Skip to article
AHFE AHFE Discoveries AHFE International Open Access Journal
AHFE OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS PAPER

Me, Myself & Data - Principles for the Design of Self-Tracking Services

IDEO GmbH Design Research 81667 Munich, Kellerstraße 27, Germany ↗
Publication year
Digital Object Identifier10.54941/ahfe100296

Abstract

In this paper, we will explore how applying principles of design research to the design of self-tracking services can lead to a more human and delightful user experience, and thus more desirable services. Design research has always aimed at helping design human-centered products and services. To do so, researchers follow various guidelines to ensure that the conducted research is relevant, ethical and inspiring. The rise of new technologies for the self-tracking of personal data has blurred the distinction between users and researchers as devices for self-tracking have become more mobile, wearable, and affordable for the mainstream, allowing users to become researchers of their own lives. Yet, having access to more data does not automatically mean people will understand this information, or know how to apply it. The main challenge, therefore, lies in interpreting the data and acting upon the information gained. We have conducted a series of interviews and analyzed concrete examples of self-tracking services, and based on our observations have defined five principles of design research. We believe that when applied to the design process, these principles will ultimately result in self-tracking data that brings more value to users.

INTRODUCTION

Research for Human-Centered Design and New Challenges Around Data Researchers for human-centered design collect and interpret data to uncover needs and inspire design solutions to better serve people’s future needs, a process which always begins with considering the people for whom we are designing. Traditionally, human-centered design focuses on qualitative data, based on the belief that observing people in context and having in-depth conversations will lead to a better understanding of their latent needs – to inspire the next instead of just describing the now (Seemann, 2012). Lately, digital technologies have had a huge impact on how we do research (Berry, 2011), primarily because of the ever increasing amount of data produced in modern society. This omnipresent accessibility of data has added more variety to data collection methods. It is easier than ever to derive information from huge quantities of data that users have produced themselves, a circumstance that has added an interesting additional source of information to our work. While this has led to a new set of questions and challenges, our general guidelines of how we understand data and make it useable have remained the same. At its core, research for human-centered design is not just about analysis of objective evidence, but rather it is a way of informing our intuition – synthesis of evidence, recognition of emerging patterns, empathic connection to people’s motivations and behaviors and intuitive interpretation of information from multiple sources (Fulton Suri, 2008).

Self-tracking of Personal Data The human behavior of tracking personal data is nothing new. For a long time humans have collected information about themselves: qualitative information, as with a journal, but also quantitative information, like weight tracked on a scale or a financial balance tracked with a bank account (Wolf, 2010). What has changed is not the need to understand more about ourselves, but rather the technologies supporting data collection: electronic sensors becoming smaller and better, devices to track personal data becoming wearable, accessibility and affordability for the mainstream. A vast number of new products and services has appeared in the market, giving rise to new opportunities for people to collect and interpret their own personal data, with users have become researchers themselves. A term often used in the context of self-tracking is the Quantified Self, coined by Gary Wolf and Kevin Kelly of Wired Magazine in 2007. With the goal of connecting users and makers of self-tracking tools, and helping people get more meaning out of their personal data, they founded the California-based company, Quantified Self Labs, which regularly organizes international meetings and conferences. The topic of self-tracking and Quantified Self has been widely discussed in regards to technology, as well as research, with early adopters of self-tracking services often referred to as ‘geeky’ or even narcissistic (Kelly, 2011). According to Genevieve Bell (as cited in Simonite, 2013), an anthropologist and director of Intel’s user experience research, this is partly due to the fact that with many of the early self-tracking services it was not completely clear how their technical features could actually enhance people’s lives. The focus when talking about self-tracking services is too often on what they can do, the ‘task’ piece of it, rather than on how one can make sense of the information provided (2013). Another challenge discussed in the context of self-tracking is the lack of ways to help users act upon the data they collect. As Adam Tinworth, blogger for NEXT Berlin, asserts “the Quantified Self needs more actionable data,” for only when we have more compelling examples of how data from self-tracking services can make a powerful difference in people’s life, will the Quantified Self movement really move from the data enthusiasts to the mainstream (2013).

How Can We Make Self-tracking Services More Human-centered?

LOOKING INTO EXAMPLES OF SELF-TRACKING SERVICES Over the last year we have immersed ourselves in the world of new and emerging self-tracking services and related literature, and had many conversations with users about their motivations, habits, beliefs and and questions concerning the self-tracking of personal data. We interviewed several representatives from existing self-tracking services about their work: Arye Barnehama and Laura Michelle Berman, founders of Melon, a headband and mobile app that measures focus; Andrea Mallard, Chief Brand Officer at Omada Health, a service that inspires lifestyle change through evidence-based digital health programs, and Ethan Fassett, VP of Product at Basis, a health- tracking service that seeks to help users become fitter, sleep better and be less stressed. In addition we interviewed our colleagues Dirk Ahlgrim, Timothy McGee and Mitch Sinclair, of IDEO Boston, who, in the last year, have been involved in the design of several self-tracking services that are not yet on the market.

PRINCIPLES FOR THE DESIGN OF SELF-TRACKING SERVICES Ask the Right Questions

Move From Data to Insight “People are not interested in getting more and more data, they want to understand what’s going on. They are interested in the message,” says Ahlgrim (personal communication, February 14, 2014). The value of a self-tracking service lies not in the data it collects, but in the insight it provides. Ethan Fassett, VP of Product at Basis, states that self-tracking services in general have to become better at confidently generating insights based on the data generated (personal communication, February 21, 2014). As design researchers we move from data to insight by synthesizing the information we have collected. We do this by cross-validating, contextualizing, filtering and interpreting the information. A well-designed self-tracking service should enable the user to make sense of the information by moving beyond the raw numbers and distinguish between important and irrelevant bits of information. Christian, early self-tracking adopter and self-proclaimed data enthusiast says, “in order to make sense of my data, I need to be able to put it into context,” and criticizes that many self-tracking services lack the ability to connect and combine different sources of data.

Melon, for example, combines contextual information, such as current activity or environment, with data about brain activity measured by the headband, moving from data to insight and understanding about what factors affect our focus. According to Barnehama and Berman, “at Melon we are really interested in the idea of Understood Self, which we are trying to add to the movement of Quantified Self” (Melon, 2013), with the term ‘Understood Self’ describing the layer of insights on top of the numbers and scores. While many self-tracking devices leave it to the user to interpret the data and make decisions based on that information, Melon is specifically designed to interact with the user and provide messages about their focus based on the data collected (Treuhaft, 2013). Barnehama says “we didn’t create a Quantified Self service. We are not just printing numbers. We believe Understood Self services are the Generation 2.0 of Quantified Self.” He strongly believes that users don’t want to “sit and look at data”

(personal communication, February 19, 2014). And self-tracker Christian confirms, “I’m not interested in the numbers, I want to see what it means for myself, how it compares to my own personal record.”

Move From Insight to Action As design researchers we believe that a good insight invites action, and should be inspiring, not simply descriptive. A well designed self-tracking service, therefore, should enable users to move not only from data to insight, but also from insight to action. Andrea Mallard, from Omada Health’s service Prevent, states “we ultimately use the tracking to prompt a behavior rather than to accumulate data,” (personal communication, February 20, 2014). When talking to users of self-tracking services, we asked them what they have learned from self-tracking and what impact it has had on their life. Aleksandra, a young biotech-scientist and passionate self-tracker, admits that although she loves self-tracking because she loves graphs and likes putting everything in a system to see the order of it, she did not really gain a lot of new information, nor did it really have much impact on her life. While there will always be users like Aleksandra, who like “self-tracking in itself,” we believe Tinworth has a point when he says that self-tracking will only move from data enthusiasts to the mainstream when there is more actionable data that makes a real difference in people’s lives (Tinworth, 2013).

Short feedback-loops and personal recommendations based on real time data are huge opportunities for self-tracking services to move from data to action. As Ahlgrim states, by getting regular feedback users see and understand the impact of behavior change in real time, becoming aware of ways to improve their health by little changes in their everyday life (personal communication, February 14, 2014). It is exactly these little changes in everyday life that Basis is about. Basis wants to help users move to action by setting very specific and rather modest goals, like sitting less or having more consistent sleep times, and then use a gaming system and positive reinforcement to motivate those users to keep at it (Fassett, personal communication, February 21, 2014). Melon’s Barnehama believes that timing is important and that embedding feedback and recommendations into people’s day-to-day activities is integral, “a good service should give feedback in the moments that count.” In the case of sleep-tracking, for example, users might get a score about their quality of sleep in the morning when they wake up, but then go through a full 12-hour day, doing all sorts of things that affect their sleep without getting feedback about those activities (personal communication, February 19, 2014). Omada Health’s Andrea Mallard adds, that behavior change is not always dependent on the actual data, but rather about the awareness that self-tracking induces, “people who track what they eat or weigh themselves every morning, will automatically eat less” (personal communication, February 20, 2014).

Tell a Human Story Researcher Brenè Brown states in her TED talk “maybe stories are just data with a soul” (2010). As design researchers we embed stories into data (Seemann, 2012) to keep data human and the user at the center of our attention. When self-trackers track data they are creating a very personal story about themselves. As Gary Wolf (2010) describes it, “the goal isn’t to figure out something about human beings in general but to discover something about yourself – the validity might be narrow, but it is beautifully relevant.” In his 2010 TED talk, Wolf spoke about how data derived from self-tracking should not be exclusively seen as a ‘window’ that allows outside institutions to look into peoples’ lives, but rather as a ‘mirror’ that allows self-discovery and self-awareness. Nafus and Sherman also discuss how the self-tracking of personal data is one of the few areas of big data collection in which the individual is not a resource whose data is aggregated and abstracted by a distant machine for the sake of advertising or controlling the behaviors of others, but instead is a meaningful reflection of oneself (2014).

Ensure an Ethical Use of Data Ethics around data are most often considered when the people analyzing and using the data differ from the ones producing it. The immense accessibility of data has given rise to much discussion about the ethical use of user provided information, with many suggesting that just because people publicly share information, it is not automatically ethical for others to make use of it (Boyd & Crawford, 2011). Ethical considerations are, of course, just as relevant when users track data for themselves. In this paper we have focused on the personal relevance of data and therefore have limited ourselves to ethical concerns related to the hypothesis of users becoming researchers of their own lives. Questions around security and confidentiality of data collected through self-tracking need to be answered on a societal, governmental and legislative level. It is imperative, however, that service providers ensure users are aware of how their data is stored and what it could be used for.

Our main goal here is to examine how self-tracking leads to new personal risks and responsibilities for the user.

CONCLUSIONS

In this paper we have proposed five principles, derived from our work as design researchers, that should be kept in mind when designing new services for users to track personal data: First, the design of a human-centered self-tracking service must start with asking the right questions and should continue to reframe those questions as the engagement with the service might change over time. Having the right questions in mind leads, as we have seen in the case of Basis, for example, to an outcome of more tailored feedback.

As the market matures, we hope to see more examples of self-tracking services that will incorporate our five principles, leading to better designed services and more value for the user. From a design research perspective we are keen to see how self- tracking services will develop in the future. Will self-tracking become more pervasive? Will self-tracking devices become invisible or even implantable? Self-tracking technology is changing the way we conduct our research as users take on the role of researchers, becoming collectors of their own data. Our role as researchers increasingly changes from passive observers to active collaborators, working together with users to collect and interpret data. We look forward to the additional learning opportunities gained as users increasingly interact with their personal data as researchers of their own lives.

REFERENCES

Cover of the proceedings volume Advances in The Human Side of Service Engineering

Explore the complete digital volume

Advances in The Human Side of Service Engineering

Read this individual research paper free through the original publisher, or explore the full digital proceedings book.

ISBN 978-1-4951-2091-6

Explore this ISBN in the AHFE Bookstore Listed in the July 2026 bookstore catalogue; search by ISBN to confirm current availability · Digital book purchase optional

Explore Related Research

Related research 8 matches

More papers from this volume

← Back to Research ExplorerBrowse the full library →