Ana Àlvarez Sànchez, Alexis Suàrez Del Villar Labastida, Jonathan Santiago Guevara Flores, Eric Martínez Tocoronte (2022). Services performance with the process standardization for tire rotation, alignment and balancing. In: Human Interaction & Emerging Technologies (IHIET-AI 2022): Artificial Intelligence & Future Applications. AHFE Open Access, vol. 23. https://doi.org/10.54941/ahfe100853
Fred E. Meyers in the book Study of Times and Movements for agile manufac-turing indicates that companies that implement standardization to services and production have a yield of 85% increasing productivity with the same resources. The objective of this investigation was the standardization of the service times of the tire rotation, Alignment and Balancing processes, carried out in a service company that sells tires and complementary products, they have three state-of-the-art workstations and two male technicians who meet the requirements to per-form the functions inherent to the position they occupy. We normalize the cycles of the operations through measurement techniques and data obtained through collective observation in the jobs to determine the current situation of each of their activities or tasks, time study sheets, the Westinghouse Method and Meth-od of returns to zero, in this way the standard times and supplementary percent-ages were established. With the established proposals to reduce the percentages of the variable supplements of use of muscular force / energy to lift, pull and push a weight of 25 kg from 13% to 1% by the implementation of a hydraulic lifting table bringing it to 5 kg and the reduction from 2% to 0% of the intermit-tent and loud noise of 95 dB using hearing protectors is reduced to 85 dB and a continuous sound is perceived, total supplements were reduced from thirty-one percent to fourteen percent which leads to have better delivery times with a de-crease of 0.722 minutes for the interlocking operation and 0.60 minutes for bal-ancing, having an effective working day of 408 minutes.
Ana Àlvarez1,2, Alexis Suárez del Villar1,2, Eric Martinez3 ,Jonathan Santiago
Author markers are provisional. Publication metadata required for verification.
Source: 978-1-7923-8989-4_16
Services performance with the process standardization for tire rotation, alignment and
balancing
Ana Àlvarez1,2, Alexis Suárez del Villar1,2, Eric Martinez3 ,Jonathan Santiago Guevara1
1Facultad de Ingeniería y Tecnologías de la Información y la Comunicación Universidad Tecnològica Indoamèrica, Machala y
Sabanilla, Quito - Ecuador 2Grupo de investigación en Sistemas Industriales,Software y Automatización-
SISAu Universidad Tecnològica Indoamèrica, Machala y Sabanilla, Quito - Ecuador 3Instituto Tecnológico Universitario Cordillera Quito - Ecuador
ABSTRACT Fred E. Meyers in the book Study of Times and Movements for agile manufacturing indicates that companies that implement standardization to services and production have a yield of 85% increasing productivity with the same resources. The objective of this investigation was the standardization of the service times of the tire rotation, Alignment and Balancing processes, carried out in a service company that sells tires and complementary products, they have three state-of-the-art workstations and two male technicians who meet the requirements to perform the functions inherent to the position they occupy. We normalize the cycles of the operations through measurement techniques and data obtained through collective observation in the jobs to determine the current situation of each of their activities or tasks, time study sheets, the Westinghouse Method and Method of returns to zero, in this way the standard times and supplementary percentages were established. With the established
Human Interaction & Emerging Technologies (IHIET-AI 2022) Artificial Intelligence & Future Applications https://openaccess.cms-conferences.org/#/publications/book/978-1-7923-8989-4 proposals to reduce the percentages of the variable supplements of use of muscular force / energy to lift, pull and push a weight of 25 kg from 13% to 1% by the implementation of a hydraulic lifting table bringing it to 5 kg and the reduction from 2% to 0% of the intermittent and loud noise of 95 dB using hearing protectors is reduced to 85 dB and a continuous sound is perceived, total supplements were reduced from thirty-one percent to fourteen percent which leads to have better delivery times with a decrease of 0.722 minutes for the interlocking operation and 0.60 minutes for balancing, having an effective working day of 408 minutes Keywords: Alignment, balancing, tire rotation, standardization, standard time, Supplements
