVID-19. When struggling, those students were not necessarily aware of campus resources or did not utilize the existing support services even when they were aware. Students sought individualized advising and wanted the uni- versity to reach out to them. In order to promote students’ success, a holistic system must be built. For instance, it might be helpful if we try to: (1) unite financial aid, career advising, physical and mental health support, counse- ling, and academic support in order to ease and foster access by students, and (2) promote a sense of belonging and connectedness between students and faculty, advisors, counselors, peers, and student support services as soon as they start their college lives. To that end, building powerful learning com- munities and sound systems for faculty- and peer-mentoring support could be one useful strategy. Particularly, during the current unique time during the pandemic, it is important for us to recognize that multitudes of issues (e.g., economic challenges, racism, and COVID-19) intersect in the lives of at-risk students who are from minoritized and disadvantaged groups.
CONCLUSION
It is unfortunate that U.S. college student attrition has drastically increased over the years. Nearly one-third of students in the nation drop out of col- lege before the start of their second year (Venit & Bevevino, 2020). One contributing factor is that increasingly more “new-gen” students (e.g., poor, minority, or first-gen students), as named by Kirp (2019a), have entered the colleges lately. The entry of new-gen students has introduced unique needs to universities in relation to sustainable accommodations, food security, expan- ded student support services, and additional campus networks. According to Stein (2018): …, first-generation students feel unprepared for college, have a lack of funds for college and are more likely to work while attending college than other generational students and express challenges in integration with the college community. First-generation students have also been found to experience “less support from their family in attending college and spend less time socializing with their peers and talking with their teachers in high school.” Both problems are linked to factors that affect college success.
Because students who cannot meet their basic needs tend to lag aca- demically, educational strategies and practices must be realigned with the additional needs that new-gen students bring in, in a way that matches their explicit difficulties. In addition, the pandemic has added another layer of dif- ficulties on those students’ college lives. Due to COVID-19, students tend to have increased obligations from school, family and work that intertwine and conflict, and have suddenly been asked to find a way to adjust their lives
Reasons Why Students Decide to Leave a University 53
with new modes of instruction and different demands that online, hyflex, and hybrid instruction would bring. Students have felt increasingly more isolated. To support students’ academic success in the current trying time, it is impor- tant that truly student-ready universities need to emerge immediately. Those student-ready universities should be able to provide their students with more integrated and holistic support. To meet the goal, the universities that aspire to become student-ready must carefully revisit their fiscal structure so they can make important decisions to quickly and sufficiently allocate necessary resources to enable effective and holistic student support. For instance, for students with financial need, it is important that they be financially suppor- ted through participation in university programs (e.g., through stipends) as opposed to off campus employment. This will allow those students to have more financial stability while benefitting from university programs that are designed to enrich their lives and improve their academic success.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors would like to acknowledge the generous support from the Uni- versity Provost’s Office. This work was funded as one of the Student Success projects under the Student Success Initiative of California State University, Long Beach.
REFERENCES
Bowman, N., Miller, N., Woosley, S., Maxwell, N., Kolze, M. (2019). Understanding the link between noncognitive attributes and college retention. Research in Higher Education, 60(2), 135–152. Goldrick-Rab, S. (2018, January 14). It’s hard to study if you’re hungry. Retri-
eved from https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/14/opinion/hunger-college-food-in security.html Kim, P. (2019b, November 12). 23 College dropout statistics that will surprise you.
Retrieved from https://www.creditdonkey.com/college-dropout-statistics.html Kirp, D. (2019a). The college dropout scandal. New York: Oxford University Press.
Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/02/opinion/sunday/graduatio n-rates-wayne-state.html Kirp, D. (2019b, March 2). When your college has your back. New York Times.
Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/02/opinion/sunday/graduatio n-rates-wayne-state.html Moody, J. (2019, March 20). How to avoid dropping out of college. Retrieved from https://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/articles/2019-03-20/drop ping-out-of-college-why-students-do-so-and-how-to-avoid-it Sagenmuller, I. (2019) Student Retention: 8 Reasons People Drop Out of Higher
Education. U-Planner. Retrieved from https://www.u-planner.com/en-us/blog/stu dent-retention-8-reasons-people-drop-out-of-higher-education Saunders-Scott, D., Braley, M., & Stennes-Spidahl, N. (2018). Traditional and vpsychological factors associated with academic success: Investigating best predictors of college retention. Motivation and Emotion, 42(4), 459–465. Silver Wolf, D.A., Perkins, J., Butler-Barnes, S.T., & Walker, T.A. (2017). Social belon-
ging and college retention: Results from a quasi-experimental pilot study. Journal of College Student Development, 58(5), 777–782.
54 Masunaga and Zhou
Stein, C. (2018, July 23). The push for higher education: College attrition rates.
American Society for Public Administration. Retrieved from https://patimes.org/ the-push-for-higher-education-college-attrition-rates/ Yool, C. (2018). Student employment and persistence: Evidence of effect heterogeneity of student employment on college dropout. Research in Higher Education, 59(1), 88–107. Venit, E. & Bevevino, D. (2020). Student success playbook: 14 recommendations
to improve student outcomes and ensure financial sustainability across the next decade. Washington, DC: EAB.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
The Human Side of Service Engineering
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-38-4
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional