Ao Zhu, Lee Yu-Chi (2022). Changes on Foot Dimensions with Elevated Heel Heights: A Pilot Study. In: Digital Human Modeling and Applied Optimization. AHFE Open Access, vol. 46, pp. 63–69. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe1001900
BackgroundWearing high-heeled shoes (HHS) has been reported to be one of the leading causes of various feet health issues, including hallux valgus, osteoarthritis, ankle sprains, and musculoskeletal disorders. Even so, females are still willing to wear HHS to increase their leg proportions and beauty. Foot dimensions were considered as a primary measure of foot deformation and related to the fitness and comfort of wearing HHS. Footwear designers and manufacturers need to consider these foot dimensional changes with elevated heel heights to fit the foot deformation. However, available information about the changes in foot dimensions with elevated heel heights is still lacking. Hence, the current study aimed to evaluate the change in the nine foot dimensions when wearing HHS with different heel heights.MethodsTen young women (age 23± 3.0 years, height 161.7± 5.5 cm, weight 53.1± 12.5 kg) with foot lengths between 230 to 240 mm were recruited in the pilot study. A 3D foot scanner was used to collect digital foot models, and the nine commonly used foot measurements for footwear design were measured, including foot length, ball of foot length, outside ball of foot length, foot breath diagonal, foot breath horizontal, instep height, navicular height, and toe height. Four elevated heel heights (low heel: 30 mm; medium-high: 50 mm; medium-high heel: 70 mm, and high heel: 90 mm) were selected for evaluation. Each condition was scanned twice, and the mean of the foot dimensions was calculated for analysis. A one-way ANOVA with Tukey post hoc test was performed to evaluate the heel height effect on the measured foot dimensions.ResultsHeel heights significantly impacted foot length, ball of foot length, outside ball of foot length, instep height, and navicular height (all p< 0.01). The result of ANOVA showed that with elevated heel heights (from 30 mm to 90 mm), the instep height and navicular height became higher, whereas foot length, ball of foot length, and outside ball of foot length were shortened. No significant difference was obtained in width-related dimensions and toe height. The Tukey post hoc results indicated that no significant foot dimensional difference was obtained except for foot length between the 30 mm and 50 mm heel height. Moreover, the instep height and navicular height were significantly increased as the heel height elevated from 70 mm to 90 mm.ConclusionsThe heel heights have a significant influence on the length- and height-related foot dimensions, resulting in foot deformations. This effect was especially noteworthy, starting from 70 mm heel height. Observed changes in foot dimensions provide a dimensional reference for shoe last design and footwear production of young women’s HHS. The findings of this study could provide helpful information for designers regarding the foot deformations of young women under different heel heights.
Wearing high heeled shoes (HHS) has been reported to be one of the leading causes of various foot health issues, including hallux valgus, osteoarthritis, ankle sprains, and musculoskeletal disorders (Snow and Williams, 1994). Even so, females are still willing to wear HHS to increase their leg length for better body proportions on beauty.
Digital technology can be used as a strategic tool for new wearable pro- duct development to save time and costs. This is especially vital in the shoe industry, particularly for HHS, where striking a balance between comfort and appearance is challenging. With the development of 3D foot scanning techno- logy and computer-aided design/manufacturing systems, many studies have been conducted on the effect of heel height for HHS. Lee and Hong (2005) reported that increasing heel height change foot pressure, impact force, and perceived comfort during walking based on experimental combinations of 10 mm (flat), 51 mm (low), and 76 mm (high) heel heights. Hapsari and Xiong (2016) investigated the wearing experience of HHS and the effect of heel hei- ght on human standing balance. The results showed that 70 mm heel height
resulted in worse functional mobility. Wan et al. (2017) developed a rapid 3D foot scanning system to obtain 3D foot anthropometric measurements while wearing HHS and discussed the dimensions related to the metatarsal- phalangeal joint and toe box design. Moreover, Milazzo et al. (2020) focused on combining the results from the digital and experimental synergies to design HHS.
Foot dimension was considered a primary measure of foot deformation and related to the fitness and comfort of wearing HHS. Two-dimensional anthropometry, three-dimensional scanning, and digital human modeling have been utilized to analyse the human foot. Foot dimensions are pivotal for footwear design and production, which is easily accessible and directly applicable. Dimensional differences were found strongly correlated with the footwear fit. Footwear design needs to consider not only foot length but also foot width and mid-foot region (Witana et al., 2004). Studies of foot shape changes provided an accurate reference for HHS design (Milazzo et al., 2020; Shariff et al., 2019). Therefore, HHS designers and manufacturers need to consider these foot dimensional changes with elevated heel heights to fit the foot deformation (Luximon et al., 2020).
However, available information about the changes on foot dimensions with elevated heel heights is still lacking. Hence, this pilot study aimed to evaluate the changes on the seven foot dimensions when wearing HHS with different heel heights.
METHODS
Participants Ten young women (age 23±3.0 years, height 161.7±5.5 cm, weight 53.1±12.5 kg) participated in the study. All the participants had HHS wea- ring experience (with a minimum heel height of 40 mm two or more times per week and at least 8 hours per day in the past year) by self-reported. Due to the reason of time constraints and a majority of proportion in the female population, the participants with foot sizes from 235 to 240 mm were first evaluated. The data were collected in 2021 at the South China University of Technology, China. All the participants were self-reported to have no expe- rience of any pain or diseases in their foot, ankle, or lower back at least one year prior to the study. Written informed consents were obtained from each study subject before the experiment.
Equipment The four elevated heel heights (30, 50, 70, and 90 mm) were selected for the evaluation according to the recommendation of the AKA64 design system (Luximon et al., 2020). This set of footbeds encompasses the most regularly worn heel heights in daily use. A 3D foot scanner (INFOOT USB scan- ning system, IFU-S01, I-ware Laboratory Co., Ltd, Japan), was utilized for collecting digital 3D foot models. The scanner consisted of 8 CCD came- ras to capture lasers in order to obtain the entire foot dimensions with a scanning duration of about 10 seconds. The scanning volume was L400 x
Changes on Foot Dimensions With Elevated Heel Heights: A Pilot Study 65
B200 × H150 (mm) and the accuracy of the foot scanner is 1.0 mm. The scanner was confirmed as an accurate and reliable instrument for measuring the foot dimensions (Lee et al., 2014).
Experiment Procedure Landmarking and Scanning To obtain the digital foot model, foot landmarking and scanning of the par- ticipant’s right foot were performed. The participants’ feet were disinfected and dried prior to scanning. The four anatomical points on the right foot surface were identified and pasted with markers including Metatarsal tibia (MT), Metatarsal fibula (MF), Navicular, and Tentative junction point of the foot & leg (TJP) (Shariff et al., 2019). Subsequently, a footbed was placed inside the scanner and the order of each heel height was randomized for each participant.
During the scanning, all participants were asked to stand on a specific heel height of a footbed with both feet and requested to stand still in a natu- ral standing posture. The footbeds were cut from real HHS and applied to simulate wearing a high heel shoe to easily scan the side view of the foot. Only the right foot was aligned and scanned under the equal balance on feet. Each right foot was scanned twice to ensure the quality of the foot model. After every scanning, a foot model with a footbed and the four landmarks were checked with integrity and then stored in STL format.
Foot Measurements Calculation All scanned data were processed in Polyworks Inspector (version 2020, Inno- vMetric, Quebec, Canada) to calculate the seven foot dimensions from the 3D foot models. The procedure was referred to the study of Schwarz-Müller et al. (2021). The generated 3D mesh foot model was realigned according to 1) the x-y plane was aligned with the bottom plane of the footbed and, 2) the foot axis was defined as a vector projected on the x-y plane from the pternion to the center point (CP). The CP is located in width of the ball girth cross- section which passes through MT & MF. The alignment rules were referred to in the previous study (Hsieh et al., 2022). Each condition was measured twice by one trained experimenter, and the mean of each foot dimension was calculated for further analysis.
Seven commonly used foot measurements for footwear design were col- lected and the definitions of foot dimensions obtained in this study were summarized in Table 1.
Statistical Analysis The data were analyzed using SPSS 26.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, United States) with the significance level set at 0.05. Before the test, Kolmogorov- Smirnov and Levene’s tests were performed to verify data normality and variance homogeneity. The effects of elevated heel heights were tested by one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA). Then, the Tukey post hoc test was conducted for post hoc comparisons. To determine the effect size and power of the significant effects, partial η2 and power tests were used.
66 Zhu and Lee
Table 1. Definitions of seven foot dimensions. (Lee et al., 2014; Redmond et al., 2008; Witana et al., 2006)
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Definitions of foot dimensions
Category of foot parameters Length 1. Foot length (FL): The distance from the pternion to the tip of the longest toe along the Foot axis (X-direction). 2. Ball of foot length (BFL): The length measured parallel to the foot axis from the end of the heel to the metatarsal tibia. 3. Outside ball of foot length (OBFL): The length measured parallel to the foot axis from the end of the heel to the metatarsal fibula. Width 4. Foot width diagonal (FWD): The straight width between the metatarsal tibia and metatarsal fibula. 5. Heel width (HW): The width of the heel at 16% of foot length forward of the pternion. Height 6. Instep height (IH): Maximum height of the vertical cross-section at 50% of foot length from the pternion. 7. Navicular height (NH): The vertical distance from the prominent navicular bone to the standing surface.
Table 2. One-way ANOVA and Tukey post hoc test results on the seven foot dimensions (unit: mm).
Table available in the original PDF paper.
Length Width Height Heel height
FL BFL OBFL FWD HW IH NH
Low heel 30 mm 230.615 A
170.339 A
144.964 A
92.747 59.771 59.901 A
35.111 A Medium heel
50 mm 226.405 B
165.293 A
142.910 AB
90.725 59.990 66.448 A
34.634 A Medium high heel
70 mm 217.767 C
159.526 B
136.550 B
90.617 59.857 82.105 B
38.532 AB High heel 90 mm 205.407 D
146.485 C
126.768 C
90.043 59.450 111.585 C
44.155 B Sig *** *** *** NS NS *** ** **Significant at p < 0.01, ***Significant at p < 0.001; NS: non-significant; A, B, C, D: Tukey grouping code.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The results of the one-way ANOVA (Table 2) summarized the overall signi- ficant difference between the four heel conditions for all the seven foot measures. Elevated heel heights had a significant impact on foot dimensi- ons in length- (FL, BFL, OBFL) and height-related measures (IH, NH), with all p< 0.01, except for width-related foot parameters (FWD and HW).
As heel heights elevated from 30 mm (low heel) to 90 mm (high heel), the IH [F(3, 36) = 104.871, p < 0.001, η2 = 0.897, 1−β = 1.000] and NH [F(3, 36) = 4.565, p < 0.01, η2 = 0.276, 1−β = 0.849] became lar- ger, whereas FL [F(3, 36) = 113.525, p < 0.001, η2 = 0.904, 1−β = 1.000], BFL [F(3, 36) = 50.315, p < 0.001, η2 = 0.807, 1−β = 1.000], and OBFL
Changes on Foot Dimensions With Elevated Heel Heights: A Pilot Study 67 [F(3, 36) = 19.088, p < 0.001, η2 = 0.614, 1−β = 1.000] were shortened. The Tukey post hoc results indicated that no significant foot dimensional diffe- rence was obtained between the 30 mm and 50 mm heel height, except for FL. The IH and NH were significantly increased as the heel height elevated from 50 mm to 90 mm. Moreover, there was a substantial variation in foot dimensions between the 70 mm and 90 mm heel heights, except for NH.
The longest length parameters were observed on low heel height (30 mm), with 230.615 mm for FL, 170.339 mm for BFL, and 144.964 mm for OFBL. The smallest length parameters were discovered when wearing the 90 mm heel height. FL, BFL, and OBFL at the 90 mm heel height is much shor- ter about 25.208 mm in FL, 23.854 mm in BFL, and 18.196 mm in OBFL compared with the 30 mm heel height.
Changes on length-related dimensions might be owing to a shift of the plantar pressure towards the forefoot region (especially the metatarsal area). This interpretation was consistent with the findings of other studies in HHS, in which plantar pressure was highest under the metatarsal heads and medial forefoot with elevated heel heights (Branthwaite et al., 2013; Melvin et al., 2019; Snow et al., 1992; Lee and Hong, 2005). Moreover, change on length- related foot dimensions might lead to the lack of footwear fit which results in slippage from the heel, as well as abrasion and ulceration in the heel area to increase the incidence of foot trips and falls (Davis et al., 2016).
The width-related dimensions did not change significantly, observed small differences in width-related dimensions (maximum difference of 2.704 mm in FWD, 0.321 mm in HW) in this study. The results were agreed with the work of Wan et al., (2017).
For the height-related foot dimensions, the IH was found to be the highest on heels elevated at 90 mm (111.585 ± 9.988 mm), followed by heels elevated at 70 mm (82.105±7.672 mm), 50 mm (66.448±5.755 mm), and 30 mm (59.901±3.219 mm). The largest NH was found on a 90 mm elevated heel (44.155±8.230 mm). Excessive IH may affect human standing balance and functional mobility. The heel elevation causes more effort from lower limb muscles (especially calf muscles) and leads to decreased functional mobility (Hapsari and Xiong, 2016). NH has a very direct physical meaning; a high foot arch causes an imbalance in the body and reduces its cushioning effect against gravity and ground reaction forces (Xiong et al., 2010).
Furthermore, changes on IH and NH can have a significant impact on the midfoot shape, which is critical for shoe upper design. The dorsal side of the foot will be under much pressure if the upper of HHS is too low. Once the top of the HHS is excessively high, the foot moves back and forth continu- ously and resulted in exerting pressure on the toes (Xiong and Goonetilleke, 2006). Therefore, the IH and NH of the midfoot shape were needed to take into consideration the compensation in the shoe upper design when designing HHS for young women.
Generally, the results of this preliminary study suggest that foot dimensions change proportionally with different heel elevations, as statistically signifi- cant mean differences were found in five of the seven foot measurements. With the elevated heel heights, FL, OBFL, and BFL extended less, IH and NH heights became higher. The heel area and shoe upper of HHS needed to
68 Zhu and Lee
be redesigned based on the changes of the foot dimensions, especially under the 70 mm and 90 mm heel height.
There are several limitations of this pilot study. Only young and healthy female subjects were studied and the sample size is relatively small. The defi- nition of foot dimensions utilized in this study has an impact on the study’s findings and application to footwear design.
CONCLUSION
The heel heights have a significant influence on the length and height-related foot dimensions and resulting in foot deformations. The effect was espe- cially noteworthy, starting from 70 mm heel height. Observed changes on foot dimensions provide dimensional references for HHS design and footw- ear production for young women. The findings of this study could provide helpful information for designers regarding the foot deformations of young women under different heel heights.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This research was supported by the South China University of Technology (Grant numbers D6192270).
REFERENCES
Branthwaite, H., Chockalingam, N., & Greenhalgh, A. (2013). The effect of shoe toe box shape and volume on forefoot interdigital and plantar pressures in healthy females. Journal of Foot and Ankle Research, 6(1), 28. Davis, A. M., Galna, B., Murphy, A. T., Williams, C. M., & Haines, T. P. (2016).
Effect of footwear on minimum foot clearance, heel slippage and spatiotemporal measures of gait in older women. Gait & Posture, 44, 43–47. Hapsari, V. D., & Xiong, S. (2016). Effects of high heeled shoes wearing experience and heel height on human standing balance and functional mobility. Ergonomics, 59(2), 249–264. Hsieh, M.C., Zhu, A., & Lee, Y.C. (2022). Stature estimation from various three-
dimensional anthropometric foot measurements of Taiwanese female population. Legal Medicine, 54, 102000. Lee, Y.H., & Hong, W.H. (2005). Effects of shoe inserts and heel height on foot pressure, impact force, and perceived comfort during walking. Applied Ergonomics, 36(3), 355–362. Lee, Y. C., Kouchi, M., Mochimaru, M., & Wang, M. J. (2015). Comparing 3D
Foot Shape Models Between Taiwanese and Japanese Females. Journal of Human Ergology, 44(1), 11–20. Lee, Y. C., Lin, G., & Wang, M. J. J. (2014). Comparing 3D foot scanning with conventional measurement methods. Journal of Foot and Ankle Research, 7(1). Luximon, A., Jiang, L., & Luximon, Y. (2020). Sizing and grading methods with
consideration of footwear styles. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 78(June 2019), 102960. Melvin, J. M. A., Price, C., Preece, S., Nester, C., & Howard, D. (2019). An investigation into the effects of, and interaction between, heel height and shoe upper stiffness on plantar pressure and comfort. Footwear Science, 11(1), 25–34.
Changes on Foot Dimensions With Elevated Heel Heights: A Pilot Study 69
Milazzo, M., Spezzaneve, A., Persichetti, A., Tomasi, M., Peselli, V., Messina, A., Gambineri, F., Aringhieri, G., & Roccella, S. (2020). Digital and experi- mental synergies to design high-heeled shoes. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 109(1–2), 385–395. Redmond, A. C., Crane, Y. Z., & Menz, H. B. (2008). Normative values for the Foot
Posture Index. Journal of Foot and Ankle Research, 1(1), 6. Schwarz-Müller, F., Marshall, R., Summerskill, S., & Poredda, C. (2021). Measuring the efficacy of positioning aids for capturing 3D data in different clothing confi- gurations and postures with a high-resolution whole-body scanner. Measurement: Journal of the International Measurement Confederation, 169(September 2020), 108519. Shariff, S. M., Merican, A. F., & Shariff, A. A. (2019). Development of new
shoe-sizing system for Malaysian women using 3D foot scanning technology. Measurement, 140, 182–184. Snow, R. E., & Williams, K. R. (1994). High heeled shoes: their effect on center of mass position, posture, three-dimensional kinematics, rearfoot motion, and ground reaction forces. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 75(5), 568–576. Snow, R. E., Williams, K. R., & Holmes, G. B. (1992). The Effects of Wearing High
Heeled Shoes on Pedal Pressure in Women. Foot and Ankle, 13(2), 85–92. Wan, F. K. W., Yick, K. L., & Yu, W. W. M. (2017). Validation of a 3D foot scanning system for evaluation of forefoot shape with elevated heels. Measurement: Journal of the International Measurement Confederation, 99, 134–144. Witana, C. P., Feng, J., & Goonetilleke, R. S. (2004). Dimensional differences for
evaluating the quality of footwear fit. Ergonomics, 47(12), 1301–1317. Witana, C. P., Xiong, S., Zhao, J., & Goonetilleke, R. S. (2006). Foot measurements from three-dimensional scans: A comparison and evaluation of different methods. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 36(9), 789–807. Xiong, S. P., Goonetilleke, R. S., Witana, C. P., Weerasinghe, T. W., & Au, E. Y. L.
(2010). Foot arch characterization: a review, a new metric, and a comparison. Journal of the American Podiatric Medical Association, 100(1), 14–24. Xiong, S. P., & Goonetilleke, R. S. (2006). Midfoot shape for the design of ladies’shoes. Age (Years), 21(1.32), 24.
LISTED IN THE AHFE DIGITAL BOOKSTORE CATALOGUE
Explore the complete digital volume
Digital Human Modeling and Applied Optimization
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-958651-22-3
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional