INTRODUCTION
According to American Marketing Association [2013], marketing is the activity, set of institutions, and processes for creating, communicating, delivering, and exchanging offerings that have value for customers, clients, partners, and society at large. In this paper, we adopt the definition of 'complexity' elaborated by Simon, which states that it is a feature of complex systems that are made up of a large number of parts that interact in a non-simple way [Simon 1962].
Technology, Higher Education and Society (2020) https://openaccess.cms-conferences.org/#/publications/book/978-1-4951-2110-4
ONLINE CONSUMER MARKET AS A COMPLEX SYSTEM Both markets and their sub-systems (companies, customer communities, etc.) may be perceived as complex systems, since they are characterised by the following systemic properties: openness (exchange of goods, information and capital with other entities), isolation from the environment (the possibility of designating the boundaries of a given entity); hierarchical subsystems; incomplete knowledge regarding their functioning, and emergence, i.e. the appearance of qualitatively new idiosyncratic features (such as a market standard, fashion or trend). Functioning of markets and their sub-systems come as a result of reciprocal interactions between their elements. Markets may maintain homoeostasis or improve themselves by increasing the degree of organisation, i.e. by decreasing entropy (e.g. by limiting the information asymmetry). The functioning of markets and the companies that operate within them are often characterised by non-linearity and counter-intention, which stems from the complexity of internal and external relations in which they stand. An increase in the complexity may lead to deterministic chaos, i.e. system sensitivity to small modifications in the initial conditions [Skyttner 2006, Doligalski 2014].
The complexity of online consumer market derives from a number of mutually interacting factors, the most important of which include:
- large number of customers (Internet using consumers) and frequently occurring herding behaviours,
- impact of technological factors (ICT) on consumer behaviour,
- importance of relationships between consumers (horizontal market relationships) to business-to-consumer relationships in the process of acquisition and consumption of products / services (vertical relationships),
- market structure and market structure-resulting relationships between the companies A large number of customers in the consumer market is a typical feature of both the traditional (off-line) and the online market. In the traditional market, a large number of customers, and at the same time the economic effects of competition, have translated into operating on large segments. The online market allows for individualisation of marketing activities (operating on smaller segments). From the point of view of system complexity, however, the influence that individual customers have on each other seems of particular importance. Nevertheless, the larger social groups are, the more difficult it becomes to predict such impact. The Internet removes physical limits of the market, promoting the globalisation of the economy. Nevertheless, one should remember that the online market processes are strongly conditioned by regional and national factors. One can state, just as it was pointed out by Kogut, that the Internet has borders (or, more precisely, that the Internet can be divided into particular areas) [Kogut, 2003]. The key local conditions are associated with:
- commercial solutions used in the traditional market
- regulations relating to the Internet
- socio-cultural determinants.
Hence, it can be said that there exists a number of contradictory trends in the scope of globalisation and in increasing the potential number of customers, with the simultaneous increase in the diversity of audiences in separate local markets. Both of these factors affect each other.
The use of ICT by consumers is dependent on several factors, such as: Technology, Higher Education and Society (2020) https://openaccess.cms-conferences.org/#/publications/book/978-1-4951-2110-4
As a result, consumers may be perceived as a factor that:
The resultant of these two positions is an approach to modelling customer behaviour in the economy, relying on the statement that customers are interacting, thoughtful (but perhaps not brilliant) agents. [Miller, Page, 2010].
PRODUCT Online products and services often rely on the so-called network effect. The network effect refers to the phenomenon whereby the value of a product for a customer depends on the number of users of the product and, in particular, increases with the number of customers [Tellis et al., 2009]. The most significant example of the network effect can be provided by social networking websites. The value for customer offered by such websites does not stem from developed functionality, but is rather associated with customer base, or rather customer network. Technology, Higher Education and Society (2020) https://openaccess.cms-conferences.org/#/publications/book/978-1-4951-2110-4
MARKETING COMMUNICATION The development of Internet has significantly facilitated the communication between the three parties: consumers communicate not only with companies, but also to a large extent with other consumers. Informal communication (between consumers) is a phenomenon that has always existed, but with the popularisation of the Internet it became Technology, Higher Education and Society (2020) https://openaccess.cms-conferences.org/#/publications/book/978-1-4951-2110-4 much easier. Nevertheless, the question whether the development of the Internet has increased the importance of informal communication in the purchasing process still remains open. It is usually assumed that the development of the Internet has increased the importance of informal communication in the purchasing process, but it should be remembered that that the importance of this (an other) types of information source depends on the frequency of use of the source and its credibility. Examination of these two factors is not an easy task. Researches based on the simplest methods (retrospective survey and respondents’ declarations) are not able to verify the cost-effectiveness and the efficiency of consumers’ actions, which are the aspects that combine consumer’s activity (which is relatively easy to measure) with purposefulness (including consumer’s competences, which are significantly more difficult to estimate).
1. The consumer must be cognitively active, as well as willing and able to process the information furnished by other users. 2. Other customers must furnish valuable (useful from the perspective of purchase decision making) information.
Information overload to which the Internet users are exposed, leading to cognitive overload, translates into increasing frequency of use of heuristics, such as social proof [Cialdini, 1999]. Inclusion of the “like” buttons in the websites or fanpages are a common manifestations of the use of such mechanisms. The influence of such proofs depends e.g. on the evaluation of the sender's intentions (consumers clicking the “like” button, writing product Technology, Higher Education and Society (2020) https://openaccess.cms-conferences.org/#/publications/book/978-1-4951-2110-4 reviews, etc.). As it has been already mentioned above, the level of trust put by consumers in such opinions remains very high [Nielsen, 2013]. Such intentions are probably perceived as clean, hence providing ground for persuasion. It should be noted, however, that following the opinions of other people may be perceived as a manifestation of superficial information processing. Wojciszke and Doliński note that the reactions of fellow receivers should be interpreted as signals of succumbing during the process of peripheral data processing [Wojciszke, Doliński, 2008]. Hence, it may be seen as a pull factor for companies. Moreover, advertisers create "fan farms", increase the number of fans by rewarding them for simply being a fan, manipulate reviews (c.f. amplifying). In addition, companies can use the tools for monitoring informal communication, including both online search engines and complex tools for monitoring of discussions, also those taking place on social networking websites, i.e. portals which normally cannot be monitored by traditional search engines. Hence, companies gain a possibility to increase the impact of their persuasive messages in a concealed manner. Such actions are not filtrated through active and deep data processing. In addition, involvement in the process of information search and choice of information sources increases the illusion of customer's control over this process [Zielonka, 2004].
1. desire to help other users in making purchasing decisions - altruism 2. desire to help the company - equity theory 3. social benefits - the need to belong to a group 4. “taking of power over the company” – this applies particularly to negative reviews 5. self-enhancement 6. economic benefits - informal and formal 7. the expression of positive emotions / ability to channel negative feelings - balance theory None of the types of motivations described above clearly indicates the actual value of the information posted by customers online. During the purchasing process, the customer would have to assess the credibility of other customers perceived as sources of information, which would require a certain cognitive involvement – the effort which in the first place was to be minimised through the involvement of other consumers. Therefore, in this case it seems that product popularity (which is also a manifestation of social proof), perceived as a proof of its value (since it was verified by other consumers), seems of prevailing importance.
PRICING In the case of products sold online, the dependence between the price level and the seller's reputation seems of particular importance. There is a positive correlation between the reputation of the seller, e.g. an online store or vendors on an auction portal, and the price the customers are willing to pay for a product [Obloj, Capron, 2011]. Internet reputation systems are often used by intermediaries, such as online auction websites or price comparison engines. Quite frequently, the majority of opinions procured by reputation systems is good or very good. One could assume that such situation is very favourable for the sellers, since it translates into an increased credibility, etc. In practice, however, it means that even a small number of negative ratings can significantly reduce the overall evaluation of the company, which is usually calculated based on the average of the ratings. A company willing to compete by means of such systems must in the first place minimise the percentage of dissatisfied customers, since it is them who, through negative comments, to the greatest extent may impact the company's reputation. Hence, we witness a situation where the positive evaluation is beneficial for the company, but at the same time makes it extremely sensitive to changes. Thus, there exists a non-linearity typical for complex systems, which in extreme cases can lead to fundamental changes in the system (leaving customers, bankruptcy).
CONCLUSIONS
Efficient online marketing requires a complex and holistic approach to the management of the company's actions, especially in the consumer market (in B2C environment), since it is controlled by contradictory trends that cause a large uncertainty of managers. Consumers are a factor that can quickly destabilise the position of the company. Predicting consumer behaviour is difficult, particularly in those areas of marketing activities (e.g. communications) where the relations between various market factors are highly complicated.
The constantly strengthening position of the consumers results from new ways of communication and information finding, owing to which consumers may choose a provider that offers the most appropriate value proposition. One can observe that there is an increase in the bargaining power of the consumer in the relationship with the company (due among others, to communication via social media), but at the same time that there exist factors that diminish their role, e.g. the possibility to monitor customers' behaviour in social media and far-reaching individualisation of communication which relies on the analysis of prior purchasing behaviours of consumers, that translate into increasing the powers of persuasion on the part of the company. The increasing ease of discussion monitoring allows for emerging trends identification and, in the case of a negative development of the discussions, for taking preventive measures. It seems reasonable to ask what may be the possible result of those two effect opposing each other. It is difficult to determine, but it can be assumed that it will contribute to the acceleration of market changes in the scope of participation of individual companies in the market or even their survival.
The problem of complexity traces into product policies. The position of a product in online trading is influenced, among others, by the network effect, value co-creation or digitisation. These phenomena increase herd behaviours among Internet users. These on their part may lead to irrational choices, market concentration and its rapid transformations, following periods of relative stability.
Online reputation systems give Internet users possibility to choose stores that offer a desired combination of reputation and price. High and almost equal levels of reputation displayed by many shops mean that they become extremely sensitive to single negative assessments from the part of dissatisfied customers. Dynamic price discrimination systems, offered by some intermediaries, give sellers a possibility to fix the pricing depending on the prices offered by competitors, which significantly increases the interdependence in the market, thus building its complexity.
Further research may focus on the impact of complexity on the company's profitability and other success determinants, such as the company's ability to engage in long-term customer relationships. The study of models of using complexity and the opposite phenomenon – simplicity - in companies may be a particularly promising research pathway. Finally, customers' inclination to choose solutions characterised by complexity in various market context seems also of particular importance.
REFERENCES
Barabási A.L. (2005), “The origin of bursts and heavy tails in humans dynamics”, Nature, No. 435 (http://www.unc.edu/~fbaum/teaching/PLSC541_Fall06/Barabasi%202005%20Nature.pdf). Beales H. (2009). “The Value of Behavioral Targeting, Network Advertising Initiative”, http://www.networkadvertising.org.uncensor.it/pdfs/Beales_NAI_Study.pdf, [20.02.2014]. Boguszewski R.(2010). „Zaufanie społeczne. Raport z badań, Centrum Badania Opinii Społecznej” [Social Trust. Report on Technology, Higher Education and Society (2020) https://openaccess.cms-conferences.org/#/publications/book/978-1-4951-2110-4
CBOS Findings] . Warsaw p.6, http://www.cbos.pl/SPISKOM.POL/2010/K_029_10.PDF, [20.09.2010] Cialdini R. (1999). „Wywieranie wpływu na ludzi” [Influence: Science and Practice ], GWP, Gdańsk, p.112 Civicpedia (2006). „Kapitał społeczny – zaufanie” [Social Capital. Trust]. Centrum Badania Opinii Społecznej http://civicpedia.ngo.pl/x/330089#ESS, [20.09.2010]. Doligalski T. (2014), “Model biznesowy z perspektywy General Systems Theory” [Business Model from the Perspective of
General Systems Theory], in: Modele biznesu w Internecie. Studia przypadków polskich firm internetowych, [Online Business Models. Polish Online Companies – a Case Study Doligalski, Tymoteusz (Ed). – to be published eMarketer (2012). “More Advertisers, Formats Bring More Money to RTB”, November 21, 2012, http://www.emarketer.com/Article/More-Advertisers-Formats-Bring-More-Money-RTB/1009496, [29.12.2012]. eMarketer, (2013). “Advertisers Continue Rapid Adoption of Programmatic Buying”, November 26, 2013,
http://www.emarketer.com/Article/Advertisers-Continue-Rapid-Adoption-of-Programmatic-Buying/1010414, [27.11.2013]; eMarketer, “Key Digital Trends For 2014”, February 2014, https://www.emarketer.com/go/keydigitaltrends2014-1, [20.01.2014]. González M. C., Hidalgo C. A., Barabási A.L. (2008), “Understanding individual human mobility patterns, Nature, No 453. Hennig-Thurau T., Gwinner K.P., Walsh G., Gremler D.D. (2004). “Electronic Word-Of-Mouth Via Consumer-Opinion Platforms: What Motivates Consumers To Articulate Themselves On The Internet?” Journal of Interactive Marketing, Vol. 18, No. 1, http://www.gremler.net/personal/research/2004_Electronic_WOM_JIM.pdf, [20.02.2014]. IAB Polska (Czerwiec 2013). „Komunikacja marketingowa online z perspektywy internautów” [Online Marketing
Communication from the Perspective of Internet Users]. IAB Polska (Kwiecień 2013). „IAB Mobile, 2012’Q4, Użytkownicy smartfonów wśród aktywnych internautów” [Smartphone Users among Active Internet Users], p. 32, http://iab.org.pl/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/2013_IABPolska_mobile_2012Q4_uzytkownicy_smartfonow_raport.pdf, [21.02.2014]. Kleemann F., Voss G.G. (2008). “Un(der)paid Innovators: The Commercial Utilization of Consumer Work through
Crowdsourcing”, Science, Technology & Innovation Studies, Volume 4, No. 1. Kogut B. (2003), „Introduction: The Internet Has Borders”, in: „The Global Internet Economy” B. Kogut (ed.), The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts 2003, p.7. Miller J.H., Page S.E. (2007), “Complex Adaptive Systems: An Introduction to Computational Models of Social Life”, Princeton
University Press, p. 3. Obloj, T., Capron, L. (2011). “Role of resource gap and value appropriation: effect of reputation gap on price premium in online auctions”, Strategic Management Journal , Volume 11 No. 4. Pentland A. (2009), “Reality Mining of Mobile Communications: Toward a New Deal on Data”, in: “The Global Information
Technology Report 2008-2009”, World Economic Forum 2009, p.75-79, http://www.insead.edu/v1/gitr/wef/main/fullreport/files/Chap1/1.6.pdf, [21.02.2014] Peppers D., Rogers M. (1997). “Enterprise one-to-one, Tools for Competing in the Interactive Age”, Curency Doubleay. Skyttner L. (2006), “General Systems Theory: Problems, Perspectives, Practice”, World Scientific Pub Co Inc, Singapur, pp. 49-
108. Tellis, G.J., Yin E., Niraj, R. (2009). “Does Quality Win? Network Effects Versus Quality in High-Tech Markets”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. XLVI, No. 2. Wójcik J. (2009). „Rola formalnych i nieformalnych źródeł informacji na rynku konsumenckim” [The Role of Formal and
Informal Sources of Information in the Consumer Market] in: A.Dąbrowska, I.Ozimek (ed.), Konsument w europejskiej przestrzeni [Consumer in the European Space] IBRKiK, Warszawa, p. 121-127. Wójcik J., Doligalski T. (2011). “The Role of Informal Sources of Information in the Polish Consumer Market”, Perspectives on Innovations, Economics & Business, Volume 9, Issue 3. Wojciszke B., Doliński D. (2008). „Psychologia społeczna” [Social Psychology] in: „Psychologia” [Psychology], J.Strelau,
D.Doliński (ed.), GWP, Gdańsk, p.348-349. Zielonka P. (2004), „Finanse behawioralne” [Behavioural Finance], in: „Psychologia ekonomiczna” [Economic Psychology] T.Tyszka (ed.), GWP, Gdańsk 2004, pp.346-347.
Technology, Higher Education and Society (2020) https://openaccess.cms-conferences.org/#/publications/book/978-1-4951-2110-4