INTRODUCTION The standardization of times in the processes currently has become a tool of vital importance since the implementation allows to reduce and control costs when man-aging processes, business competitiveness drives companies to improve the quality of the products marketed, by standardizing the production line and the good performance of the men directly to the production or service process (Javier, 2019) (Sánchez, 2016). A series of recent studies have revealed that the optimal temperature range for our optimal physical and intellectual performance is between 21 ° C and 25 ° C, outside of this spectrum, our performance is reduced by 2% for each degree (Diana, 2020). For the diagnosis of the company current situation, an analysis of the activities that intervene in each process was carried out and the type of contribution that each one means is interpreted, that is, whether or not it adds value, in such a way that with this tool aims to identify the processes that need to be studied and standardized more quickly according to their contribution rate to the light vehicle value chain (Aguinda, 2017). Basically, an alignment consists of adjusting the angles of the wheels and the di-rection, in order to balance all the forces of friction, gravity, centrifugal force and impulse, basically in putting the four wheels in the same direction by manipulating the parts of the system steering and suspension to correct the relevant angles, (Santos, 2017) (VENTAGENERADORES, 2017). Dynamic balancing requires that the weight of the assembly be evenly distributed on both sides of the center line of the tire tread (Herrera, 2017) (Molina, 2019), balancing the weight of the rim with the weight of the tire by means of pieces of lead called counterweights. In the Assembly and Disassembly of Tires, equipment is used that as a general rule are connected to a pneumatic point, that is, they work connected to a compressor that generates air (Garnica, 2017). That is why they are called automatic or pneumatic tire changers (due to the use of compressed air) (Zapata, 2017) (Tobar, 2017) (Asturias, 2019). They are intended for conventional car wheels, 4 × 4, mini-bus, etc. with profiles from 10 “to 26” (or from 7 “to 26” with special adapters) (Lemache-Caiza, 2021). Tires, due to various factors such as weather, use or incorrect alignment, cause their wear and tear and that causes poor traction and subsequent problems at a general level throughout the car (Zapata, 2017) (AutoAvance, 2015). MATERIALS AND METHODS Applying the collective observation method, the behaviors carried out by the workers
Human Interaction & Emerging Technologies (IHIET-AI 2022) Artificial Intelligence & Future Applications https://openaccess.cms-conferences.org/#/publications/book/978-1-7923-8989-4 in the execution of the activities are recorded and it is determined that the performance is 60% in the services provided during an effective working day of 331.2 minutes in the processes: Tire rotation (19 vehicles / day), Alignment (6 vehicles / day), and Balancing (17 vehicles / day), the time series data obtained during the first semester of the year 2021 can be observed in Figure 1. A type 2 sound level meter with a weighting filter is used to measure the noise, in order to calculate the dose normalized to an 8-hour working day. The study con-siders what is stipulated in the Ecuadorian standard NTE INEN-ISO 9612 (Navidi, 2019) (SOCIAL, 1986), “Acoustics. Determination of noise exposure at work. Engineering method “(ISO 9612: 2009, IDT) (ECUATORIANA, 2014), with a measurement strategy based on tasks, numeral 9.3 of the standard. In the three processes two operators take part who transport the tires and tools from one place to another manually lifting weights of 25 kg, they use to offer a high torque output and that the physical effort is minimal, Pneumatic impact pistols model DSS 1 “L Art. No. 0703 780 0 with a noise level of 95 db. (9612:2009, 2009)
Figure 1: Monthly services in the first half of 2021 The processes to follow are detailed in Figure 2.
is the exact combination of two balances, one static
done with nitrogen that is 100% safer
the rim, protector and since having a puncture in tire, and also the wheel / rim.
steering are adjusted in order to balance all the
and one dynamic, resulting in a well- balanced tire. This
the tires deflates more
In this way, damages in the
forces of friction, gravity, centrifugal
slowly which
important task is convenient to do area of the
force so that it rolls properly
provides stability to the
bead and related to the vehicle, allowing the
every 10,000 kilometers or when the car demands it, knowing some details
driver to
wear of the tread from the bad positioning
without excessively wearing the tires. Proper alignment
realize.
favors the general maintenance of tires
of the rim on the wheel are
and suspension.
can increase tire life by more than
avoided.
70%.
Figure 2: Descriptive model of the specifications of the process under study. For the year 2021 the forecasts were to provide services to 800 vehicles monthly in the area of tire rotation, alignment and balancing, in the month of May the number of vehicles with which we worked is 800 entering as the lowest of the 1st. of the semester of the year being as planned and the month of February as the month with the highest services of 840 vehicles, Figure 1. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The cycle time that must be observed to obtain a representative average time of each process is determined by statistical formulas that give a total of ten, for the calculation of the percentage of the supplement the table stipulated by the international labor organization is used (Guevara, 2021)and the qualification of the speed by means of the four factors of the Westinghouse method as observed in Table 2.Table 1: Percentage of Supplements of the three processes Supplements Tire totation Alignment Balancing
Table 2: Qualification of operator speed by the Westinghouse method Qualification for Factors Qualification for
Balancing Ability B2 +0.08 C1 +0.06 Effort C2 +0.02 C2 +0.02 Conditions C +0.02 C +0.02 Consistency B +0.03 B +0.03 Cv 1,15 1,13 The qualification granted by the four factors conceived in the Westinghouse method of each of the operations of the investigation is observed in Table 2. The ability of excellent (B2) in the Wheel process is due to the fact that the operator works with a rhythm 100% in a coordinated manner, Shows speed and smoothness in the execution of tasks, Works accurately without making mistakes and Good (C1) in the remaining processes because the operator needs little vigilance, Works correctly and according to specifications; Good Effort (C2) because the operator is interested in the job, follows the established method and is well prepared; Good Conditions (C) for being exposed to noise of 95 DB and the Excellent Consistency (B). Applying the quantitative method of timing with return to zero, the values of the time that a trained operator, knowledgeable about the work and developing it at a normal pace, would spend in the execution of the task under study are determined (Guevara, 2021). It is statistically demonstrated that the number of observations 10 satisfy the sampling error (Navidi, 2019), the normal time calculated for the engagement process of 19.60 minutes with the sum of the average time (𝑇̅) of the 6 elements and then the result multiplied by the speed rating factor (Cv) of +1.15; 12.62 minutes are used for the Alignment process and 16.43 minutes for Balancing, taking into account in both processes they have 7 elements and the speed rating factor is + 1.13, Equations 2,3 and 4. 𝑇𝑛= 𝑇̅ ∗𝐶𝑣 (1)
480 𝑚𝑖𝑛𝑢𝑡𝑒𝑠/𝑑𝑎𝑦−31𝑚𝑖𝑛𝑢𝑡𝑒𝑠 𝑑𝑎𝑦 16,43 𝑚𝑖𝑛𝑢𝑡𝑒𝑠 𝑇𝑠 𝑜𝑓 𝐵𝑎𝑙𝑎𝑛𝑐𝑖𝑛𝑔= 𝟏𝟕, 𝟓𝟔 𝑚𝑖𝑛/𝑣𝑒ℎ𝑖𝑐𝑙𝑒𝑠 (7) The results obtained in Equations 5,6 and 7, correspond to the standard times (Ts) of the processes under study, which, having supplements of 31% in the Tire rotation and Balancing processes as a result of the use of the force of 25 Kg and an intermittent and loud noise, make the values increase in each productive cycle and the effective working day of 480 minutes decreases to 331.20 minutes and 403.20 minutes respectively. CONCLUSIONS Based on Executive Decree 2393 Art. 55 [17], which establishes as reference levels: criterion time 8 hours, a criterion noise level of 85 dBA and exchange rate of 5 db. Indicating that the decibel level of 95 is exceeded that established for which hearing protection should be used to avoid future injuries to workers and the noise supplement would be 0%. For the reduction of the 13 percentage of supplement of use the force of 25 kg to 1% and not to harm the health of the workers, it was invested in a cargo car with a final price in the market of $ 63.99 and a hydraulic lifting table 350 kg capacity scissor shape ideal for moving all kinds of loads from one place to another with an elevator value of $ 559.00; the lifting tables are built and designed to raise or lower to the necessary height in these processes. With the decrease in the percentage of the variable Supplements, the standard time of the wheel process could be reduced from 20.947 minutes to 20.23 minutes with a variation of 0.717 more productive minutes for these seven elements, the standard time of the alignment process in the diagnostic stage was 13.06 minutes with the improvements being reduced to 13.00 minutes with a variation of 0.06 minutes and the balancing process was lowered from 17.56 minutes to 16.96 minutes with a variation of 0.60 minutes, for a total increase of the productive time in one minute and 38 seconds.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We thank the authorities of the Universidad Tecnológica Indoamérica who financed the research, allowing this article to be published in the scientific world and to contribute to new projects. REFERENCES 9612:2009, I. (2009). Acústica — Determinación de la exposición al ruido profesional — Método de ingeniería. https://www.iso.org/standard/41718.html#:~:text=ISO%209612%3A2009% 20specifies%20an%20engineering%20method%20for%20measuring,levels. %20Three%20different%20strategies%20for%20measurement%20are%20s pecified. Aguinda, P. I. (2017). Estudio de factibilidad para la implementación de los servicios
de alineación, balanceo, montaje y desmontaje de neumáticos para la Empresa Comercial Malán, ubicada en el cantón Guaranda, provincia de Bolívar. Obtenido de http://dspace.espoch.edu.ec/bitstream/123456789/7770/1/22T0417 Asturias. ( 2019). Ventajas de inflar los neumáticos con nitrógeno. Obtenido de http://teleneumaticosasturias.com/ventajas-inflado-neumaticos-nitrogeno/ AutoAvance. (2015). Sistema TPMS: Mucho más que un simple Sensor de Neumático.
Obtenido de https://www.autoavance.co/blog-tecnico-automotriz/182- sistema-tpms-mucho-mas-que-un-simple-sensor-de-neumatico/ Diana, H. (15 de Diciembre de 2020). El confort térmico y su impacto en nuestro rendimiento. Obtenido de https://www.dianahome.com/blog/el-confort- termico-y-su-impacto-en-nuestro-rendimiento ECUATORIANA, N. (2014). NTE INEN-ISO 9612. https://vsip.info/norma-inen-iso-
9612-pdf-free.html. Garnica, W. M. (2017). Práctica de laboratorio de balanceo de neumáticos para la asignatura Vibraciones Mecánicas, Universidad Central "Marta Abreu" de Las Villas . Obtenido de https://dspace.uclv.edu.cu/handle/123456789/8476 Guevara, A. R. (2021). La gestión de la calidad en la estandarización de procesos en
empresas procesadoras de alimentos. Herrera, S. J. (Septiembre de 2017). Diseño de un proceso efectivo de balanceo de ruedas para aros de acero y de aleación . Obtenido de GUAYAQUIL/UIDE/2017: https://repositorio.uide.edu.ec/handle/37000/2304 Javier, P. G. (2019). ESTANDARIZACIÓN DE LOS PROCESOS DE ENCAPSULADO
Y BLISTEADO DE AMOXICILINA 500mg EN LA EMPRESA BETAPHARMA S.A. Obtenido de http://repositorio.uti.edu.ec/handle/123456789/1208 Lemache-Caiza, W. A. (2021). Incidencia del aire y del nitrógeno en el desgaste de neumáticos en vehículos sedan. Obtenido de DOMINIOS DE LA CIENCIA, vol. 7, nº 3.
Molina, E. (Marzo de 2019). Diseño de un molde permanente de fundición por gravedad para la fabricación de pesas adhesivas de plomo utilizadas en balanceo de neumáticos, Universidad Internacional SEK. Obtenido de https://repositorio.uisek.edu.ec/handle/123456789/3305 Navidi, W. (2019). Estadìstica para ingenieros y cientìficos,Universidad
Iberoamericana,. México: McGrawHill. Sánchez, A. Á. (Agosto de 2016). PROCESO DE PALETIZACIÓN DE CAJAS DE CLAVOS Y SU INCIDENCIA EN LA PRODUCTIVIDAD EN LA EMPRESA ACERÍA DEL ECUADOR ADELCA C.A . Obtenido de http://repositorio.uti.edu.ec/handle/123456789/428 Santos, G. (2017). TECNOLOGIAS AUTOMOTRICES ESPECIALIZADAS . Obtenido
de https://german7644dotcom.wordpress.com/alineacion-del-vehiculo/ SOCIAL, I. (1986). DECRETO EJECUTIVO 2393 REGLAMENTO DE SEGURIDAD Y SALUD DE LOS TRABAJADORES Y MEJORAMIENTO DEL MEDIO AMBIENTE DE TRABAJO. http://www.prosigma.com.ec/pdf/nlegal/Decreto-Ejecutivo2393. Tobar, D. J. (Agosto de 2017). Estudio para la implementación del servicio de
alineación y balanceo en un taller automotriz, GUAYAQUIL/UIDE/2017 . Obtenido de https://repositorio.uide.edu.ec/handle/37000/2274 VENTAGENERADORES. ( 2017). Obtenido de Manual de montaje: http://www.ventageneradores.net/blog/manual-montaje-ruedas-como- desmontar-equilibrar-neumaticos-llantas-coches-motos/ Zapata, E. T. ( 2017). Balanceo y alineado de llantas caso NISSAN -TIIDA, Universidad Mayor de San Andrés,Ciudad de La Paz - Estado Plurinacional de Bolivia. Obtenido de https://repositorio.umsa.bo/handle/123456789/15923
Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.
ISBN 978-1-7923-8989-4
Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore ↗Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional